Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

The morality of Piracy
Post new topic   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.     Forum Index -> Tavern Goto page 1, 2, 3  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Dirk Struan
Swabbie
Posts: 121



2440 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Mar 19, 2005 8:13 pm    Post subject: The morality of Piracy Reply with quote

Salus. As a humble student of Classical Philosophy, I have found myself pondering the morality of the much romanticised life of a pirate. It certainly would seem that, from the standpoint of a number of moral systems, piracy must be considered suspect. It violates the law, causes harm to others, encourages the indulgence of vices etc etc. This begs several questions:

1) Is Piracy inherently unethical?

2) Is there a way in which one can pirate while furthering a higher good?

3) What higher goods are reachable more easily by piracy than by more conventional conduct?

Cool Have fun with this one....
_________________
"Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Mar 19, 2005 8:50 pm    Post subject: Funny you should ask. Reply with quote

You would first need to demonstrate that Spain (with its colonial policy, and participation in slave trade), England (with its colonial policy, and participation in slave trade), France (with its colonial policy, and participation in slave trade), and the Dutch (with its colonial policy, participation in slave trade and creation of the greatest of all human evils "capitalism" that rare form of piracy), had any ethical or moral validity at all. If you admit the truth about this, then you'd have to answer, "Why single-out pirates for this accusation?" The sheer size of their armies, and their centuries-long proclivities for war makes absurd the notion they've had anything to do with a "turn the other cheek" - "the meek shall inherit the earth" mentality. Rather, wasn't it the pope who created the Line of Demarcation, which divided South America in two for the Spanish and Portuguese to organize their slave trade without bringing heat to the European continent?

However, if you buy into the myth that Western Civilization has something to do with morality and ethics, then you'd probably buy into the absurdity that if the U.S. made Iraq into a system "just like us", you'd end up with a democracy. "America is free - to those who can afford it."

If the standard is the true standard that has been practiced all along, it seems piracy is just an entrepreneurial enterprise practiced by private parties, rather than on behalf of the aforementioned states. I would run through the litany of historical evidence which proves this is the case, but then that would rob you of the pleasure of studying history yourself.

I suggest you read John Perkin's Confessions of an Economic Hitman before you suggest this culture is remotely associated with either morality, or ethics. It's just out, hot from the presses. Those who read this must either recalibrate their notions of what has transpired since the end of World War II, or admit they are shamelessly disingenuous.

If you wish to learn more of MY opinion on this subject, try:

http://www.cambio.net/convention/alism.html

and be sure to bring a healthy vocabulary.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
PrinceScamp
Gunner
Posts: 862



213 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 12:21 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

huh, neat,
_________________
LORD COMMANDER OF THE PLANK
CULT OF THE POLLMEISTER
CHA CHING!!!
320.9 SCAMP'S STOP
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Dirk Struan
Swabbie
Posts: 121



2440 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 3:27 am    Post subject: Re: Funny you should ask. Reply with quote

Airsaw wrote:
You would first need to demonstrate that Spain (with its colonial policy, and participation in slave trade), England (with its colonial policy, and participation in slave trade), France (with its colonial policy, and participation in slave trade), and the Dutch (with its colonial policy, participation in slave trade and creation of the greatest of all human evils "capitalism" that rare form of piracy), had any ethical or moral validity at all. If you admit the truth about this, then you'd have to answer, "Why single-out pirates for this accusation?" The sheer size of their armies, and their centuries-long proclivities for war makes absurd the notion they've had anything to do with a "turn the other cheek" - "the meek shall inherit the earth" mentality. Rather, wasn't it the pope who created the Line of Demarcation, which divided South America in two for the Spanish and Portuguese to organize their slave trade without bringing heat to the European continent?

However, if you buy into the myth that Western Civilization has something to do with morality and ethics, then you'd probably buy into the absurdity that if the U.S. made Iraq into a system "just like us", you'd end up with a democracy. "America is free - to those who can afford it."

If the standard is the true standard that has been practiced all along, it seems piracy is just an entrepreneurial enterprise practiced by private parties, rather than on behalf of the aforementioned states. I would run through the litany of historical evidence which proves this is the case, but then that would rob you of the pleasure of studying history yourself.

I suggest you read John Perkin's Confessions of an Economic Hitman before you suggest this culture is remotely associated with either morality, or ethics. It's just out, hot from the presses. Those who read this must either recalibrate their notions of what has transpired since the end of World War II, or admit they are shamelessly disingenuous.

If you wish to learn more of MY opinion on this subject, try:

http://www.cambio.net/convention/alism.html

and be sure to bring a healthy vocabulary.


I fail to see why I need to demonstrate the morality of any of the Nations depicted in the game.... After all, the point of this thread is to discuss the ethics of Piracy, not the ethics of the national policies of the countries you mentioned. Even if these entities were, as you seem to suggest, totally immoral (or perhaps you contend that they are ammoral) Piracy, by deffinition is something that occurs outside the scope of government, that is to say, a private and criminal activity that causes harm to those victimised by it. Thus the question is not whether piracy is moral compared to other institutions, but whether it is moral generally, and independent of such considerations.

Nonetheless, since you went to all the trouble of typing up that evils of Western Civ song and dance, I suppose it is fitting to offer a nice, Hobbesian response to your assertion that pirates and empires ammount to the same sort of thing. Hobbes asserts that a nation comes into existence when people band together to escape the horrors of an anarchic state of nature. Thus, nations exist and rulers rule by the consent of the governed. Pirates, on the other hand, do not offer the benefits of the nation-state and cannot claim the consent of those they prey upon. While a state may act in a brutal and perhaps even immoral fashion to further its own interests (which must be, at some level, in keeping with those for which is was founded {common survival} lest the state collapse) a pirate's acting in this fashion furthers no end but the interests of the pirate himself (or herself of course).

As for the slave trade, at that point in history, slavery had been more or less common the world over for thousands of years. It was considered a moral alternative to killing or imprisoning a criminal or a defeated enemy. Indeed, the original slaves to come to the New World (Blacks as well as White indentured servants) had often become slaves in just such a way. In any event, the line of demarcation was more a settling of territorial boundries than anything else, designed to avoid a conflict between two major powers.

Anyway, this topic has gone a bit off of where I had intended for it to go..... Discussion of the evils of Western Civ may be better placed on another thread. Thanks for the thought provoking reply tho! Cool
_________________
"Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Dirk Struan
Swabbie
Posts: 121



2440 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 3:45 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Oh, and to any MODS out there.......... Am I out of line posting this kind of topic? Lock it if I am..... I know that I am not supposed to discuss politics or religion but I thought that philosophy might be ok.....
_________________
"Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 2:29 pm    Post subject: Re: Funny you should ask. Reply with quote

Dirk Struan wrote:

I fail to see why I need to demonstrate the morality of any of the Nations depicted in the game.... After all, the point of this thread is to discuss the ethics of Piracy, not the ethics of the national policies of the countries you mentioned.


I thought this might be said. However, making this argument only belies an elementary understanding of both law and morality. Morality exists with the acceptance a priori of a divine entity and would then be layed-out by the agents of said divinity - the church. Pirates merely practiced the ethics of the church as it existed at that time. Albeit, they used their own judgment, rather than that of the papacy, to make what policies they did. Yet, these policies differed little from those of the church. Therefore, they used morality.

Ethics would then be the "fair practices and standards" of the existing culture, which was obviously arbitrary at best, and brutal as a rule. Therefore the practices and standards of the aforementioned states would be relevant, and pirates (i.a.w. all known accounts) were no more brutal, or arbitrary than the existing standard.

Now that you're caught up, would you care to discuss the issue you raised? Or, would you rather fetch-over your gold watch and pistols, and kindly walk the plank? ARGH! Oh, did I mention what you quaintly refer to as the "scope of government" was cause for the American Revolution, or would you call THAT historic event "unethical" and "immoral"?

The gist of your response hints you may believe the romanticized version of western history taught in American public schools, and universities. This reminds me of something said by the Zulu, "As long as the tale of the hunt is told by the hunter, the hunter will always win."
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
PiratesFan
Rigger
Posts: 1659


23695 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 6:10 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

The question should be was Piracy ethical in the Era it was born? If I understand where your trying to go with this. In The Era it was created was because Nations did not want to dirty their hands and for other countries to know who was really going after who. This is why governments rewarded pirates of that Era. Call it codoned espionage in todays world to add some relevance to it. Now was the pirates life that ethical, not really but there was always a code of honor although very loose code did give some guidelines on what a pirate should do and what a pirate shouldn't do. The choice of being a pirate was for meere profit, it did come with the good points and this is why pirates are romanticised cause of the evil pirates doing good for a country and they aren't really that bad odf people. The part where it became unethical is the means they used against there foes, the life they really lived, and the fact that they would steal from their own mother if it would gain them a higher than the rest of them status.

Now that is a very summarized version of the piracy being ethical or not. If you want more I would be glad to get you some links.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address Yahoo Messenger
Dirk Struan
Swabbie
Posts: 121



2440 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 6:54 pm    Post subject: Re: Funny you should ask. Reply with quote

Airsaw wrote:

I thought this might be said. However, making this argument only belies an elementary understanding of both law and morality. Morality exists with the acceptance a priori of a divine entity and would then be layed-out by the agents of said divinity - the church. Pirates merely practiced the ethics of the church as it existed at that time. Albeit, they used their own judgment, rather than that of the papacy, to make what policies they did. Yet, these policies differed little from those of the church. Therefore, they used morality.


First of all, a priori is not a term used to refer to assumptions but rather to demonstrable logical constructs so you may need to brush up on your terms a bit before so clumsily bandying them about. However, since you brought it up, whether or not morality requires God or the Church are very much subjects of contention and have been since prior to the Reformation. In his Grounding for a Metaphysics of Morals, Kant suggests that morality is largely associated with a good will (a faculty later commentators would point out need not necessarily be connected to God) and also introduces the idea of the Categorical Imperative, the notion that one should align one's will with the highest standard of morality. Similar (and perhaps related) arguments hold that there is an a priori logical basis for moral behavior, as for example, it makes little sense to endorse murder because to do so would be endoring one's own murder and (consequently) the removal of the advocate of Murder. Thus do certain actions eliminate their own advocacy.

Now, that said, if you do consider the Church (for the record, it is more respectful to capitalize the "C") the ultimate arbitrator of morality, then you cannot exist outside the folds of its teachings and still be moral. The Church's teachings and the Church's policies are not the same thing, as the teachings are infallible whilst the policies necessarily change with the times. Pirates, in using their own judgment to dettermine morality, fell outside the bounds of the Church and, if the Church is the ultimate authority on the matter, thus became immoral and if they claimed to be in communion with the Church while holding their own judgemtns as superior, heretical.

Airsaw wrote:
Ethics would then be the "fair practices and standards" of the existing culture, which was obviously arbitrary at best, and brutal as a rule. Therefore the practices and standards of the aforementioned states would be relevant, and pirates (i.a.w. all known accounts) were no more brutal, or arbitrary than the existing standard.


Once again you introduce an idea of ethics that you make no attempt to justify. Have you read Plato? Aristotle? Or, you know, ANY PHILOSOPHER FOR THE PAST 3000 YEARS OR SO? Defining ethics as a subjective set of cultural standards is one of the less defensible "philosophies" as to the definition of ethics. A large number of Classical and Medieval commentators would contend that ethics is the study of how to lead a moral life, that is to say, a life in keeping with an ABSOLUTE MORALITY INDEPENDENT OF CULTURAL STANDARDS. If what you are arguing is moral relativism, then you have no standards by which to judge ANY system of morality because they are all subjective including relativism itself!

In any event, your argument misses my objection. Nations and individuals are held to different standards. If you person kills a criminal, (barring self-defense) without the being commissioned by the State to do so, he is himself a criminal. If a State kills a criminal, or arrests one or fines one, then it is DOING ITS JOB. That is just one of hundreds of examples of how the state and the individual serve different roles in a society.

Airsaw wrote:
Now that you're caught up, would you care to discuss the issue you raised? Or, would you rather fetch-over your gold watch and pistols, and kindly walk the plank? ARGH! Oh, did I mention what you quaintly refer to as the "scope of government" was cause for the American Revolution, or would you call THAT historic event "unethical" and "immoral"?


According to Hobbesian thought, the American "revolution" was immoral. Now, stop gasping, and prove to me otherwise.

Funny that you would request I walk the plank when it would seem you hardly have one to stand on yourself.....Laughing

Airsaw wrote:
The gist of your response hints you may believe the romanticized version of western history taught in American public schools, and universities. This reminds me of something said by the Zulu, "As long as the tale of the hunt is told by the hunter, the hunter will always win."


Good quote. Care to try arguing now? Rolling Eyes [/i]
_________________
"Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Dirk Struan
Swabbie
Posts: 121



2440 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 6:56 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

PiratesFan wrote:
The question should be was Piracy ethical in the Era it was born? If I understand where your trying to go with this. In The Era it was created was because Nations did not want to dirty their hands and for other countries to know who was really going after who. This is why governments rewarded pirates of that Era. Call it codoned espionage in todays world to add some relevance to it. Now was the pirates life that ethical, not really but there was always a code of honor although very loose code did give some guidelines on what a pirate should do and what a pirate shouldn't do. The choice of being a pirate was for meere profit, it did come with the good points and this is why pirates are romanticised cause of the evil pirates doing good for a country and they aren't really that bad odf people. The part where it became unethical is the means they used against there foes, the life they really lived, and the fact that they would steal from their own mother if it would gain them a higher than the rest of them status.

Now that is a very summarized version of the piracy being ethical or not. If you want more I would be glad to get you some links.



A most excellent summation of the issue at hand! Bring on the links! Very Happy
_________________
"Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 9:34 pm    Post subject: Re: Funny you should ask. Reply with quote

Dirk Struan wrote:

First of all, a priori is not a term used to refer to assumptions but rather to demonstrable logical constructs
Your patronization taken into account, the church and its influence, and the relevant monarchies and their influences are a matter of historic fact, not assumptions, and they do form logical constructs, which was my point. I have no respect for the church since it is responsible for the most amount of genocide in history and has little to do with the object of its "worship", Jesus of Nazareth. Don't look for a capitalized "c" here. (Tokenism on your part, btw.)
Dirk Straun wrote:
Once again you introduce an idea of ethics that you make no attempt to justify.
I don't see the point in trying to justify the mention of ethics as a basis, or standard. Morality, ethics, law ...mores and folkways...what else do you have as a set of rules these pirates were allegedly violating?

Dirk Straun wrote:
Have you read Plato? Aristotle? Or, you know, ANY PHILOSOPHER FOR THE PAST 3000 YEARS OR SO? Defining ethics as a subjective set of cultural standards is one of the less defensible "philosophies" as to the definition of ethics.

This is so typical of philosophy students, to accuse those whom they don't readily understand of having no knowledge of what they purport they do. What do majors in philosophy do for a living? They teach philosophy. Not to extend your tedium, but for the sake of clarity, I've read Plato, Aristotle, Kant (never could), Nietze and all the OTHER philosophers on the reading list if one takes philosophy at university level, because (surprise!) I took philosophy at university level. Now you can deride the quality of the school I attended, or the quality of my attendance.
Dirk Straun wrote:

In any event, your argument misses my objection. Nations and individuals are held to different standards.
Whose standards? Who decides this? You may accept this to be fact, and nations may be able to enforce their standards OVER individuals, but a double standard is still a double standard.


Dirk Straun wrote:
If you person kills a criminal, (barring self-defense) without the being commissioned by the State to do so, he is himself a criminal. If a State kills a criminal, or arrests one or fines one, then it is DOING ITS JOB. That is just one of hundreds of examples of how the state and the individual serve different roles in a society.
NOW who's being relative? You seem to be confusing truth with power.


Dirk Straun wrote:
According to Hobbesian thought, the American "revolution" was immoral. Now, stop gasping, and prove to me otherwise.
I'm not gasping. According to all the "rules" of the day it WAS not only immoral, but illegal as well. Still, that is only an opinion. Also, you may choose to view Hobbes as some sort of unimpeachable authority, but I don't. To me, Hobbes was just another guy with an opinion.

Dirk Straun wrote:
Funny that you would request I walk the plank when it would seem you hardly have one to stand on yourself.....Laughing
Funny you assume you've made a point, when all you've done is demonstrate your pedantry.

Airsaw wrote:
The gist of your response hints you may believe the romanticized version of western history taught in American public schools, and universities. This reminds me of something said by the Zulu, "As long as the tale of the hunt is told by the hunter, the hunter will always win."
The gauntlet is cast.

Dirk Straun wrote:
Good quote. Care to try arguing now? Rolling Eyes
Any day, now. I'm still waiting. Maybe you need directions to the ballfield since you can't seem to find it on your own:

A. I am Airsaw, the Philosophical Pirate.
B. My tactic is to enjoin my target ship's captain in lengthy discussions of irrelevancies, including quoting boatloads of philosophers who themselves are irrelevant - since when all is said and done, money still rules.
C. While said ship's captain is busy patronizing me, and my apparent ignorance, which all philosophy students do in the mistaken belief only they can be correct, my crew has boarded your vessel, raided your stores and made off with your treasure chest. We call this a bloodless coup.
D. Wave good-bye to my Jolly Roger, the skeleton holding a scroll.

ARGH!!!

Philosophy is a chain letter. Match, point, game.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Westley_Roberts
Iron Guts
Posts: 913



10375 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 9:42 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hear Hear ! !

At first I trolled this topic just to look at it. I'm not much on philosophy. But after seeing the debate go from podium to podium, I fear I must applaud the lot of you for keeping this professional.

I have enjoied what I have read, and am anxious to read more.

Thank you.
_________________

Have an Army Day
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail Visit poster's website
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 9:46 pm    Post subject: MORE TO THE POINT Reply with quote

What is a pirate?

Well, I know you won't believe me,
but it is the truth to tell,
That the living it is hard.
Oh, but, it suits me well.


You think you know because you've heard all that talk of criminality fomented by the landed gentry who wrote their own history after jailing anyone with the slightest disagreement? Those European prisons weren't filled with just the likes of me. This could be a major reason I preferred a life on the open sea, with the luck of wind and my own reckoning to keep me out of the reach of the royal arm. If they didn't jail you, they taxed you to finance your own captivity.

So, I use my seamanship, and my ability to withstand the toils of the ocean-going vessel within the confines of but a deck, or two, to feel what landlubbers today call "freedom." Sure, some of my ilk did murderous deeds and wanton destruction to their own profit and eventual deaths. But, there's some of my kind who used masterful seamanship and powder-induced persuasion to rob the royals of quite a sum which otherwise would have gone to their good end, and none to our own.

We wore what we wore as was good for what we had to do. None would have forgone better had it been available. We lived shoulder to shoulder in walls of wood for months on end, enduring one another and the rigors of the sea, and the food not so good often times. But, we managed to make a dent in his, or her majesty's (whichever the case may be) fortune, and dodge the graces of their gallows, in the main. So much so, they invested even more of their treasure into bringing us to bay, at last.

So, I guess it could be said we were doing a public service.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Wolfwood
Boatswain
Posts: 2484



33917 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 9:53 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Interesting discussion here, guys. Just take care that it stays so that it is issues that conflict here and not people. We don't want to see Sokrates and Plato at each others' throats here...
_________________
It is much better to be armed with a sword that has two edges than with an estoc [...], which is nothing more than a stick with a point. (Rapier Master G. Morsicato Pallavicini, La Scherma Illustrata, p. 14.)
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 20, 2005 10:46 pm    Post subject: Somebody musta pushed my button. Reply with quote

Okay, okay, okay...apologies to those who may think this got a bit hot. I've danced around this issue, and not been precise, partly for the sake of provocation, and partly because when you see a pirate, it isn't a good idea to pull up next to him and engage in discussion. Unless, that is, you have more guns than he, and know how to use them. It's best to turn tail and run, or you'll end up being robbed, and quite possibly gutted. We're all pirates here, eh? So, luring the victim within range and keeping him there long enough to succeed in our endeavors (muhahahaha) is what we're about!

Yet, the topic deserves some serious thought on some level. I personally find it difficult to look at this in black & white terms. So, I tossed around the word "relevant" in various forms. Why? I'll tell you.

"Morality" presupposes a divine entity, or God, exists and this God has rules, or laws. These rules, or laws, are morals. Moral laws made by humans are therefore laws in line with this God's law. Humans can make laws not in line with these supposed divine rules, and they can also enforce them.

I see morality, and its accompanying rules, as only opinion, that is until people agree upon them and then put them into practice. As such, I don't see that morality existed on either side, pirates or monarchies. It's not supposing there IS no God, and there ARE no divine rules. It's accepting the reality that all parties involved, including the CHURCH, were not putting them into practice. Therefore, they did not exist; there was no morality to violate.

Why I approached the discussion as I did was simple. What are we as players, and what were "they" - the monarchies (nations did not exist at that time) and the church DOING in the Carribean to begin with? They were ripping-off the locals for their gold! What treasure are we stealing from our victims? The treasure our victims stole from somebody else. Who are we "killing" when we play? The same people who were killing the original owners of the gold, and land in order to steal it from them.

It's historical fact that Spain was a theocracy under King Phillip's rule. He expressly put Spain under the hand of the Papacy. This accounts for the difficulty Spain has had keeping abreast with the rest of Europe as nations began to be formed from these monarchies. We've come to discover over time that theocracies are inefficient forms of government. Spain's experience was one of our greatest teachers of this reality. No one can seriously claim, therefore, that the CHURCH did not have a heavy hand in the robbing of the New World. This CHURCH was the so-called purveyor of morality. However, the object of their faith, Jesus of Nazareth, was known for saying things such as, "It is more blessed to give than to recieve." AND, "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." AND, "Turn the other cheek." I don't recall anything in The Holy Bible which said, "Steal the lives of more primitive peoples, along with their wealth and their land in order to spread Christianity." I also don't recall Jesus as saying slavery is an object of His Gospel.

Therefore, there was no morality to violate. There were no ethics, either. There were only laws. So, it's without foundation to ask about the moral implications of piracy. They were all pirates. They were all criminals. They were all thieves, and they were all murderers, the CHURCH included. Remember, if you're driving the getaway car in the U.S., during which a crime being committed results in a murder, you are charged with murder, too.

Maybe it's obtuse of me. Maybe it's just a long-winded harangue. From where I sit, it's this precise hypocracy which has prevented "us" from achieving the peace and prosperity that has been denied to us, and which we have been denied, and have denied, for more than two-thousand years. It's especially poignant in light of present world circumstances, where American Christians seem to be employing the same methodology as were the Spaniards - spreading democracy at the point of a gun, insinuating some divine dispensation as justification. Eighty-five percent of Americans are in the "apathetic" category. The remaining 15 percent are in a liberal/conservative conflict divided almost fifty/fifty. That means at most only 7.5 percent LIKE "the war", and 7.5 percent don't. This hardly seems like majority rule. Those involved in this conflict don't seem to be phased by this fact. I guess it's because neither side can brook disagreement. Both sides claim "morality" is on their side. Personally, for the above mentioned reasons, I don't see that morality has anything to do with it...relevancy. Thanks for your indulgence. Sorry if it gets a bit smoky with all the rounds going off. I just thought nailing-down this "morality" thing might be a good idea for once.

The more things change, the more they stay the same.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Dirk Struan
Swabbie
Posts: 121



2440 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 1:44 am    Post subject: Re: Funny you should ask. Reply with quote

Airsaw wrote:
Your patronization taken into account, the church and its influence, and the relevant monarchies and their influences are a matter of historic fact, not assumptions, and they do form logical constructs, which was my point. I have no respect for the church since it is responsible for the most amount of genocide in history and has little to do with the object of its "worship", Jesus of Nazareth. Don't look for a capitalized "c" here. (Tokenism on your part, btw.)


Your opinions of the Church aside, I was simply attempting to solicite from you the respect to which a 2,000 year old faith with many adherents, myself included, is entitled. I do not agree with the actions or teachings of many (perhaps most) other religions, but I do recognize them for what they are: important elements in the lives of people and societies and thus I treat them with the reverence they are due. Whatever your issues with Catholicism, I would kindly ask that you do the same.

That said, your response did not deal with my point. The quote that you responded to was merely a clarification of a philosophical term that you had misused.

Airsaw wrote:
I don't see the point in trying to justify the mention of ethics as a basis, or standard. Morality, ethics, law ...mores and folkways...what else do you have as a set of rules these pirates were allegedly violating?


This discussion, at least in part, assumes the existence of ethics as a standard (refer to the title). Are you asserting that ethics do not present a standard?

Airsaw wrote:
Whose standards? Who decides this? You may accept this to be fact, and nations may be able to enforce their standards OVER individuals, but a double standard is still a double standard.


I have already addressed this consideration. Government is, by nature, consentual. The people decide to create a government and for a certain purpose, thereby creating a standard for government that is and must be seperate from individuals. Hobbes argues that this is precisely why a state comes into being in the first place, because it can (and is allowed to) do things that individuals cannot do in order to fullfil the purpose for its existence.


Airsaw wrote:
NOW who's being relative? You seem to be confusing truth with power.
Now here is an objection that interests me! Not a bad point. But as I mentioned above, this question has much to do with the PURPOSE of the state. Any self-styled Hand of God with a gun can bring "justice" to a criminal, but the government because it is, as you mentioned, more powerful is able to do so more efficiently. More to the point that is WHY the government is so powerful and indeed WHY it exists in the first place. Thus the very existence of the government's power as well as its authority corresponds to the truth behind its existence: that the state is a better arbiter of justice and stability than an individual, or even a number of individuals.


Airsaw wrote:
I'm not gasping. According to all the "rules" of the day it WAS not only immoral, but illegal as well. Still, that is only an opinion. Also, you may choose to view Hobbes as some sort of unimpeachable authority, but I don't. To me, Hobbes was just another guy with an opinion.


Interesting how easily you belittle so great a mind.... Hobbes does not offer an opinion, but rather an argument as to what is true. This argument holds that only under certain circumstances can a person or persons deny the government their consent once it has been given because the state exists to further the highest good: security for those within it. Here stands tha argument. If you take issue with it you may attempt a refutation. Do not, however, expect to be able to dismiss as opinion one of the more compelling notions in the history of political thought and expect your opinion (for I have yet to see you argue the point) to go uncriticised.

Airsaw wrote:
Funny you assume you've made a point, when all you've done is demonstrate your pedantry.


I have made several points sir. I still await discussion of most of them.

Airsaw wrote:
The gauntlet is cast.
Laughing

Airsaw wrote:
Any day, now. I'm still waiting. Maybe you need directions to the ballfield since you can't seem to find it on your own:

A. I am Airsaw, the Philosophical Pirate.
B. My tactic is to enjoin my target ship's captain in lengthy discussions of irrelevancies, including quoting boatloads of philosophers who themselves are irrelevant - since when all is said and done, money still rules.
C. While said ship's captain is busy patronizing me, and my apparent ignorance, which all philosophy students do in the mistaken belief only they can be correct, my crew has boarded your vessel, raided your s
D. Wave good-bye to my Jolly Roger, the skeleton holding a scroll.

ARGH!!!

Philosophy is a chain letter. Match, point, game.


Cute. If that silly little blurb up there is any indication then you are not a philosopher but rather a Sophist and, as such you of course mistake causes for effects. Money is an means not an end. Ideas are what guide the lives of men and money is but a tool by which some ideas are realized. *sigh* Materialists.... they never learn.... Rolling Eyes
_________________
"Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.     Forum Index -> Tavern All times are GMT
Goto page 1, 2, 3  Next
Page 1 of 3

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group