
Not quite a war canoe, but close!
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
ledhed

Seaman 
Posts: 189 

 
3392 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 9:38 pm Post subject: |
|
|
The sherman when modified with the 76 mm and the British mod ( Firefly ) were acceptable Medium tanks . The problem was they had to face heavy german models that outclassed them. like sloops against a ship of the line . in North Africa against all but the few tigers they would do very well and were much better overall than anything the British had .
the Sherman was very reliable and had very good performance and cross country characteristics . It had better armor than the German mark IV 's ( the german 75 mm gun was MUCH better though ). The biggest fault of the Sherman was its piss poor gun . Thats unforgivable being that the US did have a very good high velocity 76 mm anti tank gun that did fit the Shermans turret . they could have also better used shaped charge ammo to defeat German armor but did not realise the benifits at that time. _________________ "No captain can do very wrong if he places his ship alongside the enemy " |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 9:44 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| ledhed wrote: | The sherman when modified with the 76 mm and the British mod ( Firefly ) were acceptable Medium tanks . The problem was they had to face heavy german models that outclassed them. like sloops against a ship of the line . in North Africa against all but the few tigers they would do very well and were much better overall than anything the British had .
the Sherman was very reliable and had very good performance and cross country characteristics . It had better armor than the German mark IV 's ( the german 75 mm gun was MUCH better though ). The biggest fault of the Sherman was its piss poor gun . Thats unforgivable being that the US did have a very good high velocity 76 mm anti tank gun that did fit the Shermans turret . they could have also better used shaped charge ammo to defeat German armor but did not realise the benifits at that time. | They even had some minor success in getting them to float. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 9:57 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Wow... look at all the Sherman supporters!
| Quote: | | That's not really a correction. In fact it's a gross stereotype. |
A stereotype would be going along with the government line that the Sherman was a great tank.
| Quote: | And to top it all off, the Brits modified it into a real killer.
(Firefly) |
You mean "killer with a glass jaw" to be more precise... Yeah... all 20 of them that got converted... yes, yes, there were more then 20 that were converted, but might as well have been that few... statistically speaking the Firefly was one in a thousand Shermans... of course, the only thing a Firefly was, was an upgunned Sherman... meaning it was roughly on-par firepower-wise with a Pz-IV... of course a Firefly never fixed the main problem with a Sherman... the fact it lights up like a matchbox and incinerates its crew.
Take into consideration what happened in Operation Goodwood... the Fireflies stood out like sore thumbs, every dug-in German tank picked off every Firefly they could find, and within minutes, most of Monty's Fireflies had all been converted into it's other nickname... TOMMY COOKER.
Yeah... great tank!
| Quote: | | You forget that the Sherman was not the only tank around. It was however the one most readibly availible and produced. You have to remember the state that the United States was in at the outbreak of World War II in Europe. The US was still very much a isolationist country that did not want to get involved in foreign wars for as long as it could. There were many aspects of the Unites States military that was not up to par right away, not just its availible armor. |
I forgot nothing... You're quite right... it was not the ONLY tank around for America... in fact, until approximately February of 1945, it was the BEST tank America had in the ETO. We had worse tanks then the Sherman... the Pershing showed up in very limited numbers in the spring of 1945 in Europe. Four years too late to make a differance.
America's armor department was in fact the WORST part of American military preparedness (Air Force and Navy was much better equipped, as were small arms and artillery in the Army)... it was also quite inexcusible to be in such a sorry state compared to other nations. Instead of being embroiled in an ongoing war, the United States had the ability to sit, back and learn from two years of fighting in Europe as to what a proper solution should be for a tank... considering the fact the Sherman did not enter service until 1942, there is little excuse for America to have produced such a tank that was more a hazard to it's own crew then to that of the enemy.
In fact, the Sherman was roughly on par with the Panzer IV tank... a tank that had entered German service some five years prior to the Sherman. Despite this, the Pz-IV was still better armed then the Sherman and could kill a Sherman before a Sherman could kill a Pz-IV... this says nothing of the qualitive superiority of German Panther and Tiger tanks to the Sherman on firepower and protection. In fact, Germany and Russia continued introducing newer and better tanks throughout the course of the war, while America rested on minor varients to the Sherman, never introducing a major new production model until the Pershing (which was too late to have any effect on the war).
| Quote: | | If you really want to get down and dirty with it, in an infantry support role, sans tank-on-tank, I don't think I'd want to be a grunt holding a greasegun facing down any tank, of any make or model. |
So both you and Patton concur, the Sherman was NOT a match for German tanks. In other words, it's a mobile anti-infantry weapon, but the name "TANK" is not deserved, as it was clearly inferior to German tanks and could not stand up to them in a fight.
| Quote: | | Like we always said to the fuming opposition at the end of the game...look at the scoreboard. |
Quite right... statistically speaking, in any tank-to-tank engagement, the scoreboard shows more dead American tank crews then German tank crews... a pyric victory with needless widows, mothers and girlfriends grieving for the loss of American lives that would have been spared had the US produced a more worthy tank.
The American victory in Europe can be attributed more to airpower and logistics then on the backs of the Sherman, which was an abomination. Anytime the Sherman got caught without air support, it would lose.
Case in point, the Ardennes offensive... launched (quite deliberately) in the worst weather the Germans could find... why? So there would be no airpower, and only tank to tank engagements... a situation which the Germans could not (and did not) lose. At least until the skies cleared and Eisenhower sent in the USAAC which were able to do what the Shermans could not... defeat German armor.
The only thing the Sherman excelled at was killing its own crews. At least in Europe. For arguably the greatest industrial power in WWII, America ranks at best third-place in the quality of its tanks. There is no excuse for the Americans who lost their lives driving in a tank that had no place on the battlefields of Europe... the American fighting soldier deserved better. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 10:01 pm Post subject: |
|
|
There were worse tanks available. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 10:35 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | There were worse tanks available. |
The problem was there was nothing BETTER available. Which goes back to my main point, which a lot of you seem to be missing. The American soldier deserved better then the Sherman death trap. Mechanical reliability doesn't mean much when your tank has been picked off at two kilometers and your gasoline tank ignites incinerating the entire crew. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 11:19 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Yellowbeard wrote: | | Quote: | | There were worse tanks available. |
The problem was there was nothing BETTER available. Which goes back to my main point, which a lot of you seem to be missing. The American soldier deserved better then the Sherman death trap. Mechanical reliability doesn't mean much when your tank has been picked off at two kilometers and your gasoline tank ignites incinerating the entire crew. | You would just love some of the early tanks. Especially the WW1 tanks.
Seem to remember one French tank known as the mobile Crematorium. It was Gas powered and had a tendency of . . . the name fits. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
b4lazarus

Cutthroat 
Posts: 274 

 
4739 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue May 24, 2005 11:56 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Yellowbeard wrote: | | Quote: | | There were worse tanks available. |
The problem was there was nothing BETTER available. Which goes back to my main point, which a lot of you seem to be missing. The American soldier deserved better then the Sherman death trap. Mechanical reliability doesn't mean much when your tank has been picked off at two kilometers and your gasoline tank ignites incinerating the entire crew. |
" You go to war with the army you have, not the army you might want , or wish to have"...D.R.
The fact of the matter is that we, the USA, did the best we could (AS WE ALWAYS DO) with what we had to do it with. 21st century quarterbacks and pessimistic historians may disagree, but the seat of our pants was the only choice we had in WWII. _________________ X |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 12:07 am Post subject: |
|
|
| TenYardxLetdown wrote: | | Airsaw wrote: | | Yellowbeard wrote: | | (5 dead Americans for 5 dead NAZIS), maybe you can beat them with four tanks for every one of his and still win (attrition is in your favor... even with 20 dead Americans for 5 dead NAZIS) | Just a small correction. |
That's not really a correction. In fact it's a gross stereotype. | Ah...I'll drop that comment where it belongs, in the round file. _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
TenYardxLetdown

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 48 


486 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 2:04 am Post subject: |
|
|
Nobody is saying the American soldier didn't deserve better.
Airsaw: I don't see why you feel that what I said deserves to be disregarded. I think it should be the other way. You basically said that every solider in the Wehrmact was a nazi. That's miles from the truth. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
rupertlittlebear

Helmsman 
Posts: 4434 


10417 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 2:10 am Post subject: |
|
|
Just to remind you, not all Nazis were Nazis.
As proved by their actions. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 2:25 am Post subject: |
|
|
| TenYardxLetdown wrote: | | Airsaw: I don't see why you feel that what I said deserves to be disregarded. I think it should be the other way. You basically said that every solider in the Wehrmact was a nazi. That's miles from the truth. | There are those among us who wonder why the "War Machine" (nice name) didn't turn itself on the obvious psychopath, unless perhaps there was some affinity in belief, i.e., anti-semitism, and if the revulsion felt LATER against their leader wasn't more in the vein of how RADICAL he was in implementing this belief into reality...he went a bit too far...to a professional soldier "I might be killed" isn't a valid excuse. They did get killed anyway...either way. Had they taken care of the problem when they had the chance, OUR soldiers (U.S., Canadian, New Zealand...long list here) WOULDN'T have been.
I think my view has its validity, as well. I also think this site isn't a place to get into that. I have a site where these ideas are the SUBJECT. You'd be more than welcome to post there to your heart's content. Just click the www under one of my posts, then win your way to the message board.
This string had to do with puttering about in a box of toothpicks attacking perfectly respectable vessels of war! You might notice I edited my first post to say "going up against an M-1 Abrams wearing Orangebeard's topcoat", or words to that effect.
 _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 4:02 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | " You go to war with the army you have, not the army you might want , or wish to have"...D.R.
The fact of the matter is that we, the USA, did the best we could (AS WE ALWAYS DO) with what we had to do it with. 21st century quarterbacks and pessimistic historians may disagree, but the seat of our pants was the only choice we had in WWII. |
What you are saying is you accept things as-is, even if it costs lives... the very same attitude American politicians had in WWII.
Two lines of thought come from that conclusion...
#1: The Americans had stayed out of the war for two full years, observing from a safe distance the nature of armored warfare... why couldn't they come up with a better tank then the Sherman, which was born from the experience the Americans had sitting from the sidelines? Is that truely "the army you have" or is that "what you make for yourself".
#2: Assuming the Americans DID do "the best they could" when they initially developed the Sherman, once it arrived on the battlefield in 1942, it was already outclassed by current German armor. From 1942 through 1945, no serious effort was made to correct this error or introduce a tank that could save American lives being thrown away in the Sherman. Germany, Russia, England, Italy and even Japan introduced new tanks between 1942 and 1945, while America only offered varients to the Sherman. Tell me there was no "best they can" offered in that scenario... every major combatant nation introduced new tanks in the same time span America did nothing.
It doesn't take a "21st century QB" to see the obvious lack of concern by American higher-ups that left the American soldier in an inferior and outclassed tank on the battlefield... after all, we had a lot more boys we could throw away and still win... it was all a matter of numbers, damn the American soldier.
What is interesting to note is the actual thoughts, comments and concerns raised by American G.I.'s who crewed the Sherman DURING the war, who repeatedly questioned why the Sherman main gun was basically useless against German armor unless at point-blank range and why their own comrades were being lit-up like Christmas Trees during battle. This is hardly a case of hind-sight... this was known as soon as the first Shermans met German armor in 1942, and yet nothing was done for three years while every other nation continued to introduce new tank designs. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 4:26 am Post subject: |
|
|
Geez. It was just a smartassed remark, but since it's gone this far let me add another two-billion cents worth. Any real understanding of American history would tell you that in the late thirties, George S. Patton was beating his head against the wall trying to convince the War Department that mobile warfare was the way of the future. He's dealing with an apparatus that at the time developed their own weapons. There was no private weapons industry. The Wright brothers had to slave to convince anyone to take the airplane seriously as a weapon, and not with too much success. This was only taken seriously when Hap Arnold (or was it Jimmy Doolittle?) bombed a ship from an airplane. Watching a thing that cost a few thousand to build (a LOT of money back then) destroy a thing that cost a few million to build was enough to wake them up. This War Department, at the time, were OLD MEN who still viewed war in the set-piece fashion, despite the lessons of WWI. We didn't even have a standing army then. Suggesting they develop armored vehicles, when there wasn't even a war, just didn't make any sense to them.
Patton did what he could, and ended up with a highly compromised design, which ended up as the Sherman. It was as political then as it was during the Civil War, when Gatling's gun was not taken seriously, and as it is now, when the Bradley Fighting Vehicle cost $14 billion in development and STILL wasn't ready for manufacture. Patton himself was originally a CAVALRYMAN.
Another consideration is, our intelligence services were oriented in such a way they didn't pursue Germany's weapons development in much detail. They didn't appreciate the Panzer until it was used in the field. I think the same could be said for the French and the British. Battleships had supremacy in their thinking in that era. The Japanese cured them of that. All our steel went to the bottom of Pearl Harbor in one attack, not into the tanks Patton was insisting be made.
Another consideration is, the U.S. was strictly isolationist and had no intention of involving themselves in a European war. Those European countries had been fighting one another almost non-stop for (easily) a thousand years. We were safe with our oceans as barriers, and of course, we had our fleets. Who needs tanks?
The U-boats sinking American shipping finally threw off the isolationist "yoke". By then the war was in full swing, and had been for five years, or more. There was no time to suddenly come up with the perfect tank, so we went to war with the one we had on the drawing board, a compromised version of the one Patton was touting.
It's not as though the designs, and ideas were non-existant. Read the biography of Patton by Ladislas Farago, from whence the movie was taken. There is an in-depth study of the U.S. and it's mobile armor story.
Personally, I don't see developing weapons on this scale is a human necessity, and I can't help feel it's being discussed like that in this string. Had it not been for fascism, would we have needed tanks? They weren't all that useful in the island hopping campaign against Japan. Flamethrowers were more useful than tanks...flamethrowers and grenades.
Last year, the mine removal teams in France finally cleared TEN PERCENT of the mines laid on their terrain in TWO world wars. At this rate of clean-up, France expects to have their country mine-free by the year 2050. Something's got to give, or all we are going to end up giving is the blood of our eighteen to twenty year olds. Yes. Unlike those fabulous World War II movies that have grizzled late thirties, early forties tough guys heroically doing the do, those wars were fought mainly with late teens and early twenties. I think it can be safely said a lot of the social problems we have today are precisely because we'd lost those people. They died on the battlefields, the brave and the bold. We were left with those that talk a mean war, but never can seem to find the battlefield.
It doesn't matter what tank was best now. It's hardly a subject for discussion. I'd rather talk about how we're going to lose the need for tanks. Anybody that thinks the U.S. didn't learn the lesson of armored/mobile warfare hasn't seen an M-1 Abrams. Those gems can run for eight hours before a major overhaul. We could feed and educate a generation of young on our outlay for tanks. All I've seen them do, besides race unopposed to Baghdad, is mow down Palestinian houses.
Ain't we a lovely group? _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Yellowbeard

Seaman 
Posts: 201 


7885 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 5:10 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | The U-boats sinking American shipping finally threw off the isolationist "yoke". By then the war was in full swing, and had been for five years, or more. There was no time to suddenly come up with the perfect tank, so we went to war with the one we had on the drawing board, a compromised version of the one Patton was touting. |
I'm not sure which war was going on "for five years or more" before American involvement... Ummm... that sounds more like you're confusing WWI with WWII. Years of war and constant U-Boat sinkings was more a WWI thing and had nothing to do with isolationism during WWII. In fact, 1914 to 1917 (three years) was how long the US stayed out of WWI. The Lusitania sinking occured in 1915, so it was certainly not the catalyst for war in WWI.
As for WWII, it was going on from 1939 to 1941 (two years) when America finally got involved, and unless December 7th doesn't ring a bell, our entry into WWII had little to do with U-Boat sinkings.
Despite what Patton (or his biographers) may have thought, he was NOT in charge of Army production or requisitioning in 1941 when the plans for the Sherman were initially developed (off of the M3a1 Grant). Nor was Erwin Rommel designing German tanks in 1939. Back on target, Rock Island Arsenal offered the Armored Force Board five suggested schemes for the M4 in April 1941. The most straight-forward design was selected (not the best). Rather, President Roosevelt's personal orders that tank production schedules set at 1,000 tanks per month for 1942 were doubled, which may have sank any hope of a more robust design being produced.
Politics played a lot into the War Department of 1941... in fact Senator Trumman was disgusted with a lot of waste at this level... of course, none of this excuses why the American G.I. was issued such a horrid little tank as the Sherman. It was woefully ill-equiped to deal with German armor in Europe, and only successful in the Pacific because the Japanese were even worse-off in tank design then the US.
My point still stands... this was the wrong tank, for the wrong war, against the wrong opponent (a play on words from General Omar Bradley's famous quote). Bottom line, this tank cost American lives needlessly... a better design could have been and should have been produced... if not initialy, at least after it was clear this tank was already obsolecent at the time it debuted in North Africa in 1942. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed May 25, 2005 6:33 am Post subject: |
|
|
I would take issue with your understanding of how these historical events unfolded (for instance, limiting yourself to when the first shots were fired, and overlooking what leads up to loading the guns), but not here. Here, I'll just say, "Whatever." _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|