I love the game, it's one of the only sequels to a classic game that is as good or better than the original but I think some minor changes would make it even better.
1. The treasure fleet is underwhelming. In the original game it was a Big Deal. In this game it's just 3-4 ships that often have less gold than some random pirate hunter! You also can't catch the treasure fleet in port which was awesome in the old game. If the ships had at least 5k gold each plus possibly more then it would make it much more exciting and work trying to track down. As it stands it's just meh.
2. Attacking a ship and not being allowed to keep/sink it. If you attack a ship of the line and have a full fleet, you lose it! That has happened to me several times. Also annoying when you want to sink an escort ship to pick up some free men and you are not allowed to! Ideally we should be able to take any ship, then be forced to remove a ship at the end so we can pick the one to lose.
3. Giving clues about raymundo when montalban is running around! This gets annoying and also makes no sense, tell me about the most important guy not the least. Also, don't tell me about raymundo when I dance with the daughters once he is in play, it is a waste of time and effort. This aspect of the game can be a real drag.
4. More gold for merchants. Trading in the game is kind of pointless as it is, not that it should be the main point but it often gets totally pointless to drag around loot at all.
5. Dumping the most expensive cargo. You should be allowed to dump what you want, usually there is a whole bunch of food and cannon but they end up dumping luxuries instead. This is the other thing that really puts a dent in the profits not just of trading but of even keeping cargo at all.
All in all surprising I can't think of more flaws than that, and all fairly minor. What is on your wish list? |