
I have a mod request (GOLD INVOLVED!)
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
NASSAU

Seaman 
Posts: 215 


4819 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 7:43 am Post subject: |
|
|
Well this thread or ,my involvement in it has ,I can see gone on long enough.There really is no point as I believe I made my thoughts on Patton clear.
Though I will say in parting ,that as a model of a 'Democratic pirate leader' it is obvious Patton would be a poor choice,there was no second guessing in his command ,he did not lead,he ruled.
As to the rest I disagree,that twisting the truth can be called good storytelling.
What possible good can come from the scene in Saving Private Ryan,when the 'cowardly GI fails to help his struggling comrade
in the upstairs knife fight with the veteran trooper,and is actually ignored by the victor (called mercy) only to shoot down the German without a gun in his hands after he had surrendered to fellow soldiers,because he, "gets his courage"
Hollywood leads us by the nose ,we are supposed to believe he is a hero for this ,but aside from the 'stellar storytelling' he is still a coward.
Likewise do not forget Siegfried,or rather the norse version,
steeped in Wagnerian opera ,that Hitler used to push a nation into war.
Too bad the real Siegfried as described in the General Tacituis's
journals name meant "Victory through Peace"
Too that end I leave you with a final though ,and I will respond no more to this thread,
"Those of us who do not learn the lessons of history shall one day be forced to relive them"....General Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna _________________ Hooked up and hard over! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 8:38 am Post subject: |
|
|
| NASSAU wrote: | | Too bad the real Siegfried as described in the General Tacituis's journals name meant "Victory through Peace" |
Umm . . . I think you have that backwards. It's more like "peace through victory." |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
NASSAU

Seaman 
Posts: 215 


4819 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 9:28 am Post subject: |
|
|
Sieg= Victory (Fried = through peace)
Tactitius clearly states this in his journal.
In other words achieving victory through peaceful means as opposed to war like means.or SiegKrieg _________________ Hooked up and hard over! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2007 11:26 pm Post subject: |
|
|
It's been a long time since I studied German, but I'm pretty sure that in this construction Fried is the noun and Sieg functions as an adjective. If Tacitus says otherwise, then his linguistic scholarship is open to question.
A quick search on the phrase "meaning of name Siegfried" turned up a number of pages like this, which defines it as "peace of victory."
My conclusion: Siegfried does not mean "victory through peaceful means"; it means "peace that follows from victory." |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
NASSAU

Seaman 
Posts: 215 


4819 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Aug 23, 2007 2:21 am Post subject: |
|
|
Gosh this is fun,lets boil down two pages of arguments into an arbitrary attack on one minuscule point with limited relevance ,to the main discussion.
Well okay,
But if you are arguing that a mans name as spoken in an ancient germanic tongue,translated and written down in Latin,then translated and passed on to German,several hundred years ,after the invention of that language and then expressed in the Queens english, a couple centuries later ,some how does not pass muster in modern English grammer,
then my question to you is what is your point??!!
Tacitus ,describes Siegfried ,and the name given to him as best as he could describe it in his language.
I'm fairly certain you are not arrogant enough to believe that an ancient tribe is somehow inferior simply because we have failed to find a way to properly interpret their words in a way that suits us??!!
Or do I sense something else?,really the point of my argument was that storytelling versus the truth ,rarely gets us anywhere.
Even , without a name argument ,Siegfried was ,NOT the tall blonde,dragonslaying ,inbred,blueprint for the master race ,that Hitler drew upon for his twisted cleansing programs.
And that is enough for my case ,that building up characters to a larger than life status ,does not benefit man in the long run.
But if you just like arguing for the fun of it ,okay I'm always up for debate. _________________ Hooked up and hard over! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
RobbyL9

Seaman 
Posts: 174 

 
2916 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Thu Aug 23, 2007 3:18 am Post subject: |
|
|
Christ in heaven, NASSAU, you are just too damned aggressive! And when did I ever say that Patton was the model Democratic Captain?! Blackbeard treated his men like shit and shot one every once in a while to reaffirm his command, yet as a figurehead for piracy he was one of the most feared and only after he was ganged up on and slashed into pieces did his men stop obeying him. "Gunsmith" Patton is a fictional character so stop ranting. Anyway, I should know better than to argue with someone who may have gone to West Point for all I know, about military history.
Just a parting note, though, I happen to be partial to Teddy Roosevelt, William Barret Travis and William Tecumseh Sherman as well. I hope you don't have any beef with them, because they may be my next creations. _________________ No poor dumb pirate dog ever won a swashbuckle by dying for his crew.
Last edited by RobbyL9 on Thu Aug 23, 2007 3:31 am; edited 1 time in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Dave the Knave

Rigger 
Posts: 1188 

 
22948 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Aug 23, 2007 3:26 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Quote: | | I disagree,that twisting the truth can be called good storytelling. |
Aye; as long as we pay attention to the disclaimer at the end of certain films of historical fiction, we can largely ignore or discount what has been presented.
| Dave the Brave, in an attempt to clarify and not confuse, wrote: | | The, politely putting it, dramatization of certain events in the film, should be ignored or accepted as good storytelling... |
Hence the choice of ignoring, or discounting, of the events portrayed.
I didn't really get the message of Saving Private Ryan, to be honest.
It seems that James Francis Ryan is held responsible for the deaths of the guys that followed General Marshall's orders to save him! Doesn't that make General Marshall responsible?
Captain Miller spares Steamboat Willie, who ends up killing him later; how is Ryan responsible for that?
I don't know. I'm just a simple, old soldier, who gets irritated when characters are killed off to finish a film.
"Whom the moviemakers would kill off, they first make stupid."
One last thought...
| Quote: | | ..."Gunsmith" Patton is a fictional character... |
Exactly. He's got the same instincts that his real-life namesake is popularly said to have, but, as Robby says, Gunsmith is just a character. A right clever idea, if I do say so meself.
 _________________ Rule, Britannia! Britannia, rule the waves;
Britons never shall be slaves. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Aug 23, 2007 6:29 am Post subject: |
|
|
| NASSAU wrote: | | Gosh this is fun,lets boil down two pages of arguments into an arbitrary attack on one minuscule point with limited relevance ,to the main discussion. |
What attack? I simply corrected what I believed to be a minor factual error. I'm compulsive that way. Unless you can provide a reference for your Tacitus citation, my work here is done. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
NASSAU

Seaman 
Posts: 215 


4819 Gold -

|
Posted: Thu Aug 23, 2007 7:02 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Too Agressive ?.......like.....Patton?
I was under the impresssion this was a trait you admired.
Roland,I think publishing the works of Tacituis is a bit ambitious ,perhaps you won't mind doing your own homework on the subject.
As for me I've already researched my own name(Sieg). _________________ Hooked up and hard over! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
RobbyL9

Seaman 
Posts: 174 

 
2916 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 12:18 am Post subject: |
|
|
Well, loki59 has won the contest and gotten the shiny stack of doubloons. If there is anyone else who still wishes to try their hand and send in a picture, feel free but understand that the gold's been gone.
Thank you!  _________________ No poor dumb pirate dog ever won a swashbuckle by dying for his crew. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 4:38 am Post subject: |
|
|
| NASSAU wrote: | | Roland,I think publishing the works of Tacituis is a bit ambitious ,perhaps you won't mind doing your own homework on the subject. |
I'm pretty sure all the works of Tacitus have already been published and translated. Germania is even available in multiple places on-line, but my searches turned up no references in it to Siegfried.
When I Googled Tacitus and Siegfried, the only possibly relevant things that popped up were various references to the theory that the German general Arminius, who defeated three Roman legions in an ambush at Teutoburg Forest in AD 9, was the historical model of the character of Siegfried in the Nibelungenlied.
My "homework" leads me to hypothesize that Tacitus never actually referred to Siegfried - at least not by that name. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
NASSAU

Seaman 
Posts: 215 


4819 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 5:01 am Post subject: |
|
|
Well after a quick juant over to google I can see why you have been led to think these things ,though at first I admit I could not figure out what you were on about.
It appears the internet is rife with myth and the studies of these myths.Though eeven Wiki in one entry calls Arminus\Siegfried,
and in another entry it says that too is dissproved.
I did not learn my history this way.I was in fact a History major
while attending the US Merchant Marine academy,and did my research the old fashioned way.
While I can see your point ,the fact is Tacitus does in fact describe the Germanic Race as he talks about Siegfried near the river in Xanten.
I notice most sites drop this and only mention his description as that of Germans.
Remember these are not bonified publishers but people who disseminate information for there own viewpoint and therefore are prone to slant information to suit their own viewpoint.
As does Wagner in his translated description,of Siegfried.
Hermann the supposed real name of Arminus is not described as looking like either .That is to say ,Siegfried nor Sigurd.Arminus was in fact hardly described at all .This is well recorded in several books on the lost Legions of Rome ,destroyed in the battle of the Teutoburger Wald.
And while I notice that several sites call him a Cherusci ,in an attempt to link him to Siegfried ,Arminus was then described by his contemporaries as a Teutone.
He came on the scene reeked havoc on the Romans ,and along with the other Tuetones dissapeared forever.
Siegfried on the other hand was in fact a Cherusci ,not Teutone.Important when you try to link these together because Cheruscans ,lived near the River,(Where Tacitus was) and The Herman's Denkmal is far inland in ,deep dark forests.
What does all this mean ,does it mean the old scholars are wrong and only new web savvy people should be trusted as an information source? Or does it mean we don't yet have all the facts and websites that promote their brand of knowledge as absolute do all of us a disservice?
I do know this is about one of the most pointless,arguments I've ever had.I stated my beliefs about Patton,Siegfried was a passing reference on a minor point .
The fact that you missed the forest for the trees ,leaves me with the suspicion ,that you dearly wanted to find fault with my opinions (expressed as such) about the main subject .
If that is the case then ,say so ,endlessly arguing a mute point to somehow look like you won a greater argument is ludicrous ,and hopefully beneath you. _________________ Hooked up and hard over!
Last edited by NASSAU on Fri Aug 24, 2007 5:56 am; edited 1 time in total |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Tom Pullings

Gunner 
Posts: 530 

 
11279 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 5:54 am Post subject: |
|
|
Even though it's way off the original topic, it's been an interesting thread.
Nassau said:
| Quote: | What possible good can come from the scene in Saving Private Ryan,when the 'cowardly GI fails to help his struggling comrade
in the upstairs knife fight with the veteran trooper,and is actually ignored by the victor (called mercy) only to shoot down the German without a gun in his hands after he had surrendered to fellow soldiers,because he, "gets his courage"
Hollywood leads us by the nose ,we are supposed to believe he is a hero for this ,but aside from the 'stellar storytelling' he is still a coward.
|
Though I share the sentiment that Hollywood often serves us crap, and I found this an especially disturbing part of the movie, I came to the conclusion that it was meant to be disturbing, and to be partly allegorical (America and much of the world initially standing by while the helpless perished). I did not think the final shooting was intended to be particularly heroic or courageous, but to emphasize the cost of not acting sooner. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
NASSAU

Seaman 
Posts: 215 


4819 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 6:03 am Post subject: |
|
|
| Tom Pullings wrote: | Even though it's way off the original topic, it's been an interesting thread.
Nassau said:
| Quote: | What possible good can come from the scene in Saving Private Ryan,when the 'cowardly GI fails to help his struggling comrade
in the upstairs knife fight with the veteran trooper,and is actually ignored by the victor (called mercy) only to shoot down the German without a gun in his hands after he had surrendered to fellow soldiers,because he, "gets his courage"
Hollywood leads us by the nose ,we are supposed to believe he is a hero for this ,but aside from the 'stellar storytelling' he is still a coward.
|
Though I share the sentiment that Hollywood often serves us crap, and I found this an especially disturbing part of the movie, I came to the conclusion that it was meant to be disturbing, and to be partly allegorical (America and much of the world initially standing by while the helpless perished). I did not think the final shooting was intended to be particularly heroic or courageous, but to emphasize the cost of not acting sooner. |
A highly philosophical take on that scene,I doubt hollywood is as conscientious as you,but it is nonetheless a fascinating look at how we humans perceive things.But then you always come off as a person of deep thought,and thinking for ourselves instead of letting others teach us how we should feel pretty much was the topic ,or at least the point. _________________ Hooked up and hard over! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Roland

Helmsman 
Posts: 4190 

 
23929 Gold -

|
Posted: Fri Aug 24, 2007 8:21 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| NASSAU wrote: | | I did not learn my history this way.I was in fact a History major while attending the US Merchant Marine academy,and did my research the old fashioned way. |
If you want to play the scholar card, you need to document your sources.
| NASSAU wrote: | | Remember these are not bonified publishers but people who disseminate information for there own viewpoint and therefore are prone to slant information to suit their own viewpoint. |
In addition to my Google searches, I searched public-domain unabridged translations of Tacitus's Germania.
| NASSAU wrote: | And while I notice that several sites call him a Cherusci ,in an attempt to link him to Siegfried ,Arminus was then described by his contemporaries as a Teutone.
He came on the scene reeked havoc on the Romans ,and along with the other Tuetones dissapeared forever.
Siegfried on the other hand was in fact a Cherusci ,not Teutone.Important when you try to link these together because Cheruscans ,lived near the River,(Where Tacitus was) and The Herman's Denkmal is far inland in ,deep dark forests. |
I also found an unabridged public-domain translation of Tacitus's Annals. One can easily infer from Tacitus that Arminius was a leader of the Cherusci. I found this identification repeated on many other sites, including Wikipedia, and contradicted nowhere.
Meanwhile, I found no reference to Siegfried in either Germania or the Annals. Now I have to ask who this "Siegfried" is that you say Tacitus refers to. Is it the hero of the Nibelungenlied or another figure who just happens to have the same name? If the former, it's hard to believe Tacitus would have been aware of him (unless Siegfried was Arminius). It is generally agreed that, to the extent the events of the Nibelungenlied are based on history, they are from the 5th century, and they were not written in their current form until the 11th century.
| NASSAU wrote: | | The fact that you missed the forest for the trees ,leaves me with the suspicion ,that you dearly wanted to find fault with my opinions (expressed as such) about the main subject . |
This is an ad hominem attack and, as such, illegitimate. It is also incorrect. I don't care about the Nazi forest nearly as much as I care about the trees of Germanic mythology and ancient history, both of which are much more interesting subjects as far as I'm concerned. If the mythological figure of Siegfried actually appears in ancient sources, I want to know where! |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|