Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

What frustrates you about Sid Meier's Pirates!
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirates! Chat Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 12:03 pm    Post subject: Re: What frustrates you about Sid Meier's Pirates! Reply with quote

[/quote]

Get yourself a war canoe - and use that as your flag ship when sailing, your fleet will go that much faster.

A skilled player can take down a Ship of the Line with a War Canoe.

And it is a lot of fun as well.[/quote]

How is it fun when it's not a challenge, to capture the most dangerous ship with the smallest one? A war canoe can only fit 50 men but I imagine a SOTL to carry a crew up to 300. Can I accomplish that if I just feel like it? Wow, now I'm really on the edge of my seat. Is there any proper challenge on reasonable conditions AT ALL in this game whatsoever, or is it all suppose to be one big joke?
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
fleetp
Helmsman
Posts: 4600



26028 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 3:15 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Like rusty said
"Well, like I said before, games should be fun and I don't think we can make this fun for you. "
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 3:41 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

But what about yourself? Do you have any complaints of your own about Meier's Pirates?
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Rusty Edge
Rigger
Posts: 1977



2992 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 6:19 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

In the spirit of the original post,

I think that I shouldn't be expected to please everyone. I should get points for every 10K of reward money the Spanish have on my head when I retire, just like I get points for being an English or French Duke .

I think that my reputation should count for something. If I betrayed a governor to steal his mail runner, or double crossed the haven pirates or Indians, that faction shouldn't trust me enough to cooperate with me again.

I think that the game is too repetitive.

Sure, I like solving maps, and I enjoy finding a lost relative hidden in the jungle. Maybe my sister is an indentured barmaid, and I should have to fence for her. Maybe my uncle or
grandfather is indentured to a governor as a butler, and I have to buy his freedom. Maybe one is prisoner at Montalban's tower. It should vary game to game.

I'd like to have a more gifts for when I don't feel like dancing. Pearls, perfume, silk, etc. Emeralds.

When that hotshot Spanish Pirate hunter tries to re-capture the treasure fleet from me, and I dismast him, I want his curiass. When Raymondo or Montalban surrenders to me, and he's got a better set of swords, I want them!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 6:32 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Rusty Edge wrote:
In the spirit of the original post,

I think that I shouldn't be expected to please everyone. I should get points for every 10K of reward money the Spanish have on my head when I retire, just like I get points for being an English or French Duke .

I think that my reputation should count for something. If I betrayed a governor to steal his mail runner, or double crossed the haven pirates or Indians, that faction shouldn't trust me enough to cooperate with me again.

I think that the game is too repetitive.

Sure, I like solving maps, and I enjoy finding a lost relative hidden in the jungle. Maybe my sister is an indentured barmaid, and I should have to fence for her. Maybe my uncle or
grandfather is indentured to a governor as a butler, and I have to buy his freedom. Maybe one is prisoner at Montalban's tower. It should vary game to game.

I'd like to have a more gifts for when I don't feel like dancing. Pearls, perfume, silk, etc. Emeralds.

When that hotshot Spanish Pirate hunter tries to re-capture the treasure fleet from me, and I dismast him, I want his curiass. When Raymondo or Montalban surrenders to me, and he's got a better set of swords, I want them!


Excellent suggestions! I agree with all of them. Surprised Jewelry like ruby rings, diamond necklace plus the things you mentioned like pearls, emeralds, silk, could be found in treasures among gold pieces.

Relatives being enslaved in various forms are what I originally expected the game to show actually.

My own creative head tells me that swords go blunt after years of usage and should get sharpened by blacksmiths for a small amount of gold, which would sustain my fencing ability. But I suppose it's too much for a simple game. I got lots of ideas and more ideas, some of I've written down.
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Aug 01, 2014 10:36 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

scandinavian wrote:
If I want a ship that goes fairly fast both against the wind and with the wind, what ship do you recommend?

My favorite is the mail runner - a larger version of the pinnace. It's not quite as fast or maneuverable as a war canoe, but it will carry more crew and cargo.

scandinavian wrote:
You also win the swordfight against the "jealous duelor" when your skill is Wit and Charm on Rogue? Do you make perfect dances or just average dances? I only dance to get items, and in that case I need those that improve my fencing abilities. Though I don't know if the dance is worth it, since the daughter might just tell me where Raymondo is instead when I'm not even looking for that guy.

I am far from a perfect dancer, even with wit and charm as my skill. Once I have the boots, I can usually dance will enough to get the dip and the higher reward (when I want to), but I still sometimes make a fatal flub late in the dance.

If you dance primarily for items (as most of us do early in the game), it is useful to know the reward structure. Let's call the two success levels for dancing "perfect" and "good" (as Sashanan does in his FAQ). A plain daughter will give you an item only for a perfect dance. For a good dance, she will tell you the whereabouts of a criminal. An attractive daughter will give you an item for a good dance. For a perfect dance, she will give you news on Raymondo. Therefore, with an attractive daughter you need to aim for a good, but not perfect, dance performance to get the item. Finally, a beautiful daughter will give you Raymondo for a good dance, and either a lost city map piece or news on Montalban for a perfect dance.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Aug 02, 2014 8:17 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Gotcha.
Plain daughters seems to be the thing to focus on. If I wanted Raymondo's position I can just visit any jesuit mission, and with beautiful daughters there's no guarantee I will make a perfect dance.
I have no bigger problems with the silly dances. I will never choose Wit and Charm again, mainly because of the jealous duelor. I will stick to skill at Medicine, because even that skill helps sustain my fencing abilities. Health has to do with how fast I can move and a long career is the most useful. It goes quick enough to become a Baron anyway.
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Aug 02, 2014 10:17 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Yes, medicine will preserve your health, including your fencing ability. And it stacks with the herbs and the salve - you need all three to get the maximum healthy lifespan.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Aug 02, 2014 11:30 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

What difference does skill at Navigation really do? I still find my ships stalling in the sea battles.
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Aug 03, 2014 3:22 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

scandinavian wrote:
What difference does skill at Navigation really do? I still find my ships stalling in the sea battles.

I think navigation increases your sailing speed, but that won't help if you're trying to sail to close to the wind - or if the wind is dead.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Aug 11, 2014 9:17 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Since nobody else adds to the topic I will add with a couple of ones, now when I couldn't restrain myself from playing a little bit more and need to vent:

7#
At Swashbuckler level, the duels are so ridicolous I can't possibly win even if my skill is at Fencing and I got all items. Though I am in "failing health" it's still unreasonable I think. The Metal Cuirass keeps failing me, despite it's told it should protect me from thrusts 90% of the time. The success of my escapades depends on the crew, always, and it's illogical that I as a captain gets a larger share at Swashbuckler when at Swashbuckler I'm completely dependant on my crew to do the job. In easier difficulty I'm the one doing the job, saving my crew from the enemy crew by defeating the enemy captain yet my crew gets the larger share in those levels. Perhaps people in general just feel that logic is overrated and the game designers just went "fuck logic, who needs it"? Look, all I can do is to hold my stance to the enemy captain while I wait for the crew to win the battle for me. And I'm suppose to get 50% of the loot? Who thought this pile of shit out, a dodo bird?

The wind changes so fast my ships can barely keep up with the changes (frigates). Stalemate winds occur more frequently, ESPECIALLY right in front of enemy ports so they can bombard me with cannon from long distance without me having any sort of ability to defend myself. I can't move, I always have to take those hits to my hull and somehow damage is ampled up at higher difficulty. How is this consistent? Just because it's higher difficulty doesn't mean the game can multiply everything to work against me. It's not like it's smoothly programmed to the point it feels natural. The changes betweeen difficulty levels are so poorly hidden and so blatantly unbalanced. Tsk tsk.

8#
Too many treasures are hidden too close to others. Lately I found two lost cities at almost the exact same damn SPOT, west of Blackbeard's home haven. It's a total load of bullshit when alot of the game's memory goes to create a huge world of land and ocean and so many possibilites of places where treasures can be hidden, and they seem to... sometimes be piled on roughly the same location, just like the pirates prefer to plod and going about their own business in that bay between Campeche and Santa Catalina like a bunch of confused losers. When there are so many possible mini-bays they could hang around and pose threats to various nations. For example, when a famous pirate harassing a specific port gets defeated by me, I should get popular in that port and gain more favor with that nation in particular that suffered from that pirate the most.
But if I go to that spot and "loot" the first lost city, and then look around, there is not another lost city until I get the next map because treasures doesn't spawn until I acquire the map. Sorry Sid Meier but the illusion of reality fails. Especially when lost cities are represented by two pathetic pillars... while the misc objects around to make the landscape recognizable on the map have small indian ruins that are larger and more detailed than the actual treasure.
I think I should start singing "Logic is not needed here, logic is not needed here, logic is not needed here" whenever I encounter these types of bad jokes, because I imagine Sid Meier and his team where humming that while doing this game.

Why are there indians defending the evil Montalban in his hideout, but not any indians defending their own lost cities? Logic is not needed here! Razz
How come there are an endless stream of indians backing up enemy ports when I attack this or that port a second time, the first time having defeated all indians that were there? Logic is not needed here! Razz
Why are indians helping the european ports AT ALL in the land battles when the chieftains complain they are sick of the evil colonists? Logic is not needed here! Razz
When I press space to fire a long distant round shot to an enemy port to return the hostile fire, the port's WEALTH - yes wealth, not military strength - decreases from wealthy to modest, modest to poor. Why? Because logic is not needed here! Razz
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Rusty Edge
Rigger
Posts: 1977



2992 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Aug 12, 2014 12:54 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Well, too be fair, I don't have an issue with the Lost Cities as such. They're lost because they're uninhabited. The Indians don't defend uninhabited cities.

Archaeologists find pyramids in Central America with satellite telemetry, because they are overgrown with vegetation and are mistaken for hills. The guys on the ground have to use GPS. They can be standing beside one and not recognize it.

*******************************

That said, you certainly have a pertinent point about the Indians and the cities. It defies logic that all cities are defended by Indians, considering how regularly the Indians attack the cities. You would expect them to join your side!


I don't find Swashbuckler fun, either.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Roland
Helmsman
Posts: 4190



23929 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Aug 12, 2014 1:56 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Where did you read that the cuirass will stop 90% of thrusts? In my experience, it stops about one-third of thrusts. The leather vest is about half as effective as the cuirass.

Swashbuckler is intended to be ridiculously, unrealistically difficult. I think it was inspired by the "Rogue" level of the previous edition of Pirates, which could be accessed only by starting the game without proving you owned it legally. It was designed as a humorous way to punish software thieves, but some players started playing Rogue mode intentionally for the challenge.

I read somewhere that the location of hidden treasures and lost cities depends on where you acquired the first map piece. I forget the exact relationship.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Aug 12, 2014 2:25 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Rusty Edge wrote:
Well, too be fair, I don't have an issue with the Lost Cities as such. They're lost because they're uninhabited. The Indians don't defend uninhabited cities.

Archaeologists find pyramids in Central America with satellite telemetry, because they are overgrown with vegetation and are mistaken for hills. The guys on the ground have to use GPS. They can be standing beside one and not recognize it.

*******************************

That said, you certainly have a pertinent point about the Indians and the cities. It defies logic that all cities are defended by Indians, considering how regularly the Indians attack the cities. You would expect them to join your side!


I don't find Swashbuckler fun, either.


No but you see, I imagine that even if the cities are lost to europeans and to some extent different tribes, they aren't forgotten by some indian descendors. I imagine that once a european adventurer discovers a HIDDEN city (not lost, hidden, in my version of this game) he would encounter a bunch of warriors like in Montalban's hideout defending their treasure of 50 000 because so much wealth just doesn't go "lost" when the city never moved in the first place. Why exactly would a city go lost? Perhaps I'm historically ignorant, but in the context of the game, nothing makes sense or it makes a whole lot of nonsense while making a little sense. Such as noble ladies knowing more of lost treasure than pro treasure hunters like myself do, strangers in taverns knows more about my family's whereabouts than I do and somehow I should pay 1000 money for knowing private matters - when I should threaten to kill the guy if he doesn't tell me everything, because I have a right to know - "recent visitors" know more about indian cities than indians themselves and on and on. The more inconsistent illogical absurdities and intellectual self-conflicts Sid Meier can shove down our throats, the happier man he gets! Or something. I don't know the agenda behind the making of this game but it seems having fun doing things the opposite of rational expectation in general.

I should get hated by the indians for the rest of the game because I trespassed on their property (it's theirs because they would inherit it) and stole the wealth.
While on it, if I tell them to attack a well-armed city and then get back, they would not trust me anymore...

A GPS would be a great item to buy from that guy in the tavern who seems to have everything! The "recent visitors" who found the city, did they use satellites? Somebody would know the city's location, otherwise a map to it wouldn't exist. And if there's a map that leads to it, it isn't "lost" by definition. But logic is neither wanted or needed here, intellectual conflicts is the thing of Pirates! Perhaps it's lost by europeans who really never knew it existed... but they first have to find something and own it before it can go "lost". So the cities are only lost by indians, but not by "recent visitors" who never claimed the city's wealth for themselves. Because that would make sense, and we don't want that. Smile

It would be pretty cool if indians joined my crew, but perhaps a little weird. I mostly just found it absurd that they keep coming back to join the evil europeans that I try to pillage.

And Swashbuckler is just a little sillly. I think the crew deserves the larger share as I can't perform as well in my own duels as I would be able too in easier levels. Which makes the concept intellectually self-conflicting. However it makes sense that I get the larger share of the treasures, because I own the maps.

Explain to me how round shot cannonballs can decrease the wealth of the port I'm firing against, Rusty Edge. I feel so confused about causing such disturbance. Do I somehow manage to hit the governor, the merchantman, the bankers, and kill all the stock market somehow with each blow? Or do I just damage the confidence of the city to "feel" wealthy? I thought I was just attacking the fortress, to kill some soldiers. And why doesn't the amount of soldiers decrease after a land battle I fought and lost? My own crew decrease in numbers, but not the soldiers of that port. How is that fair? How is that logical? Why should I put up with such rubbish? When I defeat pirate-hunters and invasion forces that generates from the port, the amount of soldiers defending the port is static. I thought troops leaving the port would empty the port of troops? Wouldn't that make sense? Is it illegal to make sense?
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....


Last edited by scandinavian on Tue Aug 12, 2014 2:57 am; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
scandinavian
Powder Monkey
Posts: 24


1618 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Aug 12, 2014 2:36 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Roland wrote:
Where did you read that the cuirass will stop 90% of thrusts? In my experience, it stops about one-third of thrusts. The leather vest is about half as effective as the cuirass.

Swashbuckler is intended to be ridiculously, unrealistically difficult. I think it was inspired by the "Rogue" level of the previous edition of Pirates, which could be accessed only by starting the game without proving you owned it legally. It was designed as a humorous way to punish software thieves, but some players started playing Rogue mode intentionally for the challenge.

I read somewhere that the location of hidden treasures and lost cities depends on where you acquired the first map piece. I forget the exact relationship.


Ah I see, I might have read it from someone who didn't knew what he was talking about. One third seems to be what it makes aswell.
Well I've only played Swashbuckler once, and I was pretty nervous to start doing it but really, all I was going to do was finding the treasures and get the larger share of them, and not so much fighting. I'm still not done with that character, will probably finish it tomorrow and then give the game a rest.
I'm not surprised they actually included a feature in the game that reallly wasn't suppose to be in it. Because the game has so many flaws it seems unfinished. Swashbuckler not really being intended for serious gameplay just goes to prove that Pirates! isn't properly made. Just take the items that should "improve relationships" with missionaries and indians, they aren't freaking working. And like I pointed out, the graphic representation of the lost cities is incomplete. Two pillars is just laughable. They didn't finish this game before release and they didn't think it through.

Well I got the first map pieces from the same daughter in the same town/port whatever. I always end my career in the same port I marry the girl I want. Like deciding a home port for my character, where I always divide the plunder.
_________________
A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirates! Chat All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
Page 2 of 4

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group