Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

The Large Ship in Attack
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> General Hints and strategies
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 24, 2006 12:45 am    Post subject: The Large Ship in Attack Reply with quote

A bit of discussion broke out elsewhere here regarding the use of frigates, large frigates and ships of the line. This is an instructional pamphlet in Powerpoint format showing a tactic the game uses, and which I use against the game. This isn't a ram and duel tactic. It's helpful to force surrender if you don't want to swordfight, due to age, or impatience. It involves inflicting sail damage, so it reduces the resale value of prize ships, that is unless you have the rank to get free repairs.

The Large Ship in Attack

Feedback will be appreciated, especially with regard to the presentation - if it's okay, or not preferred, whatever. The opening page has a button on the lower right of the screen. Click it for full screen, then click the center of each page to get to the next. It's got three examples, roughly 47 slides, or pages.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
WhiteWolf
Powder Monkey
Posts: 31



255 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri Feb 24, 2006 2:40 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Wow. I love your presentation. Of course, I love all the little web page presentations you've done. I look forward to them Worship Thumbs Up Worship Worship
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
headrock
Rigger
Posts: 1512


354 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Feb 25, 2006 3:16 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Brilliantly done, Airsaw.
Let me comment.

First of all, what you've done is basically taken the tactics one would use normally in Brigs, and applied them to a ship with less maneuverability and more speed. I can see a Brig easily going through all those steps without a hitch, and I have to say you know your battle tactics very well.

However, your presentation also reveals the flaws of using this tactic with the Frigate (or in that case, the SOL) for one most important reason: RISK.

I've said before that a SOL has no fear in the caribbean, and I stand behind this now. In your scenarios, the SOL is only in a slight advantage, and sometimes also in a disadvantage (the parallel opposite directions scenario in particular). The most powerful advantage the SOL can have is its safety, being able to attain utter dominance over the enemy without ever risking taking a single cannonball. After playing with my first SOL for a few days, I completely stopped taking damage, and very rarely strayed into positions where the enemy might get lucky. Repairing a SOL, as opposed to a Brig, is far more expensive, and Large Ship captains are known to avoid damage at all cost. A proper Large Ship tactics involves keeping the enemy where they can't possibly hit you, while you have free firing ability back at them.

It's ALL in the approach - A SOL attains its advantage simply by being downwind of the enemy. Large Ship captains are far better off spending that extra moment navigating to a downwind position before the match, and with a Frigate that is SO easy to do. This can be the entire quarter of the downwind direction (including Broad Reach, that is). As long as you're not facing the wind when combat starts, you can simultaneously turn downwind to gain speed AND land a starting volley on the enemy with the same starting maneuver! This itself is enough sometimes to turn a dangerous enemy into an amusing plaything. Approaching an enemy from Upwind, or travelling upwind as the battle starts, is a big no no, and is so easily avoided that speculating about this is as futile as speculating about going into battle with half max guns. It is enough that the enemy lands a volley on me for me to consider the battle a tie even if I win it. Sure, she can take lots of damage, but holes in the sails are a Bigship Captain's bane.

So while I applaud your excellent skill at maneuvering, I still say that in the world of Big Ships it is redundant, sort of like a class on "gunnery for pinnaces".
_________________
Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Feb 25, 2006 3:42 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

That's all well and good, HR, but for the fact that if you're downwind at a distance against a smaller vessel with good tacking ability, he can just flee the battle. When that happens, he disappears from the map. It seems you have to keep some closeness to keep the fish on the line, as it were. In so doing, against more maneuverable ships, you are going to encounter risk, and you aren't going to make a small target. Furthermore, it would seem in order to use chainshot, and especially grapeshot, you've got to get up close and personal.

In my first encounter I go for the downwind position, also the one with the galleon. However, I stay close enough to invite, or provoke pursuit. The second scenario is a "how not to do it" one.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
headrock
Rigger
Posts: 1512


354 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Feb 25, 2006 5:07 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

First, attacking small vessels from upwind is not disputed, but again there's no point to it when you're on a SOL. Why waste time on canoes? And if a sloop _attacks_ you, then the downwind approach still works just find (since they'll chase you no matter what). As to provoking a chase, most ships will chase you, and if they don't, that's the last mistake they'll ever make - by turning off-wind they will usually slow down (again, pinnaces and sloops deserve different consideration of course) they make themselves a far easier target to hit.

What I didn't like about your first example is that you left way too much opportunity for the enemy to turn and fire. On Swash, they can sometimes surprise you with a strange decision to fire a broadside rather than turn to chase, and I don't like that chance. Much better to stay at chainshot distance and be able to sleekly avoid anything fired your way.

And like you said before, chainshot doesn't have to be used in close range. If the enemy's chasing, they'll run into chainshot as they approach, as opposed to roundshot which may overpass them. I truly don't see any use for Grapeshot, except for thinning down an Evil Spaniard's crew, AFTER his ship has turned into a bowl with a spoon drooping sideways off it.
_________________
Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
rupertlittlebear
Helmsman
Posts: 4434


10417 Gold -

more...
PostPosted: Sat Feb 25, 2006 5:51 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

headrock wrote:
First, attacking small vessels from upwind is not disputed, but again there's no point to it when you're on a SOL. Why waste time on canoes?

cash flow concerns when the barmaid tells you that there is a canoe in the area with over 1000 gold maybe.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Feb 25, 2006 6:55 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Okay. You're traveling with the wind, the target behind you in chase mode. He turns to fire a broadside. Several things arise. Firstly, during his turn, he reaches what can be called an acute angle in relation to your own forward movement. This angle is when he's no longer moving generally the same way you are. This means immediately, the distance between you is increasing. With that increase comes a corresponding reduction in possible damage, due to the spread of the shot, but also making the aim more problematic. Secondly, the target/attacking ship has to move perpendicular to the wind to achieve the broadside. Should this happen, as you see the chasing vessel reach the acute angle, you can break to the opposite direction. If he's turning port, you turn to starboard. To maintain his aim, he has to come back around to starboard, and reestablish forward movement, or speed. While he's doing this, he's bringing himself into your targeting zone sooner. He's walking into your punch. His only other choice is to follow through with the port turn, essentially a circle, during which you again can easily target him, only from the stern "quarter panel." (I did a post on these terms. Maybe I should read it.) I don't see how the condition you propose constitutes a loss of advantage.

Rupert's right about the pinnace class ships. If you're not downwind from them, they'll run right off the board, then disappear.

Sitting off at a distance and shelling from downwind. I don't see anything wrong with that, but for the fact it must be time consuming. I doubt your full broadside hits anything at long distances. The best you could get is a third of your shells to hit. Why have 48 guns if only 16 guns hit at a time? With a BoW, the narrower spread hurls the shells in a tighter pack. You still won't get every cannon to hit, but half will, that's 16 guns, too. Then, it takes you forever to buck the winds to get back to the target to accept a surrender. Nah, I like to be a lot closer than that. And, for that, trying to use a SotL like a sloop isn't a good idea.

Speaking of sloops, here's the presentation on The Sloop in Combat.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
headrock
Rigger
Posts: 1512


354 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Feb 26, 2006 3:11 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Airsaw wrote:
Okay. You're traveling with the wind, the target behind you in chase mode. He turns to fire a broadside. Several things arise. Firstly, during his turn, he reaches what can be called an acute angle in relation to your own forward movement. This angle is when he's no longer moving generally the same way you are. This means immediately, the distance between you is increasing.


Yes, in fact it is increasing ALL the time, since you're always the fastest ship, when headed that way (except against other Frigates, but they're such nice big targets anyway). I don't condone doing this from maximum range, keeping yourself in low-to-mid roundshot distance is important. It gives you both good reaction times and excellent distance for both chainshot and roundshot firing.

Quote:
With that increase comes a corresponding reduction in possible damage, due to the spread of the shot, but also making the aim more problematic.


When an enemy makes any sort of change of direction, the Frigate captain must react or be prepared to react to it, for both the purpose of avoiding the shot, as well as firing your own volley at the right time. The result, as I will explain below, is actually the raising of your chance to hit. And again, maintaining a reasonable distance during the chase is crucial, you're not supposed to speed too far away at any time.

Quote:
Secondly, the target/attacking ship has to move perpendicular to the wind to achieve the broadside. Should this happen, as you see the chasing vessel reach the acute angle, you can break to the opposite direction. If he's turning port, you turn to starboard. To maintain his aim, he has to come back around to starboard, and reestablish forward movement, or speed. While he's doing this, he's bringing himself into your targeting zone sooner. He's walking into your punch.


Yes and no. Again this is good for a Brig which has more good sailing points, but in a Frigate this maneuver will cripple your ability to aim the guns. Let me explain how I approach the situation.

1) So the enemy's chasing you. You're preferably keeping him just between inner Roundshot and outer Chainshot ranges. You can use slight zigzags or even reefing and raising the sails as appropriate (make sure guns are loaded, first). You may need to reduce the distance a bit further for a moment to make the enemy think they've got a shot at you.

2) The enemy reaches a point where he thinks he can cut one loose ( Wink ). He begins his turn to either direction. Right now, your sails must immediately be REEFED to prevent opening a big distance. If you were inside Chainshot range when this happened, don't reef yet.

3) Once the enemy reaches his firing position, as soon as the first cannonball is fired, swing your ship around in the same direction as his ship turned. By the middle of your turn, the enemy has already begun turning back to chase you, as it has already completed his cannonfire and you haven't yet completed your turn (hopefully. This takes good timing on swash, but is much easier on rogue or lower). So the enemy is headed right toward you, or at least has already made a partial turn towards you, and is travelling at a great speed.

4) This is where GUNNERY proves itself as the most important skill for a Frigateer - With the enemy going towards you, and your sails down giving you a nice edge in aiming, aim at the endpoint for his turn (he's turning towards you, remember?) and fire chainshot.

5) As soon as that "Guns loaded" bar empties, the sail goes back FULL and the turn back downwind begins. If the enemy's REAL stupid, they'll try to turn and fire at you, presenting a part of their side to the oncoming chainshot. Either way, they're not going to escape that killzone - your firing position allows you to both concentrate and spread your fire as you like - you can even start turning back downwind WHILE firing the cannon, timed so that it would fire a concentration at one spot and a few groups slightly forward of the enemy, in case he turns.

Of the ships who will fall into the chase trick, only the pinnace has enough speed and maneuverability to escape that shot. Except to see at least a 40% hit on a sloop, and by at least I do mean at least because as your gunnery skills improve you can easily smack the mainsail right off a sloop with this. I guess this is the main reason why I advocate sailing SOLs over Large Frigates or Frigates - the difference between the actual number of cannonballs that land on the target is immense - I've broken the main mast on Frigates with this tactic (that is, in one shot). The size of the target matters a lot of course, but again, the smaller the target, the less hits you actually need.

Note that this doesn't always work with roundshot, except for the slower and large ships (brig and up) cause the small ones might speed under the roundshot volley which is a big embarassment.

Let's assume for a second that I combine the two - with or without a feint,
I turn opposite to the direction the enemy turned. If he swings back towards me, he's now heading downwind, and I was heading away from him, perpendicular to the wind. I need to swing either into the wind or away from the wind to get another shot. Turning upwind is of course pointless since the ship will stop before you can train the guns. Turn the other way, and by the time you've finished the turn the enemy has enough speed to maneuver under or aside from your volley. The trick is to catch him WHILE he's turning - I've had countless times on Rogues and Swash, before I learned how to properly sail a Biggie, when I had turned to fire on my chaser, only to have him dodge easily sideways - if you can do it so can he. So again, the trick is to stay one step ahead of the enemy while letting him think everything's going fine. Then when he misses that shot and turns towards you, you've already crossed his T.

Quote:
His only other choice is to follow through with the port turn, essentially a circle, during which you again can easily target him, only from the stern "quarter panel.


Yes, if the enemy's that stupid, he's already lost the fight.

Quote:
Rupert's right about the pinnace class ships. If you're not downwind from them, they'll run right off the board, then disappear.


Hell no! To defeat a Pinnace, you need an upwind position on it - it has to be PERCISE! You need to be correctly aligned before battle starts, with the enemy as directly downwind as possible. You'll gain enough speed to close the distance to somewhere along the lines of mid-long chainshot. If you don't make this shot, you've lost, cause you can't chase at all. But in those starting moments, you're accelerating downwind, and the enemy is only losing distance by going perpendicular to that.

Quote:
Sitting off at a distance and shelling from downwind. I don't see anything wrong with that, but for the fact it must be time consuming.


Hardly. If you put your ship where it's supposed to be at the start of battle
(I.E. downwind, and NOT facing upwind!) the first volley can either neutralize or cripple the enemy, at which point they've lost and you can maneuver easily to a closer location, whereever it may be, that gives you perfect firing position. Escort fights take longer and are of course riskier, but not remotely as risky as trying to weave a Frigate between two ships at grapeshot-to-chainshot range! If I don't have time for taking out the escort, I just use canoe tactics - approach from upwind, ram and board ASAP, gaining so much speed in doing so that you're at the merchant before the escort has had time to say "My ass is on fire".

Quote:
I doubt your full broadside hits anything at long distances.


Who needs a full broadside?! It's 48 cannons for god's sake!

Quote:
The best you could get is a third of your shells to hit.


At _LEAST_ a third, and that's what long range gunnery skills are all about. You can make 70 and 80% hits at roundshot range, and I've made full hits before, or at least what looked like full hits (a Flag Galleon exploding violently on the first hit is a fine example).

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v726/Headrock/FlagGal.jpg
Mid-Roundshot distance, Rogue difficulty

Quote:
Why have 48 guns if only 16 guns hit at a time?


Even if you only get 16 guns per hit, you're still doing it much safer than when dancing around in a sloop, having to have an itchy finger hovering over the controls, when the enemy can blast you out of the water if you're nto careful. The best thing about the chase tactic is the enemy can't touch you. And of course, once you practice your long range gunnery, it goes up from 16 per hit. Way up.

Quote:
With a BoW, the narrower spread hurls the shells in a tighter pack. You still won't get every cannon to hit, but half will, that's 16 guns, too.


Again, the Shotgun vs. Machine gun approaches. If your maneuvering skills and your ability to anticipate and react to an enemy at such close ranges is better than your ability to land a scattered, staggered volley of cannonballs on a remote target, then the Shotgun's for you. And if you're unbeatable at fencing, why bother with either ship? *Points accusedly at Rupert*.


Quote:
Then, it takes you forever to buck the winds to get back to the target to accept a surrender.


This was by far the most annoying thing I had to deal with as a Big Ship captain, but again, once you learn your long range gunnery by heart, you know if you need to close the distance even before your CBs land on the enemy, and then if they surrender you're already on your way. If you make the mistake of assuming a miss while the enemy receives a load of chainshot in his face, well, that's a lesson learned.
_________________
Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Sun Feb 26, 2006 7:05 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

hmmm...I'm at a loss to figure out what's the discussion...it's apples and oranges to me. If you want to sit "far back" and chuck from the cheap seats, have at it. Personally, I find it to be a little dull. I can imagine getting 80% on a target, but not often. A frigate with bronze cannon, and fine grain powder - copper and cotton, and there's plenty of those about, can do the same to you. I prefer to work in a bit closer like a toreador and a bull, but if you go for the three-point line, heave ho. (I don't like the 3-point shot in basketball, either.)
Smile
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
headrock
Rigger
Posts: 1512


354 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 1:51 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Well, I'm just speculating on the tactics you've shown, and arguing whether or not Big Ships should involve themselves in that, or whether they're better off using what I consider to be their natural and most comfortable use.

This... is a forum, innit? *Looks around*

*Walks off confused, mumbling something irrational*
_________________
Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
headrock
Rigger
Posts: 1512


354 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 1:54 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Airsaw wrote:
A frigate with bronze cannon, and fine grain powder - copper and cotton, and there's plenty of those about, can do the same to you.


It's all in the first shot mate. If you learn how to aim all those guns on a moving target, there's no need for a second one. And if you there is, well, usually cotton sails aren't that much help when they've got holes in them. And remember, a frigate is a MASSIVE target. If your enemy doesn't duck, or CAN'T duck (see above detailed maneuver), he's going to get a LOT of those in his sails.

All about the first shot.

*Quiver*
_________________
Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
headrock
Rigger
Posts: 1512


354 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 5:24 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I just love that screencatching program, although it sadly produces a lot of "in between renderings" shots...

Anyhow, back to pushing my point Wink

Like I said, it's all in the first shot, really. The rest of the big ship tactics are for when the first shot is either impossible or failed. With SOLs, an unerring first shot is usually enough to subdue, or at least cripple the enemy considerably.

Here's my version of a space-age, cutting-edge multi-media presentation.

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v726/Headrock/SOLvsFlagGal-01.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v726/Headrock/SOLvsFlagGal-02.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v726/Headrock/SOLvsFlagGal-03.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v726/Headrock/SOLvsFlagGal-04.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v726/Headrock/SOLvsFlagGal-05.jpg

Ok, it's just a bunch of processed screenshots and you need to click each one individually. So sue me.
_________________
Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"

Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Mon Feb 27, 2006 5:36 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Heh. "The Reefer" reefs. Very Happy Good shots all the same, pardon the pun.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> General Hints and strategies All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group