Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

Expansion or Sequel Ideas
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> General Hints and strategies Goto page 1, 2  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Riddari
Powder Monkey
Posts: 27



551 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed Feb 08, 2006 9:48 pm    Post subject: Expansion or Sequel Ideas Reply with quote

Does anyone else think that Pirates! needs an expansion or sequel? I am not trying to suggest that the game is not awesome as it is, but I think there is still a lot of room for improvement. It also appears that Pirates! has been successful enough to justify a sequel, though I really have no idea how much of a success the game was or was not. Regardless, here are a few ideas I have had for ways to improve on the Pirates! experience.

First, I would like to see more consequences for our actions. The main implementation of this would be to allow for demotions. Instead of just earning a rank once, we would have to actually maintain relations with a country to keep that rank, much more so to improve it. I know a lot of people would not want to be burdened with this, so it could be tied to a higher difficulty level or maybe even just an option to make the game more difficult. Another thing that should have a consequence is refusing the advances of one of the daughters. They just never seem to understand when you say you are not interested. I know this is suppose to allow the player to come back later, but making it a three option response would be nice. Something like "I just happen to hav ea diamond necklace right here.". "Really, I will see if I can find something for you." or "For you, are you kidding?". The last option there would tell the girl to leave you alone. Finally, the Indian, pirate and missionary relations should be implemented and there should be ways to develop those relations beyond just buying the right items. For pirates, they could just base their respect on how many ships you loot, etc. The missionaries could pay more attention to how you treat their immigrants. For the Indians, I think they could probably have some quests for you to follow in order to make them happy.

Second, it would be nice if things were a lot less repetitive. Picking on the daughters again, do they really all want the same diamond necklace or ruby ring? Could we have a few more items out there that we have to find for specific girls? Maybe that cutie in San Juan wants a bracelet with her birthstones in it. This applies to every step of the courtship. There should be several different possibilities with several different outcomes. Heck, tying in the first suggestion, maybe it should even be possible to fail to please the girl. Maybe if you don’t visit her for a year or so, she falls for some other pirate or nobleman. Having different encounters with the “Evil” guys would be nice too. Instead of finding them on their ship every time, hide them on deserted islands where you have to track them down and have a land battle with them.

Third, it would be nice to have some different story lines. Maybe make the story line depend on which time you start in. Then there would be more reason to try the different scenarios. I am not going to pretend to have enough ideas for that many different stories, but I am also not a creative writer. Maybe in one of the scenarios, you could be the son of one of the governors who has been exiled for a crime you did not commit. The goal could be to prove your innocence, by pirating of course, and regain your father’s respect.

Anyway, I am sure most of you also have ideas for stuff like this. So, I thought it would be fun to bounce some ideas around and dream about the possibilities. Try not to be too cruel to any pathetic ideas, like my innocent pirate one. Wink
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
DJ1
Cutthroat
Posts: 250


11547 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 09, 2006 1:33 am    Post subject: Re: Expansion or Sequel Ideas Reply with quote

very good ideas here.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
jbsmith
Cutthroat
Posts: 276



835 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Thu Feb 09, 2006 4:33 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

i would like to be able to start and place my very own pirate haven anywhere i choose to on the map. My own little fiefdom.
The named pirates have thier own until you capture the cap'n at sea.
And maybe even have the option of making it a nationality settlement of wich i am the mayor.
To make the choice, Haven or Settlement interesting each has its own
pros and cons:
Differences-Strategic choices to Make
if choose Haven
Forte:
Free repairs to your Ships
One or Two free upgrades to your ships
Like all pirate havens, they cannot be sacked or captured by anyone,
after all this IS your safe haven.
Foible:
Like at all pirate havens, a poor merchant with little more than rations to
sell.

if you choose National Settlement
Forte:
A merchant that does well, stocks everything, not too rich or poor, just like
settlement merchants. You get a cut of its profits.
Ship repairs are Free,,you Are the mayor after all.
A fort a garrison to protect the place.
the tavern,,here to you get a small cut of its profits.

Foible:
A "tax" to pay to the Crown to pay for the Fort and Garrison.
They are after all the Kings/Queens Troops.
[the "tax" won't excede your profit cut from the merchant and tavern.]
Must pay for ship upgrades until a rank is achieved just like any other port
of any nation.
Open to attack. Must recapture if conquered by foriegn power.

The option of romance and marry the barmaids! get them a little more
invloved in the game. nothing wrong with a common wench for a wife.
[back in those days the term "wench was a positive Compliment]

When i sack a city, the chance to plunder and clean out the merchants
shops as well!
Hey ,we are Pirates, its not as if we tell our crews "do battle with the garrison,sack the city,take the doubloons, but looting the merchants store is off limits!" like it is in the present game. Real pirates would loot the merchants in a heartbeat,
no different than taking the goods in a captured ships hold.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Cpt John Fabris
Powder Monkey
Posts: 20



235 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 09, 2006 6:32 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Apart from having fore and aft cannons and the ability to fire both broadsides if surrounded and with enough crew, what I'd favour in any remake or sequel is punishment.

At the moment, I can raid say Spanish ships and ports with abandon, and if I lose a duel, just end up in jail for maybe 18 months with at least one chance to escape in that time. I'd prefer there to be hangings.
In this scenario, if you get picked up by your enemies and incarcerated, you will be locked up for say 6-8 months and have an opportunity to escape (maybe the number of opportunities could be linked to the level you are playing at, so 1 for swashbuckler, but 3 for apprentice? or maybe no death in apprentice). This way there is no easy option. You escape, or you'll be dancin' the hempen jig and game over for that character.
_________________
'I'm gonna buy me a gun just as long as my arm and kill everyone who ever done me harm' - Jeffrey Lee Pierce
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Riddari
Powder Monkey
Posts: 27



551 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 09, 2006 8:10 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I like the home base idea of jbsmith's. An expansion on that idea, which might be a bit too much to retain a reasonable rating, is to allow us, as pirates, to kidnap the govenor's daughters. Of course, this would be high treason and instantly earn a price on your head, which grows until she is returned, or you convince her to marry you. This would be an alternative to , not a replacement of , the current courting system. This would be a tougher way to go, but if successful your wife would be in your home city rather than across the sea. Of course, they could always just allow us to transport our wives.

I definately agree with the punishment idea. I think it has to be reserved for the higher level difficulties, though. An Apprentice should be allowed to make a lot of mistakes. A Journeyman should be allowed to make some mistake. A swashbuckler should not be allowed to make any mistakes. I could even see it going as far as not allowing you to keep backup copies of the game. I am not sure how they could accomplish this, but it would be cool if they could have a "hardcore" setting like other games have where you are not allowed to reload the game to correct errors. I know you can accomplish this with some self-discipline, but without proof that you never reloaded, you can't really brag about the accomplishment.

Another idea along the lines of punishment is that when your crew mutinies, you could have to fight them with your loyal crew. If you loose, they either throw you off the ship, as when you loose to another captain and have no backup ship, or in extreme cases they could hang you from the mast.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Belegorm
Powder Monkey
Posts: 44



202 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 10, 2006 12:27 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I'd like a secret hideout, like in Port Royale, where you do a bit of work getting a map to the hideout (the hideout would be on the coast), discover it, bring immigrants to it, get ship repairs for free, produce goods cheaper, and have a nice place to hide from pirate hunters.
_________________
Uhh, to lazy to think of anything clever, yet...
*five months later*
Uhh, yeah, I'll get around to it eventually...
Maybe it'll be on my headstone...
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Azlat
Swabbie
Posts: 57



2010 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 10, 2006 1:25 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

How about this...

Take over a town, and instead of appointing a guvner from another coutry, plant a pirate captain?

Turn a normal town into a fully functional town of nothing but pirates.

It could get troops for defense from Pirate Havens, and immigrants from regular old missions or other pirate havens.

Imagine the entire Caribee owned by pirates!
_________________
Bring her about and make ready the guns!!

Break forth cutlasses and pistols men, and remember the hell that forged you!!

YARR!!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Riddari
Powder Monkey
Posts: 27



551 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 10, 2006 2:20 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I like the idea of converting towns to pirate safe havens. Really, it would be nice if any town could be converted to any other type of town. There are too many "safe" places. I never understood why you could sack a capital but not a settlement. Sure, you would not get as much from the settlement, but it would be easier to take as well. Anyway, being able to upgrade and downgrade towns would be interesting. Also, allowing Indians and Pirates to conquer a town would put quite a twist in getting them to do your dirty work. It would also be a great way to develop relations with them. Sack too many Indian towns and they won't like you any more than the Spanish generally do.

The only problem I have with the suggestion is the part about immigrants populating the safe havens. I just can't imagine why the missionaries would send their immigrants to such unsavory places. The same would really be true of the Indian towns. Not that the Indians would not take care of them, as they often did. Its just that the missionaries really did not like the Indians. You could be allowed the capture immigrants and force them into these towns, but I am not sure that would improve the situation any.

I kind of like that pirate safe havens are fairly desolate places. That is kind of how they should be. Of course, a safe haven could always grow by attracting more pirates. That could be immigrants of a different kind.

Don't take any of the above as picking on this idea. I actually think it would really improve the dynamics of the various relations in the game. If would be cool to convert every town to Pirates or Indians and watch the big four squirm. Wink
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Cpt John Fabris
Powder Monkey
Posts: 20



235 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 10, 2006 3:34 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

A few more thoughts...

Game play:
You probably should be able to 'annex' the pirate havens and the indian villages to add them to your country of choice, in the sense of the Spanish conquering the indians or something. Equally if the game's powers did this themselves then you could find favour with the indian or pirate faction by stopping the invasion force. You could also play through more accurately a historic period, like when Tortuga was a pirate haven until it was finally civilised in c.1684.
How about also restricting the named pirates to their own era? It always seemed strange to see pirates from 70-80 years apart in the same period. There must be other famous pirates not featured, and if not it can't be hard to create some.

Plus, how about having a Total War style land battles element? Seems daft that ship battles, and duels are in real time, but land battles are some 2D turn based thing. Land battles are positively my pet hate of the game.

Cosmetic changes:
I for one would also favour the cosmetic change of having voice actors actually say the dialog lines in the game. Whilst 'Chuvaan' etc are amusing, it does get irritating. Speak a proper language! Taking it to extremes I'd favour the various nations speaking their own language, just with subtitles/dialog box for the player to follow it when in a foreign port. Surely there aren't that many lines of dialog in the game?

Oh, and can we please have a Portuguese presence in the game? It wasn't just England, France, Spain and the Netherlands active at that time.
_________________
'I'm gonna buy me a gun just as long as my arm and kill everyone who ever done me harm' - Jeffrey Lee Pierce
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Azlat
Swabbie
Posts: 57



2010 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 10, 2006 5:28 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Riddiari,

Good point about the immigrants, I never really thought about the whole morals thing form the missions. But I still think that the indians taking over a town would be great as well. maybe if they attack a town, and win, the town disappears, or is left in ruins.

Oh!!Oh!! There's an idea! Indians actually sack a town and leave it in ruins! You can explore it and find lost treasures!!! Just an idea! maybe even repopulate it with a country of your choice. However, you would have to go to a settlement and get a Guvner first! Then you have to get immigrants for it. Adds a whole new dynamic for the game.

Thoughts??

Cpt John Fabris,


I agree with your idea about the countries taking over Indian villages and turning it into a settlement for the country.

Even better, what about the countries starting to hunt down and destroy pirate havens? Turning it into a settlement for that country as well.

With either of these, your going to get a lot more immigrant ships, troop ships, and military payroll ships. The other side is that towns will get big and well defended in a hurry. But they will be able to lauch larger invasion forces and raiders to take over another country's cities.

Thoughts??
_________________
Bring her about and make ready the guns!!

Break forth cutlasses and pistols men, and remember the hell that forged you!!

YARR!!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
WhiteWolf
Powder Monkey
Posts: 31



255 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 10, 2006 5:46 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Just jumping in here, but in the articles section of this site it mentions that there is/was a Pirates 2 in the works. Has this been trashed or is it still being worked on?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Azlat
Swabbie
Posts: 57



2010 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Feb 13, 2006 1:36 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Ok here is a suggestion for a Pirates! expansion.

MULTIPLAYER!!

Imagine, log into the game and lay waste to towns with your friends.

Defeat huge armadas that can get sent after you.

Team up with your fellow Pirates and go after a much increased Treasure Fleet, complete with heavy escort, and a whole lot more plunder.

Develop teams and go after other pirate teams for booty and fame.

Just a thought.
_________________
Bring her about and make ready the guns!!

Break forth cutlasses and pistols men, and remember the hell that forged you!!

YARR!!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
WhiteWolf
Powder Monkey
Posts: 31



255 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Feb 13, 2006 6:20 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Multiplayer would be so awesome. It would be fun to play on opposing teams and try to blast each other's ships to splinters. Of course, if my boyfriend did that to me, he would have many long night in the doghouse. lol
Romancing would be fun. We could sword fight one another for the girl's affection instead of the suitor.
Oh now this is so much fun to imagine I can't imagine why it's not in the game now. lol
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Azlat
Swabbie
Posts: 57



2010 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 14, 2006 12:38 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

WhiteWolf,

Here is another idea for multiplayer or a flat out expansion, being able to play as an Indian!

You could slaughter anything and everything and no one would care. Think about the possibilities of that one.
_________________
Bring her about and make ready the guns!!

Break forth cutlasses and pistols men, and remember the hell that forged you!!

YARR!!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
kvollmer
Cutthroat
Posts: 285



6103 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Tue Feb 14, 2006 6:04 pm    Post subject: noticing Reply with quote

I'm noticing you guys forgot something that I felt should be in there. A way of balancing the game so that being a peaceful trader has its advantages. Perhaps you can even start the game choosing one or the other and having different quests and points for each one. Either that or you have a main game as a pirate but a sub-game so to speak as a peaceful trader. Perhaps even having one as a privateer.

Pirate = wealth + fame (fame can be through marriage, treasures, lost cities, and not getting caught) However the balancing aspect is that pirate hunters are everywhere and any passing ship that thinks it can take you automatically attacks (especially with high bounty on your head) If you get caught you automatically lose. You can earn ranks with one country but it doesn't count for much and you lose ranks quick if you turn on them. No multiple ranks.

Privateer game = weath + land + ranks + marriage. Countries that are at war with your country will attack you if they think they can take you. All others leave you alone.

Trader = wealth + marrage. . . If you are a trader then pirates and privateers who's nations are at war with yours will attack. All others leave you alone.

Also this affects the type of crew you will select. Pirate crews are the best fighters out there and literally will fight to the death. But they also take large portions of the loot when divided. Only flagship may be kept all others sold.

Privateer crews are almost as good as pirate crews but may surrender in adverse conditions. However they are fercely loyal to their host nation and can only be recruited in host nation ports. They may mutiny if you try to attack the shipping of their host nation. Take a middle portion of loot but also allow you to keep a small fleet.

Trader crews are horrible fighters and will often mutiny if you attack too much. However they also take the least share of the loot when divided. You can also keep your entire fleet with traders.

Also there should be more options in terms of getting your family back other then fighting. (If that was kept in the game) Especially traders, maybe have them track a bunch of clues and perhaps duel in a tavern for the map pieces. However going after ships is diffiicult for traders. Same thing for vengence.

Privateers can both duel or go after ships but they always fly under enemy flags.

Pirates it just doesn't matter that much.

For traders especially you should be able to purchase ships in ports.

Marriage especially for privateers and traders should be about how high you marry. You can romance and marry from any level going from the daughter of some guy on the street to a major nobleman. Some in the middle would be the daughter of a governor, military officer, a merchant, ship maker, farmer etc etc. Also Governor's daughters are effected by the prestige of the city of which their dad is governor. So if a city is really wealthy then she is a rather high marriage while the daughter of the governor of a tiny backwater stronghold with no money isn't really much better then the daughter of a military officer.

Attractivness can be somewhat of a factor. If they really want to get complex they could make the daughter's age a factor. Daughters of course get married but new one's appear as they reach marriageble age. The ideal daughter is a beatiful daughter of a nobleman while she is still a teenager. Of course the reason for this is the same as the reasons back then. Its a question of how many kids she can give you. Althought the age thing may make it somewhat complex so its sort of optional.

At higher level marriages you may need to woo their dad more then you need to woo the daughter. You should still have dancing and things like that but the daughter of a nobleman typically had a husband selected for her so if you undertake missions for her dad and you have good wealth and score then he may offer his daughter.

Also retirement age should play a part in your final score. The younger you retire the better. Of course pirates and privateers may be forced to retire young but traders can work for longer. (this being balanced by the fact that pirates and privateers have much higher profit margins.)

Whew thats a long post, but I think those changes may make it a bit more balanced and a lot more realistic.
_________________
Sincerly,


Kirk Vollmer
Don't ever call me Captain Kirk.
Valparaiso University Alumni; Class of 2004
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> General Hints and strategies All times are GMT
Goto page 1, 2  Next
Page 1 of 2

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group