
Forgetting the Alamo
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
corsair91

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10372 

 
296923 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Sun May 03, 2020 2:16 pm Post subject: Forgetting the Alamo |
|
|
Forgetting the Alamo
https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4457
The myths and facts behind the events that made the Alamo famous reveal it may not be worth remembering much.
by Jeff Wagg
March 10, 2015
Thanks to movies and advertisements, The Alamo has become a permanent part of the American story. But how accurate is that story, and is it a story worth remembering? In this episode, I'll examine some of the many assumptions about the place and event known as "The Alamo" and try to add a bit of context to the legend that endures.
First, the short, basic version of the story from the official website of the Alamo:
On February 23, 1836, the arrival of General Antonio López de Santa Anna's army outside San Antonio nearly caught them by surprise. Undaunted, the Texians and Tejanos prepared to defend the Alamo together. The defenders held out for 13 days against Santa Anna's army.
William B. Travis, the commander of the Alamo sent forth couriers carrying pleas for help to communities in Texas. On the eighth day of the siege, a band of 32 volunteers from Gonzales arrived, bringing the number of defenders to nearly two hundred. Legend holds that with the possibility of additional help fading, Colonel Travis drew a line on the ground and asked any man willing to stay and fight to step over — all except one did.
As the defenders saw it, the Alamo was the key to the defense of Texas, and they were ready to give their lives rather than surrender their position to General Santa Anna. Among the Alamo's garrison were Jim Bowie, renowned knife fighter, and David Crockett, famed frontiersman and former congressman from Tennessee.
The final assault came before daybreak on the morning of March 6, 1836, as columns of Mexican soldiers emerged from the predawn darkness and headed for the Alamo's walls. Cannon and small arms fire from inside the Alamo beat back several attacks. Regrouping, the Mexicans scaled the walls and rushed into the compound.
Once inside, they turned a captured cannon on the Long Barrack and church, blasting open the barricaded doors. The desperate struggle continued until the defenders were overwhelmed. By sunrise, the battle had ended and Santa Anna entered the Alamo compound to survey the scene of his victory.
As with all shortened versions of stories, this one leaves out some important facts. Let's examine a few to see if we can get a better picture of what happened that day.
The Alamo is a distinctive building with an arched facade.
Let's get this one out the way quickly. "The Alamo" refers to a fortress about four acres in size. The building that is commonly associated with the words "the Alamo" was an unfinished chapel built on the site of Mission San Antonio de Valero, a Spanish Catholic mission tasked with converting the native population. Some of that native population, the Payaya, provided the manual labor for building the mission.
After about 75 years, the mission was secularized and no longer had any religious significance. The well-known chapel building remained unfinished and without a roof.
In 1803, a Spanish force converted the area into a temporary, walled fortress, with the chapel in one corner. They built a ramp inside the structure to mount canon on the walls. The unit came from Alamo de Parras, which gave the complex its current name. Alamo, in Spanish, means "cottonwood."
The distinctive "hump" that is the signature architecture of the Alamo was added by US troops stationed there in the 1850s. During the siege and battle of the Alamo, the facade of the chapel was a ruin, with a mostly flat or jagged top. Most people today would not recognize it, which is why nearly all movies and posters show the chapel as it looked after its reconstruction.
The US Army added a wooden roof over the structure, and there is mid-19th century graffiti from these troops all over the walls, inside and out. After a brief time as a Confederate stronghold, the chapel became a warehouse for a mercantile institution in what is now called "the low barrack," also within the Alamo walls. Visitors often chipped away portions of the columns and filigree, giving the structure a battle-worn look that's actually the result of vandalism more than battle.
The state bought the property from the Catholic Church in the 1890s, at which point the Daughters of the Republic of Texas donated large sums money to turn the site into a shrine. Though they've been embroiled in controversy and lost control of the gift shop (which used to be a museum), the Daughters still have a contract to administer the site today, with oversight from the State of Texas.
If you visit the Alamo expecting a museum or a national park in the desert, you might be surprised to learn that it is actually a monument in the middle of a bustling city. Though there are a few exhibits scattered about, the Alamo is a shrine. It's official name is the "Shrine of Texas Liberty," and it's considered a holy place. A private armed force known as the Alamo Rangers will enforce policies such as no hats, and no photography. Reverence is expected, once you run the gauntlet of gift shop photographers holding up the line at the front door.
The Men Defending the Alamo Were Defending Their Home, Texas
While the Tejanos were defending their homes against what they saw as a despotic ruler, most of the men at the Alamo were illegal aliens. Some, like Jim Bowie, had moved to Mexico and become Mexican citizens, but a large percentage of the defenders had only arrived in Texas just a few weeks earlier. As Texas was part of Mexico, they were in all ways illegal aliens.
As the United States expanded west, land got more expensive. The Austin family under agreement with Spain and then Mexico, offered land in sparsely-populated Texas for 1/10th of what it was selling for in the US, and under better terms. Payment could be extended over years. The Mexican constitution of 1824 granted rights to these newcomers, and they prospered.
As Santa Anna came to power, and suspended the constitution of 1824, the Texians and their Tejano neighbors revolted. It was generally believed that Texas was going to be its own country, and down-on-their luck men from the U.S. swarmed south for what they saw as a new chance at life. All they had to do was defeat the Mexican army.
It is not accurate to say that the men at the Alamo were defending Texas. They were defending what they hoped Texas would be, against the wishes of the ruling government.
Santa Anna Was a Ruthless Dictator
Santa Anna was a power-hungry opportunist. When Mexico successfully fought for their freedom from Spain, Santa Anna rose through the ranks. He would switch his politics to whatever side he thought could help him. At first, he was very friendly to the people of Texas, as they supported Mexico in the revolution against Spain. But over the course of a few years, he turned from friend to foe. All the rights and privileges that had been granted to them by Spain and then Mexico were gradually whittled away, until finally, the constitution was suspended.
All Mexicans and American immigrants who wished to remain in Mexico were required to be Catholic and slavery was severely restricted. More on that later. Also, the amount of land an immigrant could hold was drastically reduced. By 1835, militias were being organized to defend the rights granted by the old constitution. Santa Anna declared recalcitrant immigrants as "pirates," and sent a letter to Andrew Jackson asking him to exert whatever influence he had over these people, and to proclaim that no quarter would be given. In short, Santa Anna was saying that he would mercilessly kill all non-conforming immigrants in Texas. Jackson did not share the contents of this letter widely.
So yes, Santa Anna was a ruthless dictator. The Texians were promised something, and it was taken away from them. But it's important to remember that the vast majority of Americans and Europeans flooding into Texas were doing so after Santa Anna had suspended the constitution. They were illegal aliens, and as they came with arms, they could also be considered an invading force.
David Crockett
If there's one person who can be called "legendary," it's David Crockett, who never went by the name "Davey" so far as historians can tell. There's also no reliable record of him wearing a coonskin cap. Witnesses saying that he did told their stories decades after actual events. Coonskin caps weren't unheard of among frontier types, but the image of Crockett wearing one were probably from the stage shows depicting his antics in hyperbolic style.
Crockett was a Tennessee Congressman, who moved to Texas after losing re-election. He arrived there just three months before the battle, hoping to find a new start for his political career and a new home for his family. Yes, Crockett and his Tennessee followers were also illegal aliens.
As soon as he arrived, he joined the militia and was sent to the Alamo under the command of Jim Bowie and William Travis, co-commanders of the fort.
And then things get murky. At the Alamo shrine today, a plaque to the left of the chapel door marks the spot where Crocket supposedly fell during the battle. But that narrative has been replaced by the idea that he and a few others somehow survived the event, only to be executed later.
The best evidence for this is the supposed journal of José Enrique de le Peña, an officer in Santa Anna's army. In it, he claims to have seen Crockett executed by order of Santa Anna. But the "journal" wasn't published until 1955, a time when "Davey Crockett Fever" was at its height due to the Disney series. What's more, there are reports of Travis and Bowie surviving as well, and these are certainly false, as there is contemporary, corroborative evidence of their deaths during the battle.
The truth is, we don't know where Crockett died. We only know that he died during, or immediately after the battle. As for his swinging his rifle after running out of ammunition, or running to blow up the ammunition stores though mortally wounded, those are pure Hollywood fiction. Also in doubt is the idea that he killed him a 'bar when he was only three.
Jim Bowie
Hollywood depicts Jim Bowie has a heroic frontier knife fighter who died defending the Alamo. He was even the star character of a 50's TV show. It's true that the Bowie family made wide-bladed knives, but there is no single "Bowie Knife" and the large knife that's come to be known by that name probably wasn't used by Jim Bowie at all.
Jim Bowie was a likable criminal. Though most people said he was friendly and charismatic, he was also guilty of fraud in several land speculation deals. His reason for emigrating to Texas was simple: he was running from the law. He converted to Catholicism and married a local politician's daughter. They had two children, and in 1833, while Bowie was away, his new Mexican family died from cholera.
He was a seasoned fighter, and assigned to the garrison at the Alamo. He was supposed to be under the command of William Travis, but his men, mostly volunteers, wouldn't follow young Travis, so they agreed to co-command. Bowie also brought his slave Jim with him to the Alamo. Bowie was also a smuggler, and what he smuggled was slaves.
In movies, Bowie is depicted as either fighting wounded on the battlements, or fighting bravely from his sick bed. The latter is closer to the truth: during the siege and battle, Bowie was deathly ill with either tuberculosis or pneumonia. It's questionable that he was even conscious during the final battle. Contemporary reports have him "hiding under a blanket" but it's quite possible that he was simply too sick to move.
Colonel Travis Drew a Line In the Sand
Colonel William B. Travis was a young South Carolina lawyer. Saddled with debt, and under threat of arrest, he'd heard that Texas was a land of opportunity for lawyers, and he hoped to head there to escape prosecution and earn enough to pay his debts.
Travis arrived in Texas in 1831 at the age of 21, and having been there five years before the battle made him one of the few men at the Alamo who had any experience living in Texas. After setting up shop as a lawyer, he became embroiled in the fomenting revolution and joined the militia as a lieutenant colonel of the calvary. He was sent to the Alamo, which he considered beneath someone of his rank.
After Bowie fell sick, Travis was in charge. As Santa Anna rolled into town, Travis wrote a series of famous letters pleading for help from other Texians and Americans still in the United States as well. A few dozen men did answer the call, but most did not, with the nascent government of Texas worrying itself with creating a new government. Houston and others encouraged Travis to abandon the Alamo as unimportant, but he refused.
Legend has it that when Travis knew no help would be coming, he drew a line in the sand and asked every man who would fight with him to cross it. All but one, Moses Rose, did. This legend is in the official materials and video from the Alamo, though it's carefully worded as "Legend has it…"
In fact, there's little evidence that this event took place, and there's even less evidence that anyone named Moses Rose was at the Alamo. The Alamo was filled with largely volunteers, and as such not everyone knew each other and there wasn't the record keeping one would find in an organized army. The story of Travis drawing a line didn't appear until decades after the event. That didn't stop the placing of a brass line directly in front of the Alamo chapel to commemorate the likely non-event.
Travis was one of the first killed during the battle. His slaves fought by his side right up until the moment he was killed, and then went into hiding, their service done. There have been attempts by Hollywood to depict the Alamo's slaves as loyal beyond their enslavement, but in reality they knew they were slaves, and they knew this wasn't their fight.
The Alamo Defenders Killed Many More Soldiers Than They Lost
If there's one thing that's true about the Alamo, it's that you can find lots of different, conflicting facts. While most historians put the number of Mexican casualties at around 600, and the Texan casualties at around 200, some lower the Mexican figure to 78 dead, and raise the number of dead Texans to 250. Those who wish to immortalize the defenders of course want to imagine them fighting fiercly, taking down 10 for every man they lost. But there's a lot to consider here.
The siege didn't last a day, but instead took place over two weeks. During the day, Mexican artillery blasted the fort, while defenders took cover. At night, they were forced to reinforce their battered perimeter. With dwindling supplies and very little sleep, the men of the Alamo were likely exhausted.
We also don''t know how many men were inside the Alamo. There were at least 182, with 187 being officially commemorated. Some put the figure as high as 260. Santa Anna had 1,800 troops, though many times his entire army of 6,000 is reported as being there.
When the actual battle started, it was short, and took place at dawn while most of the defenders were sleeping. Some say the battle lasted only 30 minutes, others stretch that to 90 minutes or two hours. The Mexicans charged the walls before the sun came up, and it makes sense that they'd lose a lot of men. The defenders were shooting cannons and long guns from behind barriers at men standing in a line out in the open. Santa Anna fully expected to lose one third of his force. So yes, the Alamo defenders did cause more casualties than they received, but this is not surprising in any way.
The Alamo Was All About Slavery
It's become popular to suggest that the Alamo was a battle for slavery. Slavery was part of the reason Texas wanted to secede from Mexico. There's barely a mention of slavery at the Alamo today, but many of those who went to Texas in the 1830s were pro-slavery, and intended to uphold the institution.
At all times until the end of the American Civil War, Texas was strongly in favor of slavery. One need only read the Constitution of the Republic of Texas to see how important slavery was. Not only was slavery legal, it became illegal to free slaves. And those freed slaves who already lived there had virtually all their rights revoked. If they were ever found guilty of a crime, they were slaves once again. What's more, the few Indians living in Texas were also denied citizenship. There is much irony in people claiming to fight on behalf of lost rights subsequently removing the rights of others.
But to say The Alamo and and the Texas Revolution were all about slavery is to go too far. It was more about land speculation, and starting a new life in a fresh country. Texas has a very bad history when it comes to race, but slavery is just a part of the Texas birth story.
We Should Remember The Alamo
The Alamo is literally larger than life, and while it was an important event, the reasons why we should remember it aren't obvious. While it's presented to us as a pivotal moment in American history, it's more accurately described as one major event in the war for Texas independence. The Battle of San Jacinto and the massacre of Goliad are perhaps more important, but they receive far less attention.
I propose that the Alamo became the official shrine of all that is Texas simply because there was a building there that people could affix their pride to. But while we shouldn't completely forget the Alamo, perhaps we should try to remember the Alamo as it truly was: the last hold out for a ragtag band of speculators who distracted Santa Anna and motivated the rest of the Texian Army to defeat Santa Anna. These were heroic men who died fighting, but they were no more heroic than the Mexican volunteers and conscripts that charged the walls to defeat them. If the Alamo is a shrine to bravery, those dead Mexican soldiers should also be mentioned, yet the idea of a simple plaque dedicated to their memory brings howls of protests from Texans, some of whom claim that the losers don't get plaques. I wonder how these folks would explain the large Confederate monument on the state house grounds in Austin.
So yes, Remember the Alamo… and remember that the largest part of history is "story," and that story is most often written by people who have only one perspective in mind.
Oh, and in case you're wondering... I did check the basement at the Alamo. There was nothing there but an old bicycle. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Sun May 03, 2020 5:46 pm Post subject: |
|
|
The Battle of Kosovo is often compared to the Battle of the Alamo. It is a glorified loss that the Serbs exploit as key element of their national origin myth, with all the exaggeration, omission, and spin that one expects from Balkan nationalism. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Salty Dog

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10063 

 
192187 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Sun May 03, 2020 6:31 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Not much of the original Alamo complex exists today.
Fortunately, John Wayne built a copy of the compound for his 1960 Movie The Alamo. It is located 120 miles west of San Antonio in an area called Alamo Village, about 10-15 miles north of Brackettville, Texas.
You can see an aerial view of it on Google Earth , just search for Alamo Village, TX. You can also see a story of it on WikiPedia under Alamo Village.
I had the opportunity to visit the original Alamo in 1968. It was fun.
Modern Mexican immigrants do not see this as a monument to Texas or the USA! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
corsair91

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10372 

 
296923 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Fri Aug 14, 2020 10:57 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Alamo Village
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alamo_Village
Alamo Village was a movie set and tourist attraction north of Brackettville, Texas, United States. It was the first movie location built in Texas, originally constructed for and best known as the setting for The Alamo (1960), directed by John Wayne and starring Wayne, Richard Widmark, Laurence Harvey and Frankie Avalon.
fansite
http://alamovillagereunionsite.homestead.com/firstpage.html
John Wayne's Alamo - ABANDONED - Movie Set & Village
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uZ3G81blvWU
Mar 3, 2014
runtime 13:26
Alamo Village | John Wayne's Abandoned Movie Set | Texas | USA
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eXhqAPEvV3Y
American Ghost Towns
Jan 20, 2017
runtime 1:55
Alamo Village liquidation sale | 1/2018
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eGfhXfLnJK0
KTBC FOX 7 Austin
Feb 27, 2018
runtime 2:28
Alamo Village is located about seven miles north of the West Texas town of Brackettville. Faded and battered roadway signs still invite visitors to the site although its been closed for the past seven years. On January 27 and 28, Alamo Village opened to the public one last time — for a liquidation sale.
The Last Stand at Alamo Village
https://www.texasmonthly.com/being-texan/last-stand-alamo-village/
By Christian Wallace
Mar 20, 2018 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Salty Dog

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10063 

 
192187 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Fri Aug 14, 2020 11:37 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I went to the Alamo back in 1968 and remember seeing Jim Bowie's knife there. It is a big knife just as we all know it, over a foot long! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
corsair91

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10372 

 
296923 Gold -

more...
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
corsair91

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10372 

 
296923 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2020 3:59 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Rorke's Drift is a another minor battle that has been hyped as a distraction from the earlier British defeat at the battle of Isandlwana.
A barely more successful last stand than the Alamo, the Zulus came close
to winning it, one more attack and the Brits were virtually out of ammo
by then.
The Battle of Rorke's Drift
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Rorke%27s_Drift
Just over 150 British and colonial troops defended the station against attacks by 3,000 to 4,000 Zulu warriors. The massive but piecemeal attacks by the Zulu on Rorke's Drift came very close to defeating the much smaller garrison, but were consistently repelled. Eleven Victoria Crosses were awarded to the defenders, along with a number of other decorations and honours.
Apparently you only had to sneeze at Rorke's Drift to win a VC,
as the medals were showered out wholesale.
Rorke's Drift an engagement in the Anglo-Zulu War
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglo-Zulu_War
British defeat at the day-long Battle of Isandlwana
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Isandlwana
The British lost over 1,300 troops, so no surprise Rorke's Drift
is remembered and the British disaster at Isandlwana today largely forgotten.
The film Zulu (1964) portrays the Battle of Rorke's Drift
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zulu_(1964_film)
The film Zulu Dawn (1979) portrays the Battle of Isandlwana
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zulu_Dawn
"Zulu" 1964 Movie - Final Battle Including "Men of Harlech" Song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nQrE8vOM0ss
runtime 10:18
Zulu is a 1964 epic war film depicting the Battle of Rorke's Drift between the British Army and the Zulus in January 1879, during the Anglo-Zulu War. It depicts 150 British soldiers, many of whom were sick and wounded patients in a field hospital, who successfully held off a force of 4,000 Zulu warriors.
The ending of the film is somewhat fictitious. There was no Zulu attack at dawn on 23 January 1879, which in the film led to the singing of "Men of Harlech", but it sure made for dramatic Hollywood an ending to be viewed again and again.
Men of Harlech is widely used as a regimental march, especially by British Army and Commonwealth regiments historically associated with Wales. Notably, it is the slow march of the Welsh Guards, and the quick march of the Royal Welsh.
It was first used for cinema during the titles of How Green Was My Valley (1941) and has featured in a number of other films. It is best known for its prominent role in the 1964 film Zulu, although the version of lyrics sung in it were written specially for the film. It is sung twice, only once completely, in the film (the British begin shooting the charging Zulus before the start of the final couplet), in counterpoint to the Zulu war chants and the sounds of their shields. Film editor John Jympson cut the scene to the song so that on either side of cuts where the British soldiers cannot be heard, the song is in the correct relative position. The song is also heard in the film Zulu Dawn, which is about the battle that precedes Rorke's Drift, the Battle of Isandlwana.
History Buffs: Zulu
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VygWpmwBO8M
History Buffs
runtime 18:27
Review of the Historical movie Zulu
User comment
“The prerequisite for any British campaign is that the enemy should under no circumstances carry guns” - Captain Edmund Blackadder IV
Zulu - The True Story (Timewatch 2003)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jHIzA4cqkLY
runtime 49:06
A look at how the humiliating defeat at the battle of Isandlwana was played down while the small victory at Rorke's Drift, on the same day, was promoted by Victoria and Disraeli as the major engagement. The true story of the Zulu War is one of unprovoked slaughter, heroes ignored and the guilty protected - and the responsibility for this lies with those who lived above suspicion.
The Battle of Isandlwana: One of The Worst Defeats of The British Empire - Military History Animated
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gu7KmCNKjJc
runtime 11:38
The Battle of Isandlwana was one of the worst military blunders in history. In this battle, a small British force was defeated by a large but primitive force of Zulu warriors. Had the British not divided their forces, fallen for an enemy feint, and taken proper defensive measures this blunder would not have happened. However, the arrogance of the British command allowed this massive blow to British pride and colonial ambition.
The British established defenses far out from resupply as well as failed to form a defensive lagger fortification prior to the battle. As the battle progressed British forces at risk of being outflanked were forced to withdraw closer to their supply wagons. During this momentary confusion, Zulu forces were able to slip inside of the British lines and once surrounded overpowered the British.
The Battle of Rorke's Drift - Military History Animated
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=itAqDf_wemc
runtime 5:13
The battle of Roark's Drift is one of the most famous battles in English history. The battled occurred during the Anglo Zulu war, a war of British colonial aggression against the Zulu nation.
Following the stunning defeat of the British at the Battle of Isandlwana, the garrison at Roark's Drift was suddenly under threat and unable to retreat without abandoning their hospital patients to the Zulu. Over the following day and night, they led a desperate defensive action outnumbered almost 25 to 1 by Zulu warriors.
Finally, after expending over 20,000 rounds and with almost no ammunition remaining, the Zulu retreated, and the garrison was relieved shortly after. This became the most decorated battle in the history of Britain.
EDIT:
Zulu 1964 720p
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xycLDen2IBo
runtime 2:18:24
22nd January 1879, Rorke's Drift. Natal Province. On that day an epic battle was fought between 4000 Zulu warriors and approx. 100 British soldiers.
Zulu Dawn (1979) Burt Lancaster, Simon Ward, Denholm Elliott
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T5NOWCvNY-E
runtime 1:52:46
A dramatization of the Battle of Isandlwana, where the British Army met its match against the Zulu nation.
Last edited by corsair91 on Fri Sep 04, 2020 5:25 am; edited 19 times in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
corsair91

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10372 

 
296923 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Sat Aug 15, 2020 4:20 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Back to the Alamo
José Enrique de la Peña
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Enrique_de_la_Pe%C3%B1a
Jose Enrique de la Peña (1807-1840) was a colonel in the Mexican Army. Under General Antonio López de Santa Anna, de la Peña participated in the Battle of the Alamo.
In 1955, a book of his memoirs of the battle was published (in Spanish,
English version 1975). The memoirs are controversial in that they said that Davy Crockett did not die fighting (as is the common belief), but instead surrendered (along with his Tennessee boys) during the battle of the Alamo and was later executed. Historians disagree on whether the memoirs are accurate.
While De la Pena was in Texas 1836, he had kept a diary which was not published till 1955. It was located by researcher J. Sanchez Garza and subsequently translated into English by Carmen Perry of the Daughters of the Republic of Texas.
José Enrique de la Peña's Narrative of the Fall of the Alamo
Mexican officer bore witness to the last moments of the Alamo defenders
https://www.thestoryoftexas.com/discover/artifacts/jose-enrique-de-la-pena-narrative
Mexican Lt. Col. José Enrique de la Peña witnessed the 1836 Battle of the Alamo and documented it in a 109-page field diary during the 1836 Texas campaign. After the war, he wrote a 400-page narrative based on his field diary and reports from his fellow officers. The narrative was not published until 1955 and not translated into English until 1975. It includes accounts of how the Alamo’s defenders died and proved tremendously controversial with its assertion that Davy Crockett did not die fighting, but instead surrendered during the battle only to be executed by General Santa Anna.
This page recounts the story of William B. Travis’ death. De la Peña writes, “Travis was seen to hesitate, but not about the death he would choose. He would take a few steps and stop, turning his proud face toward us to discharge his shots; he fought like a true soldier. Finally he died, but he died after trading his life very dearly. None of his men died with greater heroism, and they all died. Travis behaved like a hero; one must do him justice, for with a handful of men without discipline, he resolved to face men used to war and much superior in numbers, without supplies, with scarce munitions, and against the will of his subordinates.”
"To Whom Was This Sacrifice Useful?":
The Texas Revolution and the Narrative of José Enrique de la Peña
https://www.cah.utexas.edu/exhibits/Pena/index.php
Don E. Carleton
Part 1 of the Crockett Debates
http://www.sonsofdewittcolony.org//adp/archives/delapena/delapena2.html
Examines the de la Peña account of the death of David Crockett.
Interesting the de la Peña account from what I can gather
doesn't trash the Texian defenders of the Alamo, and he did have a later falling out with Santa Anna and had no reason to defend Santa Anna.
Since peak Crockett interest was about 1955, publishing then in only Spanish doesn't ring true of exploiting the story.
Historians have judged the paper used in the account to be genuine of the period.
Not liking what is says doesn't mean it is not true and the myth will
have to changed unless you can prove otherwise with a differing
documented account. This may be difficult, as all the male Texians at
the Alamo were reportedly killed.
Until then the de la Peña account is the most accurate version.
Travis, Crockett, Bowie and other Texians died defending the Alamo
which was captured by the Mexican Army. The way Crockett died
is simply different from the myth.
Long overdue that the Mexican dead were also respected & remembered in a monument at the Alamo if not already, after all, they won the battle
and losers apparently don't get plaques in Texas.
Where the Mexican lancers caught up with and killed the Texians who broke away from the Alamo walls, which is now downtown San Antonio
has apparently no historical marker either.
Last edited by corsair91 on Mon Jun 28, 2021 12:04 am; edited 2 times in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
corsair91

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10372 

 
296923 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue Sep 08, 2020 1:28 am Post subject: |
|
|
How and why JOHN WAYNE was forced to do things he didn't want to while filming THE ALAMO!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xXzXQErKNfY
LandumC goes there
Sep 7, 2020
Runtime 11:35
A look into the massive production of the John Wayne movie THE ALAMO and the troubles he encountered during it's development and filming! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
corsair91

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10372 

 
296923 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Jun 24, 2021 1:46 pm Post subject: |
|
|
We've Been Telling the Alamo Story Wrong for Nearly 200 Years. Now It's Time to Correct the Record
https://time.com/6072141/alamo-history-myths/
By Bryan Burrough and Jason Stanford
Updated: June 21, 2021 1:51 PM EDT
Originally published: June 9, 2021 5:43 PM EDT
Imagine if the U.S. were to open interior Alaska for colonization and, for whatever reason, thousands of Canadian settlers poured in, establishing their own towns, hockey rinks and Tim Hortons stores. When the U.S. insists they follow American laws and pay American taxes, they refuse. When the government tries to collect taxes, they shoot and kill American soldiers. When law enforcement goes after the killers, the colonists, backed by Canadian financing and mercenaries, take up arms in open revolt.
As an American, how would you feel? Now you can imagine how Mexican President Antonio López de Santa Anna would have felt in 1835, because that’s pretty much the story of the revolution that paved the way for Texas to become its own nation and then an American state.
If that’s not the version of history you’re familiar with, you’re not alone. The version most Americans know, the “Heroic Anglo Narrative” that has held sway for nearly 200 years, holds that American colonists revolted against Mexico because they were “oppressed” and fought for their “freedom,” a narrative that has been soundly rebutted by 30-plus years of academic scholarship. But the many myths surrounding Texas’ birth, especially those cloaking the fabled 1836 siege at the Alamo mission in San Antonio, remain cherished in the state. Even as the nation is undergoing a sweeping reassessment of its racial history, and despite decades of academic research that casts the Texas Revolt and the Alamo’s siege in a new light, little of this has permeated the conversation in Texas.
Start with the Alamo. So much of what we “know” about the battle is provably wrong. William Travis never drew any line in the sand; this was a tale concocted by an amateur historian in the late 1800s. There is no evidence Davy Crockett went down fighting, as John Wayne famously did in his 1960 movie The Alamo, a font of misinformation; there is ample testimony from Mexican soldiers that Crockett surrendered and was executed. The battle, in fact, should never have been fought. Travis ignored multiple warnings of Santa Anna’s approach and was simply trapped in the Alamo when the Mexican army arrived. He wrote some dramatic letters during the ensuing siege, it’s true, but how anyone could attest to the defenders’ “bravery” is beyond us. The men at the Alamo fought and died because they had no choice. Even the notion they “fought to the last man” turns out to be untrue. Mexican accounts make clear that, as the battle was being lost, as many as half the “Texian” defenders fled the mission and were run down and killed by Mexican lancers.
Nor is it at all clear that the Alamo’s defenders “bought time” for Sam Houston to raise the army that eventually defeated Santa Anna at the Battle of San Jacinto the following month. Santa Anna had told Mexico City he expected to take San Antonio by March 2; he ended up doing so on March 6. In the end, the siege at the Alamo ended up costing him all of four days. Meaning the Alamo’s defenders, far from being the valiant defenders who delayed Santa Anna, pretty much died for nothing.
So why does any of this matter? What’s the harm in Texans simply embracing a myth?
Census data indicates that Latinos are poised to become a majority of the Texas population any year now, and for them, the Alamo has long been viewed as a symbol of Anglo oppression. The fact that many Tejanos — Texas Latinos— allied with the Americans, and fought and died alongside them at the Alamo, has generally been lost to popular history. The Tejanos’ key contributions to early Texas were written out of almost all early Anglo-authored histories, much as Anglo Texans ran Tejanos out of San Antonio and much of South Texas after the revolt. For too long, the revolt has been viewed by many as a war fought by all Anglos against all of Mexican descent.
“If you’re looking at the Alamo as a kind of state religion, this is the original sin,” says San Antonio art historian Ruben Cordova. “We killed Davy Crockett.”
It’s a lesson many Latinos in the state don’t learn until mandatory Texas history classes taught in seventh grade. “The way I explain it,” says Andres Tijerina, a retired history professor in Austin, “is Mexican-Americans [in Texas] are brought up, even in the first grade, singing the national anthem and the Pledge of Allegiance and all that, and it’s not until the seventh grade that they single us out as Mexicans. And from that point on, you realize you’re not an American. You’re a Mexican, and always will be. The Alamo story takes good, solid, loyal little American kids and it converts them into Mexicans.”
And Mexican-American history isn’t the only piece of the past that’s distorted by the Alamo myth. Academic researchers long tiptoed around the issue of slavery in Texas; active research didn’t really begin until the 1980s. Since then, scholars such as Randolph Campbell and Andrew Torget have demonstrated that slavery was the single issue that regularly drove a wedge between early Mexican governments—dedicated abolitionists all—and their American colonists in Texas, many of whom had immigrated to farm cotton, the province’s only cash crop at the time.
His correspondence shows conclusively that Stephen F. Austin, the so-called “Father of Texas,” spent years jousting with the Mexico City bureaucracy over the necessity of enslaved labor to the Texas economy. “Nothing is wanted but money,” he wrote in a pair of 1832 letters, “and Negros are necessary to make it.” Each time a Mexican government threatened to outlaw slavery, many in Austin’s colony began packing to go home. In time, as we know now, they put away their suitcases and brought out their guns.
This, by and large, is not the Texas history many of us learned in school; instead, we learned a tale written by Anglo historians beginning in the 19th century. What happened in the past can’t change. But the way we view it does—and, as a state and a country, now is the time to teach the next generation our history, not our myths.
Bryan Burrough and Jason Stanford are, with Chris Tomlinson, the authors of Forget the Alamo: The Rise and Fall of an American Myth, available now from Penguin Press.
Correction, June 21
The original version of this story misstated the name of the President of Mexico in 1835. It was Antonio López de Santa Anna, not Jose Lopez de Santa Anna. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Salty Dog

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10063 

 
192187 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2021 3:08 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Throughout human history countries and peoples have fought to gain land for themselves. That is the primary reason for having an Army - to protect or take over land. It has been a case of "might makes right" and whoever wins the war keeps the land and gets to re-write history in their favor.
During battles, when people surrender rather than get killed, these captured prisoners became slaves. That is where slavery came from. Is this good? No way, it sucks! I'm just saying that is how the world has worked for almost all of the past 5000 years. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
corsair91

Sailing Master 
Posts: 10372 

 
296923 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Sun Jun 27, 2021 11:17 pm Post subject: |
|
|
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Alamo
Winners write the historical record.
History is often described as a "generally agreeded upon set of lies"
There were some Texians at the Battle of the Alamo, but no Texans
as that version of the name came into general useage somewhat later.
Winston Churchill when once asked how future generations would regard him said -
"History would regard him favorably, as I intend to write it"
which he promptly did and wrote his memoirs.
Churchill was not as highly regarded during his lifetime in England
as he tends to be regarded now.
Last edited by corsair91 on Thu Jul 15, 2021 3:22 am; edited 1 time in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Pirate

Helmsman 
Posts: 5927 

 
117641 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Jun 28, 2021 12:41 am Post subject: |
|
|
I don’t know about Texas but sometimes I think California still belongs to Mexico as there is no shortage of them here. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
fleetp

Helmsman 
Posts: 4598 

 
26019 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Jun 28, 2021 3:17 am Post subject: |
|
|
About 39.3% of Texas' population is of Hispanic origin (not all are Mexican). The parents of my older daughter's husband (he's retired US Air Force lieutenant colonel) are of Mexican heritage. While neither my life partner nor I are of Hispanic heritage, it seems my grandchildren are.
California is a bit lower with 39% of the population of Hispanic (not all Mexican) heritage.
New Mexico is almost half of Hispanic origin (48.8%)
Source: https://worldpopulationreview.com/state-rankings/hispanic-population-by-state  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|