Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

Copy protection ideas
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirates! Chat Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
bryce777
Gunner
Posts: 628



652 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2005 7:29 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
The original Pirates! game for the Commodore 64 had a fun - if equally ineffective - copy protection built in. The manual had a list of the Treasure Fleet's route and which port it visited during which month in a given year. In the background story of your pirate, as you started a game, you were at some point confronted with a trivia question on which month the Treasure Fleet would be in what port. Which you would then have to look up in the manual.

If you chose the wrong answer, the story would quickly turn against you and instead of becoming the proud captain of your first ship, you'd lose a battle and be put in a small, leaky ship with a small band of supporters. The game would be played on a hidden fifth difficulty level, where every battle was impossibly hard (maybe Swashbuckler as it is in this game was modelled after this? Very Happy). You were given ten injuries right on the spot, making sure that the health of your starting pirate was already quite poor. And just to top it off, all four nations started hostile to you so that you would instantly be jumped by big pirate hunting Frigates and fired upon no matter which port you tried to visit. Basically, your game would be impossible and you'd soon be forced to retire as a beggar.


Wow. I remember some questions like that, but I dont remember the impossibly hard level. That is pretty cool.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
dragoniv
Powder Monkey
Posts: 42


84 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2005 7:36 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Now that is creative copy protection! Smile

Sid did something similar in Railroad Tycoon many years ago. If you didn't pick the right name for the engine image (the engines were in the manual), you were limited to 2 trains on your line. Considering a successful game had at least 10 trains, this was a fairly big impediment. Still, it wasn't hard to recognize the trains names, if you were a train buff to begin with, or had photographic memory.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address Yahoo Messenger MSN Messenger
bryce777
Gunner
Posts: 628



652 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2005 7:38 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
Quote:
In fact, it's a big reason why there are so few small game companies around today--piracy makes the margins too thin. Oh, and by the way--did you ever notice how much the big game companies court the consoles? Want to know why? The latest generation consoles make game duplication far harder than it is for the PC...so they make much more money in that sector. (Not to mention, there is no tech support required for consoles.)


I don't think that piracy has anything to do with the lack of few small game companies. What killed a lot of companies was the increase in term of budget. It has become an industry comparable to the cinema because of it's success and the money it can raise.

About the companies going into the console market, it has nothing to do with piracy either. You get the point : creating a game console is less tricky- you only need to test the game on one hardware (not every mainboard chipset/gfx card/drivers version combinaison) because if it works with one ps2, it will work with the other ps2. You don't have to provide patches, everybody uses the same developpment kit. It's just safer.

BTW piracy helps selling a console. It's part of the marketing of sony. The Playstation 1 & 2 were so successfull because games were easy to copy. The pathetic copy protection used are only made to limit the piracy to a supportable level, but they are part of the business. If you want to sell a console, games must be easily copied. It's the same for the Xbox, and it is one of the reason why Nintendo were not that successfull these years, and one of the reason of the failure of Sega (Dreamcast games could be copied, but it was a pain).





Well, there has ALWAYS been piracy so I dont see how suddenly it could have sunk the small companies. One thing people dont keep in mind is a lot of the piracy is from people who would simply NEVER buy the software anyhow. Look at photoshop. It costs like 1500 dollars for their whole product suite. There are lots of people who like to goof around with images and aren't making any money off it, and pirate it, but there is no way theya re going to spend 1500 dollars so they can make a cool avatar for their cutlass isle login.

Also, the kind of people who like the games small companies produce are also the type of people who actually pay for software. I think the publishers are a bit braindead because the console kids dont think twice to copy or download games whereas the hard core roleplaying game types are older and not only wiser but also in a much better position financially.

With nongame software, I often dont have much sympathy with the producers because there are companies like microsoft that basically have a monopoly and even though their software is incredibly poor, they rake in billions of dollars without having to go to any real effort.

Piracy might help one console versus another console, as you put it, but in the long run it really does cut into the amount of money that games producers are making.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Sashanan
Swabbie
Posts: 104


1172 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2005 7:41 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I have sometimes bought a game after having played it pirated previously. In these cases, the company in question has actually made a profit off me they wouldn't have if it hadn't been possible (or too hard for me to bother) to copy their game.

But I have no illusions about the impact of piracy on the software market in general: in the big picture, it hurts sales.
_________________
"Any fool can defend his or her mistakes; and most fools do." -- Dale Carnegie
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
dragoniv
Powder Monkey
Posts: 42


84 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2005 8:00 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Yes, there has always been piracy. However, you'd have to agree that it is FAR easier to pirate games today that it ever used to be. Here's an example:

1983: Commodore 64 was king of the gaming computers. Piracy was rampant, but still limited by the lack of good networking. Modems were few and far between (and egads, if you think dialup is slow these modems could take all night to download a 64K program!), so it was complimented by sneakernet. Mass production of copied games was impossible for the average Joe.

At this point, ALL game companies are small, and piracy does not chew into their revenue stream too much. In 1983, like 80% of the titles were legit. By 1986, hacker tools has proliferated around and while newer games were still hard to come by in hacked form, older games were hacked left and right. Anybody remember Fast Hak'em? Smile

1989: PC games begin to hit the big time. Copy protection methods borrow heavily from the previous computer generations (bad sector methods, primarily). Pretty soon, Average Joe figures out that tools like Norton Utilities can be made to replicate these bad sectors. Some smarter Average Joes begin patching games to remove the copy protection logic...this practice continues to this day.

Pirating gets easier, as information exchange begins to mature. The 3.5" floppy was a big help...later helped by Novell networking. Still, piracy isn't too bad yet--it is hurting the companies, but not significantly.

1994: The WWW begins to gain wide acceptance, and pirates never looked back. Suddenly, there was this very fast, very open method to exchange hack methods with the general public, not just within the hacker community. Piracy grows by leaps and bounds...and by the late 90s, many companies are reeling from the shocks. The bigger ones continue to invest in more sophisticated anti-piracy methods, but the smaller ones (again, no economy of scale) cannot afford go this route and instead use older, easily cracked methods. As time goes on, they begin to go under, or are purchased by the bigger fish in the pond like EA.

Here we are, eleven years later. Piracy hasn't declined--it has continued to get worse. Worse yet, it has GAINED ACCEPTANCE from the general public--something software companies have been dreading.

Crystal ball time: what will be the effects by the end of this decade? Will they come up with some impermeable defense (don't bet on it)? Will games on the PC dry up completely (possible)? Who knows--but it's not a pretty picture.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address Yahoo Messenger MSN Messenger
bryce777
Gunner
Posts: 628



652 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2005 10:52 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

dragoniv wrote:
Tomi wrote:

I don't think that piracy has anything to do with the lack of few small game companies. What killed a lot of companies was the increase in term of budget. It has become an industry comparable to the cinema because of it's success and the money it can raise.

About the companies going into the console market, it has nothing to do with piracy either. You get the point : creating a game console is less tricky- you only need to test the game on one hardware (not every mainboard chipset/gfx card/drivers version combinaison) because if it works with one ps2, it will work with the other ps2. You don't have to provide patches, everybody uses the same developpment kit. It's just safer.

BTW piracy helps selling a console. It's part of the marketing of sony. The Playstation 1 & 2 were so successfull because games were easy to copy. The pathetic copy protection used are only made to limit the piracy to a supportable level, but they are part of the business. If you want to sell a console, games must be easily copied. It's the same for the Xbox, and it is one of the reason why Nintendo were not that successfull these years, and one of the reason of the failure of Sega (Dreamcast games could be copied, but it was a pain).


Sony, Microsoft and Ninetendo are not making the bulk of their money on consoles. The consoles have little margin--they make the majority of the cash on game sales. Driving up console sales by making piracy easy makes absolutely no fiscal sense.

Note also that I didn't mean to say piracy was the dominant reason for moving to consoles--but it was a factor. You may think it's easy to copy games on a console, but it's far easier to pirate PC games. You can even bypass this dreaded Steam client some folks are grumbling about--even it is far from perfect.

You are quite correct on the reason why game companies like consoles--there is only one set of hardware requirements, so most hardware related bugs SHOULD be eliminated. However, patches don't exist simply because there is no way to apply them. How many console games have you played that had bugs? I can think of quite a few across the PS, PS2, Gamecube, and even long before those systems, dating back to the archaic 2600. Anyhow, I digress.

The smaller game companies aren't getting killed by big budget productions. If that were true, why are small movie companies not only surviving, but thriving? It doesn't take a big budget to make a killer title. One need only look at a title like RollerCoaster Tycoon to see what a small developer can do...and still be very successful. However, piracy hurts them far worse than the bigger companies, mostly due to economies of scale.

You can make the argument that piracy is a good thing for manufacturers of software, but it doesn't hold water. Copy protection schemes have gotten more complex and expensive to create over the past 20 years. It makes a strong argument that most companies take piracy to be a significant threat, and are willing to invest a lot of money to make it harder for people to make or use illigitimate copies. You wouldn't take that approach if (in secret) you discovered piracy actually drove up business for your firm, would you?


If anything the game industry is much bigger than ever. The marketing is also going kind of crazy, too. Movies have been around forever and movie reviewers are very high profile and they are gone in a heartbeat if people feel they are full of it.

In the game industry there are instead tons and tons of review sites and they are not nearly as high profile. They also rely not on general advertising, like a tv or newspaper magazine would, but ENTIRELY on the advertising dollars of game companies, which are well known for yanking advertising from sites or magazines that pan their games.

It is incredibly corrupt. Back in the 80s and early 90s it didn't used to be this way. Computer Gaming World had a great format, lots of content, and game reviews that were not obvious lies told by someone who only played the game 2 hours.

This is what is killing off the small guys; all reviews are based on production value and advertising budget alone, and so games with small advertising budgets and mediocre graphics get absolutely trashed in reviews, even though the big games that are total crap get rave reviews.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
bryce777
Gunner
Posts: 628



652 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2005 10:59 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

dragoniv wrote:
Yes, there has always been piracy. However, you'd have to agree that it is FAR easier to pirate games today that it ever used to be. Here's an example:

1983: Commodore 64 was king of the gaming computers. Piracy was rampant, but still limited by the lack of good networking. Modems were few and far between (and egads, if you think dialup is slow these modems could take all night to download a 64K program!), so it was complimented by sneakernet. Mass production of copied games was impossible for the average Joe.

At this point, ALL game companies are small, and piracy does not chew into their revenue stream too much. In 1983, like 80% of the titles were legit. By 1986, hacker tools has proliferated around and while newer games were still hard to come by in hacked form, older games were hacked left and right. Anybody remember Fast Hak'em? Smile

1989: PC games begin to hit the big time. Copy protection methods borrow heavily from the previous computer generations (bad sector methods, primarily). Pretty soon, Average Joe figures out that tools like Norton Utilities can be made to replicate these bad sectors. Some smarter Average Joes begin patching games to remove the copy protection logic...this practice continues to this day.

Pirating gets easier, as information exchange begins to mature. The 3.5" floppy was a big help...later helped by Novell networking. Still, piracy isn't too bad yet--it is hurting the companies, but not significantly.

1994: The WWW begins to gain wide acceptance, and pirates never looked back. Suddenly, there was this very fast, very open method to exchange hack methods with the general public, not just within the hacker community. Piracy grows by leaps and bounds...and by the late 90s, many companies are reeling from the shocks. The bigger ones continue to invest in more sophisticated anti-piracy methods, but the smaller ones (again, no economy of scale) cannot afford go this route and instead use older, easily cracked methods. As time goes on, they begin to go under, or are purchased by the bigger fish in the pond like EA.

Here we are, eleven years later. Piracy hasn't declined--it has continued to get worse. Worse yet, it has GAINED ACCEPTANCE from the general public--something software companies have been dreading.

Crystal ball time: what will be the effects by the end of this decade? Will they come up with some impermeable defense (don't bet on it)? Will games on the PC dry up completely (possible)? Who knows--but it's not a pretty picture.


Actually, I dont think it is so much easier nowadays - in the broderbund days it was quite easy to crack most games with a single krakkit program, and no lengthy downloads of an entire dvd worth of game. I think the problem is that games are being marketed to the common denominator. That means having a wider appeal, but it also means appealing to people who are not nearly as fastidious with their moral values.

I also think the problem is overstated. In china, they pirate left and right...but if they stopped would they really pay for all those movies? No one there are afford all that. Even one movie for a dollar is a vast luxury to them. They have the money as a nation, but the Chinese government does not really bother to pay its workers.

They are certainly not going to pay 50 dollars for one game.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
dragoniv
Powder Monkey
Posts: 42


84 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Feb 12, 2005 4:11 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I dunno. I found being a pirate was a lot of work back then. It's far too easy now, and even easier to make dupes for my buddies in great numbers. Media has gotten much cheaper since the good old days, too.

Not that I do any of that, mind you. I'm a reformed pirate. Laughing
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address Yahoo Messenger MSN Messenger
bryce777
Gunner
Posts: 628



652 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 15, 2005 5:46 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

dragoniv wrote:
I dunno. I found being a pirate was a lot of work back then. It's far too easy now, and even easier to make dupes for my buddies in great numbers. Media has gotten much cheaper since the good old days, too.

Not that I do any of that, mind you. I'm a reformed pirate. Laughing


Well, it is true that copying stuff is easier at least.

It seems quite a pain to download stuff, though. The 'crack' way really sucks for reasons I stated above; many devs will make sabotage code or spyware etc.

A full download is the only way to go if you go that route IMO, and that is kind of hard to find and a pain to actually wait on.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 15, 2005 7:23 am    Post subject: CASE???? Reply with quote

I bought the Commemorative, Limited Edition DVD and it came in a genuine cardboard slip. I've been thinking about cannibalizing a CD to use that cover...cardboard, geez. You know what else. It promised the "Gold" edition of the original Pirates! for NES, playable on Windows XP. I get it, you can't read the scenario text, it won't save games. Maybe there was a rush to release it. It might do well to wait until they decide which game it is, and buy that one. The map on parchment features Sid Meier's logo so prominently, instead of a keepsake, it's an ad...parchment, bah. The text of the book doesn't match the gameplay in notable places.

It kinda made me wonder. Seemed so much like Windows and Bill Gates. He never DID get Windows 95 to work. He just contorted until he found one that would, most of the time. Maybe we're supposed to take into account the great feat in programming we just don't appreciate, since we're looking at trivial bullsh*t and making a big deal of it. But, if I go to the store to buy a bucket, and it has holes in it, I don't care HOW purty it looks, there's no point in buying that one.

With software, you don't get the luxury of that look at the hardware store. You find out after the commitment in time and effort, and munny. SO, it's not seemly to appear to be painting over the holes, or figuring they're too out of the way to be readily discernable ... ooops, my mouse pointer froze again. GET BILL GATES ON THE PHONE!!! (Or, switch to the "BETTER" XP, which I did because of that and a dozen other things...bucket my A$$.)

hummma hummmma hummmma hummmma
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 15, 2005 8:04 am    Post subject: a speal about whuh? Reply with quote

I remember not long ago, but before some of you were born, there was a big argument (legal and public) about protecting "products of intelligence", someone tried to call it "works of the mind" but remembered Jack the Ripper.

They, of course were saying that computer programs were unlike anything ever before written, drawn, sculpted, erected...go down the list...and therefore had NO legal protection, and they deserved the RIGHT to have this like everyone ELSE since it cannot be denied how much people were relying on computer programs for their own profit.

whew, so

NOBUDDY, and I mean nobuddy in Washington at the time knew a blessed thing about computers except that their various grandchildren were so preoccupied with them, they didn't give hugs at the door anymore! SO, the "lawmakers" left the "programmers" to pretty much write their own copyright protection law. I thought this was kinda funny, at the time (odd funny). But, NOBUDDY listens to me. Innyway...

When they wrote it, they tried to combine various components of other protections into theirs, with a few of their own specific additions. BUT, they were't all that astute at carnivorous contract composition, and when you look at it from the perspective of the past fifteen years (or so) it looks rather awkward at best...or should we say it? "A bit on the nerdy side." Which it is.

Naturally, you want your program, if it works, to have the acclaim it deserves, and this is where it gets sticky, but what the hell. It only eats into YOUR time as the end user. "Deserves". Well, the jury is still out on what, in the long scale of human history, computer programmers will pull down as far as stature, but (ahem) at this time they viewed "programs" to mean (in this law) the equivilent of Melville's Typee, or a Picasso. WELL. In fact that isn't really how programs are written, one guy in an attic hashing it out through starvation by candlelight...usually a "team" of people sometimes numbering into the hundreds work up this stuff...all programming setting off switches in your computer while you press a button at the correct FLASH!!!!!!

So, how can you equate the value of Melville's work - writing Moby Dick; and programmer's work - writing Lotus? Can you? Another feature to this was that long-term protection. Especially during this time, the "young upwardly-mobile people (YUPPIES)" had it in mind to run money making schemes like rockets and suck out the profits as fast a possible...very little long-term commitment at the highest management levels ... industry wide. Make that ONE program EVERYBODY loves and retire in Montreaux at 30.

SO this "value" idea got a bit stretched out of proportion. The amount of the value they claimed in the convoluted way they claimed it could never actually be collected. They were left with EULAs and threats. A EULA is a threat, when you buy something with your money, just like a mattress label is...only if you TEAR IT OFF, they claim you've done THEM harm!!!!

Well, most people I know that use Word, or Corel don't use them to dig into their programming and convert it to their own software and sell it, robbing some Microsoft weenie of his potential royalties had the customers gone rightfully to HIM! I'm just trying to type manuscripts. SO, most of a EULA is so "irrelevant" to me that it makes the word surreal, irrelevant.

A certain amount of it is merely territorial pissing. On one anti-Microsoft website it was alleged there were more than 10,000 mentions of the corporation "Microsoft" scattered throughout any computer running Windows 95. This is us. This is us. You owe this to us. But it seemed a tad lame, to me. They didn't have anyone with billyclubs to come in and pound me on the head if I did it wrong, but they sure tried to make it seem like they did. They've backed off that, these days. But for a while it was a pointless belligerence that made one wonder.

If you've hung in, thanks. The model. They tried to obtain lifetime rights, like royalties on a book, having to live with the front money coming from corporate structures in the main. They've tried to keep a HOLD on the code as best they can. But, they've had to know all along it was a losing battle. Some argue they could have handled it better if they KNEW where they planned to make their "value" come to fruition. But, back then...as finally evidenced by the .com debacle, you weren't dealing with economic genius's...just computer weenies.

Now, the digital landscape is littered by paranoid and clutching text files threatening all sorts of outlandish retribution, like an FBI warning before the movie...that'll settle the kids down.

If they could take their lesson from history and rewrite their law, then it might have a chance to make more sense. I doubt, however, they'll get that chance again. After all, by now, we've all experienced Win 95 and the shine has gone off this toy.

You may now go back to what it was you were doing.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 15, 2005 8:15 am    Post subject: Chapter 2 Reply with quote

If you read all that this must interest you.

Programmers try to take two bites of the apple. They want their initial-wave money ... the fee so to speak. THEN, they want the royalties. Royalties are paid with the money you buy the program WITH. SO, to make sure they get all their royalties, LIKE THE ROCK STARS THEY ARE, and to get a one-time fee at the sale of the product...BOTH payoffs, you get this METHOD which I'm sure not even they understand, which they created.

Instead of "selling" you the program...they "license" to you. The fact you write it on your drive, or poke it into your console is evidence of the TRUST they place in you by allowing you to HAVE a copy of the program...due largely to the inefficiencies of the computer and the internet. To them, if they could put their programs on a separate drive you access for a fee with a browser, and you couldn't have a harddrive and buy software for home, they'd be "protected". SO, to them you don't "own a copy of the program", like you'd own a book. To them you've bought the right to USE the program, more like a lending library that...charges. To enforce this they've used their computer weenie genius and come up with some doozies of devices, all of which are either lame, or lame attempts to not look lame. I think Symantec goes the farthest to make you feel you aren't really getting a tooth pulled. Microsoft is getting less over-officious.

Some people have argued hooking up the "world" to the internet in this fashion. You don't install programming, you just log onto a site that has it there and use it for a fee. All you'd have on your desk is a screen, modem and keyboard. That's control. That's also not how it's working out. That's asking a culture to use a mass-transit method of computing when they won't do it to commute.

Also, consider, when people are managing to get paid "adequately", they're not likely to significantly alter something unless it's directly tied to that number declining, the "after all, it's a business" card. If it ain't broke don't fix it? They don't consider our inconvenience and annoyance on this matter as it being "broke". I'm not sure what they call it, but I find it way annoying the cloying way they try to hook into you, for more sales, but are so slippery with "service". No pride.

Programmers can be paid like Melville, ten cents a copy sold. Or like T REX, a percentage of the gate and all T-Shirt sales. They tried to get both. Thus, the EULA, and it's accompanying accoutrement. Though, you have to admit, stealing a computer program is pretty easy, if you know how. However, judging by how much Bill Gates has socked away on HIS holy bucket, it's not like they aren't getting paid.

Others may have more to add. I wouldn't be surprised. I watched this from the vantage point of a writer trying to make money off of "per copy". Being paid a sum for having written the book? That always sounded juicy to me. A program being of creative value as a novel? If you have enough coffee, I'll argue this one with you.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
bryce777
Gunner
Posts: 628



652 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 15, 2005 5:39 pm    Post subject: Re: CASE???? Reply with quote

Airsaw wrote:
I bought the Commemorative, Limited Edition DVD and it came in a genuine cardboard slip. I've been thinking about cannibalizing a CD to use that cover...cardboard, geez. You know what else. It promised the "Gold" edition of the original Pirates! for NES, playable on Windows XP. I get it, you can't read the scenario text, it won't save games. Maybe there was a rush to release it. It might do well to wait until they decide which game it is, and buy that one. The map on parchment features Sid Meier's logo so prominently, instead of a keepsake, it's an ad...parchment, bah. The text of the book doesn't match the gameplay in notable places.

It kinda made me wonder. Seemed so much like Windows and Bill Gates. He never DID get Windows 95 to work. He just contorted until he found one that would, most of the time. Maybe we're supposed to take into account the great feat in programming we just don't appreciate, since we're looking at trivial bullsh*t and making a big deal of it. But, if I go to the store to buy a bucket, and it has holes in it, I don't care HOW purty it looks, there's no point in buying that one.

With software, you don't get the luxury of that look at the hardware store. You find out after the commitment in time and effort, and munny. SO, it's not seemly to appear to be painting over the holes, or figuring they're too out of the way to be readily discernable ... ooops, my mouse pointer froze again. GET BILL GATES ON THE PHONE!!! (Or, switch to the "BETTER" XP, which I did because of that and a dozen other things...bucket my A$$.)

hummma hummmma hummmma hummmma


Well, the microsoft thing is something else altogether.

A defacto monopoly like that is a very bad thing.

Perosnally, I feel that ALL os software should be, by law, both FREE and also OPEN SOURCE. Not to mention PRIVATE.

That is the only way people a) truly know what they are getting ie no spyware and no statistics mining and b) no one has a complete monopoly or locks out competitors or changes OS code to make competitors' programs not work (which MS does CONSTANTLY).
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
bryce777
Gunner
Posts: 628



652 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 15, 2005 7:27 pm    Post subject: Re: a speal about whuh? Reply with quote

Airsaw wrote:
I remember not long ago, but before some of you were born, there was a big argument (legal and public) about protecting "products of intelligence", someone tried to call it "works of the mind" but remembered Jack the Ripper.

They, of course were saying that computer programs were unlike anything ever before written, drawn, sculpted, erected...go down the list...and therefore had NO legal protection, and they deserved the RIGHT to have this like everyone ELSE since it cannot be denied how much people were relying on computer programs for their own profit.

whew, so

NOBUDDY, and I mean nobuddy in Washington at the time knew a blessed thing about computers except that their various grandchildren were so preoccupied with them, they didn't give hugs at the door anymore! SO, the "lawmakers" left the "programmers" to pretty much write their own copyright protection law. I thought this was kinda funny, at the time (odd funny). But, NOBUDDY listens to me. Innyway...

When they wrote it, they tried to combine various components of other protections into theirs, with a few of their own specific additions. BUT, they were't all that astute at carnivorous contract composition, and when you look at it from the perspective of the past fifteen years (or so) it looks rather awkward at best...or should we say it? "A bit on the nerdy side." Which it is.

Naturally, you want your program, if it works, to have the acclaim it deserves, and this is where it gets sticky, but what the hell. It only eats into YOUR time as the end user. "Deserves". Well, the jury is still out on what, in the long scale of human history, computer programmers will pull down as far as stature, but (ahem) at this time they viewed "programs" to mean (in this law) the equivilent of Melville's Typee, or a Picasso. WELL. In fact that isn't really how programs are written, one guy in an attic hashing it out through starvation by candlelight...usually a "team" of people sometimes numbering into the hundreds work up this stuff...all programming setting off switches in your computer while you press a button at the correct FLASH!!!!!!

So, how can you equate the value of Melville's work - writing Moby Dick; and programmer's work - writing Lotus? Can you? Another feature to this was that long-term protection. Especially during this time, the "young upwardly-mobile people (YUPPIES)" had it in mind to run money making schemes like rockets and suck out the profits as fast a possible...very little long-term commitment at the highest management levels ... industry wide. Make that ONE program EVERYBODY loves and retire in Montreaux at 30.

SO this "value" idea got a bit stretched out of proportion. The amount of the value they claimed in the convoluted way they claimed it could never actually be collected. They were left with EULAs and threats. A EULA is a threat, when you buy something with your money, just like a mattress label is...only if you TEAR IT OFF, they claim you've done THEM harm!!!!

Well, most people I know that use Word, or Corel don't use them to dig into their programming and convert it to their own software and sell it, robbing some Microsoft weenie of his potential royalties had the customers gone rightfully to HIM! I'm just trying to type manuscripts. SO, most of a EULA is so "irrelevant" to me that it makes the word surreal, irrelevant.

A certain amount of it is merely territorial pissing. On one anti-Microsoft website it was alleged there were more than 10,000 mentions of the corporation "Microsoft" scattered throughout any computer running Windows 95. This is us. This is us. You owe this to us. But it seemed a tad lame, to me. They didn't have anyone with billyclubs to come in and pound me on the head if I did it wrong, but they sure tried to make it seem like they did. They've backed off that, these days. But for a while it was a pointless belligerence that made one wonder.

If you've hung in, thanks. The model. They tried to obtain lifetime rights, like royalties on a book, having to live with the front money coming from corporate structures in the main. They've tried to keep a HOLD on the code as best they can. But, they've had to know all along it was a losing battle. Some argue they could have handled it better if they KNEW where they planned to make their "value" come to fruition. But, back then...as finally evidenced by the .com debacle, you weren't dealing with economic genius's...just computer weenies.

Now, the digital landscape is littered by paranoid and clutching text files threatening all sorts of outlandish retribution, like an FBI warning before the movie...that'll settle the kids down.

If they could take their lesson from history and rewrite their law, then it might have a chance to make more sense. I doubt, however, they'll get that chance again. After all, by now, we've all experienced Win 95 and the shine has gone off this toy.

You may now go back to what it was you were doing.


Well, this comes to what I say about a monopoly, and also my example about photoshop.

Now, there is no WAY everyone who pirates photoshop and the adobe suite would all pay 1500 dollars or so for the package. that is just crazy. Especially when most people using it use it maybe once a month for a few minutes for soemthing to show their friends.

With a standard like Microsoft Word, suddenly you HAVE to have it or else no one will even accept your resume. That is pretty ludicrous. Word is about 300 dollars standalone, plus it ALSO requires that you have windows to operate it.

So, to get most JOBS now you need to have word. That is ludicrous.

That is why for things like word processors and operating systems, all software should be both free and open source.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
dragoniv
Powder Monkey
Posts: 42


84 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Feb 15, 2005 8:27 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

You have to drive a car to get a job in most of the U.S. They don't give those away.

You have to wear clothes to get a job in pretty much all of the U.S. They don't give those away, either--at least not to most of us.

The argument that an OS must be free doesn't wash. While I think it makes the most sense for them to all be open-source, if MS wants to build a "better OS" and charge for it, so be it. Not that I've seen them build that better OS, mind you.

I've a question. How many www.fark.com Photoshop regulars do you believe have legit copies of Photoshop? I'm betting 2 of 10. Most of the rest use pirate copies day in and day out. Would they have the software if they had to pay $1500 for it? Probably not. Should they then pirate it to use it for free? Absolutely not. I don't have the money for a 2005 Corvette Z06 (yet)...should I just go lift one off the lot? I want it really badly, and I'd only drive it on Sundays. Does that make it right?

Oh, that's right--we're only talking about SOFTWARE--that's not a physical good, so it's not stealing, right?

And Airsaw--I know where you're coming from with licensing--what a joke of a economic model. Here's MS's take: we give you buggy code (which you pay for), then you pay more when you have questions or issues with it (you know, support fees--either by incident, or yearly support subscription). Cute. This day and age, most big vendors are emulating that same model.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address Yahoo Messenger MSN Messenger
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirates! Chat All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3  Next
Page 2 of 3

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group