| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Illiad

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 13 


334 Gold -

|
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2005 8:19 am Post subject: |
|
|
I have a great test for critics of a movie derived from a book:
Could you have done any better? Yes? Then let's see a script. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Sun Jan 23, 2005 1:57 pm Post subject: I don't suppose.... |
|
|
...anyone could bring themselves to say it isn't necessary to have a movie of any sort, for once, rather than bog the issue down in discussing ad-nauseum the many and varied difficulties there are in "making THE movie." Or, are we so eaten up with this techno-crap, the written word needs augmentation, and books are hence forward to be written with the inevitable screenplay in mind? Naturally to this follows; if it can't be made into a movie, it can't be a good book. I know better than to ask, but it must be written down SOMEWHERE.
"It is better to be silent and be thought a fool
than to open your mouth and remove all doubt." A. Lincoln _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Auldrek

Swabbie 
Posts: 118 


1045 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Jan 25, 2005 6:05 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Well of course he makes good points. So do you. I read alot of fan mags and web sites and dvds extras explaining stuff. There are GOOD reasons for most of the decision made that piss people off.
However...the biggest problem is that it was done in 3 movies and not 6. That alone would have allowed more absent important stuff to be put in.
But that is completely impractical. NOONE wanted to take a chance on this. Peter Jackson was afraid that if he did not do all three in one shot he would never be able to complete the series if movie one did not do so good. Newline took a big chance. They one academy awards for best adapted screenplay from a book or whatever for a reason. Everyone really did say it could never be done. Reading those books I am AMAZED Peter did as good as he did. Well actually it was Fran Walch (sp) too.
Ok..I will admit I did not like Arwen taking the place of er ..forgot his name...at the ford. You know...orignally they wanted Arwen to bring him his sword too. hehe |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Rock

Cutthroat 
Posts: 410 


7607 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Jan 25, 2005 9:08 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Auldrek wrote: | | Ok..I will admit I did not like Arwen taking the place of er ..forgot his name...at the ford. You know...orignally they wanted Arwen to bring him his sword too. hehe |
It's not the fact that Arwen replaced Glorfindel that I disliked. Heck, I understand that you may have to combine some characters to fit into a time limited production. What bothered me was the fact that Frodo was ALONE at the ford. In the book, Frodo rides to the ford badly wounded and ALONE. Once on the other side he raises his sword and says something like, "GO BACK! You shall have neither the Ring nor me!" Then ELROND creates the wave that washes away the Black Riders. I think this is an extremely CRITICAL point in the book that displays the courage, endurance and just plain "intestinal fortitude" that Frodo possesses above even other hobbits. Like I said, IMO Frodo was a wimp in the movie, too young, as has been said before here, and to me this was the biggest mistake in the whole movie trilogy. I can forgive everything else and regardless, I really did enjoy the movies and have already said that it was a great accomplishment by PJ. _________________ "You can't fight in here!! This is the war room!" - Dr. Strangelove
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
grsmith320

Swabbie 
Posts: 118 

 
575 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Jan 25, 2005 9:33 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I read these books many years ago and many times since. I agree that there were numerous things I would have liked to have seen in the films: Frodo's house in Buckland, the Old Forest, the Scouring of the Shire etc. I was at least glad that they included the Mouth of Sauron in the extended DVD edition (it was even creepier than my imagination). There were a lot of goofy additions that i could have done without, especially in the Battle at Helm's Deep ( dwarf tossing Gimli and Legolas' snowboard stunt down the steps). But overall I loved the films for their entertainment value. _________________ Money makes the monkey dance! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Auldrek

Swabbie 
Posts: 118 


1045 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Jan 26, 2005 12:59 am Post subject: |
|
|
While Frodo may have acted like a puss sometimes I fail to see how he can be viewed as a whimp in the movie. Consider yourself in his position how far would you have gotten. His bravery and courage is shown when he decides to leave the Fellowship to go ALONE to Mordor.
I think it would be very hard for those who do not know the books to accept that this little hobbit somehow had the power to wash away all those Ringwraiths. Yes thats what people would think unless it was done so totally perfect. Besides...he needed an early way to get Liv into the movies and that was the perfect spot! heh |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|