
The myth of the ‘stolen country’
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
corsair91

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10372 

 
296935 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Sat Sep 26, 2020 6:01 pm Post subject: The myth of the ‘stolen country’ |
|
|
The myth of the ‘stolen country’
What should the Europeans have done with the New World?
From magazine issue: 26 September 2020
Jeff Fynn-Paul
https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-myth-of-the-stolen-country
Read article for full details
Selection of quotes:
...
democracies thrive or fail on the basis of national stories.
In the end, stories are all we’ve got as a glue to cement us together as a society.
Many in the US seem to have no clue just how much of a ‘city on a hill’ the US is still perceived to be, and how important that American beacon is to millions of people living under autocratic regimes.
Even though republican regimes are historically less popular internationally, for billions of people around the globe the US still equates with democracy — it is ‘the good place’.
If the image of US is fundamentally delegitimised, if it’s entire raison d’être is tainted, then increasing numbers of people wonder whether democracy itself is worth the trouble. So we have to be very careful what we wish for.
First, no matter who ‘discovered’ the New World, it is inevitable that a large proportion of New World inhabitants would have died within the first few decades after first contact.
The idea that the Europeans stole some land which had belonged in perpetuity to any one tribe is therefore ludicrous.
What the Europeans did in the New World was insert themselves into a fluid power struggle which had been ongoing for millennia.
Despite a few sensational cases of duplicity, most of the time, Europeans tried to buy land from Indians, just like they would buy an acre of land in England.
Many individual Europeans believed that according to the norms of both parties, they had legal usufruct to the land they were working
what precisely would our pious anthropology professors have had Europeans do with the New World once they found it?
The reality is, if the English had not colonised, then the French or the Dutch would have. If the Spanish had not colonised, the Portuguese would have. This would have shifted the balance of power at home, and any European country which had not colonised, would have been relegated to secondary status. And it is easy to overestimate the amount of control that European governments actually had.
It was extremely dangerous for Europeans to provoke fights with Native Americans, and most of them tried to avoid this when possible.
In retrospect, one could in theory be impressed that so many European governments showed a genuine concern to rein in the worst excesses of their subjects, with an express eye to protecting the Indians from depredation. The logic was simple: they attempted to protect their subjects at home, in order to secure good order and a better tax base. So they would do the same to their subjects in the New World.
In fact, the European track record shows them to be almost shockingly un-genocidal, given their clear technological advantages over the rest of the world for a period of several centuries.
Few other civilisations, given similar power over so much of the world’s people, would have behaved in a less reprehensible manner. This is not to give Europeans a pat on the back. Rather it is to point out that Europeans are regularly painted as the very worst society on Earth, when in fact they had the power to do far, far more evil than they actually did. Let us at least acknowledge this fact.
whenever a good idea comes along, which clearly increases one’s living standards, one tends to adopt it
And who is to say that this adaptation is bad, especially if it results in higher living standards?
Even as they discovered America, the Europeans were in the process of adopting dozens of superior Chinese inventions and ideas: paper money, gunpowder, pasta and fine porcelain are only the most famous.
Native Americans were quick to adapt the many useful Old World ideas which Europeans happened to carry with them, most had been adopted by Europeans from other Old World cultures
Why grind corn laboriously by hand for several hours a day, when one can use millstones instead? Why hunt with bow and arrow, when one can use a rifle? Why refuse to domesticate cattle, when they provide huge boosts in caloric intake for your family? Why refuse to adopt the wheel, for goodness sake?
Rather than jealously guard their technological superiority, many Europeans were ready to trade anything that Native Americans might want, including firearms. This made it inevitable that New World society would be changed beyond recognition, once sustained contact was initiated.
From the get-go, Isabella of Spain expressly forbade the enslavement of her New World subjects. Instead, she showed a genuine desire to bring them into what for her constituted the folds of civilisation, as Christian equals. So historians must grudgingly concede that the Spanish Crown, for its part, was likewise not nearly as bloodthirsty, genocidal or racist as they clearly hope to find.
Indians were ready to adopt whatever European ways made their lives more comfortable. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Salty Dog

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10063 

 
192187 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Sat Sep 26, 2020 9:05 pm Post subject: |
|
|
What makes the US so exceptional is the adherence to a Constitution and the acceptance of Multicultural citizenry. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2020 2:27 am Post subject: |
|
|
Thanks, corsair91. Interesting article. I generally agree with the concluding attack on cultural Marxism. But, as a student of economic history, I question a few of his assertions.
| Quote: | | This would have shifted the balance of power at home, and any European country which had not colonised, would have been relegated to secondary status. |
Colonization, for the most part, did not provide net benefits to the colonizing nation. It was of benefit to the ruling and commercial classes who received the direct benefits of colonialism, but it was not so good for the lower classes who had to pay the taxes and provide the soldiers to fight the wars of colonization. Similarly, colonization tended to benefit the leaders of the colonized peoples, who were paid handsomely for submitting and cooperating, but was not so good for the lower classes.
Spain benefited in the short term not by honest trade, but by extracting gold, either by stealing it or by enslaving the natives to mine it. But in the long run that wasn't so good for Spain. The Spaniards inserted so much gold into Europe that the value of gold was inflated away, reducing the value of Spain's efforts relative to nations that focused on production of useful goods instead of gold extraction.
| Quote: | | In retrospect, one could in theory be impressed that so many European governments showed a genuine concern to rein in the worst excesses of their subjects, with an express eye to protecting the Indians from depredation. The logic was simple: they attempted to protect their subjects at home, in order to secure good order and a better tax base. So they would do the same to their subjects in the New World. |
This might be logical, but it is not historical. The Europeans came up with ingenious arguments to rationalize their enslavement and exploitation of Native Americans. Example: The lifestyle of tropical hunter-gatherers seemed too easy and lazy to hardworking Europeans. The apparently prelapsarian lifestyle was an affront to Catholics and Calvinists. They rationalized that by imposing the discipline and suffering of hard work, they were saving the souls of the savages.
| Quote: | | Let’s remember that Columbus was first and foremost a merchant. His main purpose was to open a trade route to China. Europeans realised that China had better stuff. |
The author is apparently not familiar with the biography of Columbus. He was obsessed with receiving land grants and appointments to office in the lands he discovered. He put much effort into lobbying the Spanish monarchy for delivery of what he regarded as his due, and his heirs continued that campaign. Columbus served as Governor of the Indies until 1499, after which he was recalled to Spain to face accusations of brutality towards the natives. Under his stewardship, the Taino population of Hispaniola was enslaved and nearly exterminated. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
corsair91

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10372 

 
296935 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2020 6:10 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I had a few issues with certain statements as well.
Colonization was sort of a relief valve for the home countries.
Certain people who could have proved extremely troublesome
went elsewhere.
For example the Pilgrim fathers, The English were only too glad
to be rid of them.
Descent from the Pilgrim fathers is not regarded by the English
as having any social advantage, but rather potentially have mental
sanity issues in the family tree.
Financial support of colonies was an ongoing issue.
Standing armies and colony improvements cost money.
The British making Americans pay more,
provoked the American revolution.
Local american gentry were there to make money,
not for others to make money off them by taxes.
What the Home countries governments intended,
was not always what achived in the colonies.
Self-enrichment was a major motivation of the colonial officials
and local gentry. Local native populations stood in the way
and had to be dealt with.
Finish off the native populations was a constant issue,
In colonial america, indentured lower class introduced to replace the
native population labor.
In Ireland an early English colony, all the native Irish were to be
originally exterminated, only for the Protestant gentry to realise they
needed the labor and it never fully happened, not for lack of trying.
See the Irish penal laws for more info and what was tried
short of extermination.
Penal Laws
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penal_Laws
The lower classes did not initially have the vote.
Seem to recall in England initial certain property requirements
for the vote. Gentry had a lock on parliment seat holders.
Spanish mines priority was wealth production,
keep the gold and silver flowing.
Care of the native miners was not a priority as always more
where they came from.
One treasure fleet shipwreck salvaged by the Spanish
had more silver recovered than on the manifest,
Silver smuggling was frequent and even more mining by the natives.
Columbus exploited the native population to the full.
Originally he wanted to sail to china and the indies
to make money, only for the americas to get in the way.
Evil is evil, not doing as much as you could doesn't excuse
what was actually done. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|