
The morality of Piracy
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 2:21 am Post subject: Re: Somebody musta pushed my button. |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | Okay, okay, okay...apologies to those who may think this got a bit hot. I've danced around this issue, and not been precise, partly for the sake of provocation, and partly because when you see a pirate, it isn't a good idea to pull up next to him and engage in discussion. Unless, that is, you have more guns than he, and know how to use them. It's best to turn tail and run, or you'll end up being robbed, and quite possibly gutted. We're all pirates here, eh? So, luring the victim within range and keeping him there long enough to succeed in our endeavors (muhahahaha) is what we're about!
Yet, the topic deserves some serious thought on some level. I personally find it difficult to look at this in black & white terms. So, I tossed around the word "relevant" in various forms. Why? I'll tell you.
"Morality" presupposes a divine entity, or God, exists and this God has rules, or laws. These rules, or laws, are morals. Moral laws made by humans are therefore laws in line with this God's law. Humans can make laws not in line with these supposed divine rules, and they can also enforce them.
I see morality, and its accompanying rules, as only opinion, that is until people agree upon them and then put them into practice. As such, I don't see that morality existed on either side, pirates or monarchies. It's not supposing there IS no God, and there ARE no divine rules. It's accepting the reality that all parties involved, including the CHURCH, were not putting them into practice. Therefore, they did not exist; there was no morality to violate.
Why I approached the discussion as I did was simple. What are we as players, and what were "they" - the monarchies (nations did not exist at that time) and the church DOING in the Carribean to begin with? They were ripping-off the locals for their gold! What treasure are we stealing from our victims? The treasure our victims stole from somebody else. Who are we "killing" when we play? The same people who were killing the original owners of the gold, and land in order to steal it from them.
It's historical fact that Spain was a theocracy under King Phillip's rule. He expressly put Spain under the hand of the Papacy. This accounts for the difficulty Spain has had keeping abreast with the rest of Europe as nations began to be formed from these monarchies. We've come to discover over time that theocracies are inefficient forms of government. Spain's experience was one of our greatest teachers of this reality. No one can seriously claim, therefore, that the CHURCH did not have a heavy hand in the robbing of the New World. This CHURCH was the so-called purveyor of morality. However, the object of their faith, Jesus of Nazareth, was known for saying things such as, "It is more blessed to give than to recieve." AND, "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you." AND, "Turn the other cheek." I don't recall anything in The Holy Bible which said, "Steal the lives of more primitive peoples, along with their wealth and their land in order to spread Christianity." I also don't recall Jesus as saying slavery is an object of His Gospel.
Therefore, there was no morality to violate. There were no ethics, either. There were only laws. So, it's without foundation to ask about the moral implications of piracy. They were all pirates. They were all criminals. They were all thieves, and they were all murderers, the CHURCH included. Remember, if you're driving the getaway car in the U.S., during which a crime being committed results in a murder, you are charged with murder, too.
Maybe it's obtuse of me. Maybe it's just a long-winded harangue. From where I sit, it's this precise hypocracy which has prevented "us" from achieving the peace and prosperity that has been denied to us, and which we have been denied, and have denied, for more than two-thousand years. It's especially poignant in light of present world circumstances, where American Christians seem to be employing the same methodology as were the Spaniards - spreading democracy at the point of a gun, insinuating some divine dispensation as justification. Eighty-five percent of Americans are in the "apathetic" category. The remaining 15 percent are in a liberal/conservative conflict divided almost fifty/fifty. That means at most only 7.5 percent LIKE "the war", and 7.5 percent don't. This hardly seems like majority rule. Those involved in this conflict don't seem to be phased by this fact. I guess it's because neither side can brook disagreement. Both sides claim "morality" is on their side. Personally, for the above mentioned reasons, I don't see that morality has anything to do with it...relevancy. Thanks for your indulgence. Sorry if it gets a bit smoky with all the rounds going off. I just thought nailing-down this "morality" thing might be a good idea for once.
The more things change, the more they stay the same. |
About bloody time! Now this is a set of arguments worth dealing with sirrah! I salute the effort and will set to work giving it a proper treatment!
As to your first point, that morality requires God, I have already demonstrated that this is not necessarily true (see my post earlier on Kantian ethics and a priori constructs pertaining to morality) and that even if it is, the teachings of the Church on this matter do not allow for the individual interpretation of ethics (see again my earlier post on the subject).
As to your notion of morality as opinion.... You are rather inconsistent here. On the one hand you contend that none of the groups in the Carribean at the time was a moral group (itself a contestable claim that I will address shortly) and then in the same breath claim that morality is but opinion! One moment you denounce of a group as immoral and the next say that morality has no meaning. Which is it? If morality is opinion and the groups in the Carribean thought themselves moral than, by your logic, moral is what they were. On the other hand, if these groups can be denounced as immoral you have left yourself with two options: either that this assertion is meaningless because it is only your subjective opinion of morality and is BY NO MEAN supperior to the opinions of these groups as to their own morality OR some objective standard of morality does exist by which these groups (and all other groups) may be judged. Either way, a part of your assertion is wrong. But hang on! I am jussssst getting warmed up......
Let us look at the two views of morality you mention above: the relativist position (morality as opinion/consensus) and the absolutist opinion (an independed moral standard by which all parties can be judged). As I have shown, they contradict each other. Which one, then, should be chosen as the standard by which to discuss this issue you ask? Wellllll, relativism is tricky because it makes a meaningful discussion of morality difficult. If morals are opinions, and opinions are subjective than morals are subjective. If morals are subjective, little weight can be given to them and thus nothing is immoral, not piracy, rape, genocide or even Jay-walking! Thus we can see how this position is not a desirable one. But is it logically inconsistent? Why certainly! For if all moral systems are relative and subjective then the relativist moral position must itself be considered subjective as well and PRESTO dissproves its own premise! It is the classic relativist paradox: If all beleifs are equal, is the beleif that all beleifs are equal supperior to the opposite assertion? If yes than the statement is not truly relativist, if no then the statement is has no truth value.
This, of course, leaves the absolutist argument, which suggests an absolute moral standard. From whence is this standard to be derrived you may ask? Once again, refer to my post on Kantian ethics and morals as steming from pure reasoning.... Another option that you seem rather fond of is scripture. To that I say, fair point! The trouble with this option is that it doesnt exactly lend itself to philosophical investigation as it is, fundamentally a question of theology. Call it misplaced piety, call it lonnnng overdue humility, but I know little enough of theology to defer to experts on this matter......
Now, on to your assertion that the players in the Carribean were not moral. Let us look at several different options here. Your main arguments seem to be that Spain (a theocracy under Phillip) was present in the region to steal gold from the natives. It should be pointed out, first of all, that the natives often gave this gold out in trade as it was common enough to be of little real value to them. Indeed, often the people of the New World could scarcely comprehend the lust of the new comers for this useless metal. Similarly, if you read your history, Cortez and his men were attacked by the natives, after they made diplomatic overtures towards the Aztec King. They responded by fighting back and, using their supperior technology and help from friendly natives, crushed the empire and took the spoils of war. With this defeat, and the introduction of diseases by the Spanairds, the Aztec Empire collapsed into ruin. That said, the second part of the Spanish mission to the region was one of conversion, a task that was undertaken with much success. Despite the harshness of Spanish rule in the region, it could be argued that the (potential) eternal salvation of those many converts is not something to be ignored. Or so the argument went at the time. Put that way, the issue seems to me, to be rather less clear. Did the introduction of Christianity to the region bring spiritual benefits of a degree that far surpassed whatever physical harm the Spainards caused? Only God (if He exists) knows. What we do know is that Spanish and Indian blood mixed over the centuries to produce the ethnic makeup that still dominates the region, just as the cultures blended into truly beautiful and unique cultural entities.
Excellent points Airsaw! I look forward to your responses. _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 2:49 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Westley_Roberts wrote: | Hear Hear ! !
At first I trolled this topic just to look at it. I'm not much on philosophy. But after seeing the debate go from podium to podium, I fear I must applaud the lot of you for keeping this professional.
I have enjoied what I have read, and am anxious to read more.
Thank you. |
Glad you are enjoying the show. Feel free to contribute as well! Same goes to anyone else as well! Much though I love a good one-on-one debate, I long to hear a number of perspectives on this issue!  _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Westley_Roberts

Iron Guts 
Posts: 913 

 
10375 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 3:10 am Post subject: |
|
|
First of all, you guys are much more scholoarly than I, and I know my place in this type of discussion. But this entire topic, and most specifically, the last post, brought these two quotes to mind. So, umm.....
Have you heard of these people?
And this is the Blunder line
If you do not know where these came from, please, oh, please do not make me tell you...
Westley _________________
 
Have an Army Day |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 3:35 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Westley_Roberts wrote: | First of all, you guys are much more scholoarly than I, and I know my place in this type of discussion. But this entire topic, and most specifically, the last post, brought these two quotes to mind. So, umm.....
Have you heard of these people?
And this is the Blunder line
If you do not know where these came from, please, oh, please do not make me tell you...
Westley |
Hats off to you! _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Striker

Gunner 
Posts: 698 

 
680 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 3:49 am Post subject: |
|
|
Correct me if I am wrong, but isn’t the romanticizing of pirates been a more recent phenomenon? During the time of this game, nations and privateers alike ruthlessly hunted down pirates. Pirates (unlike the game) didn’t care about such niceties as Letters of Marquee or legitimacy. Their only goal was to wreak havoc and plunder. What people romanticized was people such as Sir Francis Drake. The Spanish and perhaps the French believed he was a pirate, but the people of England saw him as a military hero. His loyalty was to the British. Pirates, on the other hand, had no loyalty but to themselves. _________________ Prince John: Save me, save me! Hurt them, hurt them!
Sherrif of Rottingham: Save them, save them, hurt you, hurt you, yes, I've got it! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 7:45 am Post subject: Re: Funny you should ask. |
|
|
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
Your opinions of the Church aside, I was simply attempting to solicite from you the respect to which a 2,000 year old faith with many adherents, myself included, is entitled. Whatever your issues with Catholicism, I would kindly ask that you do the same. |
Ask all you want. I respect only that which is deserving of respect. I do respect Jesus of Nazereth. Furthermore, I don't think age in itself is a sign of anything but being old. Just don't get the idea I'm singling-out the Roman Catholic Church. (You do understand that "catholic" means "one true". Catholic church means "one true church". I guess that is a sign of respect for all the other denominations. Words are not small things.) Sometimes people must tolerate the speech of others, even though they may disagree. Some amendment thingy in the U.S. declares that so. You may be confident, I don't shout "fire" in crowded theaters.
| Dirk Struan wrote: | | That said, your response did not deal with my point. The quote that you responded to was merely a clarification of a philosophical term that you had misused. | To belabor the point, as I said, I didn't misuse the term.
| Airsaw wrote: | | I don't see the point in trying to justify the mention of ethics as a basis, or standard. Morality, ethics, law ...mores and folkways...what else do you have as a set of rules these pirates were allegedly violating? |
| Dirk Struan wrote: | | This discussion, at least in part, assumes the existence of ethics as a standard (refer to the title). Are you asserting that ethics do not present a standard? | Thanks for posting that quote. I think I said that in the above, unless you require I use your language...okay...what else do you have as a set of standards these pirates were allegedly violating? I thought you had a point to make, sorry.
| Dirk Struan wrote: | | I have already addressed this consideration. Government is, by nature, consentual. |
Maybe we should have told this to George III. Valley Forge would then have been just a poorly planned party! Since when is a dictatorship, or a monarchy, or a theocracy for that matter "consentual"? Or, are these something other than governments?
| Dirk Struan wrote: | | Hobbes argues that this is precisely why a state comes into being in the first place, because it can (and is allowed to) do things that individuals cannot do in order to fullfil the purpose for its existence. |
I see your confusion, now. You've decided to take Hobbes as your gospel. Note the little "g". Have you ever read Unanimo? Need I remind you that 17th Century Europe had little in the way of democracy? Maybe you need to look up the word MONARCHY.
| Airsaw wrote: | | I'm not gasping. According to all the "rules" of the day it WAS not only immoral, but illegal as well. Still, that is only an opinion. Also, you may choose to view Hobbes as some sort of unimpeachable authority, but I don't. To me, Hobbes was just another guy with an opinion. |
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
Interesting how easily you belittle so great a mind.... |
That's YOUR opinion.
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
Hobbes does not offer an opinion, but rather an argument as to what is true. |
I'm sorry, unproved arguments are opinions.
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
I have made several points sir. I still await discussion of most of them.
|
Oh yeah. Sure. Whatever you say. 'T is as clear as the summer sun.
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
If that silly little blurb up there is any indication then you are not a philosopher but rather a Sophist and, as such you of course mistake causes for effects. Money is an means not an end. Ideas are what guide the lives of men and money is but a tool by which some ideas are realized. *sigh* Materialists.... they never learn.... |
Naturally, when someone resorts to name-calling, I chalk-up the win. Make up your mind. Which is it? Am I a sophist, materialist, or just confused as to cause and effect? I'm not a philosopher. I'm just a person. I would think you'd know the golden rule: He who has the gold makes the rules. "The love of money is the root of all evil." Some famous guy said that. I gather you've been so eager to belittle me, you didn't read closely enough to see that in there somewhere. I know I hit that nail several times. Maybe you should loan me YOUR thesaurus. Your opinions, though strongly felt, remain opinions. No amount of obfuscation on your part makes it otherwise.
Philosophy is a chain letter. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:02 am Post subject: Re: Somebody musta pushed my button. |
|
|
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
As to your first point, that morality requires God, I have already demonstrated that this is not necessarily true (see my post earlier on Kantian ethics and a priori constructs pertaining to morality) and that even if it is, the teachings of the Church on this matter do not allow for the individual interpretation of ethics (see again my earlier post on the subject). | I'm sorry, you haven't demonstrated anything of the sort. Morals are God's rules. Laws are men's rules. Kant never could.
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
As to your notion of morality as opinion.... You are rather inconsistent here. | You are wrong, sir. I said morals are opinions until they are made manifest into reality by agreement and action. Otherwise, they're just nice ideas, akin to a wish list. This means sentient beings must accept, adopt and USE these ideas, make them manifest into reality, or they remain opinions. I would think this puts the onus on mankind as a responsibility; practice what you preach, to oversimplify. I'm afraid this misreading makes your lengthy dissertation which follows rather...unnecessary.
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
Excellent points Airsaw! I look forward to your responses. |
I somehow think I should thank you for saying this. However, it sounds a tad like, "Come into my parlor," said the spider to the fly.
If we back off the egos, and the loyalties a moment, allow me to ask that you not take my responses as an attack on you. To me its words words words. At the meeting where the Nazi high command was formalizing what is quaintly called "The final solution," an SS officer who was also an attorney was asked how he squared being a lawyer with murdering 20,000+ Latvians. He replied, "It's made me mistrustful of words. Bullets. They speak the truth. You can believe them."
words...words...words... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:10 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Striker wrote: | | Correct me if I am wrong, but isn’t the romanticizing of pirates been a more recent phenomenon? During the time of this game, nations and privateers alike ruthlessly hunted down pirates. Pirates (unlike the game) didn’t care about such niceties as Letters of Marquee or legitimacy. Their only goal was to wreak havoc and plunder. What people romanticized was people such as Sir Francis Drake. The Spanish and perhaps the French believed he was a pirate, but the people of England saw him as a military hero. His loyalty was to the British. Pirates, on the other hand, had no loyalty but to themselves. |
Yeah, in a long-winded way I was trying to say that. To me, there was nothing wrong with this. The European monarchies weren't loyal to their citizens, they were loyal to themselves first. So, who are THEY to get it all their way? I think this drove pirates more than anything else; a desire for freedom. Most pirates had worked "for the crown" to find their ways to the Caribbean. Not many set out from Europe on a store-bought boat to go be a pirate. Most had worked, and been abused, on state-run vessels. Most were tired of the bullshit. I think that's what caused the later romanticization. We who don't feel all that free in general tend to idealize those who strike out on their own courses, despite the dangers and difficulties, showing true independence. Anyway, that's how I see it. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:19 am Post subject: Re: Somebody musta pushed my button. |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | | Dirk Struan wrote: |
As to your first point, that morality requires God, I have already demonstrated that this is not necessarily true (see my post earlier on Kantian ethics and a priori constructs pertaining to morality) and that even if it is, the teachings of the Church on this matter do not allow for the individual interpretation of ethics (see again my earlier post on the subject). | I'm sorry, you haven't demonstrated anything of the sort. Morals are God's rules. Laws are men's rules. Kant never could.
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
As to your notion of morality as opinion.... You are rather inconsistent here. | You are wrong, sir. I said morals are opinions until they are made manifest into reality by agreement and action. Otherwise, they're just nice ideas, akin to a wish list. This means sentient beings must accept, adopt and USE these ideas, make them manifest into reality, or they remain opinions. I would think this puts the onus on mankind as a responsibility; practice what you preach, to oversimplify. I'm afraid this misreading makes your lengthy dissertation which follows rather...unnecessary.
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
Excellent points Airsaw! I look forward to your responses. |
I somehow think I should thank you for saying this. However, it sounds a tad like, "Come into my parlor," said the spider to the fly.
If we back off the egos, and the loyalties a moment, allow me to ask that you not take my responses as an attack on you. To me its words words words. At the meeting where the Nazi high command was formalizing what is quaintly called "The final solution," an SS officer who was also an attorney was asked how he squared being a lawyer with murdering 20,000+ Latvians. He replied, "It's made me mistrustful of words. Bullets. They speak the truth. You can believe them."
words...words...words... |
You do not seem to understand my points. Does not necessarily have anything to do with God. Indeed, Kant's Categorical Emperitive doesnt require God in order to provide a moral basis. Read my posts, I have explained this. Advocacy of murder is self-limiting in that it eliminates the advocate and thus is logically inconsistent WHETHER GOD EXISTS OR NOT. Read my posts, I have explained this.
So morality is just any set of values put into action then? Im afraid that my lengthy discussion is only too pertinent because applied opinion is still subjective, and thus we RUN INTO THE SAME PROBLEM AS BEFORE. Here we once again run into the relativist problem of internal inconsistency. There has to be some sort of universal standard for morality apart from opinion APPLIED OR OTHERWISE. You cannot get around this argument. Answer it or admit defeat but do not shirk the issue by attempting to question its pertinence. Read my posts, I have explained this.
Words are what matter man! Even in the example that you gavem Nazism was an Ideology. A set of ideas. Words gave it life. Words drove men to fight and die and kill for it. Money is a tool. That SS grunt was a tool. Means to an end. That end was, is and remains an idea. Power is irrelevent unless it furthers AN END. And that is what you fail to comprehend. _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:27 am Post subject: Re: Somebody musta pushed my button. |
|
|
| Dirk Struan wrote: | | Power is irrelevent unless it furthers AN END. And that is what you fail to comprehend. |
You philosophy types always feel it's necessary to tell someone they do not comprehend. Power is an end unto itself. Power for the sake of power is the basis of sociopathy. Apparently you aren't a sociopath and your reasoning mind leads you to the need for an end. Not everyone is like that, so it's not an absolute. It's not that I don't comprehend what you assert about power. It's just that I didn't think it was necessary to hash over the obvious, just like I don't think I need to assert that rain comes from the sky, and if you jump into the ocean in your birthday suit you get wet.
Now, I'm tired of your petty ad hominem attacks offered as witty asides and my participation in this string is terminated. Philosphy is still a chain letter, and you know very well what I mean by that. Stew over it if you like. If you place each philosopher end-to-end, they point in every direction. One thing my extensive experience in dealing with philosophy majors has led me to suspect is that they all are closet logisticians. Allow me to immorally and unethically go blast some Spaniard papists outta the water. Nice talking to you. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:36 am Post subject: Re: Funny you should ask. |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | | Dirk Struan wrote: |
Your opinions of the Church aside, I was simply attempting to solicite from you the respect to which a 2,000 year old faith with many adherents, myself included, is entitled. Whatever your issues with Catholicism, I would kindly ask that you do the same. |
Ask all you want. I respect only that which is deserving of respect. I do respect Jesus of Nazereth. Furthermore, I don't think age in itself is a sign of anything but being old. Just don't get the idea I'm singling-out the Roman Catholic Church. (You do understand that "catholic" means "one true". Catholic church means "one true church". I guess that is a sign of respect for all the other denominations. Words are not small things.) Sometimes people must tolerate the speech of others, even though they may disagree. Some amendment thingy in the U.S. declares that so. You may be confident, I don't shout "fire" in crowded theaters.
| Dirk Struan wrote: | | That said, your response did not deal with my point. The quote that you responded to was merely a clarification of a philosophical term that you had misused. | To belabor the point, as I said, I didn't misuse the term.
| Airsaw wrote: | | I don't see the point in trying to justify the mention of ethics as a basis, or standard. Morality, ethics, law ...mores and folkways...what else do you have as a set of rules these pirates were allegedly violating? |
| Dirk Struan wrote: | | This discussion, at least in part, assumes the existence of ethics as a standard (refer to the title). Are you asserting that ethics do not present a standard? | Thanks for posting that quote. I think I said that in the above, unless you require I use your language...okay...what else do you have as a set of standards these pirates were allegedly violating? I thought you had a point to make, sorry.
| Dirk Struan wrote: | | I have already addressed this consideration. Government is, by nature, consentual. |
Maybe we should have told this to George III. Valley Forge would then have been just a poorly planned party! Since when is a dictatorship, or a monarchy, or a theocracy for that matter "consentual"? Or, are these something other than governments?
| Dirk Struan wrote: | | Hobbes argues that this is precisely why a state comes into being in the first place, because it can (and is allowed to) do things that individuals cannot do in order to fullfil the purpose for its existence. |
I see your confusion, now. You've decided to take Hobbes as your gospel. Note the little "g". Have you ever read Unanimo? Need I remind you that 17th Century Europe had little in the way of democracy? Maybe you need to look up the word MONARCHY.
| Airsaw wrote: | | I'm not gasping. According to all the "rules" of the day it WAS not only immoral, but illegal as well. Still, that is only an opinion. Also, you may choose to view Hobbes as some sort of unimpeachable authority, but I don't. To me, Hobbes was just another guy with an opinion. |
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
Interesting how easily you belittle so great a mind.... |
That's YOUR opinion.
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
Hobbes does not offer an opinion, but rather an argument as to what is true. |
I'm sorry, unproved arguments are opinions.
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
I have made several points sir. I still await discussion of most of them.
|
Oh yeah. Sure. Whatever you say. 'T is as clear as the summer sun.
| Dirk Struan wrote: |
If that silly little blurb up there is any indication then you are not a philosopher but rather a Sophist and, as such you of course mistake causes for effects. Money is an means not an end. Ideas are what guide the lives of men and money is but a tool by which some ideas are realized. *sigh* Materialists.... they never learn.... |
Naturally, when someone resorts to name-calling, I chalk-up the win. Make up your mind. Which is it? Am I a sophist, materialist, or just confused as to cause and effect? I'm not a philosopher. I'm just a person. I would think you'd know the golden rule: He who has the gold makes the rules. "The love of money is the root of all evil." Some famous guy said that. I gather you've been so eager to belittle me, you didn't read closely enough to see that in there somewhere. I know I hit that nail several times. Maybe you should loan me YOUR thesaurus. Your opinions, though strongly felt, remain opinions. No amount of obfuscation on your part makes it otherwise.
Philosophy is a chain letter. |
Catholic means Universal. Look it up. And while you are at it, look up A priori, a term that you did misuse and that we need in applying it to a beleif rather than a rational construct. It is a nonsensical statement to have a "beleif in God a priori."
As for Hobbes, he backs his assertions with logic which is more than I can say for your counter-assertions.... You do no seem to understand Hobbes' point in this regard so I will try again before deeming you a lost cause. I will repeat his reasoning once more: people band together to form states consentually and for their own protection. This is the primary reason any state (even a monarchy) comes into being and is the source of its authority. Since a state exists, most fundamentally to protect itself and (by extension) its people, it has absolute authority. This statement is proven in how states behave in that all states will, when it comes down to it, ACT TO PRESERVE THEIR SECURITY. You want proof? Well thats it.
As to your Golden rule, its a good one liner but no real argument. I have already dealt with it sufficiently: Gold is a means not an end. Ideas are power. Beleif in the supremacy of materialism both mistakes an effect for a cause, and is materialistic, while pretending to philosophize for your personal ends is sophistry. Thus you can see why I applied all of these titles to you, based upon what you have said. In any event, it is late and I grow weary of defining terms and repeating arguments that you refuse to address..... Come back when you have something new and substantial to offer the discussion.... _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 5:01 pm Post subject: Re: Funny you should ask. |
|
|
| Dirk Struan wrote: | | Come back when you have something new and substantial to offer the discussion.... |
Try this, Dirk. Kiss my xxx -grits.
Last edited by Airsaw on Mon Mar 21, 2005 6:43 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Striker

Gunner 
Posts: 698 

 
680 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 5:06 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Let's cool it, guys. Remember this is just a friendly discussion related to Pirates! the game. We don't want Falconer to have to put a lock on this thread. It's actually quite informative.  _________________ Prince John: Save me, save me! Hurt them, hurt them!
Sherrif of Rottingham: Save them, save them, hurt you, hurt you, yes, I've got it! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 5:39 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Well I, for one, will not mourn the end of that particular discussion....
For the record let me state that it was not my intention that this thread degrade into a shouting match between any two participants.....
So, in the perhaps vain hope of keeping what is at least potentially an interesting thread open, I will attempt to bring us back to the original topic: the morality of Piracy.
Does anyone have any new thoughts to add?  _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
TheDon

Rigger 
Posts: 1289 


16718 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 6:26 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Concerning the morality of Pirates... I'll just say that morality, whether of any particular act or of a lifestyle in general, is a personal issue. Yes, it is most often judged by the standards of the community, but it still comes down to personal belief of whether something is the right or wrong thing to do. Then it's a choice of whether to go ahead and do it anyway. Just because you believe something is wrong doesn't mean you're not going to do it.
We of the 21st century can take "the pirate life" and make it playful and fun because we didn't live it and haven't suffered any harm because of it. (The same holds true for some who like to dress in Nazi uniforms for Halloween, even though many others think it's wrong.)
Every year at Fernandina Beach, Florida, they hold the Blessing of the Fleet and the Landing of the Pirates. The Pirates come ashore and run around pretending to terrorize everybody and it's a lot of fun (they rarely rape or kill anyone, of course). I'm sure there are some who want to criticize the glamorization of a bunch of murderous thieves, but most people just enjoy the show.
As for the morality of the GAME Pirates!... to quote Star Wars creator George Lucas (when told about the throngs of people who were lined up for blocks dressed in Star Wars outfits) "...it's just a game, people. Get a life!"
or in this case... live the life.
That's my 2 doubloons. Your knots/hr may vary.
thedon |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|