| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Falconer

Captain 
Posts: 1839 

 
2865 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2004 6:05 am Post subject: Designer Diary 2 - Reality: Threat or Menace? |
|
|
This thread discusses Pirates! Designer diary 2. (http://www.gamespot.com/pc/strategy/sidpirates/preview_6102516.html)
I think Jeff broached an interesting topic in this new designer diary: Do we, gamers in general, demand realism at the expense of fun?
I think this discussion started with the coming of VGA adapters. No one expected realism on Atari 2600's, Commodore 64's or PC's with Hercules or EGA cards. With the introduction of VGA cards, quite possibly in conjunction with the original Wolfenstein 3D game, I feel people started looking at games in a different light.
Obviously realism CAN be fun but how often does realism ruin the game experience for you and how often does it enhance it? For me, realistic racing games simply suck and when a single shot from a foe in Far Cry would kill me, I'd be taking the game back to the shop the day after I bought it.
In Pirates!, the team obviously chose fun over realism and Jeff's article on Gamespot gives us enough to imagine how realism would kill gameplay in Pirates!
So, how do you people feel about this? What does realism in games mean to you and what do you think about Firaxis' reasons to go for fun? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
John Buford

Guest 


 
0 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2004 11:11 am Post subject: |
|
|
hello all,
for me realism in games is the most important single factor if i like a game or not. it depends on the genre what realism exactly means. i was a bit "shocked" as i read Jeff remarks about realism and fun. for me there is no fun without realism, so i fear i can skip sid's remake. i hoped the new pirates would stick to a game concept like cutthroats, with better GUI. but i understand that firaxis and atari will make the game in a way to earn the most money. and with at least a decent realism like in the original pirates, you cant reach the selling numbers you need to earn that money.
well this all doesnt mean pirates wont be a good game. but for me realism IS fun. so it seems the new pirates wont be a game for me as i cant find the fun in it, i am seeking for.
Regards
John Buford |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Falconer

Captain 
Posts: 1839 

 
2865 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2004 7:58 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Hi John, welcome.
Did you play the original? Because there wasn't a whole lot of realism in the game back then. It really seems to me it will be a true remake which means the level of realism will be about the same as the original. Will give you a pretty decent idea wether you'll like it or not, right?
Anyways, I agree on the genre thing. I mean, a tactical shooter like Splinter Cell should be VERY high on realism, so there are genres that need it. I'm inclined to agree with Jeff when he argues that a pirate themed game wouldn't be much fun if it is too realistic though. I think his point about the player wanting to fight against the odds is very true. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Matt

Guest 


 
0 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2004 8:46 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I played the original on my old C64 and C128D till I burnt through about 5 sets of the game. While realism is important to me, so is having a fun time. I personally think they should make a compromise between both fun and realism. Disease should DEFINITELY be a part of the game though. That was so much a part of the life back then. Sadly, I've not read Jeff's notes as I'm at work and the site is blocked, so I don't know just how much of the realism has been removed. I hope it won't be a campy kiddy kind of game that makes one out to be invincible to everything as that won't be much fun at all. We should have to face all kinds of challenges but perhaps have a bit of luck on the side to get through it all.
Perhaps, and I know it's probably late for this, they should have the realism based upon the difficulty rating of the game itself. High difficulty means tons of realism but not as much fun (starving in a boat going no-where with angry men isn't much fun) while very low difficulty means little realism but oodles of fun. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Guest




 
0 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2004 11:21 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I tend to agree with Matt about the realism going along with the difficulty level in the game. The easy levels (if there will indeed be difficulty levels) should be simple with limited realism, while at the higher levels, your crew should become sick, be more inclined to mutiny if you're not making money andit should be harder to impress governors and their daughters.
After saying all that though, I'd rather play a game high on fun rather than one high on realism. Lets face it, who wants to have to go to the merchant to buy oranges so your crew doesn't die of scurvy - not me.
I think the team at Firaxis has probably done the right thing by making the game not too realistic. Sure there should be some realism about the game, but don't bore everyone with small details. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
KingWilly

Rigger 
Posts: 1298 

 
9917 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Jul 15, 2004 11:24 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Damn, I forgot to log in. That was my post above. _________________ Shiver me timbers!!!
"It's good to be the king" - Mel Brooks
AKA. Will Scarlett. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
PiratesFan

Rigger 
Posts: 1659 


23695 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 3:55 am Post subject: |
|
|
If it plays anything like the original PIrates! realism to an extent should be there. I mean really ... I coudn't keep a crew happy ... of course I had 600 men or plus all the time. They was always mutiny with that many... I think that really hit a realistic idea of Pirates! ... Losing battles and being sent to prison was pretty normal too.. cause they wanted the pirate to face charges and have a public execution in order to show why you shouldn't be a pirate. I mean the original Pirates had quite a bit of realism to it. Sailing was a little too realistic.. Hates going through the wind the opposite direction.... that really sucked.It also had a lot of fun to it to without realistic things happening. Like my favorite sea battles against a fort. I mean one ship against a 250 men on a sea fort... ummmm yeah right, but was fun.
I like relism in racing games just cause I love to be able to tweak a cat and it do what it is supposed to do cause of the tweak. Gran Turismo is my example there. But even they know not to go to far on realism. For instance the cars don't crumple (but that has to do with licensing also with the car manufacturers). I like a fine line of realism mised with fun....
My opinion of course
PF |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Falconer

Captain 
Posts: 1839 

 
2865 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Fri Jul 16, 2004 4:51 am Post subject: |
|
|
Hey Matt, welcome to you too. You alls should register you know!
I would be very surprised if the crew happiness would be taken out, so that bit of realism and prison and such will likeley still be there. The crew stuff could be very frustrating though. It made it very hard to attack medium sized cities and almost impossible to have a go at the large cities. In a way, that was a really good 'difficulty level' that YOU pushed the limits of, depending on how far you would like to take the game. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Sonicsfan

Cutthroat 
Posts: 347 

 
1729 Gold -

|
Posted: Sat Jul 17, 2004 4:04 am Post subject: |
|
|
Maybe it was tuff to go to the east direction with your ship,but i like it that way,i hope that kind of realism stays the same.What diseases and ruthless pirates concern,they may cut that part.We don't wanna make it a horror game but a nice adventure game. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
El Diablo

Cutthroat 
Posts: 305 


218 Gold -

|
Posted: Sun Jul 18, 2004 4:04 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Realism is quite important for me - but it has to stop at the point where it meets the scope of the game.
Realism has to be smoothly in line with the story, the idea and the "red line" in a game.
If it leaves the support, one has to either cut it at that point or one has to change the games' idea. Which would be in most cases the more difficult way. _________________ Don't consider a creation to beeing perfect, unless you sat on it from dusk till dawn |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Guest




 
0 Gold -

|
Posted: Sun Jul 18, 2004 8:04 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Falconer wrote: | Hi John, welcome.
Did you play the original? Because there wasn't a whole lot of realism in the game back then. It really seems to me it will be a true remake which means the level of realism will be about the same as the original. Will give you a pretty decent idea wether you'll like it or not, right?
|
Thank you for the Welcome !
Yes i played the original a lot and loved it..and you are right it hasnt much focus on realism. Since Cutthroat was released i hoped someone would pick up the trail of Hot House Creations...but Firaxis wont do it.
I dont know if they will release a demo, but if they do i will for sure check it out and decide then if i buy it or not...
Regards
JB |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Firaxis_Barry

Firaxian 
Posts: 26 
 

347 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2004 6:18 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| John Buford wrote: | but i understand that firaxis and atari will make the game in a way to earn the most money. and with at least a decent realism like in the original pirates, you cant reach the selling numbers you need to earn that money.
Regards
John Buford |
Hi John,
Sid doesn't think about sales or money when he's working on a game. He has always been solely interested in making games he thinks are fun and sales just seem to follow that philosophy. It's not that there isn't any realism in the Pirates! remake - there is at least as much as in the original game - it's just that Sid is going to let fun trump realism if there is a conflict between the two.
-Barry _________________ Barry Caudill
Pirates Producer
Senior Producer - Civilization IV
Firaxis Games |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Guest




 
0 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Jul 19, 2004 7:32 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Firaxis_Barry wrote: |
Hi John,
Sid doesn't think about sales or money when he's working on a game. He has always been solely interested in making games he thinks are fun and sales just seem to follow that philosophy. It's not that there isn't any realism in the Pirates! remake - there is at least as much as in the original game - it's just that Sid is going to let fun trump realism if there is a conflict between the two.
-Barry |
Hi Barry,
i am sure Sid's primary concern is to make fun and good games. All the best for Firaxis and Pirates!
Regards
-JB |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|