Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

Talking about movies: Lord of the Rings
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Tavern Goto page 1, 2  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Rock
Cutthroat
Posts: 410


7607 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Jan 14, 2005 9:03 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

OK Billy Bones,
Now you've Struck a series I've read (at least 6 times!) The Lord of the Rings Trilogy. You're right, it was about as good of a movie adaptation as anyone could hope. Especially the extended DVD series. However, Making Arwen the hero at the "Ford" was totally stupid and almost ruins the first movie for me. Biggest mistake in the series... Frodo is portrayed as almost a wimp. The WHOLE reason he was the ring bearer was because of his strong moral character, fortitude and intelligence.

More OT... DngrMse, I think I will check out the books someday.
_________________
"You can't fight in here!! This is the war room!" - Dr. Strangelove

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Billy Bones
Seaman
Posts: 137



1817 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Jan 15, 2005 2:50 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Rock, I would agree with you WRT the ford, but the biggest mistake (IMHO) was not making four movies starting with The Hobbit.
_________________
Capt Billy Bones
at sea aboard the BlackSwan
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Rock
Cutthroat
Posts: 410


7607 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Jan 15, 2005 4:14 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Honestly, I don't really see how Jackson could have been very faithful to the Hobbit and then kept it in keeping with the rest of the movies. The Hobbit and for that matter the first half of the Fellowship of the Ring are written nearly as a childrens story. I'm sure you noticed that Jackson left out a lot of the first book (ie: Tom Bombadil) and I think that's why. In the hobbit all the creatures talked and had nice names like William and such. One of the things that always facinated me reading the series is how he shifts gears into more of an adult fantasy style of writing halfway through the Fellowship. From there on it's not childlike anymore. Anyway, for it to have the same feel and seriousness of the rest of the series, I think Jackson would have had to change a lot and I doubt many true fans would have been very happy with the result. As it is, he pulled off one of the best paper to film transitions in history. At least IMO. Especially considering he did it with what many people consider the best fictional literature of the 20th century.

Sorry guys. I know this is totally off topic.
_________________
"You can't fight in here!! This is the war room!" - Dr. Strangelove

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2005 6:32 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Rock wrote:
Honestly, I don't really see how Jackson could have been very faithful to the Hobbit and then kept it in keeping with the rest of the movies. The Hobbit and for that matter the first half of the Fellowship of the Ring are written nearly as a childrens story. I'm sure you noticed that Jackson left out a lot of the first book (ie: Tom Bombadil) and I think that's why. In the hobbit all the creatures talked and had nice names like William and such. One of the things that always facinated me reading the series is how he shifts gears into more of an adult fantasy style of writing halfway through the Fellowship. From there on it's not childlike anymore. Anyway, for it to have the same feel and seriousness of the rest of the series, I think Jackson would have had to change a lot and I doubt many true fans would have been very happy with the result. As it is, he pulled off one of the best paper to film transitions in history. At least IMO. Especially considering he did it with what many people consider the best fictional literature of the 20th century.

Sorry guys. I know this is totally off topic.



Personally, I don't think the movies remotely had a THING to do with the Lord of the Rings, which wasn't written as a trilogy, it was SOLD as one, since publishers couldn't imagine selling a thick book to the public.

I think the movie takes advantage of the run and gun blockbuster, see my fabulous computer graphics preferences of the current movie-going audience at the expense of the thrust, and gist of Tolkein's classic work.

I don't see how the Tolkein Foundation even allowed it. They must've needed money really badly. It's such a BAD representation of the story, I find it hard to believe anyone involved in the production actually read the book. You'll never get me to believe otherwise. It is so BAD, I can't bring myself to watch it all, and I am saddened to think those who do watch it might say to themselves, "I don't need to read the book(s), I saw the movie." Too sad for words.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Rock
Cutthroat
Posts: 410


7607 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2005 9:38 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Airsaw, hard to believe you found no redeeming qualities in the movies. I certainly agree that they can never match the world that Tolkien creates but what movie ever could. I think you're one of the folks who feels that a movie should never have even been attempted. Though I understand this, I enjoyed some of my favorite moments from the books visualized. I TOTALLY understand your point of view however, because I felt the same way about Stephen Kings "The Stand". Loved the book... couldn't watch the mini-series past the second night. HATED IT! Sound familar? Very Happy
_________________
"You can't fight in here!! This is the war room!" - Dr. Strangelove

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2005 9:10 pm    Post subject: Welp ... Reply with quote

I've been into Tolkein since I was fourteen. I'll be fifty in May. I've read TLoR once a year since 1980, cover to cover...actually I begin with the Silmarillion and move to the Hobbit, then the Red Book of Westmarch.

I named my children Jimi Manwe and Amelia Yavanna

Named my dog Turin, Turin of Turimbar.

I name my ships in Uncharted Waters, by KOEI, Turgon, Huor, Tuor, Hurin and Turin... IN FACT, I guess you'd say I'm "into" Tolkein's work.

What I find strange is the underlying themes of the book, which are carried forward in the characters and how they try to deal with an impossible situation, is lost by these movie characters who present the timeworn qualities of superhuman ability, aided by devices such as swords and magic, rather than the more positive qualities of hope vs. despair, honesty vs. deceit, persistance vs. brute force. The movie, probably forced by the stale repetition of it as a media, just got these things reversed, so that none of the characters were anything like the ones in the book. It was as though the movie creators were saying Tolkein got it wrong, here's how it should have went. This is what led me to believe they never really read the book. If they did, they read it like the disposable fiction that permeates our culture today, and not with a careful eye like one would read Arthurian legends, or the legends of Charlamagne.

The fact they left out Tom Bombadil says a lot. He's not just a passing character, like one passes a diner on a long trip and talks to an interesting waitress. He represents a quality within the creation of Illuvitar. The ring had no power over him, and he took the hubbub over the ring as he took the hubbub all these creatures managed to find over the ages ... not as significant in the main at all.

They portrayed Gimli like a barbarian, not with the dignity and pride the Dwarves possessed with the long lineage they called their own over the same several ages of time. He was just a gruff, rough axe swinging kinda guy. The elves were just pretty people, the kind you'd find on the beach in Venice, CA. But, the Hobbits, UGH, small teenaged boys, CUTE the way a junior high school girl would drool over.

They completely missed Sam's wisdom, portraying him as a fool, and only the events of the story itself salvaged what strength he lent to the entire affair.

Aragorn? Why didn't they just cut to the chase and get Arnold to play him? He was a handsome Conan.

But, the worst portrayal was that of Gandalf. Unless you want to belabor the point and go for days on how they didn't come close to catching Smeagol, or Gollum.

To me, you either know what you're doing, or you don't. I play music. People pay money to come see me play. They're expecting music. If I told them, "HA! you got it wrong! I do magic tricks." Then proceeded to pull rabbits from hats and guess what cards they picked, I imagine they'd be justified in wanting their money back. Same here. That's all.

If they wanted to do a movie with a bunch of monsters and guys with swords, they could have, and left Tolkein's masterpiece out of it. I have a young friend here with whom I reside, he saw the movies. I gave him the book and said, "Read this, see if it's the same." His response was that it wasn't even the same story, except in the most scant ways.

It's a lot more than just, "You can't really get the book into the movie." They did with Patton. They probably should have just left this book alone. I know it must be tempting, reading the book and imagining seeing these things on the silver screen, but some things just aren't doable.

I'll tell you, Frodo never dropped the ring. This has more significance than the movie producers understand..."OOPS!" <brushes the dirt off>

The letters were on the inside of the ring, this too is significant.

To understand the signficance of the subtleties of this tale one must have more than a passing knowledge of humanity's mythology and the symbolism therein contained. Instead they were treated by this movie as things that held up the action and used too much film. It just isn't a "cut to the chase" kind of thing. But doesn't that characterize our culture today more than anything else - people messing with things they should just leave alone? What gives them the temerity, the unmitigated gall? They have "good self-esteem."

Just an opinion.

Stephen
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Wolfwood
Boatswain
Posts: 2484



33917 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2005 10:47 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I must say that you make a persuading argument, Airsaw.

Still, I must say that although I am a fan of Tolkien's books, I could still enjoy the movies as well. I agree that they deviate a lot from the books and, in parts, tell a completely different story than Tolkien did, but I cannot blame Jackson for it.

Tolkien himself was ready and willing to sell the rights to his story if only he got good enough money for it and he gave permission to some of the worst adaptations of his work that one could imagine. Just remember how the Fellowship was supposed to fly around with eagles in one adaptation, as the walking around was deemed too boring and time consuming.

Compared to the previous attempts, Jackson's achievement is a spectacular one. It is just too bad that he did it in the vein of today's action movies...
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Jan 16, 2005 11:33 pm    Post subject: I see what you're sayin' Reply with quote

Don't get me wrong, as far as movie production goes, and what is available compared with what used to be possible ... the set design, color selection, makeup, that whole go around the movie is top notch, and in some ways sets a new standard. The massed battle scenes go way beyond what's been done before. They overcame the problem of there being so many people, and so much terrain involved. The mood is palpable, drama, fear all the emotional mix, so it can't be criticized as a stand alone work in cinema.

There, I said something nice about it. That wasn't so hard.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Hayashi
Swabbie
Posts: 121



519 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Jan 17, 2005 1:04 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Airsaw
Having read the trilogy a few times over, over the course of decades (literally), I must agree with you. But isn't that a shortcoming of the film media? To portray accurately the gist of Tolkien's work in greater depth would've required much more than 3 3-hr movies I think.
But having said all that, I enjoyed the movie trilogy. As someone else pointed out, my biggest disappointment is the portrayal of Frodo. Wimp-like in the movie, he was no wimp in the books. At the end (Scouring of the Shire) he shows great wisoom dealing with Saruman, just before Grima kills him.
He also stabbed the cave troll in the fight in Balin's tomb in Moria, whereas in the movie he was just cowering.
Pity.
I suppose also that the movie, for a person who has not read the series, would have been confusing to the average person. Heck I was pretty much confused after I completed reading the 3 books the first time. The mythology is just so rich.
So all in, I figure PJ did justice. Could've been better, but it could also have been worse.

Edit: I also wanted to add that PJ's treatment of Gollum, and the internal conflicts he faced, was imho very good. The soliloquy he had whilst Frodo & Sam were sleeping (1st half of Two Towers, coming out of Emyn Muil) was very good.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
KingWilly
Rigger
Posts: 1298



9917 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Jan 17, 2005 2:15 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Although I agree with a number of Airsaw's points, I'd have to say that I really enjoyed the Trilogy on the big screen as portrayed by PJ.

I read the books when I was growing up, and re-read them when I found out there was to be a screen adaption made. The movies left out much of the story (such as Tom Bombadil and the return home for the Hobbits), but as mentioned, if it was all left in the movies would have spanned 4.5 hours each.

I think PJ did a really good job in telling the story, but would suggest that anyone who enjoyed the movie to read the books.
_________________
Shiver me timbers!!!
"It's good to be the king" - Mel Brooks

AKA. Will Scarlett.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Rock
Cutthroat
Posts: 410


7607 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Jan 17, 2005 5:04 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Airsaw, I agree with most of your points however I don't think my reading experience was as in depth or even as emotional as yours. I too have read the books several times starting at 15 with The Hobbit. I even read it and the trilogy to my kids once. They knew all about the movies coming out years before all of thier friends did because I stumbled on a website about it around '1997' and of course they already knew the story. My oldest is 15 and he's read the whole series himself (before the first movie came out). So for us, we were waiting for the movies with baited breath. They enjoy them much more than I have and but for a few skepticisms, I try to keep my opinions to myself. Simply didn't want to piss all over it for them. They have enough of their own complaints about differences between the book and the film. However they love the movies and many (not enough) people will read JRR Tolkien's work as a direct result. Isn't that a good thing?

Someone mentioned that the Trilogy was difficult reading. The first time I read it, it was very difficult for me but I trudged on. Even now I learn or actually understand new things that I just didn't catch in a previous reading.

While reading it to my kids I found myself interpreting a lot of it. I would sometimes read a word and explain what it meant but if I did this for everything they didn't understand, I'd STILL be reading it to them (ie: instead of "league" I'd say "a long way" or "many miles" or for "clad" I'd say "dressed" etc. Sometimes I might even edit an entire paragraph so that they could grasp it. My point here is I can understand how Jackson had a monumental task to translate this all into a movie and a movie that could make money. It's too bad but that is always the bottom line no matter the topic.

I'll end here with a couple of things I find rather funny...

1) Airsaw, I won't even try to debate the books with you. You are obviously one of the biggest fans I have ever known and you express yourself well. However, I just have to point out the fact that your spelling Tolkiens name wrong. Very Happy I can't spell to save my ass and probably have spelled words wrong all over this forum - even in this post! But I couldn't help but jab you with it. Wink

2) One great thing about the movies... It sure pointed out to me how much I was butchering the place names!! I had most (or all) the character names right on but the way I was sounding out several of the place names were Waaaaaay off! Rolling Eyes

OK. That's it for me. I guess I'm just not that deep. See ya around the forum.
_________________
"You can't fight in here!! This is the war room!" - Dr. Strangelove

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Jan 17, 2005 6:46 am    Post subject: muhahahaha Reply with quote

Thanks for the correction. I have no excuse. If you make me walk the plank over this, I wanna go with the barmaid in Trinidad. See that she's wearing a two-piece.

I do hope the movie leads people to read The Lord of the Rings. I hope also that in reading that, people might then go on to take a look at the Iliad and the Odyssey, Mort D'Arthur and the Legends of Charlamagne, as well. Not to get in any deeper than I am, I also prefer Julius Caesar's account of his campaign in Gaul to anything Tom Clancy can gin-up from his rather limited experience, and fanciful thinking. But, there you go. I must be a hardass.

I guess my point is preferring a literate culture to one that's merely well-entertained. Rome was well-entertained...there at the end.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Auldrek
Swabbie
Posts: 118


1045 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Jan 23, 2005 3:18 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

You guys are being to hard on Peter.
Face it, he did the best job anyone could have done with converting those books to a movie.

Sure it would have been great to actually break it up into 6 movies.
Sure it would have been great to have Tom Bombadil.
Sure it would have been great to have so many things done....

We are all damn lucky to have seen 3 movies are great as these as close as they are to the books.

My one complaint....
Paths of the dead King of the dead? Didnt I just see all that in Pirates of the Carribean? haha
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
GrapeJ
Swabbie
Posts: 62


349 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Jan 23, 2005 4:49 am    Post subject: I concur Reply with quote

Auldrek wrote:
You guys are being to hard on Peter.
Face it, he did the best job anyone could have done with converting those books to a movie.


If you really want to see a bad job on Tolkien try and find the Ralph Bakshi versions of "The Lord of the Rings", not only are the hobbits wimpy, but kind of dull and talk like morons. And the 1977 TV movie "The Hobbit" was pretty bad too.

Only issue I had was mainly with the third movie. OK, we get it, Sam LOVES Frodo, don't have to keep making the point over and over, so overdone that it's almost gay. And the look Aragorn gave Legolas and Gimli when they were going into the mountain of the dead army. It was the cheesiest "you guys" look ever given in a dramatic film. It came right out of a mediorcre sitcom, just out of place.
_________________
"Me? I'm dishonest, and a dishonest man you can always trust to be dishonest. Honestly. It's the honest ones you want to watch out for, because you can never predict when they're going to do something incredibly... stupid." Captain Jack Sparrow
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Rock
Cutthroat
Posts: 410


7607 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Jan 23, 2005 6:01 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

OK. I know I said I was done here... BUT... GrapeJ brought up such a good point I just have to comment. These movies (IMO) are one of the few things that has been spawned from the books that was actually worth a damn. Over many years I have bought just about everything I have found for sale that relates to TLOR. Just for fun here's a list of stuff that comes to mind...

Several years worth of calendars. (usually pretty good)

An Avalon Hill board game. (OK)

Bakshi's disaster on DVD (choke) The kids couldn't wait for the movies (I warned 'em!)

Rankin/Bass' "The Hobbit" on VHS (stupid)

A huge beautifully hand carved chess set (originally bought in Germany - AWESOME!) Before anybody even asks... I sold this like a dumb ass but I couldn't turn down the profit at the time. Each piece was about the size of a small coffee cup and the board was about the size of a small card table.

A LOTR computer game that I bought for my old Apple so long ago I don't remember the name (Junk) but I played the HELL out of it!! Rolling Eyes

A Risk style board game that me and my kids have fun with (OK)

13 audio CD set of the BBC radio Broadcast "JRR T's TLOR" it's available at Amazon. (In many ways superior to the movies) airsaw, if you're reading this, what did you think of this? Dare I ask? Laughing

"Battle for Middle Earth" real time stratagy game - Only good if you liked the movies (actually spawned from the movies) and very limited replay value. (pretty good).

And last, a couple of PS2 games my kids play. I don't take any ownership of them 'cause they're "hack n slash" arcade games. Not my cup.

I'm sure there's been other stuff but that's all that comes to mind.

Auldrek I only saw one guy being really hard on PJ's work Wink
But you have to admit, he made very strong points.

Also, I have to disagree... he did the best job anybody would not could making the movies. Example: Having Arwen be the big hero at the ford was just stupid and only put in the movie to have a female hero since Eowyn didn't appear until the second. As I understand it PJ only did this because he was under pressure. The almighty dollar speaks again.
_________________
"You can't fight in here!! This is the war room!" - Dr. Strangelove

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Tavern All times are GMT
Goto page 1, 2  Next
Page 1 of 2

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group