
I would like to see a space pirates sequel
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
bryce777

Gunner 
Posts: 628 

 
652 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:29 pm Post subject: I would like to see a space pirates sequel |
|
|
In the future deflector shields could largely make guns obsoloete.
Battles would become largely hand to hand once again, once boarding had occurred.
If any of you have seen the cult classic ice pirates, you might agree that space piracy could be a really really cool idea for a computer game. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
grsmith320

Swabbie 
Posts: 118 

 
575 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Jan 19, 2005 7:38 pm Post subject: Freelancer |
|
|
Try the game Freelancer. It's alot like the old Privateer space game. Great graphics, good multiplayer (something I wish Pirates had) and short storyline so you can quickly get to the open ended playing. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Wed Jan 19, 2005 9:38 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Here comes that war canoe with the tactical nukes again. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Illiad

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 13 


334 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jan 20, 2005 12:28 am Post subject: |
|
|
Call me a killjoy, but the idea of "Space Pirates" is so cheesy I can't even begin to explain why.
But I'll try anyway. We all know that Pirates! is less than realistic given that you have war canoes taking Frigates and Ships of the Line appearing outside of their natural habitat, namely in an entire squadron of SotLs, but there is at least some loose historic basis to the game and the concept of High Seas robbery makes perfect economic sense.
Piracy in space just wouldn't happen, given the expenses and technologies involved. It's too easy to escape a pirate ship -- just change your delta V and unless he's real close to you to begin with, you've lost him.
Don't get me wrong. I love games for the sake of playing games, but I do get twitchy around game concepts that merely serve to perpetuate silly ideas. Like Mechs, for example. They make no sense in the real world. Fun to play for a while though. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Zem

Gunner 
Posts: 653 


3281 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Jan 20, 2005 12:00 pm Post subject: Re: Freelancer |
|
|
| grsmith320 wrote: | | Try the game Freelancer. It's alot like the old Privateer space game. Great graphics, good multiplayer (something I wish Pirates had) and short storyline so you can quickly get to the open ended playing. |
Freelancer is a pretty good game indeed. But I think the 'Elite' is more similar to Pirates! _________________ I don't have a drinking problem, 'cept when I can't get a drink. Tom Waits |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Jan 20, 2005 6:19 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Illiad wrote: | | We all know that Pirates! is less than realistic given that you have war canoes taking Frigates |
Seems to me that the Spanish Admiral in charge of that good old Armada had a similar comment as he sailed into the English Channel.
The Brits had some very small ships at that time and a number of Pinnaces got decorated for their part in the action(s).
We also forget that Drake prefered the Pinnace as his assault ship on the Spanish Main.
There was even a Time Magazine article (10+) years ago about US Aircraft Carriers being concerned about Patrol Boats bearing Surface to Surface Missles. (SotL afraid of Canoe?) |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
bryce777

Gunner 
Posts: 628 

 
652 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jan 20, 2005 6:21 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| rupertlittlebear wrote: | | Here comes that war canoe with the tactical nukes again. |
LOL
ALl I need is a red rider wagon, a space suit, some duct tape, and a nuclear reactor and that battlestar is mine!
Last edited by bryce777 on Thu Jan 20, 2005 6:31 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
bryce777

Gunner 
Posts: 628 

 
652 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jan 20, 2005 6:28 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Illiad wrote: | Call me a killjoy, but the idea of "Space Pirates" is so cheesy I can't even begin to explain why.
But I'll try anyway. We all know that Pirates! is less than realistic given that you have war canoes taking Frigates and Ships of the Line appearing outside of their natural habitat, namely in an entire squadron of SotLs, but there is at least some loose historic basis to the game and the concept of High Seas robbery makes perfect economic sense.
Piracy in space just wouldn't happen, given the expenses and technologies involved. It's too easy to escape a pirate ship -- just change your delta V and unless he's real close to you to begin with, you've lost him.
Don't get me wrong. I love games for the sake of playing games, but I do get twitchy around game concepts that merely serve to perpetuate silly ideas. Like Mechs, for example. They make no sense in the real world. Fun to play for a while though. |
Mechs actually make sense. The military has been working on them for years. The benefit is that legs are much more terrain friendly than treads, and a mech would not be able to get overturned like a turtle.
I'm not saying the whole mechwarrior universe makes any sense, because it has glaring continuity and logic flaws, but the military already has mechlike robots on a small scale and they will eventually replace tanks.
As for how realistic piracy is, it depends on what direction technology develops, and how far.
Chances are good that there will be some form of space piracy some day assuming space travel ever becomes common, but it may not be very exciting in its actual implementation.
I think it could potentially make a great game though.
I have seen the freelancer game, but that was more like a fighter oriented game really. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Illiad

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 13 


334 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jan 20, 2005 6:59 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| rupertlittlebear wrote: |
Seems to me that the Spanish Admiral in charge of that good old Armada had a similar comment as he sailed into the English Channel.
|
Ah, but if you read about the make-up of the English fleet, you'll note that it didn't exactly consist entirely of small, fast ships. There were any number of lumberous armed merchants and about thirty actual Royal Navy ships that included frigates.
| Quote: | The Brits had some very small ships at that time and a number of Pinnaces got decorated for their part in the action(s).
We also forget that Drake prefered the Pinnace as his assault ship on the Spanish Main. |
We all know this, but come now, an Indian War Canoe does not a Pinnace make. The Indians weren't exactly well known for strapping great big bronze carronades on their canoes and firing 32 lb roundshot, were they?
Again, this is simply a case of forgiving ahistorical elements for the sake of a game. The idea of an Indian War Canoe taking a SotL is ludicrous. But I didn't say it wasn't fun.
| Quote: | | There was even a Time Magazine article (10+) years ago about US Aircraft Carriers being concerned about Patrol Boats bearing Surface to Surface Missles. (SotL afraid of Canoe?) |
There is no parallel. Modern-day Patrol Boats carry ordnance that can decimate much larger ships -- this is a function of weapons technology and has absolutely no parallel to the comparison of numbers of guns that naval warfare experts relied on in the Age of Sail. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Illiad

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 13 


334 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jan 20, 2005 7:19 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| bryce777 wrote: | Mechs actually make sense. The military has been working on them for years. The benefit is that legs are much more terrain friendly than treads, and a mech would not be able to get overturned like a turtle.
I'm not saying the whole mechwarrior universe makes any sense, because it has glaring continuity and logic flaws, but the military already has mechlike robots on a small scale and they will eventually replace tanks. |
Where on earth did you hear that? I'm fairly well-read on military technology and history, and the idea of mechs replacing tanks is -- well, silly.
A single mech provides such an *enormous* and *expensive* target that they'd be ridiculous to deploy on the modern battlefield. Any mech you could build would cost the same as, say, several platoons of tanks. That same group of tanks could out-tactic a mech and bring it down, super-hero mech pilots notwithstanding.
And the *maintenance* required for a mech!! Apache gunships are pretty complex war machines, and they require one hour of downtime for every hour in the air. Mechs would be several orders of magnitude more complex -- I couldn't imagine how ghastly the down-to-deployed ratio would be. And the *cost*!
I'm not sure where you get the idea that MBTs (Main Battle Tanks, like the U.S. M1A1 Abrams or the German Leopard 2) "can be turned over like a turtle." This isn't even an issue -- modern tanks exert a ground pressure of well over 40 tons (60 or more tons for the Abrams), not exactly something "easy to flip over."
Anything standing on two legs, by the way, is much less stable than something built low and broad like a brick on treads.
| Quote: | | As for how realistic piracy is, it depends on what direction technology develops, and how far. |
I'm not sure what you mean by this. Delta vee is delta vee. Space is big. Even if you limited your space piracy to cislunar space, you'd have a hell of a time trying to intercept anything. They just have to change their vector and they're gone, unless you have far more delta vee than they do. Piracy in space is both expensive and impractical, and the returns would be minimal.
| Quote: | | Chances are good that there will be some form of space piracy some day assuming space travel ever becomes common, but it may not be very exciting in its actual implementation. |
On what do you base this conclusion? Space travel becoming common != the birth of space piracy. Now, *hijacking* a spaceship is a possibility, but intercepting and boarding a spaceship? Look how hard it is for the Space Shuttle to dock with the ISS -- and the ISS is on a predictable orbit.
| Quote: | | I think it could potentially make a great game though. |
It might, if you presented the game as space opera-ish, kind of like Star Wars. Any pretense of seriousness in the game would kill it for me. It's why I like Pirates! -- it's fun, swashbuckling adventure that you read about in books and watch on Saturday morning TV. It doesn't particularly pretend to be historically accurate.
The idea of a Ship of the Line only carrying 48 guns still makes me laugh.
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
bryce777

Gunner 
Posts: 628 

 
652 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jan 20, 2005 7:41 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Any way in which a ship could be taken over would be piracy.
It is silly to say a mech would cost more than a main battle tank, and it is incorrect to say two legs is less stable than treads. Treads are really very very limited.
Also, tanks being turned over is a very serious issue. A couple sticks of dynamite on the roadside is all it takes to turn over an abrahms tank, and in afghanistan the russians lost lots of tanks to unarmed foes...if you get 20 guys together, they can and have simply overturned tanks which renders them helpless.
Most likely a low to the ground chicken walker two leg mech or four leg mech is the future. They have experimented for many years in this. Like any new technology it might be more expensive at first, but even in the mechwarrior games the mechs in general range 20-110 tons. An MBT is already 70 tons. I think the new one after the abrahms is actually 90 tons.
These would not be giant 100 foot robots, but just replacements for treads on some tanks basically. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Illiad

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 13 


334 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jan 20, 2005 8:08 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| bryce777 wrote: | | Any way in which a ship could be taken over would be piracy. |
Ah, but would that be a fun "space pirate" game? Hijacking spaceships? I don't think that's what you intended. So my point stands.
| Quote: | | It is silly to say a mech would cost more than a main battle tank, and it is incorrect to say two legs is less stable than treads. Treads are really very very limited. |
Oddly enough, modern armies have been using tracked vehicles for over a century. In fact, tracked vehicles form the backbone of fast-attack forces over rough terrain for over half a century.
Mech technology is so new that it most certainly isn't silly to say that they'd cost more than an MBT. Simple engineering economics.
Two legs = smaller base of contact and a higher center of gravity. Treads = spread out, larger base of contact and much lower center of gravity. Ergo, treads (such as on MBTs) provide a more stable platform than legs. Put a GI Joe Doll next to a brick lying on it's widest surface. Which one is easier to knock over?
| Quote: | | Also, tanks being turned over is a very serious issue. A couple sticks of dynamite on the roadside is all it takes to turn over an abrahms tank... |
Where did you read that? Two sticks of dynamite can strip the treads off any tank, but flip it over? Really, if you have a case study, I'd love to read it. I just hadn't heard of that before.
| Quote: | | and in afghanistan the russians lost lots of tanks to unarmed foes...if you get 20 guys together, they can and have simply overturned tanks which renders them helpless. |
Please place these incidents in context. Ambush? Pitched battle? Was the tank already disarmed? Was this in an urban environment and were the tanks unprotected by infantry? Twenty men do not have the strength to physically overturn a 60 ton machine.
In general, tanks are desperately feared by infantry -- even the infantry of today -- because they're heavily armed and hard to kill. Infantrymen like to sneak up on tanks. Much easier to kill them in a city.
And what gives you the idea that a mech is going to be any safer than a tank in exactly the same circumstances? Why can't two sticks of dynamite remove a foot from a mech? Why can't twenty guys knock out a mech? And to boot, a mech is much more expensive than a tank.
| Quote: | | Most likely a low to the ground chicken walker two leg mech or four leg mech is the future. They have experimented for many years in this. |
This I am aware of, and I can see their utility -- but replacing tanks? Not likely. No biped or quadruped conveyance can match much less exceed the speed of a tracked vehicle. Speed is critical in today's mobile warfare.
| Quote: | | Like any new technology it might be more expensive at first, but even in the mechwarrior games the mechs in general range 20-110 tons. An MBT is already 70 tons. I think the new one after the abrahms is actually 90 tons. |
So lets consider the amount of miniaturization going on, and the sheer number of *moving parts!* Good God -- I wouldn't want to maintain anything like a mech on the battlefield. The cost would be staggering.
So when the new technology of the mech gets cheaper, so does the new technologies for tanks -- and tanks are still more stable, cheaper and therefore more efficient than mechs. How on earth would a mech replace a tank?
| Quote: | | These would not be giant 100 foot robots, but just replacements for treads on some tanks basically. |
I can buy that. What I can't buy is that they're the new Armour forces of tomorrow. They might serve as infantry support, but replace tanks? I think that's some mecha fan's pipe dream. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
bryce777

Gunner 
Posts: 628 

 
652 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Jan 21, 2005 7:52 pm Post subject: |
|
|
As I said before, while I am sure there will be some sort of piracy in the future I never said it would make for a fun game for it to be 100% factual.
legs can do things treads never could possibly do, and that is undisputed fact. Such as climbing or even leaping. Longer legs could even let a 'mech' cross a river that would require a tank bridge normally.
Every technology is expensive at first, but I already said that. An M1 is 10 times more expensive than a sherman tank at the minimum, but an M1 could also take out a small army of sherman tanks. The new tanks, I forget their names, are even more expensive. Whatever replaces them will be much more expensive then that initially, as well. New weapons cost money, but once they become the norm the price drops.
There are many things that can be done to overcome the amount of space of contact. On a tread, your real friction points are smaller than you think anyhow. They correspond to the wheels that turn the treads, not the total surface of the treads, because that is where all the weight lies.
With legs and perhaps arms, a mech that is knocked over could get up very easily, whereas a tank would be helpless and also very difficult to move.
As for being able to knock over tanks, you should try reading the news as the US has lost lots of tanks that way recently in Iraq. When on an embankment, you have leverage and it is easy to knock a tank over. You are not flipping it over with main force.
As for 20 men turning over a tank, fewer men could, and have, done it. You are not lifting it up and throwing it - you have leverage. Two men can very easily flip over a 5 ton car. 20 men is more than enough to flip over a tank. One really strong man could tur over a car - I know because I have seen it in person.
In a pitched battle, yes infantry will protect tanks and vice versa, but in situations like iraq and afghanistan tanks are used for patrol and protection and the troops stay int he tak so they don't get picked off. In this situation, it is very easy to take a tank by surprise and overturn it as happened again and again and again in afghanistan tot he russians.
Even in pitched battles there are many cases of this. Int he battle outside moscow where the germans were eventually finally stopped, 200 russian infantry without ANY anti-tank weapons, and they stopped over 50 tanks, using grenades or simply overturning them when the grenades ran out.
Anyway, skeptical as you amy be, these are the plans for the future of the US military. Plans change, but they have been working on walkers for more than 30 years now and eventually they will probably totally replace treaded vehicles.
| Illiad wrote: | | bryce777 wrote: | | Any way in which a ship could be taken over would be piracy. |
Ah, but would that be a fun "space pirate" game? Hijacking spaceships? I don't think that's what you intended. So my point stands.
| Quote: | | It is silly to say a mech would cost more than a main battle tank, and it is incorrect to say two legs is less stable than treads. Treads are really very very limited. |
Oddly enough, modern armies have been using tracked vehicles for over a century. In fact, tracked vehicles form the backbone of fast-attack forces over rough terrain for over half a century.
Mech technology is so new that it most certainly isn't silly to say that they'd cost more than an MBT. Simple engineering economics.
Two legs = smaller base of contact and a higher center of gravity. Treads = spread out, larger base of contact and much lower center of gravity. Ergo, treads (such as on MBTs) provide a more stable platform than legs. Put a GI Joe Doll next to a brick lying on it's widest surface. Which one is easier to knock over?
| Quote: | | Also, tanks being turned over is a very serious issue. A couple sticks of dynamite on the roadside is all it takes to turn over an abrahms tank... |
Where did you read that? Two sticks of dynamite can strip the treads off any tank, but flip it over? Really, if you have a case study, I'd love to read it. I just hadn't heard of that before.
| Quote: | | and in afghanistan the russians lost lots of tanks to unarmed foes...if you get 20 guys together, they can and have simply overturned tanks which renders them helpless. |
Please place these incidents in context. Ambush? Pitched battle? Was the tank already disarmed? Was this in an urban environment and were the tanks unprotected by infantry? Twenty men do not have the strength to physically overturn a 60 ton machine.
In general, tanks are desperately feared by infantry -- even the infantry of today -- because they're heavily armed and hard to kill. Infantrymen like to sneak up on tanks. Much easier to kill them in a city.
And what gives you the idea that a mech is going to be any safer than a tank in exactly the same circumstances? Why can't two sticks of dynamite remove a foot from a mech? Why can't twenty guys knock out a mech? And to boot, a mech is much more expensive than a tank.
| Quote: | | Most likely a low to the ground chicken walker two leg mech or four leg mech is the future. They have experimented for many years in this. |
This I am aware of, and I can see their utility -- but replacing tanks? Not likely. No biped or quadruped conveyance can match much less exceed the speed of a tracked vehicle. Speed is critical in today's mobile warfare.
| Quote: | | Like any new technology it might be more expensive at first, but even in the mechwarrior games the mechs in general range 20-110 tons. An MBT is already 70 tons. I think the new one after the abrahms is actually 90 tons. |
So lets consider the amount of miniaturization going on, and the sheer number of *moving parts!* Good God -- I wouldn't want to maintain anything like a mech on the battlefield. The cost would be staggering.
So when the new technology of the mech gets cheaper, so does the new technologies for tanks -- and tanks are still more stable, cheaper and therefore more efficient than mechs. How on earth would a mech replace a tank?
| Quote: | | These would not be giant 100 foot robots, but just replacements for treads on some tanks basically. |
I can buy that. What I can't buy is that they're the new Armour forces of tomorrow. They might serve as infantry support, but replace tanks? I think that's some mecha fan's pipe dream. |
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
jeff204vk

Cutthroat 
Posts: 406 

 
529 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 22, 2012 5:21 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| rupertlittlebear wrote: | | Illiad wrote: | | We all know that Pirates! is less than realistic given that you have war canoes taking Frigates |
Seems to me that the Spanish Admiral in charge of that good old Armada had a similar comment as he sailed into the English Channel.
The Brits had some very small ships at that time and a number of pinnaces got decorated for their part in the action(s).
We also forget that Drake preferred the pinnace as his assault ship on the Spanish Main. |
To be fair, though, the game leaves out one advantage large ships have over small ones. If a huge ship rams something tiny in real life, most likely the smaller vessel will be destroyed and the people on it will drown. In the game, any ship touching another goes right to a duel, unless there's a huge player crew advantage. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|