Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

Turning with speed and grace
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Life at Sea Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3  Next
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Junior
Powder Monkey
Posts: 33



852 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 23, 2006 12:02 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I think we need to coordinate a trial of this crew jobs thing.
Do we REALLY know if reefing the sails slows the gunners, all you SOTL people should have no troube verifying this. But i agree about raising and lowering the sails taking longer after a short pause, I always thought it was just the riggin' monkeys moaning a bit before getting on with it...

One thing i have found to help you frigate sailors, Brief weaving left to right while keeping on the same course really seems to foul up the enimies shooting, even while the cannons are flying towards you.
I did a few tests and the cannon balls display few realistic newtonian properties, and i'm still not sure just how much auto aiming there is on them. The sea makes it hard to judge Confused
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
headrock
Rigger
Posts: 1512


354 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 23, 2006 12:43 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Junior wrote:
Do we REALLY know if reefing the sails slows the gunners, all you SOTL people should have no troube verifying this. But i agree about raising and lowering the sails taking longer after a short pause, I always thought it was just the riggin' monkeys moaning a bit before getting on with it...


Eh?

All I know is that raising takes more time than reefing, always, and that while changing sails there is no cannon reload. As to the exact speed of reloading and of changing sails, our good friend Strange had already done all the testing and came to the conclusion that the exact time depends on how much crew you have on board in relation to the exact ship you're using. Having below the ideal amount gives you slower reefing and raising (although the ratio of times between the two seems to be constant). Having an ideal crew amount (which is usually about 1/3 of the max crew) allows optimal speeds at reefing and raising (and the ratio is still the same). Having above that crew neither speeds the sail changes further, nor allows you to reload the cannons any faster. Dunno about any "short pauses", I've never noticed sail change or reload rate times changing during one sea battle, as long as you don't lose crew of course.
_________________
Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 23, 2006 7:28 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Firstly, take a large enough crew to handle both the guns and the sails. With 32 guns or more, minimum for seamless action is 180 - preferably 200. Secondly, sure you have tons of guns, but don't sit off broadside to broadside taking pot shots - maneuver.

Maneuver - View it as a running battle. Movement is continuous and must be done with the windrose as much in your eye as the target. Downwind, or upwind - both are doable, but they differ. Downwind with large ships means keeping your distance - a goodly distance. Even though you get the "out of range" call, the enemy is moving toward your fire. Lobbing shells into his course. He of course, will try to maneuver as well, so you have to do some guessing. As you damage him, you can move in closer. Each shot that lands affects his capacity to move.

If you're moving downwind with the enemy on your tail, but you have a speed advantage of 2kts or better, swerve to one one side in a feint, wait for him to follow that move by trying to bring his guns to bear - doesn't take that much of a turn for him, then quickly swing about the other way and set up your broadside. Don't wait for the shells to hit. Swing back around and follow a line directly in front, and abeam to him - your keels form a straight line - same heading. Feint one way, turn the other, fire, pull away.

Approaching the vessel from a distance, take a line that gives the enemy the impression you're moving into his broadside. Timing is key here, just before he fires, turn in the opposite direction. You can see his port covers open for a cue. He'll try to lay a shot to intersect your line of travel - mistakenly. BoW to SotL class ships must approach in an S fashion digging deeply into the water with the stern. Ending up parallel with the cannon fire, but just to the side of it.

Aim for his bowsprit, not exactly there, but where it should be when your lines of movment intersect. He'll usually make a radical turn to fire. Just as his shots leave, come about and head for his stern. He'll turn to meet that line, then is when you swing about again, heading for his bowsprit. If you're approaching from upwind, getting his bow faced directly into the wind is ideal for the coup de gras. That's when you come perpendicular to his stern while he luffs and rake his decks with grapeshot - furl your sails and sharply turn into him to board.

You should be heavily leaning on your direction keys, baiting him to fire on one line, so you can swing about and approach on another, the time it takes him to reload is the time you get to close the distance. Anticipate his shots and already be turning as his shells leave his guns. Expect to be hit one good time, generally but not always. It should be the only time he gets a good shot off on you - usually as you make your sharp turn to make contact.

If you prefer to damage the ship for a surrender in the larger vessels, marksmanship and distance are your best friends. These ships have plenty of speed and maneuver but only in relation to that wind rose. Trying to approach from downwind will only result in damage. (This is why I prefer the BoW - smaller target profile; the further downrange you are the more the shells spread; in that vein the beam of a BoW is shorter, so their guns go off in a more compact spread. A SotL's shells spread over distance allowing you to hit with usually only a third of the shells.) Never take a direct line toward a target. Even a small sloop of 8 guns will damage you enough before you reach them, and have plenty of speed left to escape.

It's most important to remember, his fire is moving and so is your ship. You come underneath his cannonballs, or they soar overhead - swing your stern around so it doesn't get hit. These ships are long. They are so fast you can maneuver out of the line of fire, and back into it, if you aren't careful enough. The time you get for maneuver includes his reload rate, as well as the time it takes his shells to cover the distance. That's plenty of room if you use it.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
headrock
Rigger
Posts: 1512


354 Gold -

PostPosted: Thu Feb 23, 2006 9:42 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

First of all, very nice, maybe we'll see some schematics for that? Razz

Also, your expertise as a BoW captain shows well, unfortunately it is also apparent how little time you spend in Frigates, unfortunately. Then again, I must admit that I spend very little time in Brigs as well, so we're both to blame. Wink

However you've made some strange observations about Frigates and especially SOLs, so I've got to clarify for the readers.

Firstly, the minimum ideal crew for SOLs is 168 men, that gives fastest reloading and reef/raise times. This is also the largest ideal crew of all ships.

Now, let's go on.

The number of cannons on a SOL equals 48, which is 1.5 times more than that of a Frigate or a Brig of War which both have 32. Airsaw is absolutely correct about keel size - the Frigate, as a longer ship than the Brig, will spread its shots over a much greater spread. At Killzone distance, which is about grapeshot and less, a shot from a SOL can score a massive, 70-90% hit on a Treasure Galleon (the ship with the largest profile). That is, 70-90% of the cannonballs fired, which is about 24 for a Frigate, 36 for a SOL, which is pretty much instant death or surrender. A smaller ship, like a Brigantine or a Sloop will receive about 40-60% of the damage, which is around 24 cannons for a SOL. Again, since these are smaller ships, the punishment they can take is also smaller, again this is why it's called the Killzone. Canoes that are trying to get away from you would probably not be able to survive any roundshot volley at this distance.
At a longer distance from the target, is where you'll be able to really show off that spread. Much like the difference between a Shotgun and a Machine Gun, the Brigs can kill another ship just as well as the Frigates, but their intended use is years apart. The brig will fire the aforementioned volley nice and compact even at medium range, which is the Brig's optimal range for combat. On a good aim, the Brig can deliver all of those rounds at the enemy, an utterly devastating effect on medium-size ships, which are the Brig's specialty. The great Galleons and Frigates will not be easily dismayed by a hit, but Merchantmen, Fluyts and Barques and even the occassional Royal Sloop are prime targets for such a volley, and it may singlehandedly defuse them.

But to get that perfect shot, the brig must make long series of elaborate maneuvers. This happens because the Brig is an averagely-fast vessel. It's certainly faster than the merchants, but has the lowest maximum speed of all warships. Instead, the Brig is designed for the maneuvering, the weaving and zagging while trying to bring its own guns to bear. If it gets too close to a dangerous target, that target can open fire and cause some nasty damage, usually not TERRIBLE damage, but stuff that can ruin your day or just make you unable to keep chase.

The Frigate offers the Machine Gun solution to the same problem, and I'm afraid that Airsaw has tried, perhaps unwittingly, to apply the same laws of Brigs to that of Frigates. However there are fundemental differences that require fundamentally different tactics. Let me explain.

Returning to the Frigate's spread, it has to do with a lot of factors, but the two most important ones are speed of fire and distance of fire. Rarely have I seen (and yes, it happens) a Frigate release its entire volley at once. Firing 32-48 cannons can take a few moments, and by the time the last group of cannonballs in the volley is fired, you've moved a considerable distance, and have probably also turned slightly to one way or the other. This means that the last cannonballs fired are travelling somewhere else than the first ones fired. At large distances, this truly comes into effect, spreading the shot over a large patch of ocean.

So what's good about that? You'd assume that this produces a partial hit on the enemy. And it does! Hit rates drop to a much lower percentage, about 50-70% for a well-aimed shot at a Treasure Galleon. So surely, the Brig, which couldn't possibly have missed the shot, would've caused more damage.
But there are two things to remember! One, the Brig would've delivered around 70-90% of its cannonballs, but that equals, at the most, around 28 cannonballs. At the same time, a SOL firing at large distance would've landed around 28 cannonballs on the target! But it has fired them from a location where the enemy could not POSSIBLY hope to retort. The captain of the frigate has done far less maneuvering, and requires a FAR less accurate shot, to put those 28 cannonballs on the enemy.

SOLs make use of the advantage of Speed rather than Maneuverability. You have to know which way the wind is blowing, because THAT's where you're going! And once distance is sufficient, then it is time to turn and release. If your gunnery isn't completely in the dumps, you'll get a hit not matter what. If your gunnery is at its peak, expect 70-80% of the fire to smak into a Treasure Galleon, 23-26 cannons on a Frigate, a whopping 35-40 cannonballs on a SOL! After that kind of hit, nothing is going to stop you from dancing around the enemy and shelling them as much as you like. Smaller ships will take a smaller hit, of course, and here the weakness of SOLs shows, as in longer ranges it is far more difficult to predict where the Sloop or Pinnace are going to be when the cannonballs land. But since the volley is spread out more too, a good aim can blanket the target zone with cannonballs, ensuring at least a partial hit.

In the meanwhile, "feinting" to left or right is only useful if the enemy has already fired. Reef and turn as quickly as possible, returning fire if you like, and go back downwind ASAP to regain speed. Frigates can't afford to waste precious speeds on turning (your speed is slightly reduced for each degree in a turn, regardless of anything). At the ranges where a Frigate is used, there's really no need for it either. A Frigate can dodge cannonballs very easily when it is so far away from the enemy. Just turning downwind can sometimes give you enough speed to flee in the same direction the cannonballs are heading! At around 16-20 knots, they'll probably just splash behind you!

So Where the Brig keeps swinging around and trying to catch good winds, the Frigate has done its business calmly, quickly, and with no risk to itself whatsoever. The Frigate turns combat into a far more linear battle, one ship chasing after the other. Attention to the wind gauge should be done each time you turn to fire and turn back to sail, but hardly demands much more attention than that. You pay much more attention to aiming.

As to coming from the other direction (from upwind), the Frigate closes a circle with the Pinnace, and goes for the simplest tactic - Dart and Board. With the huge resistance to punishment they have, Frigates shouldn't fear an incoming volley when they are travelling at top speed. A roundshot volley will usually go overhead if you're at about 13+ knots, and unless facing another Frigate, mere chainshot isn't going to slow you down. You're on collision course with the enemy. Of course, there is seldom reason to attack from this direction.

I agree with everything else Airsaw has said.
_________________
Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 24, 2006 12:29 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

headrock wrote:
First of all, very nice, maybe we'll see some schematics for that? Razz
Your wish is my command. This is a Powerpoint presentation. I figured out myself (nyah) that a picture is worth a thousand words. This is what I explained above in easier to understand terms. There's a button at the lower right of the presentation that gives you a full screen. Click that, then click the center of each page to turn to the next. Kill the browser window to exit the presentation. It'll open in another window.
The Large Ship in Attack

I'll post this on the tactics and strategy forum under "general".
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Junior
Powder Monkey
Posts: 33



852 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 24, 2006 3:39 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Goddam, you guys have really worked on this eh?
The only problem is see with both of these theories, is that we have to apply the to eejit computer sailors... But I'll assume from the length and detail you've gone into, you've got a better sailing game than us.
OR You're really reincarnated admirals from our nautical past come back to haunt our pitiful sailing skills. Worship

It's good to have a visual guide to these things too, sometime halfway through reading one of your guides you suddenly realise you've no idea whose ship is which or where they're ment to be going.

Will we see more of these for the smaller classes? Wink
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
kvollmer
Cutthroat
Posts: 285



6103 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Fri Feb 24, 2006 5:30 pm    Post subject: sloop Reply with quote

Ok with a sloop its a little bit different. The optimal fighting range (at least for me) is typically long range depending on what your fighting. If your fighting a much heavier ship like a war galleon or an SOL your best fighting distance is at long range. Even with the SOL's huge spread at long range the sloop is manuverable enough to avoid most if not all of the SOL's cannon balls. Where as at medium and short ranges a sloop is going to be scrap wood after one broadside.

Now while manuvering a sloop needs to shoot back at the SOL. You probablywon't have the time to aim carefully so if you shoot from the hip. You can shoot a consolidated shot from the hip that will be either hit or miss or you can spread your shots by turning while firing. The spread probably won't land more then 25% or about 5 rounds on the SOL. The consolidated shot could be a 80% or it could be a 0% depending on if your shot was good or not. This of course can be done because the AI seems to prefer sitting back and taking potshots at you rather then using speed to its advantage. Eventually you wear him down so you can sink him or board him.

With trade galleons I actually don't use the long range tactic at all. They often have so few cannon that closing in isn't that big of a risk. So I close in to very close range and get on the bow or aft of the ship. From there I carefully manuver my ship so I just stay with their bow or aft the whole time while I pummel them with Grapeshot or chain shot. This may sound hard and it is but done properly I've been able to unload 3 full broadsides into a trade galleon without ever entering the "danger zone" where they can shoot me. (After 3 full broadsides they are pretty easy to board.)
_________________
Sincerly,


Kirk Vollmer
Don't ever call me Captain Kirk.
Valparaiso University Alumni; Class of 2004
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 24, 2006 9:45 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Junior wrote:
But I'll assume from the length and detail you've gone into, you've got a better sailing game than us.
OR You're really reincarnated admirals from our nautical past come back to haunt our pitiful sailing skills. Worship

It's interesting that you say this. I did that presentation with a Rogue-level pirate. I'm using a PC/DVD. The AI doesn't fool around on my game. Maybe we're talking about different versions of the game.
Junior wrote:

Will we see more of these for the smaller classes? Wink
Heh. The first thing I did after that pres. was trade the SotL in for a war sloop. Trying to capture the war sloop was like an elephant trying to swat a bumble bee. It had cotton sails and copper, and literally ate my lunch, sinking the SotL, though it had 12 guns. 12 guns, with good hits is all you need to deal with the larger vessels. That's why rupert littlebear reads all this and chuckles to himself. He drives a fully-rigged war canoe.

What I've noticed in my game is the smaller ships stand off and inflict damage until they've got an advantage, then they make for you to board. Some will go ahead and sink you, though. Merchant vessels tend to try to run, but if they can't, they try to sink you. A merchantman with five cannon can do some greivous damage.

But, yeah, I've considered doing a blow-by-blow for smaller ships, but for the fact I don't have that much experience with them. I'll either make a straight run at the target, dodging shell as I go, then board. Or, I'll zig-zag about lobbing volleys from a distance. There is a technique, I'm sure rupert uses, where you get on a victim's stern and stay there (zigging and zagging) firing into larger vessels from pretty close-on. I've done that a couple of times, but not enough to claim any expertise.

The reason I nabbed the war sloop was to get into the mercantile business in my old age. I can't sword fight woffadamn anymore, like moving through molasses. So, I captured two large merchantmen, and the sloop. Now I'm plying the waters buying and selling. I started at St. Martin and went completely around the map visting every port, village and settlement (no havens or monestaries) including Panama and Port Principe, not Gran Granada. It took 5 years to make the circuit back to St. Martin!

Usually I use a brig of war. I only used the SotL as a lark.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Feb 25, 2006 7:58 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Junior wrote:
Will we see more of these for the smaller classes? Wink
Here's your smaller class presentation:

The Sloop in Combat This link is posted under this same title in the General section of the forum. There, discussion is invited with regard to tactical questions and small vessels.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
headrock
Rigger
Posts: 1512


354 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Feb 26, 2006 2:09 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Airsaw wrote:
The first thing I did after that pres. was trade the SotL in for a war sloop. Trying to capture the war sloop was like an elephant trying to swat a bumble bee. It had cotton sails and copper, and literally ate my lunch, sinking the SotL, though it had 12 guns. 12 guns, with good hits is all you need to deal with the larger vessels.


Which is why in a battle where the enemy is likely to give chase (Sloops of War, I can't think of a reason why they would run away), the downwind run still gives you a massive advantage even over such a maneuverable enemy. You're simply at a place where he can't touch you. Fire the chainshot just as he turns from firing his own salvo and back into pursuit. This'll catch him square in the mainsail.
. o O (Triangle in the mainsail? Razz)

No use to tassle with such an enemy upclose, thus demonstrating the importance of the downwind barrage tactic. If the enemy were running away, the upwind approach with a very swift swoop-in can easily neutralize him.

Quote:
What I've noticed in my game is the smaller ships stand off and inflict damage until they've got an advantage, then they make for you to board.


Which is why you need to deprive them from that advantage by standing off yourself. If they were hostile in the first place, they'll chase you because they want to win the match, and run into aforementioned hail of chainshot. If they're looking to run away, again, your approach must be utterly quick and ruthless, no time or room for maneuvers, just the fastest run to a firing position, and a hail of roundshot or chainshot as appropriate.

Quote:
Merchant vessels tend to try to run, but if they can't, they try to sink you. A merchantman with five cannon can do some greivous damage.


For this situation, the Ladder is the best technique - say the enemy is running at about broad reach or further offwind. Match his heading, and you'll surpass his speed (these are merchants we're talking about, right? The Tubs?). Whenever he thinks he can fire a volley at you, dodge that volley out slightly downwind, fire your own (roundshot) then swing back with your added speed and regain the position you were in before, or a better one. Once the enemy needs to turn even slightly to starboard (into the wind) to properly aim the cannons at you, he's going to slow down to a point where no matter where you are on the map, a roundshot volley is going to cripple him. All the while, you are maintaining Chainshot to Roundshot distance, no less, to give yourself ample room for maneuvering.


Quote:
There is a technique, I'm sure rupert uses, where you get on a victim's stern and stay there (zigging and zagging) firing into larger vessels from pretty close-on. I've done that a couple of times, but not enough to claim any expertise.


Rupert has cannons on board?! When did this happen?! Smile
_________________
Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Feb 26, 2006 2:21 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Oops! Masterswordsman! I hope I can keep my head after that faux pas... Shocked
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
kvollmer
Cutthroat
Posts: 285



6103 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 3:58 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Airsaw wrote:

The Sloop in Combat This link is posted under this same title in the General section of the forum. There, discussion is invited with regard to tactical questions and small vessels.


I'm looking at that and the guy seems to have the right idea but he makes quite a few mistakes. (Due to the fact he hasn't used it in a while). For example he seems to turn too early or too late while trying to stay on the merchantman's stern. So yeah you can use that but with practice it should go a lot more smoothly then that.

Plus it seems like he's damaging the ship a bit much. I personally like to haul off my targets to be sold, and I'd prefer selling them in a condition better then firewood.

I'll edit this post if I see anything else interesting.
_________________
Sincerly,


Kirk Vollmer
Don't ever call me Captain Kirk.
Valparaiso University Alumni; Class of 2004
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 4:28 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I use a brig of war. I also shot those with a guy that had all the rank, and the merchant vessel was to be part of a fleet. Repairs cost 0 gold, and at those rates there's no point in being anal about it.

You use a brig of war differently than all other vessels. It's somewhat like a sloop, somewhat like a frigate, but not really either. It packs a wallop and does real damage. It also takes damage well. I use it for sailing and fighting, since it does both well. I see it as the best of all worlds. But, it's played differently.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
headrock
Rigger
Posts: 1512


354 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 4:48 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

My question is, how come we're seeing all these "rather good" combat tactic presentations for Large and Small ships, but haven't seen one for your own specialty yet?! I wanna see how Airsaw sails his mean BoW!!!
_________________
Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 4:55 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

headrock wrote:
My question is, how come we're seeing all these "rather good" combat tactic presentations for Large and Small ships, but haven't seen one for your own specialty yet?! I wanna see how Airsaw sails his mean BoW!!!
How did I know you were going to say that? Working...please wait...
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Life at Sea All times are GMT
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3  Next
Page 2 of 3

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group