
Let's end the War Canoe Speed Myth
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 12:23 am Post subject: |
|
|
| ruf wrote: | if there are any D&D players out there, I would like to refer them to Dragon magazine #70: "The Hull Truth About Speed: larger ships make faster frigates."
There is a great chart on pg.9:
Length at waterline (in ft) Best speed (knots)
10- 4.3
15- 5.2
20- 6.0
25- 6.8
30- 7.4
ect... (The above reflects best speeds. Absolute top speeds are slightly higher). | Are you talking "Real World" or how Firaxis programmed Pirates!?? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Guest




 
0 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 3:42 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | When I first noticed that the mail runner felt a bit more sluggish and slower I was using a captured one. When I wanted to confirm this fact I used a trainer (the Phalzyrian Trainer btw). As it was running on the background, I entered battle mode with a war canoe, destroyed the enemy sails with the trainer so as to force a surrender and avoid any unwanted gunfire, chasing and/or fleeing, did some acceleration and top speed tests (19 knots), paused, switched to the trainer, substituted the war canoe with a mail runner, did some acceleration and top speed tests (18 knots). The wind speed and direction had NOT changed during the tests. What I did change was number of crew and cannons, I used the maximum number of both depending on the ship. I did the same with the pinnace and it reached 19 knots too, but its acceleration was a bit worse. I might be a brick when it comes to maths, but I do know that 19 is greater than 18. |
Do you mean you switched ships While in 'Sea Battle' Mode, or did you reload and re-engage the battle? I've tried to change ships dynamically during a sea battle without exiting and it hasn't taken.
Also, the wind speed tends to change much more the higher the level you are on, which is why I didn't try and account for it, it simply changes too much to be reliable.
I got my conclusion by trying to run away from a pinnace in a mail runner and a war canoe, and on adventurer, you can't outrun. If you are right about the war canoe having a higher top speed, why can't I outrun them if I match their heading??.
and I just finished getting futher proof.
repeated the running away tests, still same results.
and...
found the in memory value for your ship speed, your ship heading, wind speed, and did some adjustments
speed is stored as a 2byte number which is as follows:
'1366' which is 13.66 knots. This displays as 14 knots.
Wind speed is a Integer, ie no decimal places.
I set the Difficulty level to Apprentice to Guarentee a steady westward wind direction and I locked the heading to '0' (due north) and I locked wind speed (5 for one set of tests, and 10 for another.) (I couldn't find wind direction or enemy ship speed in my search of the game memory)
I tested all 3 Pinnace class ships.
They pretty much came out equal top speed. (there was about a 0.05 knot variance from the various times I took the readings. I took mulitple readings each test. The variance seemed to occur in all 3 ships)
As I keep saying, all three Pinnace class ships have equal top speed.
As for turning ability, I don't really care at the moment. though my hunch says Turning time is equal. Maybe I'll get out my stopwatch tomorrow and test it.
And for size affecting ability to dodge fire, I'd say the smaller ship has a better ability cause of less of a target area. This is most pronouced with the Frigate vs Ship of the Line, where I noticed the frigate to be better at dodging fire. That, however is a subjective observation. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Strange

Swabbie 
Posts: 56 


2194 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 3:43 am Post subject: |
|
|
oops, forgot to login.
I'm sure you all know that the immediately above post was made by me  _________________ Check this out -----> piratehaven.net |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
fossaman

Gunner 
Posts: 717 

 
3515 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 4:38 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | I'm sure you all know that the immediately above post was made by me |
Really? I thought it was one of those 'one million monkeys banging away on one million typewriters' things, but instead of the complete works of Shakespeare, we had a totally plausible and believable explanation that war canoes aren't faster than mail runners.
Seriously though, good work. This is very useful to know. I can stick with my trusty mail runner instead of trading down to a rowboat.  _________________
Like my fossa? He's a pirate!  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
ruf

Seaman 
Posts: 197 

 
899 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 4:44 am Post subject: |
|
|
Hey Rupert:
I meant real world. Sorry I wasn't clear.  _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 5:41 am Post subject: |
|
|
| ruf wrote: | Hey Rupert:
I meant real world. Sorry I wasn't clear.  | As you would see if pondered the problem . . .
Real World means little in programming.
What matters is how Firaxis programmed the function, not how we would evaluate the concept in a real physics lab.
Besides in your example, you were using an example from another system, not from the real world.
This example is also flawed.
There is an interaction between length and width concerning top speed. In case you do not believe me consider the example of an obscene barge. 100 feet long and 1000 feet wide. Flat fore and aft. This thing moves how fast?
(yes wider from side to side than from front to back.) |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 6:11 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Strange wrote: | and I just finished getting futher proof.
repeated the running away tests, still same results.
and...
found the in memory value for your ship speed, your ship heading, wind speed, and did some adjustments
speed is stored as a 2byte number which is as follows:
'1366' which is 13.66 knots. This displays as 14 knots.
Wind speed is a Integer, ie no decimal places.
| Interesting assertion.
There is a fly in this ointment.
Sid is known to demand that his programmers use shifts and such for numerical manipulations. This suggests that the number in question is Octal/Hexidecimal not Decimal.
If this is true, the value is not anything like reported.
You might read two seperate bytes, the first being the whole number, the second as the fraction, but 1366 would not yield 14!! Sid has a history of just despising division by 10 (or 100).
Also your results do not account for DrBeast's results.
One of you has made an experimental error.
Since my expectations are known to color my evaluation of events . . . I was expecting a Mail Runner to perform as well as a Canoe . . .
I am still convinced by my observations of the two that the Canoe is faster.
This alone is very hard to explain.
DrBeast forms another nail in the theory that kills my expectations and confirms my observations. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Kristian95

Boatswain 
Posts: 3091 


4687 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 8:33 am Post subject: |
|
|
| ruf wrote: | | Second-- In the real world, the larger the ship, the faster it goes. The Titanic was the biggest AND fastest ship of it's time. |
That is not a good example! As soon as you go from wind powered ships to engine powered ships, it's not the size that matters, but the engine power to weight/size that matters
Besides, size isn't necessarily a good thing... I think we'll all agree that a slim ship ought to be faster than a "fat" one, i.e a viking knarr is likely to be faster than a Fluyt
All this said, I am not a ship designer, so it's just my "logic" telling me it must be like that.... maybe I'm wrong ???  _________________ HaP! Real Pirates hang out there! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
DrBeast

Cutthroat 
Posts: 489 


5316 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 9:31 am Post subject: |
|
|
I switched ships while in "battle mode", no exit and re-enter. I wanted the same conditions for both ships, that's why I tried to rule out any outside interference. I am a scientific researcher after all (though I still find that hard to believe!), so I acted just as if I was measuring another set of samples at the laboratory. And yes, 400 people on a war canoe is plain overkill, but I did that just to demonstrate that you need such an overkill to decrease top speed.
Also, as you may have noticed, I did not compare top speed in comparison to an ENEMY SHIP, but between the two samples...eeh!...ships I wanted to check. The enemy ship is an outside factor, thus has to be ruled out. I don't care how fast the enemy goes or if a war canoe can catch up with him when the mail runner cannot. _________________ Let the Beast inside you free! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Gun Pierson

Gunner 
Posts: 797 


5053 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 11:07 am Post subject: |
|
|
@ Drbeast: Nice doc
So if I understood the test well we can say that it is indeed no longer a myth that the war canoe is the fastest ship, it's simply a fact? Taking acceleration into account ofcourse.
@ Fossaman: It seems the pinace and especially the mailrunner got owned by a rowboat. Just kidding, what difference does it make, everybody should play with the ship they like  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
DrBeast

Cutthroat 
Posts: 489 


5316 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 1:12 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Gun Pierson wrote: | @ Drbeast: Nice doc
So if I understood the test well we can say that it is indeed no longer a myth that the war canoe is the fastest ship, it's simply a fact? Taking acceleration into account ofcourse.
|
Based on the tests I conducted and the parameters I involved (and excluded), yes. If acceleration is a factor as well, then definitely. _________________ Let the Beast inside you free! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Howie

Helmsman 
Posts: 4223 

 
45890 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 1:33 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| ruf wrote: | Two things:
First-- a specialist navigator will influence the speed of a ship.
Second-- In the real world, the larger the ship, the faster it goes. The Titanic was the biggest AND fastest ship of it's time.
When a ship sails, it pushes a wake in front of it. The faster the ship, the bigger the wake. Eventually a small ship will push such a large wake, that it will be sailing "Uphill" if you will. The faster the ship, the further the distance will be between the peaks of the waves that support a ship. Like this:
^--^--^--^
The faster the ship, the longer the waves:
^-----^-----^-----^
So a larger ship can be supported by more wave peaks, and is therefore not sailing "uphill."
Theoretically, the fastest ships would be supported by one wave peak on the bow, and one in the stern, keeping the ship level. However, if the wave get too big, there will be no support in the middle of the ship and it will break in half (like the Edmound Fitzgerald).
I hope this makes sense.  |
I don't know much about numbers and integers and stuff like all you PhD’s and other more intelligent and smarter people do. I go by what seems or looks like is most feasible. Mr. ruf has brought up some good points about how fast a ship will go. His analogy of the Titanic is correct. I draw on my experience with real life ships in the real world. When I was in the Navy I was on a tin can (destroyer for those non seafaring folks). Our main task was to serve as a torpedo stopper. Our top speed was supposed to be 31 knots, but we very rarely were able to top 25 to 28 knots and hold it for very long. The Air Craft Carrier's reported top speed was 40 knots plus! It was our job to escort them. A Carrier is the largest ship in the world and the fastest. Sure it couldn't make a sharp turn and it would take miles for it to come to a complete stop. The point to my stupid opinion today is that game numbers and integers don't translate into real world performance. Games are fantasy and it is all about numbers in a program. In the real world it's about nuclear propulsion versus an oil fired steam-powered power plant. In today’s navy most of the old ships like I was on are gone. Replaced by state of the art gas turbine power plants.
What does this have to do with the topic being discussed here? Well.... nothing... I just thought I would put my 2 cents in and say that Rupertlittlebear is usually right in his assessments when it comes to these types of questions or issues. Plus I just felt like writing a story that no-one will read any ways.... Go figure huh..... _________________
   |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
DrBeast

Cutthroat 
Posts: 489 


5316 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 1:58 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Just how many guys in this forum served in the US Navy?!? Man, there are lots and many of you!
Edit: this is my 200th post...I've done some mileage!  _________________ Let the Beast inside you free! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Striker

Gunner 
Posts: 698 

 
680 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 3:07 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Howie wrote: | | ruf wrote: | Two things:
First-- a specialist navigator will influence the speed of a ship.
Second-- In the real world, the larger the ship, the faster it goes. The Titanic was the biggest AND fastest ship of it's time.
When a ship sails, it pushes a wake in front of it. The faster the ship, the bigger the wake. Eventually a small ship will push such a large wake, that it will be sailing "Uphill" if you will. The faster the ship, the further the distance will be between the peaks of the waves that support a ship. Like this:
^--^--^--^
The faster the ship, the longer the waves:
^-----^-----^-----^
So a larger ship can be supported by more wave peaks, and is therefore not sailing "uphill."
Theoretically, the fastest ships would be supported by one wave peak on the bow, and one in the stern, keeping the ship level. However, if the wave get too big, there will be no support in the middle of the ship and it will break in half (like the Edmound Fitzgerald).
I hope this makes sense.  |
I don't know much about numbers and integers and stuff like all you PhD’s and other more intelligent and smarter people do. I go by what seems or looks like is most feasible. Mr. ruf has brought up some good points about how fast a ship will go. His analogy of the Titanic is correct. I draw on my experience with real life ships in the real world. When I was in the Navy I was on a tin can (destroyer for those non seafaring folks). Our main task was to serve as a torpedo stopper. Our top speed was supposed to be 31 knots, but we very rarely were able to top 25 to 28 knots and hold it for very long. The Air Craft Carrier's reported top speed was 40 knots plus! It was our job to escort them. A Carrier is the largest ship in the world and the fastest. Sure it couldn't make a sharp turn and it would take miles for it to come to a complete stop. The point to my stupid opinion today is that game numbers and integers don't translate into real world performance. Games are fantasy and it is all about numbers in a program. In the real world it's about nuclear propulsion versus an oil fired steam-powered power plant. In today’s navy most of the old ships like I was on are gone. Replaced by state of the art gas turbine power plants.
What does this have to do with the topic being discussed here? Well.... nothing... I just thought I would put my 2 cents in and say that Rupertlittlebear is usually right in his assessments when it comes to these types of questions or issues. Plus I just felt like writing a story that no-one will read any ways.... Go figure huh..... |
Don't worry! I didn't read it. Especially the part about aircraft carriers going faster than destroyers. This was a very good read, Howie. Don't put yourself down. Back to the subject. I think that the larger ships in all periods had a top speed that was higher than the smaller ships. The problem has always been acceleration and maneuverability. I bet the aircraft carrier would have a tough time running down the destoyer that you were on. I believe that this was what Sid was going for. _________________ Prince John: Save me, save me! Hurt them, hurt them!
Sherrif of Rottingham: Save them, save them, hurt you, hurt you, yes, I've got it! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Mar 24, 2005 5:42 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Gun Pierson wrote: | @ Drbeast: Nice doc
So if I understood the test well we can say that it is indeed no longer a myth that the war canoe is the fastest ship, it's simply a fact? | I agree, Dr Beast did a nice experiment. And his method shows an obvious understanding of the Scientific Method.
Variables nicely contained. Unknowns reduced/eleminated.
Simple and to the point. More interestingly, he did not let his world knowledge (about ships) color his experiment.
Quality shows. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|