Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

The "Please fix this in a patch" thread :)
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Technical Issues Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Minoan
Powder Monkey
Posts: 1


201 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Jan 24, 2005 3:02 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Sid came up with another "almost-winner" game. There is a lot of nice detail in the artwork, but the gameplay is a little weak. This is very much in contrast to Sid's earlier games like Civilization and Railroad Tycoon (and the original Pirates! for that matter).

My brother and I work at an ice arena and we both play Pirates, and in-between zam times today we talked about possible Pirates improvements for the patch (or for expansion/sequel considerations). It turned out to be a great way to pass the boredom. Smile

(Note: I haven't taken the time to read through all the posts in this thread, so if I go over something that someone else already brought up, I'm sorry in advance.)

#1 - LAND BATTLES

ISSUE: The movement of the men is too slow. Having to wait until every last man in the platoon has stopped moving before you are allowed to move the platoon again is aggravating.
POSSIBLE FIX: Speed up the movement, and allow troop movements to be queued.

ISSUE: Sometimes you start with four platoons, and sometimes you start with eight. Moving eight around can be slow, and the number of spaces on the battlefield can make things a bit crowded.
POSSIBLE FIX: We believe some standardization is in order. There should always be a total of six (6) platoons that you start each battle with, consisting of one (1) officer platoon, two (2) buccaneer platoons, and three (3) pirate platoons. Crewmates should be divided evenly between all platoons. Six platoons is not to much, yet provides a well-proportioned army.


#2 - SEA BATTLES

ISSUE: Sometimes after a ship strikes its colors, it will still fire cannons at you.
POSSIBLE FIX: My brother has experienced this, but I haven't yet. I'll take his word for it though. It's not a problem if that is the way it was meant to be (spite fire?), but if it's a bug then it needs to be fixed.


#3 - SWORDFIGHTING

ISSUE: This is a joke in that it's way too easy. You can win any swordfight in the game just by hitting one (1) button (forward thrust) and timing it properly.
POSSIBLE FIX: Make swordfighting harder, somehow. Maybe give opponents on harder difficulty levels an auto-riposte skill that kicks in primarily against forward thrusts (the cheesiest attack). Conversely, give certain opponents immunity to forward thrust attacks.


#4 - DANCING (a defense of)

Dancing is a WONDERFUL new addition to the game. Women of social stature didn't need to marry for wealth or security during that era, unlike the eras before it, primarily in Europe, where marriages were arranged for peace/survivability/profitability. So, it is sensible to conjecture that winning a governor's daughter's heart was a precursor to winning her hand in marriage. Waltzing into town and trying to use the sinking of hundreds of ships as your tool to woo girls over shouldn't work...any ugly, antisocial, repulsive pirate can do that, but it doesn't make them attractive to beautiful, well-to-do young women.
You start out as a pirate, and haven't had the years of experience in dancing and socializing like they have. That's reasonable, yet you can come surprisingly good at it if you give it a chance. It's simply becoming familiar with the dance choreography the game uses. Once you know that, then following the daughter's cues to each dance "set" is very easy...it's very repetitive.
The concept of governor's having SONS would help relieve dancing burnout (read next topic)


#5 - GOVERNORS AND THEIR "X" CHROMOSOME SPERM

It's kind of ridiculous that governors only have daughters, and not sons. Of course, I'm not suggesting that while playing a male character I should be allowed to dance with and romance a son, BUT they can still be useful. Imagine that all governor sons have hopeless love affairs with governor daughters. Imagine that for security reasons they cannot leave their own city, yet they can ask you to deliver gifts (jewel necklaces, candies, flowers, etc) to these daughters, and are willing to pay you handsomely for it. The catch? Well, they have to be delivered before a deadline, which is calculated by the game depending on the relative distance between the two cities. Sound good?

And while we are at it, how about giving you the option to be a female pirate? We realize that this is probably a sequel/expansion consideration, but it would be a nice addition. Also, you could simply reverse the roles then....female pirates dance/romance with governor sons and deliver gifts for the daughters.


#6 - "X" MARKS THE SPOT...NOT!

ISSUE: Some completed maps have no "X" on them. This is a very frustrating, yet probably easy-to-fix bug. My last game, I could not find any lost cities because my first completed map had no "X".
POSSIBLE FIX: Whatever it takes Smile


#7 - TAKING WIFE-SWAPPING TO A WHOLE NEW LEVEL

ISSUE: (I glanced over an earlier post and saw this happened to others too, so this is not really new). The way the game is now, the romances are not linked to the daughter, but the city (silly). So, that daughter you have been romancing has her city conquered, and the next time you see her she has died her hair and speaks a different language, lol.
POSSIBLE FIX: Once a city is conquered, then the romance progress in that city with that daughter is ended. You may not like it, but you can always take it out on the conquering nation if you want.


#8 - PROTECTING MY WIFE'S DNA, AND WHAT TO DO WITH HER

ISSUE: Imagine what I just wrote above, happening to your wife
POSSIBLE FIX: Once you become married, your wife LEAVES that city and goes to live on your plantation (all that acreage you have earned) along with your family members (as you rescue them). This means she will never be replaced, and she will always be safe and will watch over your sister/aunt/uncle/grandpa for you. The location of your acreage is not a real consideration...it can be transparent to the way the game operates. On the character status screen, where you see your romance progress, is your wife's picture. Clicking that picture while in any port should allow you to dance with her (for fun...imagine that you sent for her and had her meet you there for a romantic getaway). Clicking that picture while out at sea should show the wedding video.


#9 - DID I ALWAYS LOOK THIS OLD?

ISSUE: When viewing a video (from the character status screen) of you finding buried treasure, or getting married, or killing a named pirate, the age you are in the video is not the age you were when you did it, but the age you are now. This makes no sense. (Example: If you rescued your sister at age 20, and then replay the video when you are age 40, you appear as age 40 in the video.)
POSSIBLE FIX: When the video goes to play, have the program check to see what your age was when you did that action, and display you as the correct age in the video, or play the correct aged-video (however it's coded).


#10 - EXECUTION...SWINGING CRATE STYLE

ISSUE: Every time you take out a named pirate, it involves that crate. There should be a different ending for each of the 9 pirates. No more than 3 of them should involve that stupid crate.
POSSIBLE FIX: Be a little more original in these ending videos. Also, come up with more than one npc (Raymondo) that you have to chase down for you family info and more than one kidnapper for the governor's daughters (Mendoza or whatever his name is).


#11 - PROMOTIONS FOR SALE...CHEAP!!

ISSUE: Promotions are way too easy to get, and they are largely meaningless in the grand scheme of things.
POSSIBLE FIX: (take this time to get a large cup of coffee or other beverage before continuing, this is kind of long, but is worth reading...)

OFFICER PROMOTIONS should require you to do basically what you do now....kill pirates, sink enemy ships, hunt down criminals and anything else that increases favor with a country. However, the rate of promotion should be slowed down dramatically.

NOBILITY PROMOTIONS should be a totally different animal, and should have different requirements. See below:


(governor speaking) "My dear Admiral XXXX, you understand that nobility is a birthright, not something you strive to attain. However, if you were to make it worth my while, I could probably come up with a forged noble lineage and the paperwork to back it up. The total amount I would demand is a mere 20,000 gold pieces for this favor. That price includes admission to our royal school of dance...something you are in dire need of assistance in, if I may say so."

summary...to be promoted from ADMIRAL to BARON, you should have to spend 20,000 gold pieces. The benefits of becoming a baron are: WHILE YOU ARE DANCING IN A CITY OF THAT COUNTRY: 1) flourishes are easier to get off (larger timing window for them), and 2) incorrect dance moves are "covered" from time to time (similar to the effects of the calfskin boots and dancing slippers, but the effects are cumulative). To reiterate, being an English baron will not help you while dancing in Spanish cities, since they have different dance customs and heritages.


(governor speaking) "My dear Baron XXXX, a Count commands great respect, and therefore our cities tend to be more accomodating to Counts while they are in port. If you would like to be promoted to Count, you must conquer an enemy city that has been a thorn in our side for a long time. That city is XXXX. Come back to me when you have accomplished this feat."

summary...to be promoted from BARON to COUNT, you must conquer the city that the governor tells you to conquer. This city should be a large, well-defended city. The benefits of becoming a COUNT are the combined benefits that you currently get for being promoted to baron/count/marquis/duke...free ship repairs, free ship upgrades, etc.


(governor speaking) "My dear Count XXXX, the title of Marquis is only earned by performing a 'special' service for our country. I can think of one such service that is within your abilities, if you are interested. The evil Governor XXXX in the city XXXX has been known to encourage privateers to torture our countrymen after their capture in order to extract information on our cities' defenses. I wish him assassinated. You cannot simply capture his city, as he would likely escape in the chaos of a grand assault. Please return to me when you have finished this task, and I shall promote you to the noble rank of Marquis."

summary...to be promoted from COUNT to MARQUIS, you must assassinate the chosen governor. You MUST sneak into the city, enter the governor's mansion, and defeat him in a swordfight to the death. Immediately after you have defeated (killed) him, guards will storm the mansion and capture you (unavoidable) and you are imprisoned. You can escape prison early with a skeleton key or lockpicks, else you must spend the mandatory 6 months in prison. This incurs the first real "sacrifice" in the game, since in Pirates everything is petty compared to time (age). The benefit of becoming a MARQUIS is that people who recognize your rank (from the same country that gave it for you) understand that you can be deadly and ruthless, and that you probably had to assassinate someone important to get it. Therefore, when you are involved with swordfights of anyone from that country, their swordfighting speed is reduced by 25% (they are afraid of you). This would mean that if you are an English Marquis and are fighting an English sea captain (or an English captain of the guard in a bar, or an English criminal that you are sent out to capture, or an English fiance of the daughter you are romancing, etc) then their swordfighting speed is reduced. This means that if you somehow become a Marquis for all 4 countries, pretty much everyone (except other pirates) will be dueling you at a slowed speed. This will be a good thing to implement if they in turn implement tougher swordfights across the board as part of a patch.


(governor speaking) "My dear Marquis XXXX, a Duke is a vanquisher of enemies. In order to become a Duke, you must attain a bounty on your head of at least 50,000 gold pieces by one of our enemies. Return to me when you have achieved a 'value' of said amount."

summary...the price is flexible here but the idea is the same. You must really ruin your faction with an enemy kingdom in order to achieve this rank. The benefits of becoming a DUKE depend on which nation you are becoming a duke with:

FRENCH DUKE: All ships under your command have their speed increased by 50% (assume they are always outfitted by special French silk sails, or whatever)
ENGLISH DUKE: All cannons on ships under your command reload 50% faster (and therefore fire faster...assume they are always outfitted with fine English smoothbore cannons, which seldom get dirty as fast as normal cannons, therefore can be fired without having to clean the barrel between every firing)
DUTCH DUKE: All ships under your command have their cargo space increased by 50%. So, a captured Spanish treasure galleon with a normal cargo space of 140 becomes 210 while it is part of your fleet.
SPANISH DUKE: All ships under your command have their manning capacity increased by 50%. So, if a ship normally has a 30 man capacity, under your command its capacity is raised to 45 men.



That's pretty much all we went over today, and I'm tired of typing anyway. Thanks for reading.

Sean
Cheshirecat1951@hotmail.com
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
pliz
Powder Monkey
Posts: 3


140 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue Jan 25, 2005 6:01 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
There is a lot of nice detail in the artwork, but the gameplay is a little weak. This is very much in contrast to Sid's earlier games


Precisely. I may be old-fashioned, but I still see graphics as simple acessories to strong gameplay, not the core of a game. Yep, I'm aware that market trends don't favour me these days and Firaxis has to compromise - but still...

I don't understand why did Firaxis remove features that added to the game (see my post above) and added others that stress the repetitive character of the game (like having very few names for criminals in daughter's missions and turning family quests into the Raymondo-Mendoza routine). Sometimes I feel I'm playing a beta version of a game of great potential - but a beta version nonetheless.

Anyway, your idea for making promotions really matter in the game is great - hope they'll listen to you. And the governour's sons would be nice addition too.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Lengo
Powder Monkey
Posts: 36


325 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed Jan 26, 2005 11:50 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:

I reported what I see as a technical bug in the other thread (you marry a French brunette and soon afterwards the city is captured by the Dutch and you are suddenly married to a Dutch blonde).


Oh man! Why are you complaining about getting two for the price of one! Or maybe it's Mabeline! Or maybe her name is Sybil!

Blast your scuppers, ya barnacle bitten land lubber! Don't ya know two is better than one?

Laughing
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
moussaillon
Powder Monkey
Posts: 3


85 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Jan 28, 2005 4:29 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I dont think this issue has been discussed in this thread:
on my comp, and on many others according to what I read on the internet, the game crashes VERY often.
I mean on 2 saved games, I cant simply play. The game gets loaded and then it crashes, back to the desktop.
I think this is related to something to display in the scenery, because it always crashes at the same time.

This makes the game implayable and so far, I have thrown away 60 EUR for a game I cant play to at all.


The concerned configs are:
Panasonic R2B:
Pentium M 1000
Intel i855GM
40 Gb toshiba hdd
512 mb ram
win xp pro sp1 all updates done except sp2, drivers up to date as well

Panasonic W2C:
Pentium M 1100
Intel i855GM
60 Gb hitachi hdd
512 ram
xp pro sp1 up to date, sp2 not applied, drivers up to date


(posted in the PATCH!!! thread as well, didnt really know where to put it, sorry)
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Reservoir Duck
Powder Monkey
Posts: 1


71 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Jan 30, 2005 3:07 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Raymondo: Names randomization for this guy

Clipping issues Ships sailing into towns, forts etc. Both on the overview map and in the sea battles.

Colonel Mendoza

Two problems with him.

(a) If you romantizise several daughters at once and several of them are kidnapped by Mendoza(s) the game have problems identifying which daugther you rescue. So when you get your first mendoza all daugthers are rescued but on the quests bar you still have mendozas to hunt. Sometimes this makes a daughter return but don't give you any reward and you are unable to get futher with her.


(b) If you are on a quest to rescue a daugther and enter her town to talk with the govenor again you will get a second quest to rescue. You can get unlimited mendozas with the same girl on the quests screen all being in different ships etc. This will give problems with further romantising this particular daughter and will not give any rewards from her.

Settlements Settlements are weird. You cannot attack settlements even though they are often larger (1200 pop) than the smallest towns. Mayors give you missions even though you are an enemy of his nation.

Forced sea battles Please make forced sea battles return (pirate hunters etc.) At least on harder difficulty levels.

Ranks It is way to easy to obtain ranks please make it way harder.(if im playing 1 nation at war with spain I'm duke within a year or 2 on Swashbuckler lvl). It should also be possible to be demoted if you anger the nation (refuse missions, attack them etc).
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
BastardMan
Powder Monkey
Posts: 19


322 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Jan 30, 2005 5:55 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Sometimes, when i board the enemy ship (or vice versa), when the screen comes up to choose my weapon, the game will freeze for a second and then crash. This probably happens to me about 50% of the time, and it is really frustrating. I have to save before every battle, but the worst part is justh te pain of having to restart the game, only to have it happen 10 minutes later. Not to mention that one time there were two treasure ships very close to each other, and the game froze when i boarded the first one. Oh man... I can't even explain my anger. Evil or Very Mad Mad Crying or Very sad .
I know it is just on this screen that there is the problem, my game never crashed once on apprentice.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address
Jando
Powder Monkey
Posts: 44


1236 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 10, 2005 3:42 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Haven't yet seen that mentioned:

Sometimes when you start a new game (it only happened to me when I started a new game as Spanish sailor) Spanish cities will immediately treat you as enemy. One "spawns" these 100 milli-seconds away from a city but cannot enter the city and the fort will send cannon balls after you.

This is with the normal European version of the game.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Feb 19, 2005 8:56 pm    Post subject: TRUE BUG REPORT Reply with quote

I have disabled the French and Dutch, no ports. I'm fifteen years into the 1640 scenario/85 fame points. Already took out Montebaln, in the process of taking out Raymondo/second part-third map.

I accept a tasking to escort an ultimatum, Curacao (B) to Puerto Bello (S), and am intercepted by two Dutch brigs. I defeat the first and get minus (-) 32,740 in gold. I attack the second and get 8,000+ I try again from a game save. Same thing. One ship takes 32,000+ from my own gold. It shows in red at the top of the booty screen -32,740

ALSO: I have the second hidden city map, Maya. No red ex. I've tromped over every inch of the map locale, no city. No city, no advance to next search for Aztec, then Olmec, game stops here, so to speak.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
VenusPrince
Powder Monkey
Posts: 8


125 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Mar 06, 2005 11:55 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Fighting wanted criminals:
dunno if it was mentioned earlier, but IMHO imprisonment after loosing a sword duel with "wanted" criminal should be removed under certain circumstances ie. when you achieve certain rank in certain country service, and u're fighting above mentioned criminal in this country's city.
For example, when I'm a French Duke, fighting a criminal in the tavern, in a city of Tortuga (French), when I loose a duel, I shouldn't go to jail having such a high rank (it isn't natural to go to jail as a duke, because of a scum who you lost your duel with...how would he do that? call guards to throw a famous Duke into jail? doesn't make much sense).
So, when you are low ranked sailor, maybe it should be possible, but impossible for hi ranked ones....
Things are different, when u're fighting a criminal in some other nation's city, where u sneaked into for example of course...
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Eskimo_pirat
Swabbie
Posts: 59



92 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed Mar 30, 2005 12:51 am    Post subject: Wanting some changes Reply with quote

Hi Pirates

As I can remember on my Amiga Pirates! (2 disc = 2,9 MB)
I could have several pirates maps on different location, not like now, where I have to collect just from ONE single pirate.
The other fix I will say is: When you marry a governor daughter, then you get higher point if you can marry the beauteful one, and less point if you get marry rather daughter.

Eskimo Pirat
_________________
The horrible Eskimo Pirat
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Send e-mail
miko
Powder Monkey
Posts: 42


925 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed Mar 30, 2005 8:44 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

do you guys think that theres likely to be a big patch which will significantly alter the game (new cutscenes or characters/missions) or will any patch just be a bug fix ?

to put it another way does Sid Meier have some kind of record with giving out big patches full of goodies to the fans after relaese ?
or
are these ideas/fixes/suggestions things i'm only likely to see in an expansion i'd have to pay for...
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Javi
Cutthroat
Posts: 458


2778 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Mar 31, 2005 10:14 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Minoan wrote:
Sid came up with another "almost-winner" game. There is a lot of nice detail in the artwork, but the gameplay is a little weak. This is very much in contrast to Sid's earlier games like Civilization and Railroad Tycoon (and the original Pirates! for that matter).

My brother and I work at an ice arena and we both play Pirates, and in-between zam times today we talked about possible Pirates improvements for the patch (or for expansion/sequel considerations). It turned out to be a great way to pass the boredom. Smile

(Note: I haven't taken the time to read through all the posts in this thread, so if I go over something that someone else already brought up, I'm sorry in advance.)

#1 - LAND BATTLES

ISSUE: The movement of the men is too slow. Having to wait until every last man in the platoon has stopped moving before you are allowed to move the platoon again is aggravating.
POSSIBLE FIX: Speed up the movement, and allow troop movements to be queued.

ISSUE: Sometimes you start with four platoons, and sometimes you start with eight. Moving eight around can be slow, and the number of spaces on the battlefield can make things a bit crowded.
POSSIBLE FIX: We believe some standardization is in order. There should always be a total of six (6) platoons that you start each battle with, consisting of one (1) officer platoon, two (2) buccaneer platoons, and three (3) pirate platoons. Crewmates should be divided evenly between all platoons. Six platoons is not to much, yet provides a well-proportioned army.


#2 - SEA BATTLES

ISSUE: Sometimes after a ship strikes its colors, it will still fire cannons at you.
POSSIBLE FIX: My brother has experienced this, but I haven't yet. I'll take his word for it though. It's not a problem if that is the way it was meant to be (spite fire?), but if it's a bug then it needs to be fixed.


#3 - SWORDFIGHTING

ISSUE: This is a joke in that it's way too easy. You can win any swordfight in the game just by hitting one (1) button (forward thrust) and timing it properly.
POSSIBLE FIX: Make swordfighting harder, somehow. Maybe give opponents on harder difficulty levels an auto-riposte skill that kicks in primarily against forward thrusts (the cheesiest attack). Conversely, give certain opponents immunity to forward thrust attacks.


#4 - DANCING (a defense of)

Dancing is a WONDERFUL new addition to the game. Women of social stature didn't need to marry for wealth or security during that era, unlike the eras before it, primarily in Europe, where marriages were arranged for peace/survivability/profitability. So, it is sensible to conjecture that winning a governor's daughter's heart was a precursor to winning her hand in marriage. Waltzing into town and trying to use the sinking of hundreds of ships as your tool to woo girls over shouldn't work...any ugly, antisocial, repulsive pirate can do that, but it doesn't make them attractive to beautiful, well-to-do young women.
You start out as a pirate, and haven't had the years of experience in dancing and socializing like they have. That's reasonable, yet you can come surprisingly good at it if you give it a chance. It's simply becoming familiar with the dance choreography the game uses. Once you know that, then following the daughter's cues to each dance "set" is very easy...it's very repetitive.
The concept of governor's having SONS would help relieve dancing burnout (read next topic)


#5 - GOVERNORS AND THEIR "X" CHROMOSOME SPERM

It's kind of ridiculous that governors only have daughters, and not sons. Of course, I'm not suggesting that while playing a male character I should be allowed to dance with and romance a son, BUT they can still be useful. Imagine that all governor sons have hopeless love affairs with governor daughters. Imagine that for security reasons they cannot leave their own city, yet they can ask you to deliver gifts (jewel necklaces, candies, flowers, etc) to these daughters, and are willing to pay you handsomely for it. The catch? Well, they have to be delivered before a deadline, which is calculated by the game depending on the relative distance between the two cities. Sound good?

And while we are at it, how about giving you the option to be a female pirate? We realize that this is probably a sequel/expansion consideration, but it would be a nice addition. Also, you could simply reverse the roles then....female pirates dance/romance with governor sons and deliver gifts for the daughters.


#6 - "X" MARKS THE SPOT...NOT!

ISSUE: Some completed maps have no "X" on them. This is a very frustrating, yet probably easy-to-fix bug. My last game, I could not find any lost cities because my first completed map had no "X".
POSSIBLE FIX: Whatever it takes Smile


#7 - TAKING WIFE-SWAPPING TO A WHOLE NEW LEVEL

ISSUE: (I glanced over an earlier post and saw this happened to others too, so this is not really new). The way the game is now, the romances are not linked to the daughter, but the city (silly). So, that daughter you have been romancing has her city conquered, and the next time you see her she has died her hair and speaks a different language, lol.
POSSIBLE FIX: Once a city is conquered, then the romance progress in that city with that daughter is ended. You may not like it, but you can always take it out on the conquering nation if you want.


#8 - PROTECTING MY WIFE'S DNA, AND WHAT TO DO WITH HER

ISSUE: Imagine what I just wrote above, happening to your wife
POSSIBLE FIX: Once you become married, your wife LEAVES that city and goes to live on your plantation (all that acreage you have earned) along with your family members (as you rescue them). This means she will never be replaced, and she will always be safe and will watch over your sister/aunt/uncle/grandpa for you. The location of your acreage is not a real consideration...it can be transparent to the way the game operates. On the character status screen, where you see your romance progress, is your wife's picture. Clicking that picture while in any port should allow you to dance with her (for fun...imagine that you sent for her and had her meet you there for a romantic getaway). Clicking that picture while out at sea should show the wedding video.


#9 - DID I ALWAYS LOOK THIS OLD?

ISSUE: When viewing a video (from the character status screen) of you finding buried treasure, or getting married, or killing a named pirate, the age you are in the video is not the age you were when you did it, but the age you are now. This makes no sense. (Example: If you rescued your sister at age 20, and then replay the video when you are age 40, you appear as age 40 in the video.)
POSSIBLE FIX: When the video goes to play, have the program check to see what your age was when you did that action, and display you as the correct age in the video, or play the correct aged-video (however it's coded).


#10 - EXECUTION...SWINGING CRATE STYLE

ISSUE: Every time you take out a named pirate, it involves that crate. There should be a different ending for each of the 9 pirates. No more than 3 of them should involve that stupid crate.
POSSIBLE FIX: Be a little more original in these ending videos. Also, come up with more than one npc (Raymondo) that you have to chase down for you family info and more than one kidnapper for the governor's daughters (Mendoza or whatever his name is).


#11 - PROMOTIONS FOR SALE...CHEAP!!

ISSUE: Promotions are way too easy to get, and they are largely meaningless in the grand scheme of things.
POSSIBLE FIX: (take this time to get a large cup of coffee or other beverage before continuing, this is kind of long, but is worth reading...)

OFFICER PROMOTIONS should require you to do basically what you do now....kill pirates, sink enemy ships, hunt down criminals and anything else that increases favor with a country. However, the rate of promotion should be slowed down dramatically.

NOBILITY PROMOTIONS should be a totally different animal, and should have different requirements. See below:


(governor speaking) "My dear Admiral XXXX, you understand that nobility is a birthright, not something you strive to attain. However, if you were to make it worth my while, I could probably come up with a forged noble lineage and the paperwork to back it up. The total amount I would demand is a mere 20,000 gold pieces for this favor. That price includes admission to our royal school of dance...something you are in dire need of assistance in, if I may say so."

summary...to be promoted from ADMIRAL to BARON, you should have to spend 20,000 gold pieces. The benefits of becoming a baron are: WHILE YOU ARE DANCING IN A CITY OF THAT COUNTRY: 1) flourishes are easier to get off (larger timing window for them), and 2) incorrect dance moves are "covered" from time to time (similar to the effects of the calfskin boots and dancing slippers, but the effects are cumulative). To reiterate, being an English baron will not help you while dancing in Spanish cities, since they have different dance customs and heritages.


(governor speaking) "My dear Baron XXXX, a Count commands great respect, and therefore our cities tend to be more accomodating to Counts while they are in port. If you would like to be promoted to Count, you must conquer an enemy city that has been a thorn in our side for a long time. That city is XXXX. Come back to me when you have accomplished this feat."

summary...to be promoted from BARON to COUNT, you must conquer the city that the governor tells you to conquer. This city should be a large, well-defended city. The benefits of becoming a COUNT are the combined benefits that you currently get for being promoted to baron/count/marquis/duke...free ship repairs, free ship upgrades, etc.


(governor speaking) "My dear Count XXXX, the title of Marquis is only earned by performing a 'special' service for our country. I can think of one such service that is within your abilities, if you are interested. The evil Governor XXXX in the city XXXX has been known to encourage privateers to torture our countrymen after their capture in order to extract information on our cities' defenses. I wish him assassinated. You cannot simply capture his city, as he would likely escape in the chaos of a grand assault. Please return to me when you have finished this task, and I shall promote you to the noble rank of Marquis."

summary...to be promoted from COUNT to MARQUIS, you must assassinate the chosen governor. You MUST sneak into the city, enter the governor's mansion, and defeat him in a swordfight to the death. Immediately after you have defeated (killed) him, guards will storm the mansion and capture you (unavoidable) and you are imprisoned. You can escape prison early with a skeleton key or lockpicks, else you must spend the mandatory 6 months in prison. This incurs the first real "sacrifice" in the game, since in Pirates everything is petty compared to time (age). The benefit of becoming a MARQUIS is that people who recognize your rank (from the same country that gave it for you) understand that you can be deadly and ruthless, and that you probably had to assassinate someone important to get it. Therefore, when you are involved with swordfights of anyone from that country, their swordfighting speed is reduced by 25% (they are afraid of you). This would mean that if you are an English Marquis and are fighting an English sea captain (or an English captain of the guard in a bar, or an English criminal that you are sent out to capture, or an English fiance of the daughter you are romancing, etc) then their swordfighting speed is reduced. This means that if you somehow become a Marquis for all 4 countries, pretty much everyone (except other pirates) will be dueling you at a slowed speed. This will be a good thing to implement if they in turn implement tougher swordfights across the board as part of a patch.


(governor speaking) "My dear Marquis XXXX, a Duke is a vanquisher of enemies. In order to become a Duke, you must attain a bounty on your head of at least 50,000 gold pieces by one of our enemies. Return to me when you have achieved a 'value' of said amount."

summary...the price is flexible here but the idea is the same. You must really ruin your faction with an enemy kingdom in order to achieve this rank. The benefits of becoming a DUKE depend on which nation you are becoming a duke with:

FRENCH DUKE: All ships under your command have their speed increased by 50% (assume they are always outfitted by special French silk sails, or whatever)
ENGLISH DUKE: All cannons on ships under your command reload 50% faster (and therefore fire faster...assume they are always outfitted with fine English smoothbore cannons, which seldom get dirty as fast as normal cannons, therefore can be fired without having to clean the barrel between every firing)
DUTCH DUKE: All ships under your command have their cargo space increased by 50%. So, a captured Spanish treasure galleon with a normal cargo space of 140 becomes 210 while it is part of your fleet.
SPANISH DUKE: All ships under your command have their manning capacity increased by 50%. So, if a ship normally has a 30 man capacity, under your command its capacity is raised to 45 men.



That's pretty much all we went over today, and I'm tired of typing anyway. Thanks for reading.

Sean
Cheshirecat1951@hotmail.com


GREAT IDEAS! Congratulations
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Apr 11, 2005 3:45 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
ISSUE: The movement of the men is too slow. Having to wait until every last man in the platoon has stopped moving before you are allowed to move the platoon again is aggravating.
POSSIBLE FIX: Speed up the movement, and allow troop movements to be queued.

I guess everyone must have slow systems or something... I'm not saying the above doesn't happen... surely enough folks have mentioned this that it does happen, but it has never happened once to me under any circumstance after countless times fighting land battles.

I have a 3.0GHz P4 with 512MB of DDRAM and a GeForce 6600GT, and land battles have never once been slow in anyway under any resolution with the details cranked.

Now I realize folks have systems with differant specs, but it seems to me the land battle "speed problem" is more system spec related then anything else. Maybe if you turn-down some of the graphics if you have a slower system, the problem will go away in land battles.

I have every graphic option cranked up, and I've never had a "slow" land battle... I think it's more system-spec related then an actual game bug.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Grimmelshausen
Cutthroat
Posts: 278



1811 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Apr 15, 2005 10:13 am    Post subject: Re: Puh - leeeeze Reply with quote

Airsaw wrote:
The sailing times/speeds/calendar, aren't scaled correctly, in my view. If it took three months to sail the length of Cuba going eastward on it's northern side, sailing ships would have been considered to be too inefficient as modes of transportation, and they would have tried to put flippers on the hooves of their horses and paddled in a saddle.

I know for a fact it doesn't take two months to sail from the northern tip of the Yucatan to the eastern coast of Mexico. It only takes days, in real life and even "back then" to sail from Caracas to Santiago, or Santo Domingo. If the times, speeds and distances reflected in the game's calibration were accurate, Spain would never have made it back with one ounce of gold, let alone with enough tonnage to trash their own economy, which they did.

It wouldn't be such a big deal, many computer games have unrealistic values for variables and one takes them in stride, but this game pins your success on the age of your character, and it's so unreasonable as to be ridiculous. No one likes to do things they know are ridiculous, do they?

I see no reason why more accurate reflections of sailing distances and times would upset the balance of the game. That they are so far out of kilter, however, is simply annoying.

Get real.


I totally agree. Apart from that, I´d only like to see forced sea battles instead of getting bombarded and maybe randomized name for Raymondo, else I much like the game the way it is.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
blarghus
Powder Monkey
Posts: 10



21 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Apr 16, 2005 2:45 pm    Post subject: Captains of the guard Reply with quote

I haven't seen anyone else mention this, but whenever i challenge a captain of the guard who has been hitting on the barmaid i see the nation specific guard model, the same as when i sack a city with too few soldiers and am forced to fight on the batlements. Between when he accepts my challenge and the animation of him running upstairs, however, the model is switched to colonel mendoza. Every single time i fight one of these guys, from any nationality, i always end up fighting mendoza. This is obviously a bug, and one that should be relatively easy to fix, but i'd like to know if anyone else has experienced this.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Technical Issues All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8  Next
Page 7 of 8

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group