
Hurricanes???? What's those, eh?????
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Crookshanks

Cutthroat 
Posts: 256 

 
336 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Jul 11, 2005 9:45 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Howie wrote: | | But if memory serves, both storms lost a lot of their punch by the time they got here |
Indeed. Hurricane Gloria was a cat 2 storm, so a moderate storm, by the time it hit the Northeast, and most of the damage seemed to be in the Long Island area, but it cut up through central CT, and MA.
I believe Hurricane Bob missed CT completely, but nailed southeast MA. I think it was classified as cat 3 storm.
| Airsaw wrote: | | I think you could predict tornados, but not fast enough to help much |
That's what's so terrifying about them. I've been through 2 of them at Purdue. Fortunately, they didn't hit where I lived.
It's difficult to say where lightning is going to strike when you're looking at miles and miles of open farm land. So not sure how you'd go about predicting a tornado from the electrical charge in the ground and disseminating that info out so that people have a chance to take cover, as you've indicated. It would be interesting to study trailer parks - seriously, tornados have a tendency to rip through trailer parks. _________________ "It is not our abilities that show what we truly are. It is our choices." |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Jul 11, 2005 10:51 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Crookshanks wrote: | | It's difficult to say where lightning is going to strike when you're looking at miles and miles of open farm land. So not sure how you'd go about predicting a tornado from the electrical charge in the ground and disseminating that info out so that people have a chance to take cover, as you've indicated. It would be interesting to study trailer parks - seriously, tornados have a tendency to rip through trailer parks. | At first blush, it's natural to think of lightning. Lightning is a discharge of built-up electricity. Everything, except the neutreno, has either a positive or negative charge of electricity. You've seen, I'm sure, those clocks that run on a potato. If you put an electric meter to your skin, you'll see the needle move, if set at a very low setting. Even YOU are electric! If I remember correctly a human is 1.5 volts. This electricity isn't confined within your body, or the potato, but you don't shoot sparks from your fingers every time you point. You don't build up a charge that seeks an easy release. "Fair" weather is similar in this regard. The electricity is still there, but it's not so intense a charge as to seek a sudden discharge.
Since you've experienced these sorts of storms, you've likely also experienced a strange sensation, often times it feels like the hair on your neck stands on end, or the air is "full of energy." I contend that since your nervous system is an efficient carrier of electric charge, you're actually feeling additional electricity passing through your body. Thunderstorm systems carry with them a hyper-charge of electricity compared to the normal background charge. The ground, I suggest, also intensifies when a storm is present, not just the air. (Bear in mind, density of objects are an illusion. There is more space between the atoms and electrons that circle them which make up your body, than there is "matter".) Everything is permeable to electricity. So, you have to view the ground in this context. The ground seems dense from our perspective, but it's only marginally more dense than air at the atomic scale.
A discharge is when built-up postively-charged electricity suddenly speeds toward a negative pole, like a tree, or a golfer holding a nine-iron (the group most frequently struck by lightning.) The negative end could be viewed as a low level, the positive end a high level, water rushing downhill. What if the levels of positive and negative are even, but only at a certain point? This is not only possible, it's highly likely. Also, I'm not referring to a homogenious, geometrically perfect "field" of electricity.
What I theorize is based on the fact electricity forms a vast field that runs unbroken throughout the entire universe. It's present everywhere in all things. Rather than a sudden burst of energy, I postulate the electric charges move toward one another in a conical shape, and not nearly so violently, but just as strong, like the electricity that travels in a power cord to an appliance. The negative (ground) reaches UP toward the positive which is pulled (like an electromagnetic field) by the positive, but the positive is equally being pulled by the negative. It's similiar to pressing your fingers on either end of a balloon; the resulting shape inside the balloon, for a lame example. Instead of a SUDDEN release, you have an even one, with the rotation following the force of the earth's spin. Since water especially conducts electricity, it's also reactive to electromagnetic force. You can demonstrate this by running a faucet at a small stream, and putting a statically charged item near the stream, such as a nylon comb. The water will bend toward the comb. So, it would stand to reason the water in the storm would be drawn to this conical form toward the ground. Some tornadoes seem to rise from the earth. That's been photographed
So, you're not measuring or using lightning to observe or predict, or possibly control, which I agree is far too random, and has been studied extensively anyway. I'm suggesting this occurs on the atomic level, with electrons as ions, or charged particles. Imagine the tornado as the upper end of an hourglass shape, the rest of the phenomena is in the ground, making an entire tornado shaped roughly like an...hourglass.
Once this electromagnetic field is created, the force of the storm kicks in - windspeed, water density - and you get a whirling vortex that travels like a finger, and as you said, seems to always head for trailer parks. This, of course, is an over-simplification. I doubt you'd want to read for three hours to get the entire story, but it's close enough.
I trust this was sufficiently confusing.  _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Vulture

Gunner 
Posts: 501 


606 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2005 12:48 am Post subject: |
|
|
I hope I don't have to give a lesson on tornados as well. The science to back up the electrical connection is not there, and it has been de-bunked (I hope thats spelled right) by most leading scientist in the field. To think that electricity causes tornados is ludicrous. Meteorology is a hobby for me and I have good knowledge on everything from lenticular clouds to virga. I cannot see any solid evidence to link tornados to electrical currents. You might as well link 'em to hail stones too. _________________
32 brightly polished cannons, a bottle o'rum, ahh..... a pirates life for me! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Crookshanks

Cutthroat 
Posts: 256 

 
336 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2005 2:24 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | | Even YOU are electric! |
I better know this, or I better get out of dietetics and healthcare!
The difference between electricity in my house - electrons, and the electricity in my body - ions, may explain why I don't go shooting sparks everywhere...at the cellular level, ions are exchanged through channels in the cell membrane- this is how the body communicates and sends messages to do whatever the message says for the body to do. The whole resting potential concept and the exchange of positive and negative ions and the cell membrane acting as the barrier/channel to keep the electricity in balance.
I'm way off topic, but wanted to note the difference between the electricity in your house vs the electricity in the body.
Thanks -  _________________ "It is not our abilities that show what we truly are. It is our choices." |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2005 4:01 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Vulture wrote: | | I hope I don't have to give a lesson on tornados as well. The science to back up the electrical connection is not there, and it has been de-bunked (I hope thats spelled right) by most leading scientist in the field. To think that electricity causes tornados is ludicrous. Meteorology is a hobby for me and I have good knowledge on everything from lenticular clouds to virga. I cannot see any solid evidence to link tornados to electrical currents. You might as well link 'em to hail stones too. | ah, right. nevermind. electricity causes tornadoes...debunked, like UFOs? valence of electrons in the earth's magneto-sphere...debunked...foh-getta-bouttit _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Howie

Helmsman 
Posts: 4223 

 
45890 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2005 12:09 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Crookshanks wrote: | | Howie wrote: | | But if memory serves, both storms lost a lot of their punch by the time they got here |
Indeed. Hurricane Gloria was a cat 2 storm, so a moderate storm, by the time it hit the Northeast, and most of the damage seemed to be in the Long Island area, but it cut up through central CT, and MA.
I believe Hurricane Bob missed CT completely, but nailed southeast MA. I think it was classified as cat 3 storm.
| Airsaw wrote: | | I think you could predict tornados, but not fast enough to help much |
That's what's so terrifying about them. I've been through 2 of them at Purdue. Fortunately, they didn't hit where I lived.
It's difficult to say where lightning is going to strike when you're looking at miles and miles of open farm land. So not sure how you'd go about predicting a tornado from the electrical charge in the ground and disseminating that info out so that people have a chance to take cover, as you've indicated. It would be interesting to study trailer parks - seriously, tornados have a tendency to rip through trailer parks. |
I live in north central CT and remember the storms. They were strong but I remember thinking when it was over that if this is what a hurricane is like then whats the fuss about because it didn't seem that bad. Just a few branches fell off the trees. I remember people were putting tape and plywood on their windows like that was going to help. The storm wasn't even strong enough to do much of anything. I remember It got all sunny and I thought it was the eye of the storm. In fact the silly storm was over and I was still expecting the back side to really come in and hammer us. Needless to say the weather forcasts whipped up all kinds of panic and it didn't even come off. At least where I live it didn't. Maybe the storms didn't bother me much because I live it an area with lots of real big trees. I'm not saying that you didn't experience a bad hurricane. I'm just saying I didn't percieve them as being something to be overly concerened about... _________________
   |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2005 5:30 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Howie wrote: | | Just a few branches fell off the trees. I remember people were putting tape and plywood on their windows like that was going to help. The storm wasn't even strong enough to do much of anything. I remember It got all sunny and I thought it was the eye of the storm. In fact the silly storm was over and I was still expecting the back side to really come in and hammer us. | At the risk of earning the ire from a local hobbyist...I've sat through seven hurricanes since 1997. I stand to be corrected on what follows (as long as the correctee knows from whence he/she speaks and isn't merely a supercilious dilettante.) These hurricanes ranged from category 3 to 5, and none were a direct hit. The eye of only one came within one hundred-twenty miles of the house, that was the category 5. So, there was no real need to evacuate, adding to the traffic pileup that was like a sitting duck when the big one DID hit.
What we got were bands coming off the hurricanes. They slide in at an odd angle, both moving outward, but twisting with a lengthwide slide. The weather will be overcast with a low cloud ceiling and a stifling humidity, then the winds suddenly pick up with sheets of rain of the pelting and stinging the face variety. If they hit lengthwise, they last up to twenty minutes. If they hit straight on, they last about five minutes. The wind speed depends on the strength of the storm itself. The power goes down almost fifteen minutes, sometimes thirty, after the first bands strike. This is the major difficulty, and why you need supplies. The other problem is windborne debris. If you go outside you could be hit by some flying object, tree limbs and the like. (Part of our preparation is to trim limbs from trees that might fall, and tie down lawn furniture, and other things that could be picked up by the wind, in hopes the flying debris damage might be reduced. And, of course, the plywood goes up over windows.)
So, you sit in the darkness, or the dull gray light of an unseen sun, and listen to battery-powered radio. If you're lucky you find a station playing music, instead of inanely babbling broadcasters who talk incessently, but never tell you anything you need to know. Suddenly the wind picks up and the rain pours down at an almost 90 degree angle. The trees bend over almost perpendicular to the ground, as well, and you think the house is going to blow over. Then it dies down and is relatively calm again. This happens as each band passes through in succession. When it's gone past, the winds become steady (as if it's a wake from a passing ship), and remain at about 40 to 45 mph for almost a day. Then it's blue skies and a slight breeze. The power company won't fix downed lines, or even go outside until the winds are lower than 35 mph, so even if the storm is gone, the power won't be back on at best for another day. The most I've sat without power was three days. Then, you go outside and pick up tree limbs. Everybody makes a huge pile at the street, so you see neighbors you haven't seen in months. That's pretty funny. (During the storm certain brave souls will dash outside with a rake and rake the debris that's collected over water drains in the street. If you don't, you stand a chance of flooded streets. You're not supposed to do this, but we do it anyway.)
Everybody recalls Andrew, I'm sure. NOAA said the primary damage from that storm was due to a series of tornadoes spawned by these bands coming off the hurricane. The high end estimate was "hundreds", and that's the biggest thing I worry about. I come from a tornado afflicted area, and am accustomed to TV meteorologists who know what they're doing. They know locating tornadoes using Doppler is the only forwarning there'll be, so instead of having people in yellow raincoats standing outside saying, "WOW! Look at the wind blow ME!" - they watch the radar looking for the signature "hook" that says "tornado on the ground." Such is not the case with the wannabee movie star TV weather people here in South Florida, so the only way you'll know a tornado is near you is if you see it yourself, or you get hit. That's very comforting to know.
Now, if you're directly in the path of the eye you have two major concerns; windspeed and storm surge. Windspeed is handled by building codes. Some of the most ridiculous, and cheap structures mankind has dreamed up, like the large awnings over gas pumps, and the huge plastic signs with their inner lighting, are the first to go. That, and aluminum prefab buildings make up most of the destructive debris. Make this form of construction illegal (fat chance) and you'll reduce a majority of the damage. Other residential building codes contingent on being able to buy insurance have reduced (somewhat) the phenomena of houses flying to pieces sending nails and boards through the air to batter other things. However, this is a major problem still with tornado activity. I'm in a house now that took a direct hit from Andrew. There's a major crack in a two-story tall load bearing wall, but at the spot with two windows one above the other, between the windows. We have a vaulted ceiling, which keeps the house cool during the very hot summers here. However, it takes a well-built structure to withstand winds approaching 200 miles per hour. Those most powerful winds are close to the center of the storm and cut a wide path. You might notice on video footage, most of the destroyed buildings are aluminum prefab, pinewood framed houses and trailers. There are construction methods that withstand even these forces, but contractors can't make millions building them, so they pretend they don't exist. You get the idea.
The storm surge, however, is nothing to toy with. A storm surge can bring a column of water within the eye of the storm that's up to 20 feet (or more). Look up from where you're sitting now and imagine twenty feet of water over your head. Storm surge is only a major threat from the beach out to seven miles from the beach. I'm about fifteen miles from South Beach, so I'll probably never see a storm surge hit my house. Zoning, and not allowing rich people to build on the coast would prevent damage from that, but again, fat chance they'll ever do that. Your tax dollars rebuild their beachside resorts.
Again at the risk of incurring correction from certain regions, how strong the storms are as they move northward, New England and Long Island, depends on the strength and track of the storm starting out, and the water temperatures. Hurricanes love warm water. It keeps them energized. So, global warming can only increase the risk of those areas that don't normally see 'canes, or see only the type of storms Howie describes. I'd keep my eye on things, and not become complacent. Don't PANIC (heh), but be advised. There was a devastating hurricane that wiped out the coast of New England in the late twenties, or thirties, I forget which. It could happen. But, they're not magic. They're quantifiable forces, and with satellite imagery and aircraft fly-throughs, the data is available. Those links I provided in a post above are good places to get all the info you need to know what you need to do, if anything. | Howie wrote: | | Needless to say the weather forcasts whipped up all kinds of panic and it didn't even come off. At least where I live it didn't. Maybe the storms didn't bother me much because I live it an area with lots of real big trees. I'm not saying that you didn't experience a bad hurricane. I'm just saying I didn't percieve them as being something to be overly concerened about... | I watch the radar on websites, not on the weather channels, because TV meteorologists use scare tactics to keep people glued to channel 10, not channel 6, or vice versa. They give you all sorts of scenarios among which is always one that will send us all to the nether regions. People who know they aren't that informed on this subject have no choice but to listen, then worry. When nothing that catastrophic happens, then they feel they've been bamboozled by being made afraid, so the next time they decide they'll be brave about it. Today these storms are predictable to a degree in their track if you can read a weather map and recognize the critical features from satellite photos. (When I see one bearing down on ME, I'm outta here, and hopefully way before the rush to evacuate.)
From what I've observed over the past thirty years regarding TV weather: A hurricane was heading for NY. The weather people were using their hysterical approach to weather reporting; "watch us or die", and the storm petered-out, becoming only a lot of rain with some wind gusts. The people of NY were miffed and raised cane about it. So, there followed a period of time that the scare tactics were dropped. THEN a storm suddenly struck (South Carolina, I believe) causing massive damage, and complaints came that there was not enough forwarning. So, the National Weather Service "overreacted", since they drew so much criticism. Now EVERY storm is a possible death trap and cause for hysteria...then they tell us to remain calm, they're keeping an eye on things. Ironically, one of the first things Andrew did when it made landfall was blow the roof off the NWS hurricane center in Miami, with all its antennae array and satellite download equipment.
With global warming, or CLIMATE CHANGE, and the OBVIOUS increase in the number and intensity of these storms, the resulting equation has the weather professionals behaving like children. This, too, is verrrrrry comforting to know. They say to evacuate, but your boss says "we're going to be open." They don't tell you that part. Not many people can afford to take off for a week and stay in a motel ONCE a year. We certainly aren't going to do it three or four times a year, and NOBODY'S going to risk being fired from their jobs. The weather people say people are in a few categories; those who have good sense and evacuate, those who want to experience the storm, and those who have lived here a long while and just aren't scared. MOST people who stay don't want to lose their jobs. Neat stuff, eh?
Another irony is, we used to get our forwarning from Cuba. The Cubans were way ahead (before the "revolution") in tracking storms. The information needed to prevent the Galveston disaster was readily available in more than enough time for an evacuation. Our arrogant "scientists" didn't feel it was necessary to call them. _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Pizza_Peep

Cutthroat 
Posts: 341 


0 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2005 8:43 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I live in louisiana and i think two years ago a hurricane hit us. We're pretty close to Texas and the Hurricane was supposed to go our way, so we went to baton rouge bad idea! _________________ I disgraced my own name and forgot to think of corn as the most obvious and only answer.  |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
b4lazarus

Cutthroat 
Posts: 274 

 
4739 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue Jul 12, 2005 11:50 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | | Everybody recalls Andrew, I'm sure. NOAA said the primary damage from that storm was due to a series of tornadoes spawned by these bands coming off the hurricane. |
Additional widely accepted theories have also been put forth on the destructive power of "Andrew". I sat thought an 8hr. CEU class that was titled "The Venturi Effect" and it put forth how most of the destruction was caused not by tornadoes but by wind rushing around obstacles getting squeezed, compressed, and sped up etc. on the ground. The class was based on an article written in part by Richard J. Pasch, NOAA Miami, FL
All I know is that I spent two months in Homestead repairing and drying in roofs. The amazing thing about the wind damage was how selective it was. Some of the crappiest houses ever built survived that storm, while other well built homes down the street were blown apart. A lot of the surviving houses had good garage doors, still intact. The blown-up houses (which literally looked like they were blown-up) were the ones that the garage doors wound up across the street, causing a rapid decompression of the structure, followed by the wind having its' way with the building entering through the gaping hole left by the missing garage door. (BOOM)
"The Venturi Effect" along with crappy, poorly installed garage doors was a major contributing factor to the wide spread destruction of "Andrew".(Eyewitness report)
NOAA also later on upgraded "Andrew" to a Cat 5 hurricane to cover their butts.
My 2 cents worth. _________________ X |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Vulture

Gunner 
Posts: 501 


606 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2005 12:36 am Post subject: |
|
|
Andrew was unique in one respect. Its second intensification was the fastest ever recorded drop in barometric pressure in a tropical system to this day. _________________
32 brightly polished cannons, a bottle o'rum, ahh..... a pirates life for me! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
b4lazarus

Cutthroat 
Posts: 274 

 
4739 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2005 1:14 am Post subject: |
|
|
Florida then has the distinction of having the three strangest hurricanes ever to come on shore.
1. "Andrew" fastest drop in barometric pressure... AKA "Giant Tornado"
2. "Frances" slowest moving storm with 100+ mph winds. The eye was over my house for 7 hours.
3. "Jeanne" skirted the coast, headed out to sea but then did a loop (wind up punch) and slammed into my area. The eye also came over my house.
My area also holds the World Record....having two major storms, "Frances" and "Jeanne", hit 3 weeks apart and come on shore in virtually the same spot (locations listed are less than four miles apart).
BTW Lightening has hit a tree accross the street (in a field) from my house at least three times that I know of in the past six years.... _________________ X |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Crookshanks

Cutthroat 
Posts: 256 

 
336 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2005 1:19 am Post subject: |
|
|
@ b4lazarus - time to move!  _________________ "It is not our abilities that show what we truly are. It is our choices." |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
b4lazarus

Cutthroat 
Posts: 274 

 
4739 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2005 1:49 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Crookshanks wrote: | @ b4lazarus - time to move!  |
Naaa...I built this house, and just installed a whole house generator so I'm OK.
I read your post about Gloria in '85...If you check where the eye came on shore on Long Island, you will see that it was over my house in Dix Hills then too. This kind of stuff sorta scares me but when you have had these up-close and personal experiences, it gives you a certain bravado.
But I tell you if a Cat 4 is gonna come my way you can bet your a$$ I'll be out of here. The flooding worries me more than the wind. I built my house to withstand 150 m.p.h.+ winds, but it is only 15 ft. above sea level. _________________ X |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Airsaw

Rigger 
Posts: 1806 


3281 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2005 3:29 am Post subject: |
|
|
| b4lazarus wrote: | | Crookshanks wrote: | @ b4lazarus - time to move!  | Naaa...I built this house, and just installed a whole house generator so I'm OK. | Heh heh heh, I'm not living next door to YOU!!!!  _________________
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
b4lazarus

Cutthroat 
Posts: 274 

 
4739 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Wed Jul 13, 2005 11:39 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Airsaw wrote: | | b4lazarus wrote: | | Crookshanks wrote: | @ b4lazarus - time to move!  | Naaa...I built this house, and just installed a whole house generator so I'm OK. | Heh heh heh, I'm not living next door to YOU!!!!  |
This unit is a totally enclosed self contained unit. It operates at full power (15KW) with a sound output level of 70 dB(a), or around the same level as an automobile. It's pretty quit. Also, I'm gonna allow my neighbor to run an extension cord to run her refrigerator, lights and fan from it.
The noise of a generator running the necessities is a welcome sound, you get a lot of visitors during power outages too! _________________ X |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|