Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

Not quite a war canoe, but close!
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Life at Sea Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
TenYardxLetdown
Powder Monkey
Posts: 48


486 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 6:41 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

We've created a monster!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 10:36 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

TenYardxLetdown wrote:
We've created a monster!
I'm still trying to figure out what all this has to do with a pinnace.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 1:48 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
I'm still trying to figure out what all this has to do with a pinnace.

Maybe I'm mistaken, but I believe it was you Airsaw who mentioned the Sherman tank first, I merely commented on the value of said Sherman tank.
Confused

Quote:
I would take issue with your understanding of how these historical events unfolded (for instance, limiting yourself to when the first shots were fired, and overlooking what leads up to loading the guns)

Hmmm... I am NOT a casual student of WWII history... in fact, it is my field of specialty. I've been studying everything about WWII for over thirty years and have amassed quite a large personal library of WWII books & documentaries over the same period.

I'd be more then happy to discuss the politics of war that led to the opening gunshots for each nation involved if you care to banter the subject, as I am quite comfortable in the intricacies of the war and its creation out of the ashes of WWI and Versailles Treaty, and of Japan's economic and political needs. I'd be happy to cover each day of the war from September 1939 to August 1945 if you so desire, or discuss armor thickness, slope and ballistics on guns if you'd like to cover that as well.

Of course this would have little to do with a Pinnace... but then again, I'll be the first to admit... I don't know much about a Pinnace.
Very Happy
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 4:56 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Yellowbeard wrote:
I'd be happy to cover each day of the war from September 1939 to August 1945 if you so desire, or discuss armor thickness, slope and ballistics on guns if you'd like to cover that as well.

Of course this would have little to do with a Pinnace... but then again, I'll be the first to admit... I don't know much about a Pinnace.
Very Happy
Well, my friend, if you look at it from the social anthropological point of view, as I do, then you DO realize WWII was started the day they signed the Treaty of Versailles. If one looks at it from purely the military angle, when the bullets began to fly and the geese began to step, you see it from 1939. From my perspective, when the last shot was fired from the trenches, Europe embarked upon the road to WWII. You can call my understanding of these things into question all you want, but I know I'm right.

Maybe because you specialize in the military perspective, all that politics and stuff is just window dressing. If you specialize in the "ah...do we really need to be shooting at each other like this?" perspective as I do, then these seemingly innocuous events take on a lot more meaning. 500 years from now, they won't be discussing WWII in your terms. They'll be discussing it in mine, and there'll be a whole lot of explaining to do, i.e., How did they get themselves in such a ridiculous position so as to burn their treasure and their blood for such a pitiful cause? The answer to that is found before the bullets fly, not on the day they did.

I find it amusing you don't know what is a pinnace. It's apparent you're not much interested in "the whole story", just the parts you like. Mention a Sherman tank next to an ashcan lid, and you'd take the ashcan lid...that was the original comment. You've yet to tell me how an achcan lid is technologically superior to a Sherman tank. But, then, you've explained a lot as to how the sense of history becomes blurred by being bogged down in the detail...what size were the bullets, how long were the gunbarrels. Gee. That's some real significant information there. Future generations are going to be wondering what our fascination for war truly said about us as a "civilization", since it ain't really very civilized.

You go ahead and see things as you wish. You can believe I'm doing the same thing. I have a friend who would say, "We know a LOT about things we need to know little of, and we know very little about things we need to know a lot about." With that I've said about all I've got to say on this sidetrack of my original post. You know, I have a suspicion military historians would be lost without a war. I'd rather be concerned with the women and children who are so blithely called "collateral damage." We may not be on the same side, after all. For me, I'm not going to let the army generals burn this world.

Thanks for your kind of attention.
Wink
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 7:44 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
Maybe because you specialize in the military perspective, all that politics and stuff is just window dressing.

I never said such a thing.

Quote:
From my perspective, when the last shot was fired from the trenches, Europe embarked upon the road to WWII.

It's not just your perspective, it's pretty much anyone's with an understanding of WWII, including my own. Wink

Quote:
500 years from now, they won't be discussing WWII in your terms. They'll be discussing it in mine

The prelude to war and the actual war cannot be seperated from each other and exist in a vacuum... to alienate one from the other, you would be missing the whole picture. Both must be studied and appreciated for what they ment to each other to be fully understood... I am confident both the politics of the prelude to war and the military operations will both still be in the history books 500 years from now... how can you forget over 30-million dead!?!? Wink

Quote:
I find it amusing you don't know what is a pinnace. It's apparent you're not much interested in "the whole story"

I'm glad I amuse you. That's what I was put on this earth to do. I never said "I don't know what a Pinnace is"... I said "I don't know much about a Pinnace"... there is a differance you know.

Quote:
Then you'll be kind enough to overlook my ascerbic response to you on the pinnace string, I hope?

Ooops... okay... well I'm ignoring it now... I was beginning to sense a bit of hostility coming from your direction... I hope you weren't taking anything personal. I just love talking WWII stuff, whether it be politics and prelude or the details of a gunbarrel, I'm proficient on it all if it deals with the war.

My main point all along was that the Sherman is generally over-rated in the concious minds of many people in today's world. It was NOT a war-winner. The Sherman tank needlessly cost America a lot of its youth when this country was fully capable of doing better. My grandfather died in a Sherman tank in France when the gas tank ignited after a hit. The same way a lot of fathers, husbands and loved ones died in the Sherman. If America had produced a better tank with better protection and less-explosive, as they were fully capable of doing, myself and a lot of other people, may have gotten to enjoy thier loved-ones after the war. America owed its fighting men the best tank America had to offer... the Sherman was not the answer.

Airsaw, I hope you realize I was only trying to point out this simple point, nothing more. Happy 50th friend!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 8:55 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Yellowbeard wrote:

My main point all along was that the Sherman is generally over-rated in the concious minds of many people in today's world. It was NOT a war-winner. The Sherman tank needlessly cost America a lot of its youth when this country was fully capable of doing better. My grandfather died in a Sherman tank in France when the gas tank ignited after a hit. The same way a lot of fathers, husbands and loved ones died in the Sherman. If America had produced a better tank with better protection and less-explosive, as they were fully capable of doing, myself and a lot of other people, may have gotten to enjoy thier loved-ones after the war. America owed its fighting men the best tank America had to offer... the Sherman was not the answer.

Airsaw, I hope you realize I was only trying to point out this simple point, nothing more. Happy 50th friend!


I never said a word about the quality of the Sherman tank, one way or the other. I think it's common knowledge it was no match for the Tiger tank, especially. And, thanks for the birthday wishes. I hope you make it to 50, too! (jest? jest? ahar?)
Rolling Eyes
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
b4lazarus
Cutthroat
Posts: 274



4739 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Wed May 25, 2005 9:30 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Yellowbeard wrote:
Quote:
Maybe because you specialize in the military perspective, all that politics and stuff is just window dressing.

I never said such a thing.


You did not have to say it for it to be obvious.


Yellowbeard wrote:
My grandfather died in a Sherman tank in France when the gas tank ignited after a hit. The same way a lot of fathers, husbands and loved ones died in the Sherman.


This (understandably) explains your personal condemnation of the Sherman tank, but the "War Machine" in 1942 was not complely (and probably not at all) focused on our armored divisions. Patton may have warned them of these problems, but they had England and France among others working on upgrades to the Sherman. The United States had more pressing things to worry about.

A major portion of our naval fleet had been destroyed by the Japanese on December 7th. The U.S. was much more concerned about the fleet than what unknowns lay ahead with land battles in Europe. I don't need to cite the statistics about Pearl Harbor. The U.S. also knew a major battle had to be fought in the Pacific.

I am sorry that your grandfather died in a Sherman tank. I am also sorry that you, and many more who served in those armored divisions felt that they took took the brunt of the consequences of the American malaise towards the Sherman tank, and our woeful armored divisions.

I guess what I'm trying to say is these were not the only areas of concern our military needed to ramp up for war. When all is said and done I feel the United States and our allies did a pretty damn good job with what they had, not perfect, but damn good.
_________________
X
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu May 26, 2005 5:22 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
You did not have to say it for it to be obvious.

You do not know me, nor do you have any idea just how much I know about the war... you PRESUME way too much, for how little you know about me.

Quote:
Patton may have warned them of these problems, but they had England and France among others working on upgrades to the Sherman. The United States had more pressing things to worry about.

This shows right here you haven't a clue what you're talking about at all.

News flash for the uninformed... the Sherman tank development STARTED in 1941... fully a year AFTER France fell to the Germans. You might want to crack a book sometime and learn about the war.

Quote:
A major portion of our naval fleet had been destroyed by the Japanese on December 7th. The U.S. was much more concerned about the fleet than what unknowns lay ahead with land battles in Europe.

Oh Lord, you better quit while you're behind. Once again, I need to repeat the same dates... Sherman design was completely chosen and decided on in 1941... BEFORE PEARL HARBOR. Anyone who knows jack-didly about WWII knows the "Germany First" priority the United States had, and that it was agreed upon that Japan and the Pacific would get minimal forces until Germany was dealt with first... this pretty much blows away your uninformed deductions.

Quote:
United States and our allies did a pretty damn good job with what they had, not perfect, but damn good.

Not much to say about that... it's a matter of opinion if all was done that could have been done... hindsight is 20/20, but the experiences and lack of effectiveness of the Sherman was known in 1942 when it went up against the enemy for the first time... three years went by and the Sherman was still the top of the line tank in American service. Other nations put out completely new tank designs in the same time-frame. The US did not... come to your own conclusions on why nothing was done for a known problem.

Do not presume you know me and can assume "it's personal" on the Sherman tank when the facts are on the table concerning this vehicle. I suppose if my brother died in a Ford Pinto that was struck in the rear and exploded you would assume "it's personal" and there was never anything wrong with the Ford Pinto either. When you make statements like "France among others working on upgrades to the Sherman", or "The U.S. was much more concerned about the fleet than what unknowns lay ahead with land battles in Europe", it shows you are clearly speaking out of your area of knowledge.

I'm sure you excel at many things in life, and know more about certain things then I do. However it is clear, WWII is NOT your field of expertise, so please don't talk with certainty about things you do not fully understand. A library is a great place to start about dates when nations fell (like France in 1940) or what American priorities were in the war (Germany first).

I apologize for being harsh b4lazarus... it's not personal, but when you spend 30 years of your life studying something, then somebody who clearly does not understand what you're talking about starts spouting off uninformed deductions and acting like they're an expert on something they know little about, I get a little upset. I'm sure you're good at a lot of things, and I know you've been around for a good number of years, but please, when you speak about the work France is doing on the Sherman when they're already knocked out of the war a year before the development even started...

No harm, no foul, but please don't talk above your knowledge level on a subject. I do my best not to pretend to be an expert on Pinnaces in return.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu May 26, 2005 9:37 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Yellowbeard wrote:
No harm, no foul, but please don't talk above your knowledge level on a subject. I do my best not to pretend to be an expert on Pinnaces in return.
As Henry V said, "I was not angry since I came to France until this minute!" (Or, something close, anyway.) My point was about the pinnace, and the idea one "understands" one's area of focus when looking at history. I wouldn't have "planted" the remark to evoke a response were it not so. For instance, wouldn't the evolution of available ship design impinge closely upon the inevitable make-up of any given naval fleet? The point isn't the ship, or the navy, it's the interconnectedness of historical events which seem unrelated at one level, but are closely connected at another.

One would have to understand the greater field upon which one's area of focus resides, to understand the context of that focus. Where, if any, borderlines exist, is also where understanding fails, does it not? In this discussion about what tank, it was agreed to "eventually got made" to describe the tank. Not the Sherman. A tank, any tank. THE tank design that was "accepted", though not very enthusiastically, evolved itself over a relatively short period of time in some historical sense into what we now call the "Sherman", named for William Tecumseh Sherman, who said "War is all Hell."

I think you gave, and I think most major History departments in the University realm would back me up, short shrift to the scope and nature of "Isolationism" and how it affected U.S. policy (up and down) even during Roosevelt's administration. Roosevelt did sic Truman on the procurement process for the War Department. The point is, Patton WAS heavily involved in the development and testing of THE TANK, which at the time was only A TANK.

You should know, and I know you DO, that no weapons system we use today, or have ever used can be credited with one single event or invention. Everything has piggybacked itself on something else all the way back in time when our ancestors picked up the first rock.

In that sense, arguing about the Sherman tank in the vein it was being discussed is a moot argument. "Moot" does not mean "so obvious, it doesn't merit discussion". It means "there are so many arguments for and against we'd be here till doomsday discussing this and not have budged an inch."

For instance. You take a look down the business end of a Winchester '74, or the barrel of a Sherman tank and you see essentially the same thing, rifling and alloy. You have muzzle velocity and size of the round. The tank is a gun dragged around by an engine. The engine's so big, you can carry a BIG GUN. Well, you can also carry some extra weight, too, with that big diesel under the hood, some armor, okay. They did theirs, we did ours. Their's was better. Most kids already know that. A valid point, to me, then would have to be framed from something else. At this point in time, the argument would necessarily move forward in time, "what have we learned from this, if anything?" Most of us know that it happened. So, from that angle you're preaching to the choir.

And, as I said, other angles from which history can be viewed take a longer perspective and view human behavior in a more collected sense, over a longer expanse of time and can see the repititions and refinements more clearly. I come from where rocketry was honed to its finest point. Daddy did that for a living. So did coach, teacher's husband, friend's parents. That's purely weapons development. So, my squint on history tends to lean toward aircraft, and aerospace - the ultimate taking of the high ground.

I think everybody was right in their own way. Everybody had to try to show their butts, without looking like that's what they were doing. I freely admit I do that! BUT, for the sake of humor MOSTLY. If anybody wants to get personal, I read their text more for the quality of the epithets, not whether they're being thrown at me.

That's my take on all this. All I wanted was to be admired for what a wonderful presentation, so witty and well-designed was my pinnace thingy. But nooooooo some TANK thing erupts! BOOM!!
Very Happy
But, I lost patience with the pinnace and swapped it for a Sloop of War which I'm in the process of decorating with various accoutrement. At the risk of starting WWIII! It's like trading a Spitfire for a Mustang.
_________________


Last edited by Airsaw on Thu May 26, 2005 9:40 pm; edited 2 times in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
b4lazarus
Cutthroat
Posts: 274



4739 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Thu May 26, 2005 9:38 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

WOW, what a spanking!! Shocked Shocked (I just realized that Airsaw posted 1 minute before I did...I was talking about Yellowbeard's spanking of me)

Yellowbeard wrote:
You do not know me, nor do you have any idea just how much I know about the war... you PRESUME way too much, for how little you know about me.


Your right, I don't presume to know you, but I can read your dissertations and draw (opinionated) conclusions about your views, the same way I draw my own opinions from the historical accounts from news articles, books, and other forms of media. The facts and statistics never tell the whole story, nor do the people who write them (IMHO). I'll just leave it at that and reiterate that I am sorry about your grandfather.

Hey this topic is suppose to be about "Life at Sea" Sailor anyway....didn't I read somewhere that the Sherman tank could float???? I might even try to take on a SotL in my Sherman (forget about that Pinnace Airsaw)....I know, I know, Not funny...
_________________
X
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat May 28, 2005 5:10 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I traded the sloop of war for a royal sloop. I saw this guy drivin' one and I just HAD to have it!
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
millerman67
Powder Monkey
Posts: 39



78 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun May 29, 2005 6:03 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

The attrition cocept is a bit like The Civil War. Even if the Union would lose @ 2or 3 to 1,they could replace men and especially equipment where the south could'nt
_________________
"but why's the rum gone?"
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun May 29, 2005 2:25 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

The Attrition concept works great when you have the numbers on your side... unless of course you're one of those "2 or 3" men that are going to lose you're lives when you're fed into the grinder... or the mother/daughter/girfriend/brother/sister/son of said individuals... deliberately throwing away human lives if you have a differant course of options is not a sound policy. America changed it's tune after WWII making QUALITY more important then QUANTITY. The Sherman was a cornerstone of quantity/attrition warfare... where something like an M1-Abrams is quality over quantity thinking.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun May 29, 2005 4:56 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Yellowbeard wrote:
The Attrition concept works great when you have the numbers on your side... unless of course you're one of those "2 or 3" men that are going to lose you're lives when you're fed into the grinder... or the mother/daughter/girfriend/brother/sister/son of said individuals... deliberately throwing away human lives if you have a differant course of options is not a sound policy. America changed it's tune after WWII making QUALITY more important then QUANTITY. The Sherman was a cornerstone of quantity/attrition warfare... where something like an M1-Abrams is quality over quantity thinking.
The Sherman Tank and the Liberty Ship seem to have some things in common. If you were going to design a ship, that primo-design, you wouldn't design a Liberty Ship. If you needed so much cargo space per horsepower, a design that can be knocked out in two months, or so, and wouldn't cost an arm and a leg if torpedoed, then you'd probably build something like it.

Right, or wrong, or indifferent, the Sherman was a tank that was rushed into production because, having been caught flat-footed, it was what they had on hand and could throw into production, not because it was the tank of all tanks every tankman dreamed of. The M-1 Abrams, however, is. So, lessons have been learned about this mobile, turret mounted cannon, including it still uses a version of the 55-cal., swivel-mounted machine gun, used in WWII, and still used today because of the mechanical efficiency of its design, and does it still do its job? What can be gleaned from that, I leave to you.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Life at Sea All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3
Page 3 of 3

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group