
The morality of Piracy
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 6:34 pm Post subject: Argh! |
|
|
| Striker wrote: | | Let's cool it, guys. Remember this is just a friendly discussion related to Pirates! the game. |
Well, okay. When you're right, you're right. I should be satisfied in knowing an objective eye can read in plain English what my point of view is with regard to western civilization's sanctimonious charade with regard to morality. I am a pirate at heart, and if the present empire didn't have nukes, I'd be out there with my cannon givin' 'em hell. I didn't mean to (pontif)icate. But, readers of this thread can be assured I've done my best to present a view based in historical fact, regardless of how it might singe the sensibilities of those still in thrall of conventional wisdom. In fact, one might surmise how this all boiled-down (if placed in the 17th Century) obviates Frederick the Great's engraving he placed on all his cannon: "The final argument of kings." Pirates wanted to be their own kings.
The mention of Sir Francis Drake is very significant in that what he was commissioned to do for Elizabeth I is now considered to be a valid military tactic, which was raiding the enemy's line of supply. During WWII a massive effort was made by the Allies to destroy the Ploesti oil fields in Romania. The cost in aircrews and aircraft was staggering even by the standards of the time. The effort was to deprive the Nazis of black gold. You may have a lot of tanks, but if they don't have fuel, their mobility becomes non-existant. Then comes Patton's philosophy: "Fixed fortifications are monuments to the stupidity of man."
When Elizabeth took the throne she had nothing in the way of an army. Her navy wasn't even an afterthought, being only what flotillas she could assemble from volunteers from either Dover, or Bristol. Her treasury was depleted from the corruptions of the royalty which had preceeded her, and in short she was targeted by both Spain and France who didn't share her weaknesses by a long shot.
Drake saved England from conquest. He diverted the funds which would have served to strengthen Spain, into England's coffers. Elizabeth made judicious use of the wealth. Even during the attempted invasion by the Spanish Armada, England was not militarily fit enough to stave-off a successful landing of forces. Had the Armada succeeded in landing troops, she would have been able only to fight an enforced retreat until she ran out of island to retreat to.
If you were English, Drake provided a means for survival. If you were Spanish, Drake was a scurrilous pirate. It defies belief to assume Spain was unaware of the military ramifications of this "strategy" employed by England. So, their protestations to the contrary could be an example of the first spin doctors in history. Spain was also aided and abetted by the Papal See because Elizabeth was allowing the Protestants to practice their beliefs unopposed. Some say to avoid civil war. Some say because she was that liberal in her thinking. She said it was both.
When we (the U.S.) were targets of Nazi U-boats attacking supplies headed for Britain, we viewed it as an act of war. This more than anything else stimulated the change from an isolationist point-of-view in the U.S. to one which allowed Roosevelt to enter the war without much domestic opposition - something he'd wanted to do much sooner, but for the possibility of unrest at home. In fact, the U-boat's main object was to interdict shipping. There we have a new term enter the vocabulary. What was once called "piracy" became known as "interdicting shipping." However, this is illusory in a sense, because the U.S. public still viewed supply ships as civilian, not military targets, and thus arose the indignation.
It's safe to say today that all modern military planners view supply shipping, and supply lines as military targets without question. We can thank Francis Drake for initiating this innovation. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 7:32 pm Post subject: ah, not so fast there skippy |
|
|
| Dirk wrote: | | Catholic means Universal. Look it up. And while you are at it, look up A priori, a term that you did misuse and that we need in applying it to a beleif rather than a rational construct. It is a nonsensical statement to have a "beleif in God a priori." |
belief, not beleif - You are incorrect. Before Martin Luther, as there was but one Christian religious organization, it was called "The Universal Church". After the 99 Theses, the name was changed to "Catholic Church", which indeed means "One True Church", because there were now two "churches", and the once "Universal Church" felt it was necessary to make this distinction. "Universal" was used in the sense of the language of that age - "uni" being Latin for "one." It would have been inaccurate to say, after the advent of Protestantism, there was only one church. The response by the Universal Church was to declare by its name that though there were now two churches, only one was a valid church, hence the name "Catholic Church" - or One True Church. A visit to a first-year western civ textbook should be sufficient enough to bear me out on this.
Insofar as your continued insistance I used the term "a priori" incorrectly, I suggest you read more carefully. Apparently you read with the swiftness, and care of someone who's more intent upon preparing a response, than clearly cognating that to which you are responding. I used "a priori" in reference to the English, Spanish and French monarchies which were indeed well-established logical constructs. But, then, I saw you had trouble even viewing monarchies as forms of government. It might behoove you to read more carefully. If what I write isn't worthy of careful reading, how then could it be worthy of a volatile response?
An a priori argument is taken to reason deductively from abstract general premises, while an a posteriori argument relies upon specific information derived from sense perception. The necessary truth of an a priori proposition can be determined by reason alone, but the contingent truth of an a posteriori proposition can be discovered only by reference to some matter of fact.
Thus, for example: It can be deduced the European monarchies existed as legal, moral and logical constructs by deducing from the behaviors of their adherents. It can't be deducted a posteriori, since it's just an idea - an idea with substantial effects, i.e. I am the king. If you don't believe me, meet my army. In other words, a monarchy doesn't exist unless one believes it exists. The trappings of the monarch don't come into reality until this belief is accepted. These trappings, armies, thrones, crowns, realms, don't come into existence until after the belief is adopted. The belief is not attained by the physical proof of these trappings, these are results of the belief. Many is the time two men claimed to be the monarch of a realm, for instance the Yorks and Lancasters. It wasn't until enforcement by military means, when one defeated the other that this belief was then transformed into a reality that could be seen a posteriori.
Insofar as belief in God a priori, I would refer you to Descartes who ginned-up the "ergo sum" (I think, therefore I am) attempting to prove to himself the existence of God with "demon-proof certainty". Firstly, this need to not be decieved infers there was no physical proof, or proof by the senses. Secondly, we can assume Descartes was unaware of the cognitive processes of the brain, i.e. synapses, axons, dendrites, neural pathways, etc., and so considered "thought" in more of an atmospheric sense, or he would have said "I have a brain, therefore I am." Wasn't this an attempt to prove God's existence "a priori"?
I'm not sure what the jargon of your field calls the approach you've taken in this string. My field of literature calls this "tilting at windmills." Your suggestion to get back to the issue at hand, which you introduced, sounds like a good one to me. Why don't you give it a shot?
Last edited by Airsaw on Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:37 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:08 pm Post subject: Re: ah, not so fast there skippy |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | | Dirk wrote: | | Catholic means Universal. Look it up. And while you are at it, look up A priori, a term that you did misuse and that we need in applying it to a beleif rather than a rational construct. It is a nonsensical statement to have a "beleif in God a priori." |
belief, not beleif - You are incorrect. Before Martin Luther, as there was but one Christian religious organization, it was called "The Universal Church". After the 99 Theses, the name was changed to "Catholic Church", which indeed means "One True Church", because there were now two "churches", and the once "Universal Church" felt it was necessary to make this distinction. "Universal" was used in the sense of the language of that age - "uni" being Latin for "one." It would have been inaccurate to say, after the advent of Protestantism, there was only one church. The response by the Universal Church was to declare by its name that though there were now two churches, only one was a valid church, hence the name "Catholic Church" - or One True Church. A visit to a first-year western civ textbook should be sufficient enough to bear me out on this.
Insofar as your continued insistance I used the term "a priori" incorrectly, I suggest you read more carefully. Apparently you read with the swiftness, and care of someone who's more intent upon preparing a response, than clearly cognating that to which you are responding. I used "a priori" in reference to the English, Spanish and French monarchies which were indeed well-established logical constructs. But, then, I saw you had trouble even viewing monarchies as forms of government. It might behoove you to read more carefully. If what I write isn't worthy of careful reading, how then could it be worthy of a volatile response?
An a priori argument is taken to reason deductively from abstract general premises, while an a posteriori argument relies upon specific information derived from sense perception. The necessary truth of an a priori proposition can be determined by reason alone, but the contingent truth of an a posteriori proposition can be discovered only by reference to some matter of fact. Thus, for example: It can be deduced the European monarchies existed as legal, moral and logical constructs by deducing from the behaviors of their adherents. It can't be deducted a posteriori, since it's just an idea - an idea with substantial effects, i.e. I am the king. If you don't believe me, meet my army.
I'm not sure what the jargon of your field calls your approach. My field of literature calls this "tilting at windmills." Your suggestion to get back to the issue at hand, which you introduced, sounds like a good one to me. Why don't you give it a shot? |
Trying to change your story I see..... Lets take another look at just what you said:
| Airsaw wrote: | | Morality exists with the acceptance a priori of a divine entity and would then be layed-out by the agents of said divinity - the church. Pirates merely practiced the ethics of the church as it existed at that time. |
Uh oh..... someone either cant remember the original context of his statements OR is trying to cover up his ignorance of terminology....
As for the word Catholic, since you did not take my advice by looking the term up I will, as usual, do it for you:
(14:59:34) SmarterChild: Definition provided by The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition. Copyright © 2000 by Houghton Mifflin Company. Other important copyright information here.
catholic:
Adjective
1. Of broad or liberal scope; comprehensive: "The 100-odd pages of formulas and constants are surely the most catholic to be found" (Scientific American). 2. Including or concerning all humankind; universal: "what was of catholic rather than national interest" (J.A. Froude). 3. Catholic a. Of or involving the Roman Catholic Church. b. Of or relating to the universal Christian church. c. Of or relating to the ancient undivided Christian church. d. Of or relating to those churches that have claimed to be representatives of the ancient undivided church.
Noun
Catholic A member of a Catholic church, especially a Roman Catholic.
Etymology
Middle English catholik, universally accepted, from Old French catholique, from Latin catholicus, universal, from Greek katholikos, from katholou, in general : kat-, kata-, down, along, according to ; see cata- + holou (from neuter genitive of holos, whole; see sol- in Indo-European roots).
There it is in black and white. Sorry, wrong again. _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Westley_Roberts

Iron Guts 
Posts: 913 

 
10375 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:16 pm Post subject: |
|
|
<Westley stands from his seat on the floor and meanders to the stage, in a clear move to obtain one of the microphones from the positioned podiums. >
Gentlemen, although I am not as learned as our esteemed colleagues, I shall attempt to make my thoughts on the subject at hand known. I realize much of this debate has been based and discussed on various philosophies, and religions. I cannot and will not march into this foray, but instead discuss the use of pirates by the various governments of the time, as ‘I’ see it.
First and foremost, this may sound rambling, but if you can follow my train of thought whilst I make my points, I will thank you, and return to my seat, and allow you to continue on.
I believe that at the point of history we are discussing, there was a New World waiting to be discovered and exploited by the Powers that be. Each of these Powers were taking what they could get their hands on and attempting to hold it for all they were worth. Each of these Powers had their own fleets, flying their own banners. Some were at declared war at times, some actually found peace between them, for a time. While all this was going on, some enterprising individuals acquired the means to patrol the area in question. Some even went as far as to take what they could, regardless of what banner was displayed. These enterprising individuals, when placed in front of various Powers, were either lambasted for their crimes, or were thanked, with much appreciation. These, I’ll call them Pirates for the remainder, just for simplicities sake, Pirates, flew their own banners, and did not sail for any Power, save their own. When they were thanked, it was in prestige for that Power, and sometimes land, which was a valuable currency for the time. As the Pirates raided the shipping lanes, they took what they could, for their own gains, and were rewarded for it, depending on the Power that was on the other side of a battle line.
The area of this conflict was contested land, for all the major Powers were striking claims to it. There was no system in place to say what area was whose, save whoever was standing on it at the time. All these Powers wanted was to further their own wealth and land, and reap the riches of the commodities available in the area.
Back to the subject, Pirates only performed, under their own flag what the other Powers were doing under their own banner. They were rewarded for it, and thus continued their business. So, to ask if it was moral would not be proper, for they were following what was being shown to them by the Powers. Did not Spain have a little thing called the Inquisition? Did not England have its own issues with disposing of their non-conformists? Did not the Dutch look upon these waters for financial gains only? What of the French that acquired a large portion of the mainland?
Therefore, I present to you, a current scenario, an example of people taking law into their own hands, and praised for it... Hells Angels. Now, I am by no means saying I know much about the organization, but from what I have seen and remember from the news media. this group performs what the government does, establishes a safety perimeter for concerts, attempts to keep the peace in otherwise unruly areas, and is sometimes thanked, other times lambasted for their actions? I only provide this for an example of having a government support an outside source which is providing a service that said government cannot perform under their own banner/uniform/flag…
I hope somewhere in there my thoughts on the matter made some sort of sense. To sum up, Pirates were an outside source, loyal to none, but thanked by the opposing team for their actions, perhaps even condoned for it. The Powers at the time were doing the same, but under their own banner.
Thank you for your time.
<Westley places the microphone back into the stand, and returns to his place, in the chair, on the floor of this great debate hall, silent, again.> _________________
 
Have an Army Day |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:17 pm Post subject: Re: Argh! |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | | Striker wrote: | | Let's cool it, guys. Remember this is just a friendly discussion related to Pirates! the game. |
Well, okay. When you're right, you're right. I should be satisfied in knowing an objective eye can read in plain English what my point of view is with regard to western civilization's sanctimonious charade with regard to morality. I am a pirate at heart, and if the present empire didn't have nukes, I'd be out there with my cannon givin' 'em hell. I didn't mean to (pontif)icate. But, readers of this thread can be assured I've done my best to present a view based in historical fact, regardless of how it might singe the sensibilities of those still in thrall of conventional wisdom. In fact, one might surmise how this all boiled-down (if placed in the 17th Century) obviates Frederick the Great's engraving he placed on all his cannon: "The final argument of kings." Pirates wanted to be their own kings.
The mention of Sir Francis Drake is very significant in that what he was commissioned to do for Elizabeth I is now considered to be a valid military tactic, which was raiding the enemy's line of supply. During WWII a massive effort was made by the Allies to destroy the Ploesti oil fields in Romania. The cost in aircrews and aircraft was staggering even by the standards of the time. The effort was to deprive the Nazis of black gold. You may have a lot of tanks, but if they don't have fuel, their mobility becomes non-existant. Then comes Patton's philosophy: "Fixed fortifications are monuments to the stupidity of man."
When Elizabeth took the throne she had nothing in the way of an army. Her navy wasn't even an afterthought, being only what flotillas she could assemble from volunteers from either Dover, or Bristol. Her treasury was depleted from the corruptions of the royalty which had preceeded her, and in short she was targeted by both Spain and France who didn't share her weaknesses by a long shot.
Drake saved England from conquest. He diverted the funds which would have served to strengthen Spain, into England's coffers. Elizabeth made judicious use of the wealth. Even during the attempted invasion by the Spanish Armada, England was not militarily fit enough to stave-off a successful landing of forces. Had the Armada succeeded in landing troops, she would have been able only to fight an enforced retreat until she ran out of island to retreat to.
If you were English, Drake provided a means for survival. If you were Spanish, Drake was a scurrilous pirate. It defies belief to assume Spain was unaware of the military ramifications of this "strategy" employed by England. So, their protestations to the contrary could be an example of the first spin doctors in history. Spain was also aided and abetted by the Papal See because Elizabeth was allowing the Protestants to practice their beliefs unopposed. Some say to avoid civil war. Some say because she was that liberal in her thinking. She said it was both.
When we (the U.S.) were targets of Nazi U-boats attacking supplies headed for Britain, we viewed it as an act of war. This more than anything else stimulated the change from an isolationist point-of-view in the U.S. to one which allowed Roosevelt to enter the war without much domestic opposition - something he'd wanted to do much sooner, but for the possibility of unrest at home. In fact, the U-boat's main object was to interdict shipping. There we have a new term enter the vocabulary. What was once called "piracy" became known as "interdicting shipping." However, this is illusory in a sense, because the U.S. public still viewed supply ships as civilian, not military targets, and thus arose the indignation.
It's safe to say today that all modern military planners view supply shipping, and supply lines as military targets without question. We can thank Francis Drake for initiating this innovation. |
Historical fact huh? What has that to do with morality? Ethics deals with right and wrong not historical details. So piracy is a useful tactic that can be used for certain ends..... so what? That fact has nothing to do with this thread, which was intended by its creator to be a discussion of certain philosophical questions as they relate to piracy. The question at hand deals with whether or not Piracy is morally defensible or capable of being rendered so by a coherent and reasonable system of ethics. If you are looking to discuss the merits of Piracy as a tactic, I would suggest that you do so on a thread in which such a discussion would be more appropriate. _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:26 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| TheDon wrote: | Concerning the morality of Pirates... I'll just say that morality, whether of any particular act or of a lifestyle in general, is a personal issue. Yes, it is most often judged by the standards of the community, but it still comes down to personal belief of whether something is the right or wrong thing to do. Then it's a choice of whether to go ahead and do it anyway. Just because you believe something is wrong doesn't mean you're not going to do it.
We of the 21st century can take "the pirate life" and make it playful and fun because we didn't live it and haven't suffered any harm because of it. (The same holds true for some who like to dress in Nazi uniforms for Halloween, even though many others think it's wrong.)
Every year at Fernandina Beach, Florida, they hold the Blessing of the Fleet and the Landing of the Pirates. The Pirates come ashore and run around pretending to terrorize everybody and it's a lot of fun (they rarely rape or kill anyone, of course). I'm sure there are some who want to criticize the glamorization of a bunch of murderous thieves, but most people just enjoy the show.
As for the morality of the GAME Pirates!... to quote Star Wars creator George Lucas (when told about the throngs of people who were lined up for blocks dressed in Star Wars outfits) "...it's just a game, people. Get a life!"
or in this case... live the life.
That's my 2 doubloons. Your knots/hr may vary.
thedon |
Interesting points.
I would perhaps question the degree to which morality can be called solely a matter of personal taste (if that is what you mean to suggest by calling it a personal issue), as this would eliminate the possibility of moral judgments of any kind., a position that is as undesirable as it is illogical. If however you mean that the choice as to whether or not one lives in keeping with a system of morality, then I would certainly agree! Kant argues that "there is no [moral] good apart from a good will" thus contending that being moral has everything to do with a person's free will and the aligning of that will to a universal standard. _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:51 pm Post subject: Re: ah, not so fast there skippy |
|
|
| Dirk wrote: |
Trying to change your story I see..... Lets take another look at just what you said: |
| Airsaw wrote: | | Morality exists with the acceptance a priori of a divine entity and would then be layed-out by the agents of said divinity - the church. Pirates merely practiced the ethics of the church as it existed at that time. | As I said, refer to Descartes. The existance of a divinity cannot be ascertained by physical proof, or we would not be discussing it in terms of belief, but as a proved fact, would we not? I was also in a more "unquoted" diatribe lumping the monarchies and the church together as a social order dictating morality in an arbitrary sense, and who could blame a pirate for doing the same as they - relegating unto himself the same authority they claimed to possess?
Running-down the etymology and current definition of a word has nothing to do with how policy was derived by the Vatican, or the reasons they chose to take what acts they did. We're not discussing the actual definitions of words, we are discussing policy changes within the church itself. I might add, you've left off "Roman" Catholic Church, the need to distinguish itself from the Byzantine Church.
You might find a way to be less snide. Just a suggestion. Or, do your religious beliefs allow you this patronizing attitude as a reflection of the object of your faith - Jesus of Nazareth? Who are you to set yourself up as the gatekeeper of thought on this board, anyway? Nothing you've said is accurate. For instance, you don't see a moral distinction in descriminating between military and civilian targets in war? Whether you do, or not, your culture does, and it does so on a moral basis. I'm sorry that point escaped you.
Last edited by Airsaw on Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:56 pm; edited 2 times in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
TheDon

Rigger 
Posts: 1289 


16718 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 8:52 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | I would perhaps question the degree to which morality can be called solely a matter of personal taste (if that is what you mean to suggest by calling it a personal issue), as this would eliminate the possibility of moral judgments of any kind., a position that is as undesirable as it is illogical. If however you mean that the choice as to whether or not one lives in keeping with a system of morality, then I would certainly agree! |
No, I didn't mean that it's only immoral if you decide it's immoral for you. Society could never survive if every man decided right and wrong for himself. I did mean that the choice to live within the society's standards of morality requires personal choice.
Many subcultures exist (which the Pirate culture is one of) that define different sets of morality and ethics than the genteel society cling to. The biker culture is another example (and a close modern example to historical pirates). Their codes of conduct are far afield from the rest of society, but they still live by a code. To remain in that culture is to decide to abide by the code... or suffer the consequences. And I guess that was my real point (or did I even have one?). We can all decide to live by the laws that are set upon us or decide not to. If we decide not to, we have to be willing to suffer the consequences or fight against those who come to administer the consequences.
I decide every day whether to obey the speed limits or ignore them to whatever extent I can get away with. When I see the flashing blues in my mirror, I get to decide whether to stop or try to outrun him (yea, right). When he gives me a ticket I decide whether to sign it or go to jail and then whether to pay it or have them issue a warrant on me. That extends to everything we do practically.
Is it unethical (beside illegal) to rig the cable box so that you get free service? I'd say yes. Do lots of people do it? Again, yes. Why do they do it? Because they define stealing differently, or they justify it because the cable company has millions of dollars and don't need their money, or, and this is the most common reason... they think they can get away with it.
Think about it. What would you do if you thought you could not get caught and there would never be any negative consequences? That's the real question of personal morality. If laws and consequences are the only thing that keep you from stealing, killing, raping, etc, then you're not a moral person. You're simply a (mostly) law-abiding one. I contend that a moral person abides by the law because it's the right thing to do, not because there are negative consequences if you don't.
Gee, is this rambling and wandering diatribe mine? That's enough.
thedon |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 9:01 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Westley_Roberts wrote: | <Westley stands from his seat on the floor and meanders to the stage, in a clear move to obtain one of the microphones from the positioned podiums. >
Gentlemen, although I am not as learned as our esteemed colleagues, I shall attempt to make my thoughts on the subject at hand known. I realize much of this debate has been based and discussed on various philosophies, and religions. I cannot and will not march into this foray, but instead discuss the use of pirates by the various governments of the time, as ‘I’ see it.
First and foremost, this may sound rambling, but if you can follow my train of thought whilst I make my points, I will thank you, and return to my seat, and allow you to continue on.
I believe that at the point of history we are discussing, there was a New World waiting to be discovered and exploited by the Powers that be. Each of these Powers were taking what they could get their hands on and attempting to hold it for all they were worth. Each of these Powers had their own fleets, flying their own banners. Some were at declared war at times, some actually found peace between them, for a time. While all this was going on, some enterprising individuals acquired the means to patrol the area in question. Some even went as far as to take what they could, regardless of what banner was displayed. These enterprising individuals, when placed in front of various Powers, were either lambasted for their crimes, or were thanked, with much appreciation. These, I’ll call them Pirates for the remainder, just for simplicities sake, Pirates, flew their own banners, and did not sail for any Power, save their own. When they were thanked, it was in prestige for that Power, and sometimes land, which was a valuable currency for the time. As the Pirates raided the shipping lanes, they took what they could, for their own gains, and were rewarded for it, depending on the Power that was on the other side of a battle line.
The area of this conflict was contested land, for all the major Powers were striking claims to it. There was no system in place to say what area was whose, save whoever was standing on it at the time. All these Powers wanted was to further their own wealth and land, and reap the riches of the commodities available in the area.
Back to the subject, Pirates only performed, under their own flag what the other Powers were doing under their own banner. They were rewarded for it, and thus continued their business. So, to ask if it was moral would not be proper, for they were following what was being shown to them by the Powers. Did not Spain have a little thing called the Inquisition? Did not England have its own issues with disposing of their non-conformists? Did not the Dutch look upon these waters for financial gains only? What of the French that acquired a large portion of the mainland?
Therefore, I present to you, a current scenario, an example of people taking law into their own hands, and praised for it... Hells Angels. Now, I am by no means saying I know much about the organization, but from what I have seen and remember from the news media. this group performs what the government does, establishes a safety perimeter for concerts, attempts to keep the peace in otherwise unruly areas, and is sometimes thanked, other times lambasted for their actions? I only provide this for an example of having a government support an outside source which is providing a service that said government cannot perform under their own banner/uniform/flag…
I hope somewhere in there my thoughts on the matter made some sort of sense. To sum up, Pirates were an outside source, loyal to none, but thanked by the opposing team for their actions, perhaps even condoned for it. The Powers at the time were doing the same, but under their own banner.
Thank you for your time.
<Westley places the microphone back into the stand, and returns to his place, in the chair, on the floor of this great debate hall, silent, again.> |
Cheers sirrah! *claps*
I would hardly dispute the assertion that Pirates did, to a large degree, the same things as the Powers. This realization begs the question, however, if they had the authority to do such, not being themselves Powers. This is what led me to propose the existence of an authority unique to nations (and thus, lacked by pirates), on the basis of Hobbesian political theory. You do bring up an interesting point in that Pirates, Hell's Angels and so on, may be useful to the powers at points, and it could certainly be argued that the authority of the state passes to such groups when the do they act in ways beneficial to that state. By that reasoning Privateers would enjoy exemption from the moral issues inherent to Piracy as an extra-national activity....
I would just like to pause here a moment and provide my fellow forumites with some humble recs to aid in the eternal search for the Truth. So, without further adeu I give you DIRK STRUAN'S READING LIST FOR THE PHILOSOPHER-PIRATE:
1) Immanuel Kant, Grounding for a Metaphysics of Morals: an excellent primer on Kantian ethics, this work introduces the Categorical Imperative that I used in my earlier assertion that Morality need not require a higher power in order to be logically consistent.
2) Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan: His definitive work on the state, in this work Hobbes introduces his argument as to the role of the government, why governments are formed, and what they have the authority to do.
3) Plato's Republic: An excellent analysis of Justice in the earlier books. Also an excellent definition of the Philosopher at the end of Bk IV
4) Augustine's City of God (Civitas Dei): In addition to being an excellent text on how Christian ethics can be applied to life in the Polis, this work (if memory serves) actually makes an argument similar to that presented by Airsaw and Roberts earlier in this forum: namely that pirates and Empires are the same thing at different scales!
and finally......
5) The Portable Nietzsche (Viking Portable Library) An excellent collection of the works of Nietzsche, this book contains some of the most eloquent arguments for "taking charge of one's own moralit" and rising above the standards set by others. More than any of the other philosophers I have mentioned, Nietzsche, with his view that morality is something to dominate rather than be dominated by, seems to provide the best philosphical rationalization for the rugged individualism of a pirate's life.
If anyone has anything to add to this list, I for one, would love to see it! _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 9:01 pm Post subject: PU |
|
|
| TheDon wrote: |
Gee, is this rambling and wandering diatribe mine? That's enough.
thedon |
Yes, it is, and no truer words have been spoken. I would, since you asked for respect for your faith, remind you that the object of your faith said, "It is through humility you attain sublimity." Read the parable about the guest at the wedding feast.
"I am, therefore I'm right" -TheDon- |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 9:16 pm Post subject: Re: ah, not so fast there skippy |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | | Dirk wrote: |
Trying to change your story I see..... Lets take another look at just what you said: |
| Airsaw wrote: | | Morality exists with the acceptance a priori of a divine entity and would then be layed-out by the agents of said divinity - the church. Pirates merely practiced the ethics of the church as it existed at that time. | As I said, refer to Descartes. The existance of a divinity cannot be ascertained by physical proof, or we would not be discussing it in terms of belief, but as a proved fact, would we not? I was also in a more "unquoted" diatribe lumping the monarchies and the church together as a social order dictating morality in an arbitrary sense, and who could blame a pirate for doing the same as they - relegating unto himself the same authority they claimed to possess?
Running-down the etymology and current definition of a word has nothing to do with how policy was derived by the Vatican, or the reasons they chose to take what acts they did. We're not discussing the actual definitions of words, we are discussing policy changes within the church itself. I might add, you've left off "Roman" Catholic Church, the need to distinguish itself from the Byzantine Church.
You might find a way to be less snide. Just a suggestion. Or, do your religious beliefs allow you this patronizing attitude as a reflection of the object of your faith - Jesus of Nazareth? Who are you to set yourself up as the gatekeeper of thought on this board, anyway? Nothing you've said is accurate. For instance, you don't see a moral distinction in descriminating between military and civilian targets in war? Whether you do, or not, your culture does, and it does so on a moral basis. I'm sorry that point escaped you. |
http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/03449a.htm
This is a link to a New Advent entry on the subject of the word Catholic, as it relates to the Church. I hope that this will clarify things somewhat.
This thread is one that I created towards a specific purpose. If you do not wish to discuss that which is the subject of this thread then you can leave. I have done nothing in this thread other than state well known and demonstrably valid arguments, coming from recognized thinkers, on the issue at hand.
I never claimed not to see a distinction between civilian and military targets in war so heaven only knows where you got that idea....
[/url] _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dirk Struan

Swabbie 
Posts: 121 

 
2440 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 9:22 pm Post subject: Re: PU |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | | TheDon wrote: |
Gee, is this rambling and wandering diatribe mine? That's enough.
thedon |
Yes, it is, and no truer words have been spoken. I would, since you asked for respect for your faith, remind you that the object of your faith said, "It is through humility you attain sublimity." Read the parable about the guest at the wedding feast.
"I am, therefore I'm right" -TheDon- |
Dont presume to lecture on such matters. What I have done here is attempted to begin a discussion, that by an effort those involved may come nearer to the Truth. It seems to me that I have spent most of this discussion either trying to get you to actually attempt to answer arguments made early in the forum or explaining to you concepts and terms that you misunderstand. Didnt you state in an earlier post that you were finished with this discussion?
Since you seem incapable of furthering its progress, you may want to make good on that statement at least..... I, for one, have wasted more than enough time on you. _________________ "Even the strongest man must sleep and even the smallest child can carry a knife" -Hobbes |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Falconer

Captain 
Posts: 1839 

 
2865 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Mon Mar 21, 2005 9:34 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Hmm, this seems to heat up the blood a little too much. A very interesting discussion with some good points. Quite a read by now actually.
Still, before we all start bashing each others heads, it's probably better to leave this thread as is.
Locked so people can cool down a bit.  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|