
Massive Invasion--only with me there to catch it??
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Hawkins

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 28 

 
1650 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Oct 16, 2006 3:50 am Post subject: Massive Invasion--only with me there to catch it?? |
|
|
I've noticed that I see a decent number of invasion ships (and pirate ships, for that matter), and most of the time if I let them by they will succeed in plundering or capturing their target city. Despite this, I don't think I've ever noticed a city changing nationalities without me either in the area when it happened, or at least noticing the invasion force passing by me. Likewise, cities I am nowhere near seem to do pretty well economically, especially if they are near other cities of the same nation to trade with. But as soon as I show up, I better be ready to defend it from a barrage of indians, pirates, and enemy raiders, or they will be plundered into oblivion!
I noticed this casually and didn't give it much thought, until this recent experience:
After finishing with the dreaded Gulf of Mexico area (I sailed back and forth quickly between the area and my wife in Port Royale in a fleet of four war canoes all upgraded with cotton sails, grabbing the quick 300,000 gold so I wouldn't have to divide the plunder again), I captured Vera Cruz, Villa Hermosa, and Campeche all for the English so I wouldn't have to go back to the area chasing Raymondo.
After roughly a decade of blissfully ignoring the area, I decided to make a trip to Campeche to capture a pair of criminals. I was surprised to notice that not only were the three cities still English (Spain apparently made no attempt to capture them back), but they were all also Prospering despite the fact that I left them poor and the area is full of pirate bases and indian villages. They still had garrisons under 200 men, so probably any attack would have easily succeeded.
After taking care of my business in Campeche, I sailed north and then east along the coast (Yucatan Peninsula?) and spotted an Invasion Force going for one of my captured cities. As I moved in to capture it, I noticed _another_ invasion force go by the northern edge of my screen, swooping down from Havana. Fortunately I was able to capture them both without chasing too far--my fleet was built for speed and agility (one war canoe (flagship) and four royal sloops, all fully upgraded). Within seconds after I conquered both invasion forces and going back to sailing along the coast, I spotted another one.
And another one.
And another one.
Six invasion forces, all one after the other, all right off the northern coast between Campeche and Cuba, each one spotted within 5-10 seconds after conquering the last. All of them headed for my Gulf of Mexico cities.
I altered my course to sail toward the northern coast of Cuba, instead of my original destination of Port Royale, to punish Havana--at least two of the invasion forces were from Havana, which had apparently gotten too wealthy while being in another area of the map I'd been neglecting.
And on my way to Havana, I spotted and captured yet another Invasion force from Havana headed for the Gulf of Mexico. That brought the total Invasion Forces to 7, all spotted within a couple minutes of real time. Of those 7, 3 were headed for Campeche, two to Villa Hermosa, and 2 to Vera Cruz. All of them were Spanish. The three target cities all had less than 200 men defending them, so I'm guessing any of the invasion forces would have succeeded--and if I sailed by and let all of them through, then ALL three Gulf of Mexico cities would have been recaptured for the Spanish.
Despite how intensely Spain tried to recapture those cities while I was in the area, now, after a few more years of completely ignoring the area, all three cities are still Prosperously English (and yes, Spain and England have been at war the whole time).
Has anyone else noticed things like this? I wonder if the game only spawns certain things, like pirate raiders and invasion forces, if you're near either the source or target area? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Oct 16, 2006 6:12 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I have noticed a similar phenomenon with regard to international relations. It seems that sometimes a switch gets flipped, and suddenly all the governors of one nation are sending ultimatums or treaty proposals to another nation. Eventually, one of them will get through if you don't spend all your time stopping them. I think there might be something similar with a nation's decision to invade an enemy.
But I don't think it is directly related to your presence in the area. Your activities in the area might influence the wealth and military capability of cities, but not your mere presence.
I have seen instances where I entered a region after a long absence to find that several cities had switched nationality. Successful invasions can certainly take place in your absence. In my first game, the French, English, and Dutch between them captured every city in the eastern half of the Spanish Main - and I was responsible for only one of the captured cities! Most of the successful invasions took place while I was elsewhere.
You only get the notifications of success/failure of raids and invasions at the bottom of your screen if you encountered the raiders or invasion force at some point. Therefore it is easy to overlook such activity outside the region you are operating in. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Cussler

Cutthroat 
Posts: 371 


2686 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Oct 17, 2006 4:55 am Post subject: Re: Massive Invasion--only with me there to catch it?? |
|
|
| Hawkins wrote: | | Has anyone else noticed things like this? I wonder if the game only spawns certain things, like pirate raiders and invasion forces, if you're near either the source or target area? |
I remember a conversation we had about this awhile back.
http://www.hookedonpirates.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=2976&start=0&postdays=0&postorder=asc&highlight=
It was decided that Caribbean changing events only occur if you encounter the ship with a specific mission. In other words, an invasion force ship leaves Havana for Campeche. If you do not see that ship at any point on its journey, the mission is nullified. It's almost as if you have to be aware of the existence of the mission in order for it to be fufilled.
(EDIT: you don't really have to "see" it, but just being nearby is enough.)
I'll give you an example I used in the last discussion:
I got a tip from the barmaid in Curacao that the Treasure Fleet was heading for Santa Marta (was a French port, but the Spanish reclaimed it recently). So I sailed west because I thought it had passed me already. It didn't, but I caught site of a French Frigate carrying Invasion Forces headed for Santa Marta. I watched them all the way in, and they captured the town.
I reloaded and headed east. After more than enough time, I looked at my map and noticed that Santa Marta was still Spanish. I even sailed back west to see if perhaps the Frigate hadn't arrived yet, but it had. The Invasion Force had launched prior to my save point, so they were still in route in both scenarios, but only when I had been in the vacinity did they succeed.
I reloaded a second time, and sailed west once again, caught sight of the Invasion Force, watched it sail into Santa Marta, and they were victorious again. Not only that, but I saw that there was actually another Invasion Force Frigates sent to capture Santa Marta. The place was weak. The French would have reclaimed it every time, but they didn't unless I was there.
There is much more to discussion in that old thread. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Oct 17, 2006 7:28 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Very interesting. But I'm still skeptical.
However, let's say this theory is correct - that significant events are enabled by your sighting the vessel that triggers them. Does this mean that when you obtain the Quality Spyglass or the Fine Telescope, which allow you to see farther at sea, that such events become more prevalent? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Hawkins

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 28 

 
1650 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Oct 18, 2006 4:16 am Post subject: |
|
|
Thanks for the example and link to the old thread, Cussler. What you said is consistent with what I've experienced. I was looking at it from the wrong angle--thinking perhaps the ships only spawned if I was in the area. But it makes more sense that they spawn anyway and only apply their effect if you see them. That fits, since I've seen towns I was not near captured--but I still saw the invasion ships passing by, or leaving their originating ports.
To emphasize my own example for anyone who is still skeptical, looking back at my Captain's log I see that:
In Feb. 1669 I finished capturing the three Gulf of Mexico cities.
In June 1669, shortly before I left the area, I captured a Spanish invasion force.
I did not return to the area until nearly 10 years later. On my way out, in the first couple months of 1679, I captured 7 Spanish invasion forces heading for the area, as detailed in my original post.
In my game, it is now March 1686. Campeche, Villa Hermosa, Vera Cruz, have remained English since I first captured them (yes, I do look at the map frequently and, out of my interest in the subject at hand, I've been paying close attention to the status of the three Gulf of Mexico cities). For a very, very long time they have all three been Prosperous with garrisons between 120 and 180, though Villa Hermosa did recently drop to Modest with a garrison of 100.
Now, that is 17 years so far of those cities belonging to England, during which I've been around them for roughly 10 months. (I have not divided the plunder in that time, BTW.) They have, that entire time, had garrisons small enough to be easily captured by an invasion force. I saw and captured 8 invasion forces in the 10 months or so I was near them. Statistically speaking, it seems very, very improbable that Spain would send _8_ invasion forces in the 10 months or so I was around and _none_ in the slightly over 16 years of time that I haven't been around. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Hawkins

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 28 

 
1650 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Oct 18, 2006 4:42 am Post subject: |
|
|
Looking at my map from my current game , there are 7 cities that have been captured for other nations (8 if you count Santa Marta, which I promptly recaptured for Spain (so it could keep giving me fat trade galleons) after witnessing the Dutch snatch it). I should note that I check the map fairly frequently, and cities that belong to a nation other than their original nation tend to catch my attention.
Of those 7, 4 were captured by me for the English (the three Gulf of Mexico cities, plus Cumana). I try not to get excessive with "political restructuring".
The remaining 3 are Nombre de Dios, captured by the French--I witnessed the invasion force swooping down from one of the French cities in Haiti; Santa Catalina, captured by the Dutch--I passed the invasion force coming from Curacao as I sailed east along the Spanish Main; and Leogane, which the English captured early in the game (saw the invasion force coming from Port Royale), and then, just recently, the Dutch captured (I was just south of Curacao and watched the invasion force leave from there).
Interestingly, Spain has not captured any cities, though I've seen numerous Spanish invasion forces. Perhaps it's not a coincidence that I ruthlessly pounce on any Spanish invasion force I spot, regardless of how I feel about the nation it's targetting. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Hawkins

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 28 

 
1650 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Oct 18, 2006 4:51 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Roland wrote: | | Does this mean that when you obtain the Quality Spyglass or the Fine Telescope, which allow you to see farther at sea, that such events become more prevalent? |
That's a good question. I suppose it depends on whether the game checks to see if the ship passes within a certain, set distance of your ship, or if it checks to see if you are capable of seeing the ship at any point.
I can say the ship certainly doesn't have to be visible on your screen. For example, recently I left a port and as I was sailing away from it I saw a message saying it was plundered by pirates even though I just left it and saw no sign of a pirate ship. To see what happened, I loaded my save, switched my view from top-down to the looking straight ahead view, and spun my ship around to scan the area. Sure enough, off to the west there was a pirate ship--easily within sight with the forward view, but off the screen with a top-down view. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Oct 18, 2006 5:46 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Hawkins wrote: | | Statistically speaking, it seems very, very improbable that Spain would send _8_ invasion forces in the 10 months or so I was around and _none_ in the slightly over 16 years of time that I haven't been around. |
Not necessarily. These things run in streaks, like a switch being turned on and then off. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Hawkins

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 28 

 
1650 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Oct 18, 2006 1:25 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Roland wrote: | | Hawkins wrote: | | Statistically speaking, it seems very, very improbable that Spain would send _8_ invasion forces in the 10 months or so I was around and _none_ in the slightly over 16 years of time that I haven't been around. |
Not necessarily. These things run in streaks, like a switch being turned on and then off. |
Yes, it is still improbable, streak or not. Assuming the game decides to send out one massive streak of invasion ships to that area in 17 years, and I'm there for 10 months of that time, there is a less than 1 out of 17 (5.88%) chance that the streak would happen during the time I was there.
Add on the other data that I and others have observed, and the possibility of it simply being a coincidence, and not a symptom of the game mechanics, is pretty miniscule. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Oct 18, 2006 8:02 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Hawkins wrote: | | Yes, it is still improbable, streak or not. Assuming the game decides to send out one massive streak of invasion ships to that area in 17 years, and I'm there for 10 months of that time, there is a less than 1 out of 17 (5.88%) chance that the streak would happen during the time I was there. |
Your probability calculation implicitly assumes that the AI's choice to invade is distributed uniformly and independently. But we know this is not the case. Most obviously, it depends on the state of relations between the two countries. It might also depend on the cities' wealth and populations, either relative or absolute. Unless all of these criteria are met simultaneously, the probability of an invasion is zero. There might be additional criteria as well.
| Hawkins wrote: | | Add on the other data that I and others have observed, and the possibility of it simply being a coincidence, and not a symptom of the game mechanics, is pretty miniscule. |
Your observations are interesting enough to justify further testing of this hypothesis. But they don't prove much without a control to compare them to.
Moreover, this theory ignores the contrary data that have been submitted, both in this thread (by me) and in the old thread (by Kristian95).
Another example: In the first few years of my most recent game, I never ventured northwest of Hispaniola, and I spent most of my time in the Lesser Antilles. On my first trip to the Havana/Florida/Bahamas region, I passed by Tortuga, intending to stop at Florida Keys for a French promotion. Upon arrival, my first port call anywhere in the region, I found that Florida Keys was Spanish! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Hawkins

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 28 

 
1650 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 2:17 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Roland wrote: |
Your probability calculation implicitly assumes that the AI's choice to invade is distributed uniformly and independently. But we know this is not the case. Most obviously, it depends on the state of relations between the two countries. It might also depend on the cities' wealth and populations, either relative or absolute. Unless all of these criteria are met simultaneously, the probability of an invasion is zero. There might be additional criteria as well.
|
That's an excellent point. However, the variables you mentioned have been, over the course of my current game, rather stable. Spain and England have been at war for the vast majority of the game--probably over 90% of the time. The three Gulf of Mexico cities, since growing to prosperous after their initial capture, have stayed steadily at prosperous, with garrisons between 120-180, except for Villa Hermosa recently dropping to Modest with a garrison of 100. Though I did punish Havana and Cartagena after encountering the string of invasion forces, they were wealthy the entire time before that, and I have since rebuilt Cartagena's economy.
On top of all that, it's worth noting I've never seen any of those three Gulf of Mexico cities' economies drop to Poor (like I said, I check the map often) even though they are surrounded by pirate bases and have never had a large enough garrison to fend off an attack.
So, you're right that other variables prevent my given % chance of coincidence from being perfectly precise. But I think it's still reasonable to consider the probability of that many invasion forces being sent and crossing my path, and none being sent while I was away, to be "low".
And I didn't even attempt to come up with a probability for the other data about my game I mentioned--namely the fact that, 26+ years into my current pirating career, no cities have changed hands without me witnessing the invasion force.
| Quote: | | Your observations are interesting enough to justify further testing of this hypothesis. But they don't prove much without a control to compare them to. |
Of course. I'm not putting anything in terms of "this is definitely what's happening", but rather suggesting what seems most likely based on what I've observed.
| Quote: |
Moreover, this theory ignores the contrary data that have been submitted, both in this thread (by me) and in the old thread (by Kristian95).
Another example: In the first few years of my most recent game, I never ventured northwest of Hispaniola, and I spent most of my time in the Lesser Antilles. On my first trip to the Havana/Florida/Bahamas region, I passed by Tortuga, intending to stop at Florida Keys for a French promotion. Upon arrival, my first port call anywhere in the region, I found that Florida Keys was Spanish! |
That data, and some of my own data (Leogane and Nombre de Dios being captured while I wasn't near them) certainly does contradict the idea I had when I started this thread. That idea was that invasion forces and perhaps some other things might only happen, or just happen more often, when you are around to witness them.
But as I indicated in response to Cussler, I've dropped that hypothesis in favor of his idea that the ships spawn whether you're there or not, but if they don't pass within a certain distance of your ship between their origin and destination, then their effects don't happen.
With that hypothesis, the capture of a city that is far away from you is NOT a counterexample. Some invasion forces sail to targets that are very far from their originating ports. For example I wasn't near Leogane when the Dutch recently captured it in my game, but I witnessed the invasion force spawn from Curacao.
What WOULD be a counterexample is if we saw cities being captured without ever having the corresponding invasion forces within our viewing range.
Now, I'm sure you have plenty of those counterexamples too, but there's a problem! You cannot have a false positive (i.e. if you see an invasion force, there's definitely one there, of course), but you CAN have a false negative (i.e. an invasion force passes within viewing range, but you don't notice it either because you're not checking every ship you see or it even doesn't show up your screen, due to the view you're using). Refer to my example above about completely missing a pirate raider even though it was within viewing range.
I think a big reason that, in my game, no cities have changed hands without me having seen the invasion forces (and Spain having not captured ANYTHING, because I never let their invasion forces go), is because I always keep the view zoomed out as far as I can, and I mouse-over every ship I see to check what it's up to (_especially_ if it's a frigate or a galleon like the invasion forces use). I also proactively switch views a lot, e.g. as I approach a port I'll switch to the forward view until I'm close enough for the port to show up on the top-down view. If you don't do that, you can easily miss a lot of ships that were technically, for a short time, in your viewing range.
I'd hypothesize that players that keep the default zoom level, don't switch views much, and/or don't mouse-over every ship they see, probably have cities changing hands more frequently in their games due to invasion forces passing them by off-screen. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 4:24 am Post subject: |
|
|
As I understand it, if a ship that passes within your viewing range subsequently does something significant - e.g., deliver (or fail to deliver) a governor, immigrants, troops, or a treaty; sack a city; or capture a city - an announcement will appear on your screen. So even if you do not notice such a ship, you should still receive notification of its activities. Under your hypothesis, therefore, if you pay attention to these messages, you should never be surprised by a city's changing hands.
This suggests the question: Is it possible for a vessel to pass close enough for you to enable it to capture a city, but not close enough to result in your being notified of the capture after it happens? If so, then your hypothesis could be correct, but it would be very difficult to test.
One way this might happen: If the range for enabling a vessel to capture a city is fixed at your maximum visual range with the Fine Telescope, then early in the game before you have acquired the Telescope you could enable a vessel to capture a city even though the vessel is outside your current, more limited visual range.
But this is just wild theorizing to rationalize how your theory might square with our data so far. I don't think I've generated a testable hypothesis. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Hawkins

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 28 

 
1650 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 12:29 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | This suggests the question: Is it possible for a vessel to pass close enough for you to enable it to capture a city, but not close enough to result in your being notified of the capture after it happens? If so, then your hypothesis could be correct, but it would be very difficult to test. |
The answer to your question is certainly yes. I've seen it happen numerous times. In the examples I mentioned above, of seeing invasion forces sailing toward far away cities, I did not get the message saying the invasion happened. I simply saw that the town had changed hands when I checked the map after enough time had passed for the invasion force to reach its target.
It seems there are two requirements for getting the message about an event:
1. "Seeing" the ship (where seeing is defined as the ship being within viewing range, not necessarily on your screen).
2. Being within a certain range of the city when the event happens. (What exactly that range is, I'm not even going to try guessing! It does seem to be a bit larger than viewing range, but perhaps not by much.)
I had two more examples while playing last night. I watched two English invasion forces leave Port Royale--one for Tortuga and the next one for Santo Domingo. A couple months of game time later I checked my map, and saw Tortuga was English; and then a little later I checked and saw Santo Domingo was now English too. I did not get the notices of England conquering those cities because I was not near them when it happened.
| Quote: |
One way this might happen: If the range for enabling a vessel to capture a city is fixed at your maximum visual range with the Fine Telescope, then early in the game before you have acquired the Telescope you could enable a vessel to capture a city even though the vessel is outside your current, more limited visual range.
|
Well, the overall hypothesis is at least somewhat testable in, IMO, at least two ways:
1. A decreasing probability of coincidence, such as a situation like mine where I've seen the invasion force for every city that has been captured in my current game. This of course requires being very vigilant so as not to miss invasion forces that briefly pass through the edge of your viewing range.
2. A situation like Cussler's, where one has a saved game that is both after an invasion force has been spawned, but before the player has spotted it.
If/when I get lucky to experience situation #2, you can bet I will test it thoroughly and post the result here.
But as for your question of the exact viewing range? I'm having trouble imagining how I could even begin to test that. Is the range for "activating" a ship fixed at a specific range, or is it always your current actual viewing range, taking your items or lack thereof into account? Or, hell, is the "activating radius" actually a little larger or smaller than your viewing range? I don't know, and I'm purposely NOT stressing myself too much with trying to figure that detail out. The only thing I can say in that regard is that I'm sure it's the actual range that matters, and not whether you saw the ship on your screen (refer, again, to my example above about the pirate raid from the ship I missed--in my range, but I only would have seen it if I used a forward view and faced west). Which means that it's easy to "activate" these ships without actually seeing them. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Cussler

Cutthroat 
Posts: 371 


2686 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Oct 19, 2006 11:01 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Roland wrote: | As I understand it, if a ship that passes within your viewing range subsequently does something significant - e.g., deliver (or fail to deliver) a governor, immigrants, troops, or a treaty; sack a city; or capture a city - an announcement will appear on your screen. So even if you do not notice such a ship, you should still receive notification of its activities. Under your hypothesis, therefore, if you pay attention to these messages, you should never be surprised by a city's changing hands.
This suggests the question: Is it possible for a vessel to pass close enough for you to enable it to capture a city, but not close enough to result in your being notified of the capture after it happens? If so, then your hypothesis could be correct, but it would be very difficult to test.
|
Hmmm...I think Roland, you are misinterpreting what I and perhaps Hawkins were getting at.
You don't have to be near the target, you just have to see the ship anywhere.
Obviously if you are near Port Royale, let's say, and you see a French Invasion Force heading toward Port Royale. If you move far enough away that you no longer see Port Royale or the ship on your screen, but you are still in the region, then yes you'll see the pop-up announcement and accompanying sword slashing sound to notify whether or not the invasion was successful.
However, you can see that same invasion force ship pass you by while you're near Martinique. Even if you go nowhere near Port Royale later on, that mission ship is still active and continues on to its destination and can still capture the town even though you're on the other side of the Caribbean.
It's just that if you don't see (or just be in the vacinity of) that Invasion Force ship near Martinique heading toward Port Royale, then it's like that ship was never spawned.
Or, to put it another way, let's say you spend all your time in the Bay of Campeche. While you are there, an Invasion Force might spawn from San Juan and try to take over St. Martin. But there's no threat of St. Martin being captured because you never encountered the mission ship at any point along its journey.
Does that clarify things more, or was that not even what you were getting at? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Oct 20, 2006 12:37 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Cussler wrote: | Hmmm...I think Roland, you are misinterpreting what I and perhaps Hawkins were getting at.
You don't have to be near the target, you just have to see the ship anywhere. |
No, I understood what you and Hawkins were saying. When did I suggest you had to be near the target? |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|