
What frustrates you about Sid Meier's Pirates!
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2014 8:48 am Post subject: |
|
|
For a long time it was widely believed that the items that supposedly improve relations with the Jesuits and Indians did not work. But someone in this forum did the research to prove that they actually do work. It's just that most of us, in normal gameplay, do not normally find ourselves in scenarios where the items come into play in an obvious way.
Check out this thread. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
scandinavian

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 24 


1618 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2014 1:47 pm Post subject: |
|
|
"most of us, in normal gameplay, do not normally find ourselves in scenarios where the items come into play in an obvious way."
Hahahahaha! I think what you're trying to say is: most of us who play this game to win, find no use of these items because they become irrelevant in the context of the game's objectives. It's either insufficient programming, or it's badly thought out game design. Take your pick. _________________ A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity.... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Rusty Edge

Rigger 
Posts: 1977 

 
2992 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2014 6:57 pm Post subject: |
|
|
******************************************************
Those of us that are still here love the game, and wish for a remake or an expansion.
I'm glad to have you here to keep the place lively. If you think Sid's Pirates! is broken, you must have a poor opinion of more recent games, which generally are released incomplete, and require patches, expansions, and download content to be playable.
What games do you enjoy playing, Scandanavian?
************************************************************** | scandinavian wrote: |
Why exactly would a city go lost? Perhaps I'm historically ignorant, but in the context of the game, nothing makes sense or it makes a whole lot of nonsense while making a little sense. |
Historically, cities have reasons for existing. They aren't random. They can suddenly spring up when gold or silver or gems are discovered, and become ghost towns just as quickly when the wealth runs out, or more gold is discovered someplace else.
Other cities usually have more organization than one caused by a gold discovery. Maybe they're based upon other natural resources ( which can also run out or die off eventually ) If the cause of a city or the organization that makes it possible goes away, the city can be abandoned. Lots of things can happen-
Floods, volcanoes, and other natural disasters. Plagues and famines. Wars.
The cities become too dangerous, or there's no food , and they are abandoned. The people flee or go elsewhere. Leaves and dust blow, then plants grow. The ruins get covered in dirt. Or settle into the mud. The city becomes lost. Archaeologists have to dig them up.
| scandinavian wrote: | | Such as noble ladies knowing more of lost treasure than pro treasure hunters like myself do, strangers in taverns knows more about my family's whereabouts than I do and somehow I should pay 1000 money for knowing private matters - when I should threaten to kill the guy if he doesn't tell me everything, because I have a right to know - "recent visitors" know more about indian cities than indians themselves and on and on. |
The noble ladies can learn more than you because they are prettier with beautiful boobs. ; )
As for the family's whereabouts, I've already shared my suggestions with you about that. The game has a lot of room for improvement. You are at a distinct disadvantage because they were imprisoned when you were ten, and now you are 18 before you even start looking in the right hemisphere of the planet.
All I can say about the Indians is that there are plenty of people who don't
know or care much about history, even their own, and have never traveled far from home. They live in the here and now, and anticipate the future.
You Scandinavians are lucky to have your saga tradition. I know which countries my ancestors supposedly came from, but nothing more than that.
Everything pretty much begins with their arrival in the New World in the 1700s. I don't even know which cities/ provinces they came from or why.
I guess they wanted a fresh start, and to forget whatever they left behind.
| scandinavian wrote: | | Somebody would know the city's location, otherwise a map to it wouldn't exist. And if there's a map that leads to it, it isn't "lost" by definition. | You're right. If there's a map it isn't lost. I agree with this whole-heartedly! But the more I thought about it..
Somebody definitely knows where it is.... unless that somebody is dead and the map is torn up or otherwise destroyed. Then nobody would know where it is. It would be re-lost.
Somebody who re-discovered the city while looking for a good place to settle or something would certainly take the treasure for himself...unless it were more than he could carry, in which case he might make a map to find his way back with some mules...
Somebody traveling alone with as much gold as they could carry might be a tempting target for murderous thieves.
Murderous thieves might divide the map evenly along with the gold. OR
Murderous thieves in possession of new-found wealth might go to a tavern or brothel to spend it, and might fight over the map when their riches ran out. Fighting over a map is a good way for it to get torn into a few pieces..
A fight among murderous drunks could lead to death, or somebody who was drunk at the time might forget where they hid their piece of the map.
One way or another, nobody knows where the city is. It's lost, but there are some rumors and map fragments.
Does that sound logical to you? I never thought about it before.
| scandinavian wrote: | | Explain to me how round shot cannonballs can decrease the wealth of the port I'm firing against, Rusty Edge. I feel so confused about causing such disturbance. Do I somehow manage to hit the governor, the merchantman, the bankers, and kill all the stock market somehow with each blow? Or do I just damage the confidence of the city to "feel" wealthy? I thought I was just attacking the fortress, to kill some soldiers. And why doesn't the amount of soldiers decrease after a land battle I fought and lost? My own crew decrease in numbers, but not the soldiers of that port. How is that fair? How is that logical? Why should I put up with such rubbish? When I defeat pirate-hunters and invasion forces that generates from the port, the amount of soldiers defending the port is static. I thought troops leaving the port would empty the port of troops? Wouldn't that make sense? Is it illegal to make sense? |
I agree, a cannonade should weaken the city's defenses rather than it's wealth.
The story I tell myself is that while the city is besieged, the residents are busy hiding their valuables in wells, burying them in the garden and under paving stones, etc. Perhaps even moving piles of garbage to hide things. The more time they have, the more they can hide.
In my experience sacking a city reduces the size of the garrison.
So does fighting a land battle. Sometimes I have to do it 3 or more times to get it small enough to capture, but when I fight them, they lose men.
Of course sometimes a ship can arrive with more Spanish troops while I'm in the Tavern .
On the other side of that, when I board an invasion force galleon, I don't have to fight 200 extra men. They must be seasick!
Yes it would certainly make more sense if departing invasion forces reduced the number of defenders in a city. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2014 7:29 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I recently read a book on the history of salt. In an age when salt is cheap and plentiful, it is hard for us to imagine how valuable it was in the ancient world. Many important cities grew up near salt works. They might prosper or vanish depending on how long the salt held out, whether better or cheaper salt became available nearby, and changes in the salt tax.
Plagues also caused cities - and even entire civilizations - to collapse practically overnight. The Europeans brought diseases that wiped out much of the native population of the Americas.
Indians might all look alike to us European imperialists, but they identify themselves as members of particular tribes, which do not always get along with each other. Just because you attack Indians from one village does not mean all Indians will hate you. Many tribes that had been subjugated by the Aztecs were happy to assist Cortez in overthrowing their masters.
If you fire cannons indiscriminately into a town, it will damage property. Making repairs will deplete the community's wealth. Fragile, irreplaceable items (e.g., the artwork and the fancy china in the governor's palace) will be lost permanently. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
scandinavian

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 24 


1618 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2014 8:16 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Rusty Edge wrote: |
Those of us that are still here love the game, and wish for a remake or an expansion.
I'm glad to have you here to keep the place lively. If you think Sid's Pirates! is broken, you must have a poor opinion of more recent games, which generally are released incomplete, and require patches, expansions, and download content to be playable.
What games do you enjoy playing, Scandanavian?
|
I would rather wish to make my own pirate game. That would be so awesome. I have too many ideas to fit into an expansion of this. I don't really play recent games, I don't play games that much at all, I usually prefer old Nintendo depending on the game. I play Age of Empires 3 sometimes. I often have lots of opinions on games but I think Pirates! is the one singular game that have frustrated me the most. I'm not even gonna begin to think playing new games that are even more lacking.
| Rusty Edge wrote: |
The cities become too dangerous, or there's no food , and they are abandoned. The people flee or go elsewhere. Leaves and dust blow, then plants grow. The ruins get covered in dirt. Or settle into the mud. The city becomes lost. Archaeologists have to dig them up.
|
Assuming this happened to four specific cities of four specific cultures, they all abandoned their legacy, what they had built, yet they live relatively close to them by the shore in small villages and generally just don't give a damn. No wonder they're so poor, they're morons. Assuming they had to abandon their cities some hundred years ago, it's still too early for the city to go completely invisible in the jungle - I think. I could be mistaken, but a lost indian city being lost already in the 17th century would be less hidden by nature than if it was lost from that point til today. Which means nobody would use satellites at that time to locate one of these cities (satellites didn't exist back then, I suspect even Sid Meier knows). And if our hero can just walk right into the city and pillage it, it clearly isn't disguised by nature. Just at what point did the cities go lost? When the spanish arrived 100 years earlier, or when a disease struck the place 300 years ago? Regardless, nothing would rationally prevent the indian tribes to go back and re-establish their wealth so they wouldn't have to be so poor and starving anymore. Especially in war times, when spanish are a threat to them from the ocean. They would be safer deep in the jungle where nobody could find them.
| Rusty Edge wrote: |
The noble ladies can learn more than you because they are prettier with beautiful boobs. ; )
As for the family's whereabouts, I've already shared my suggestions with you about that. The game has a lot of room for improvement. You are at a distinct disadvantage because they were imprisoned when you were ten, and now you are 18 before you even start looking in the right hemisphere of the planet.
|
Well I'm a professional sailer, discoverer, general and warrior. I know my sea maps, I know the Caribbiean, I've developed experience and good judgement. Why do I get information from overclass girls who stay home all the time? I might aswell get my map pieces from a kid on the street who found it in a pile of garbage, yay. Nothing against the idea when it comes to retrieving the map from the evil colonel Mendoza... but you get my point. All pirates on the Caribbiean should be competitors to these treasures, and whoever get there first is the winner. Killing off other pirates would ensure my chances, AND getting new map pieces.
So a miserable drunkard knows more about my family than me because I lived in Europe when I was a kid? The reason I don't buy this, is because - and you should go look up what it says in Pirateopedia - the guy doesn't care who I am or where I'm coming from as long as my money is good. So you pretty much got Sid Meier lying straight into your face right there. He doesn't care who I am, but he cares about my family somehow, yet STILL doesn't care about me. Whatever that means. Pirateopedia. The game confesses to be retarded. How is this mysterious stranger a mysterious stranger if he knows matters that are private to me? This is what we call a self-conflict in reason, or a logical oxymoron, ok? A lost city isn't lost if there's a map that shows where it is to be found, a stranger isn't a stranger if he has family connections, and a pirate isn't a pirate if he asks for clues instead of taking them by force. Indians aren't enemies to the europeans if they support them in battle against the enemies of the europeans.
And paying the guy 1000 bucks for it? Pfft. I would see it more reasonable to pay him 1 or 2 dubloons for information on ports I haven't visited. Or why not, tips where to get the items I really need?
| Rusty Edge wrote: |
You Scandinavians are lucky to have your saga tradition.
|
We most certainly are, but our legacy and our countries are currently being invaded by immigrants making requests to change our societies. So the situation for us right now is serious. Roots is a very good thing to have.
| Rusty Edge wrote: |
Somebody definitely knows where it is.... unless that somebody is dead and the map is torn up or otherwise destroyed. Then nobody would know where it is. It would be re-lost.
Somebody who re-discovered the city while looking for a good place to settle or something would certainly take the treasure for himself...unless it were more than he could carry, in which case he might make a map to find his way back with some mules...
Somebody traveling alone with as much gold as they could carry might be a tempting target for murderous thieves.
...
A fight among murderous drunks could lead to death, or somebody who was drunk at the time might forget where they hid their piece of the map.
One way or another, nobody knows where the city is. It's lost, but there are some rumors and map fragments.
|
I like this explanation alot, but the problem with it is that if the original discoverer of the city didn't take any gold from it, he has nothing on him for thieves to loot. A broken map is a useless map, pirates can't be that dumb to damage it when it's worth the price of the X on it, what they should have done is to go find the city and then share the loot from it. It's not that hard to think out, it ain't rocket science etc and you have to consider this happened 4 times with 4 discoveries to 4 cities! It's too unlikely to have happened, and a traveler would have plenty of time to go back to it in secret. A person smart enough to discover a lost indian city without satellites or GPS or the aid of indian descendors, would be smart enough to defend himself against stupid ass pirates that would damage the map if they laid their hands on it.
On an extra note, the daughter said she heard "wondrous tales" from a "recent visitor" which I interpret as that visitor being also a visitor to the city, him being recent means him being alive. Making "quick notes" means she wrote something down, not that the stole a piece of a map for her beloved nr 1 pirate or drew a copy to the piece of a map. Or if I just read it wrong, and she did exactly this but said "make quick notes" to make it sound more polite, she needs to tell me WHERE THAT RECENT VISITOR TOLD HER HE WAS GOING TO TRAVEL NEXT SO I CAN FIND HIM AND GET THE WHOLE STORY OUT FIRST HAND. As when you find wanted criminals. Heck, I can imagine sharing the loot with the guy.
Perhaps the map is just a visual representation of a gathering of various information and clues. The map isn't literally torn into 4 pieces... it just symbolizes that I have to make research on the subject 4 times before I can make a coherent "picture" of where the treasure is. This makes sense, if only the game wouldn't be so repetitive in its ... uh, display, storytelling, whatever, the way I find clues. Rumors and map fragments is an acceptable (brilliant) idea, and the city would still be "lost" in the sense that it might still be a myth it actually exist. I'm not against the idea, but the concept of how I find it.
Here's my own suggestion: an indian descendor of the people living in the city knew where it was, drew a map, his village got attacked by evil spaniards and one of them took the map and shared it with the woman I happened to dance around with.
| Rusty Edge wrote: |
I agree, a cannonade should weaken the city's defenses rather than it's wealth.
The story I tell myself is that while the city is besieged, the residents are busy hiding their valuables in wells, burying them in the garden and under paving stones, etc. Perhaps even moving piles of garbage to hide things. The more time they have, the more they can hide.
|
Rusty Edge, that actually explains the problem. Thank you. It seems like a bad joke, but you rationalized it, though I don't know if I rob the citizens or just the gathered treasure in the town. If I leave the innocent people in peace and just attack the market or something, the problem isn't really explained.
| Rusty Edge wrote: |
In my experience sacking a city reduces the size of the garrison.
So does fighting a land battle. Sometimes I have to do it 3 or more times to get it small enough to capture, but when I fight them, they lose men.
Of course sometimes a ship can arrive with more Spanish troops while I'm in the Tavern .
On the other side of that, when I board an invasion force galleon, I don't have to fight 200 extra men. They must be seasick! |
They lose men, IF you win the battle. If not, they are magically resurrected. As if to taunt you, you didn't really accomplish anything.
I don't view it like that, time seems to be standing still while I'm in port, as it might should be.
I always intercept and sink battleships with large crews, if I want to help a nation or its port. Crews would/should get exhausted fighting so many battles every day or week.
That's it, I've done my last pirate for the year on Swashbuckler, I became Governor of Guadelope with almost 300 000 gold and 18400 acres! One of the last battle was with Blackbeard, my favorite foe whom I saved to last. New complaint: I approached Blackbeards frigate with the wind coming from behind my own frigate and it going against him, I broadsided him with Chain Shot and then he chased me. I had him right in my tail, very close to boarding me, and on it went. Me having fully repaired cotton sails going full speed, him having damaged cotton sails, him still going the same speed as me. I got so pissed off at this game lying to me with its rules I reloaded and forced it to look proper, and got the man properly.
Why do I have to keep experiencing the game cheating its own consistency? A broadside of Chain Shot should slow my enemy down. So why didn't it? Because it's Swashbuckler and sails don't take damage? Or logic is not needed here? I'm not making this up, I SAW that shit. _________________ A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity.... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
scandinavian

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 24 


1618 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Aug 12, 2014 8:25 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Roland, history is very fascinating, though my reading concentration is bad. I can understand towns, villages, ports, cities, weren't as established as of today but more in the style of nomad colonies moving from one place to another depending on natural resources.
But hey, my cannon is aimed at the fortress! I don't buy that for a second, because one round shot damages perhaps a little of a ships hull, then take that into context of an entire colony. Nope. I still think I'm just hurting their confidence and their mood. They start calling themselves "poor" so I would just sail away and not bother them anymore. They get in bad mood. "Go and raid someone else, we're poor here. So poor. Can't you see how POOR we are?" Yeah right. I fired a couple of cannon balls to your fortress. Why is there a fortress if you don't have a place you store big piles of money? _________________ A pirate game called Pirates. Mindblowing creativity.... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Wolfwood

Boatswain 
Posts: 2484 

 
33917 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Sep 05, 2014 2:18 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Just installed the game after a _long_ break. I even found my old personalised sail designs (howling wolf sail).
Annoyances the I'd wish were fixed in a future sequel / re-remake:
- Renewing NPC pirates: it makes no sense that after I've beaten them all, no new pirate captains rise to take their places.
- Repetitive fights/animations: the sword fights are far too simple.
- No historical events: A lot happened in history during the years represented in the game. Some of the major events could be programmed in here (such as missions involving Roundheads vs. Royalists for England, the 30-year-war in Europe etc.).
- Repetitive gameplay: more variety is needed and perhaps a slightly deeper management of crew/officers. It would be great to be able to hire your officers, get better ones as time goes by etc.
In fact, a lot could be improved if the people who make the sequel will just take a look at Expeditions: Conquistador and copy/imitate some of the good design decisions there. _________________ It is much better to be armed with a sword that has two edges than with an estoc [...], which is nothing more than a stick with a point. (Rapier Master G. Morsicato Pallavicini, La Scherma Illustrata, p. 14.) |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
davyjones

Cutthroat 
Posts: 302 


5230 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 5:31 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I admit I havent played in a few months or more, but here are some that still jump out...
The repetitive nature of it. Sure the first game you play, having to do things 3-4 times isnt too bad. But to replay and replay the game, I wish there was a way to skip the duplicate tasks (defeating Raymondo past the 1st time, etc.)
the lack of challenge regarding nations' love hate for you. It seems way to easy for them to forgive you for killing off their future governor you were hired to escort there.
The historically accurate but annoying weather patterns that force you to use a month to go from Vera Cruz back to the eastern carib.
I am sure there are others. Many are really just lack of better idea, instead of a bad idea. Wish there was more variable trading. Wish you could set up your own haven, especially with the land you're given. Wish the daughters travelled and you had to find/avoid certain ones for information. Wish the suitor was a navy capt that chased you for revenge. Wish the game included round trip tickets and hotel for one of those islands. Wish the story arc had some variety, so the 2nd or third time playing could have random objectives. Or, a chance to randomize the map. and so on... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 8:36 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| davyjones wrote: | | The historically accurate but annoying weather patterns that force you to use a month to go from Vera Cruz back to the eastern carib. |
Some seasonal variation in weather patterns might enhance the game at higher difficulty levels. One might want to avoid long-distance travel across the open sea during hurricane season! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Captain Teague

Rigger 
Posts: 1176 

 
12207 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Sep 26, 2014 2:03 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Somehow I missed this entire thread; what a fascinating read! Couple o' notes o' me own:
1. Natives defendin' europeans. Look at th' history o' th' native americans an' thar dealin's with each other an' the French/English in North America. It's not too unbelieveable that some tribes despise th' colonists an' some sell thar services as mercenaries (fer th' record, th' game says; "You have found the Marquis Montalban's hidden fortress! A band of indian mercenaries blocks your path!").
2. I too have noticed an' complained t' me brother (who watches me play) 'bout the whole speed thin'. I had a sloop with no upgrades outrun me pinnace with cotton sails an' copper platin'. Because, reasons.
3. An' th' crew! Every time I board a ship I'm shoutin' at th' screen "Stop dyin', ye cowards!" Even if I win ASAP, I lose near two dozen men. Insane.
Fer more notes, ye can see this thread o' mine: http://hookedonpirates.com/forwarder.html?http://hookedonpirates.com/forums/portal.php?sid=1929522f7508400178a6af6bcb020a15 _________________ The Code is the Law. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Sep 26, 2014 7:45 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Captain Teague - Your link just took me to the HoP home page. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Captain Teague

Rigger 
Posts: 1176 

 
12207 Gold -

|
Posted: Sun Sep 28, 2014 7:03 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Roland wrote: | | Captain Teague - Your link just took me to the HoP home page. |
For some reason it does that. Why don't these pages have thar own addresses!? Here be some o' me rants from th' page.
| Captain Teague wrote: | My game is being really messed up right now. My current pirate ("Lucky" Luke) sails a fully upgraded ship of the line (Phoenix). I've been haunting the Lesser Antilles (due to high trade volume) and every ship I've fought has had no upgrades. At all. Yet they all hit me with 3-5 cannonballs, and each one always takes out a cannon. I always lose 10-20 men as well. Per broadside that hits me. Meanwhile, It takes me 3 and 4 broadsides to sink sloop class vessels. Take my latest battle, I had my (undamaged) flagship. I attacked a French Barque and his War Sloop escort. Neither had upgrades. By the time I sank the escort (only lost 2 cannons to him, but took me 5 broadsides to sink him) and captured the Barque, I had lost 8 cannons and 47 men. This is typical right now! "Lucky" Luke is anything but.  |
| Captain Teague wrote: | It's not that, I managed to capture two East Indiamen, so I sail around with them in tow. I put all my plunder on them, and sink the damaged ships. It's worked fine, up until last night. The reason I don't board as much is because my pirates are wussies. Since the beginning of the career, no mater what ship I board, I lose more men then I kill. After making the original post, I boarded an English Large Merchantman (85 crew. I had 450). At the end of the battle, they had 84, and I had 423. I play on Swashbuckler, because I like the challenge. I just wish Swashbuckler meant "difficult" not "We'll make the enemies supermen because that's all we have left." The game is still fun, last night was just head smashingly frustrating.  |
| Captain Teague wrote: | I may do that; however, I've never had an issue before. The first ship my pirate took was Henry Morgan's. It had 7 upgrades, and his haven had the last one (so why he didn't have all eight is beyond me ). I've always been able to dodge a vast majority of enemy fire, taking very little damage throughout my career. And with iron scataings my crew losses were between two and eight men per battle, if I lost any all(not counting boarding). This didn't change once I got a SotL, until the night I posted. I don't know why. It's fine, I posted more out of frustration then trying to get tips. But I do appreciate all the advise.  |
_________________ The Code is the Law. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Sun Sep 28, 2014 10:36 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Captain Teague wrote: | | Roland wrote: | | Captain Teague - Your link just took me to the HoP home page. |
For some reason it does that. Why don't these pages have thar own addresses!? |
They do have their own addresses. Using IE in Windows, you can right-click on the page, the click on Properties. That will show you the URL, which you can highlight and copy. If the URL is long, you can only see the first two lines of it, but you can highlight the entire address and copy it. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Salty Dog

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10063 

 
192187 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 12:33 am Post subject: |
|
|
Oh how I wish for an upgrade. Something new and different, just about anything. This is a fun game and can be brought back to a new audience. I first started playing Pirates using the Macintosh version back around 1987. It was black and white and very different from what it looks like now but it was still fun! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Rusty Edge

Rigger 
Posts: 1977 

 
2992 Gold -

|
Posted: Sat Jun 06, 2015 9:38 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Wolfwood wrote: | Just installed the game after a _long_ break. I even found my old personalised sail designs (howling wolf sail).
Annoyances the I'd wish were fixed in a future sequel / re-remake:
- Renewing NPC pirates: it makes no sense that after I've beaten them all, no new pirate captains rise to take their places.
- Repetitive fights/animations: the sword fights are far too simple.
- No historical events: A lot happened in history during the years represented in the game. Some of the major events could be programmed in here (such as missions involving Roundheads vs. Royalists for England, the 30-year-war in Europe etc.).
- Repetitive gameplay: more variety is needed and perhaps a slightly deeper management of crew/officers. It would be great to be able to hire your officers, get better ones as time goes by etc.
In fact, a lot could be improved if the people who make the sequel will just take a look at Expeditions: Conquistador and copy/imitate some of the good design decisions there. |
Yes, there should be some new named pirates spawned, even if he's only named "Bart Roberts Jr."
A Main Gauche, perhaps?
I love historical random events and quests in Civilization IV.
Yes, whenever I lose a ship to mutiny, a specialist should go with it. But at the same time, if I'm paying an extra share to a prize captain/ 1st mate , and giving him some special equipment, he should also have my back. He should lead another party of officers in land battles for example, and stun Monty with a couple of pistol shots while I regain some of my balance. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|