Shop  •   Avatar  •   FAQ  •   Search  •   Memberlist  •   Usergroups  •   Profile  •   Log in to check private messages  •   Log in  •  Register 

Rate the different minigames!
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirates! Chat
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
DJ1
Cutthroat
Posts: 250


11547 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri May 20, 2005 7:28 am    Post subject: Rate the different minigames! Reply with quote

We have had the game for a long time now so we should be able to give fair judgements now. How do you rate the different minigames?

Here is my verdict:


LANDBATTLES, 4+/5
You have to think here and this is the minigame that really is different each time. The only negative aspect is that defencive play is to rewarding. They should have added in the cannons.

SAILING 4+/5
Like the GFX and it is great to explore and watch the Pirates world. They could have added in more wildlife though.

FENCING, 4/5
So full of action and fun. However I found it extremely easy in lower difficulties but you never play those anyway. The advantage-meter really makes it all! Great work there Firaxis!

SNEAKING, 3+/5
Really like this too. Like the feeling to it. Sadly you never use it though cause it is to risky. They should have added in some missions were sneaking were inviolved. I use to plasy it offcareer though so get to play it. The Xbox version of this minigame seems really fantastic. I wish they would have done it in the PC version directly too. But the PC minigame is allready very good so dont wanna complain.

SEABATTLES, 3/5
They did it as good as you can do it but the only thing I mostly think of when I'm in a seabattle is: "I wanna fence"

TREASSURE HUNTING (ON LAND), 3-/5
Way to easy. You found one intresting task once in 20 maps. Why cant you dig as you did in the original. The GFX are really bad too. However. Treassurehunting is always something special and once you get that difficult map it is very very funny. But they could have done so much more out of this concept.

DANCING 1+/5
Sooo booring. I actually like the concept of having it in. But they have done the minigame so booring. No thinking needed what so ever. I cant stand this minigame any more. The only good you get out of it is that you can see the daughter from different angles. but how fun is that in the long run? I still think it was good that they had it in the game but you should have needed to dance far more rarely and you shouldnt get those item rewards etc for doing so. Now you are forced dance. Not because you are intrested in the daughter but because you have to to get items and mappieces. What happened with the romance? To dance with beautiful future possible wives are fun but to dance with those ugly ones! huu! Since when did I became a prostitute? Wink
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Airsaw
Rigger
Posts: 1806


3281 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri May 20, 2005 1:35 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Lessee...

Land Battles: These have gotten boring to me. I'm at the point where just to keep an edge on, I attack with 50% fewer men. Otherwise, it's a cakewalk, and rote.

Sailing: This is always a challenge. The wind rarely blows the way I want it to. Time is of the essence, as it is said, and each tack is significant. My palms still sweat with this one.

Fencing: With TheDon's counsel I've mastered taking-out opponents in 3 to 5 swipes with a sword. Is there NO ONE who can pose a challenge out there? Argh...my sister could beat Monty! This is routine, now.

Sneaking: I posted something on this somewhere else. I've got this down to a technique which works well enough, usually. When it doesn't, I reset on "arrival", and try again. I'm more interested in what I'm after, than in successfully "sneaking" about. Routine.

Sea battles: Here I still get a thrill, if you call a heart attack "thrilling". No matter what you do, there is always some skipper out there with a surprise up his sleeve. I can't throw caution to the wind with this, not even against a fluyt, or a barq. The edge remains.

Treasure hunting: This has become pretty easy. I now go for finding these with one map piece as a goal. Being familiar with the coastlines and coastal features comes with time. When you can easily identify a slip of coast, boom, you're there. Routine.

Dancing: I still remember going to sock hops in jr. high. There, I date myself (it's cheaper). For those youngsters who don't know what is a sock hop: Dances were held in the gym. You can't wear street shoes on the gym floor, so everybody took off their shoes and danced in their socks. Ergo: Sock hop. I get that same feeling I did as a gangly youth at a sock hop, fearful I'll fall on my keister and make a fool of myself in front of that one-in-a-million babe who's name I (today) can't recall. Nervous and anxious with every twist and turn. Childishly giddy when I "do it right." One slip, grip, and you go from a piece of a map to some thousand-dollar fugitive.

I've turned my game-within-a-game into catching Monty A.S.A.P. That gets more than a little exciting to try. My best with that is catching him at age 22. My average is age 26. I get him so early, I don't have rank enough to get a beautiful daughter to dance with me for hidden city maps. It's touch-and-go, though. The way I like it.
_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Mycroft Stanyer
Seaman
Posts: 145



2709 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri May 20, 2005 1:47 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Land Battles are great with the randomization, but it suffers two faults: it doesn't really scale up with the higher difficulties. Aside from the addition of Cavalry, playing a battle at Apprentice is not all that different than at the higher levels.

Secondly, you can play the game defensively. Which is odd, given that you are the attacker in the scenario. The game's AI is just way too simple— they'll move out to attack your forces and thus you gain the natural advantage of becoming the defender in the battle. Tack that onto your other natural advantages (high-damage melee units, long-ranged musket units) and it becomes possible (hell, it becomes likely) to take on a port's defenses with a 1:2 numerical disadvantage and still come away victorious.
_________________
Let's get one thing straight: Errol Flynn pretends to be me— not the other way 'round!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Willard
Powder Monkey
Posts: 18



12 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri May 20, 2005 6:15 pm    Post subject: Mini Rating Reply with quote

Land Battle 4/5. I agree that the AI is odd... but the sound of musket fire and watching the baddies drop makes up for that.

Sea Battle 4/5. Every now and then I get annoyed that my first shot always misses, or that I runthe baddies up on the shoals and it has no effect on them. But, sometimes I can almost smell that acrid mix of gunpowder and sea spray...

Dancing 3/5. Not missing a step until the very end of the dance and she blows me off instead of shivering me timbers. Governers' daughters are a spoiled lot.

Sneaking 1/5. That may be unfair since I've only done it once... and I only went a few steps before I turned around, left the city, then went back and attacked by land...

Treasure Hunting 4/5. Not as tedious as dancing. Good quick money.

Fencing 3/5. Formulaic and slow on easy levels, formulaic and fast on hard levels. Surprising graphics changes from the original that are very nice...

Family Quests 2/5. Even in the original Pirates! and Pirates! Gold, I never bothered to find the whole family. Never liked that crabby ol' uncle of mine anyway...

I wish characters were made with mini-game desires or aspirations (al la Sims 2)... an addition to skill set. Why be a jack of all trades but master of none? Or, even a master of all trades? Perhaps Willard the Bold prefers duelin' and wenchin', but Willard the Adventurous prefers treasure hunting and family reunions. But, that's for another thread.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri May 20, 2005 8:53 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I pretty much enjoy all of the mini-games, but I do want to offer some specific notes to a few of them:

SNEAKING (3/5): I really think this is fun by itself, however, as has been mentioned, it is SOOOO dangerous and for the most part, pointless, that I deduct because as fun as it is, you either won't do it, or don't need to.

SEA BATTLES (5/5): To counter the original thread starter who didn't like sea battles because you want to fence, this is why I rate sea battles so highly... they're fun, they can take awhile, there can be strategy involved with wind position, full or battle sails, type of shot, etc, etc, etc. Add in the fact that you can lose or take serious damage, it's one of the more fun and challenging aspects of the game... however... because of the following, some folks get their priorities wrong:

FENCING (0/5): Zero out of five you ask? Why so low? It's not because of fun factor I lower fencing... in and of itself, fencing is fun to do and doesn't take too long... it's also graphically pleasing (if you have a good video card and everything turned up). No, the reason why I give a zero rating is because the ease of fencing... from the lowest to hardest difficulty levels in the game, fencing is always simply too easy. Losing a fight with a Frigate? Why not board and easily win! Got a damaged, leaky Native Indian War Canoe with five men on board? Why not board that 300 manned Ship of the Line and take her over in three strokes of your sword!

I'm sorry, but the ease of fencing has ruined an otherwise excellent game. Can't hack naval battles? Close in and fence for your prize... there is no worry you'll lose! Don't want to risk damaging an enemy prize vessel with cannon-shot? Close in and fence your way to the Gold... after all, you can't lose, right?

The ease of fencing is what makes War Canoe jockeys out of us all... how many Ships of the Line were lost to Indian War Canoes in real life? That's what I thought... I'm sorry, but Fencing is sooooo damn easy, it is ruining the game. I deliberately avoid fencing if I can, simply because I know I'll never lose... in fact, that's accurate... I have NEVER lost a sword fight on any difficulty level (including Swashbuckler, though I don't like that setting for other reasons).

I remember in the original game, I feared fencing because it was difficult and dangerous... just as it should be... in SMP, it's simpler, safer, easier to board then it is to actually fight on the high seas. Turning us away from being Pirates, and more into becoming Fencing snobs.

For all these reasons and more... Fencing gets a big fat ZERO in my book!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
fossaman
Gunner
Posts: 717



3515 Gold -

PostPosted: Fri May 20, 2005 11:33 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I like them all, I suppose, but I do have a few favorites. Everything except those specifically mentioned gets a 4/5.

Dancing: 5/5
I really like this, especially since I'm musically inclined. Plus, it's often very rewarding, in the way of items, info, and maps.

Sea Battles: 5/5
I love the strategy involved in these. When to zig and when to zag, when to reef your sails, what kind of shot to use...

Land Battles: 5/5
Once again, I love the strategy. I almost never have more or even as many men as the enemy. But making buccaneers survive indian braves in a melee is just COOL!

Sneaking: 4.8/5
I am probably one of the only people who actually enjoys this, which I think is too bad. It requires a lot more finess than just bludgeoning the town into submission in battle. Plus, I like the sound effect when I thump the guards.

Family Quests: 1/5
I HATE RAYMONDO!!!
I don't like having to go haring all over the carribean to find this loser. Why does he always know about my family, anyway? Is he stalking us? He better keep away from my sister!

Montalban Quest: 5/5
This one I like. I only have to get him four times, and sometimes as few as two times. The end cut scene is great, and the reward rocks.
_________________

Like my fossa? He's a pirate! Razz
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message MSN Messenger
SubDivi
Powder Monkey
Posts: 30



842 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 12:55 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Yellowbeard wrote:
FENCING (0/5): Zero out of five you ask? Why so low? It's not because of fun factor I lower fencing... in and of itself, fencing is fun to do and doesn't take too long... it's also graphically pleasing (if you have a good video card and everything turned up). No, the reason why I give a zero rating is because the ease of fencing... from the lowest to hardest difficulty levels in the game, fencing is always simply too easy. Losing a fight with a Frigate? Why not board and easily win! Got a damaged, leaky Native Indian War Canoe with five men on board? Why not board that 300 manned Ship of the Line and take her over in three strokes of your sword!

I'm sorry, but the ease of fencing has ruined an otherwise excellent game. Can't hack naval battles? Close in and fence for your prize... there is no worry you'll lose! Don't want to risk damaging an enemy prize vessel with cannon-shot? Close in and fence your way to the Gold... after all, you can't lose, right?

The ease of fencing is what makes War Canoe jockeys out of us all... how many Ships of the Line were lost to Indian War Canoes in real life? That's what I thought... I'm sorry, but Fencing is sooooo damn easy, it is ruining the game. I deliberately avoid fencing if I can, simply because I know I'll never lose... in fact, that's accurate... I have NEVER lost a sword fight on any difficulty level (including Swashbuckler, though I don't like that setting for other reasons).

I remember in the original game, I feared fencing because it was difficult and dangerous... just as it should be... in SMP, it's simpler, safer, easier to board then it is to actually fight on the high seas. Turning us away from being Pirates, and more into becoming Fencing snobs.

For all these reasons and more... Fencing gets a big fat ZERO in my book!


Aye, Mon Capitan! I bow to ye fer so graciously explaining that view as I too share the same thoughts. However, the only way I can think of making it better is actual skills. Almost like a mini-level system.. perhaps you could 'Buy' or 'Earn' the right to learn how to fight from several masters across the Spanish Main. Taking a few months to a few years depending on exactly how highly rated the skill/teacher/etc. are.

Montalban shouldn't be able to be outdone by some unrefined shrip-arm scallywag who has learned his fighting skills from fighting his own shadows! Nor should you be able to beat a Captain of 250, sailing the pride ship of any port, with men with 30 men, a rowboat, and 2 years experience at sea!

Now.. fer more rates and less rants (I hope.. XP Forgive if this not be the case, mateys.)

Dancing: 4.5/5 - I love them for some reason. It's like DDR.. without the sweat and people laughing at how dorky you look... plus, you're a pirate while doing it! Not to mention you actually get PAYED, in one way or another, to dance with a Girl.. why can't that happen in life? Even i'd dance if I got payed to.. and by Beauties no less. Yesh <_< Sadly.. there in also lies the bad part about dancing... you should be dancing for the RP factor.. not the "bling". Sure! Every once in a while a present or tidbit of info would be nice.. but not all of the time! Add on to this that the Gouverner's Daughters are highly predictable leads to a pretty lousy relationship... but.. as said, I like to shake that booty and the dancing mechanics are great as far as im concened so there.

Sneaking: 2/5 - I actually like it alot.. it's just.. well, there is very little practical application for it! If'n ye must be gettin into ah town that don't be want'in ye, just sack'er down and kick the doors open! The concept is great.. but the execution is flawed.

Land Battles: 3.5-4/5 - Fun all depends on whether you 'make the challenge yourself' by going after a town with less men than the town garrisons. Otherwise, I enjoy it quite well - even if the AI IS stupid.

Treasure Hunting: 2/5 - As said, if it's not super-easy, then it goes to super-tedious; neither are real fun.. but it is interesting enough to do reguardless.

Quests: Doesn't need to be rated; they're just quests. I kinda want to keep seeing my family afterwards and I also wish to 'inherit' Montalban's Hideout, the Lost Cities, and perhaps even make my own Haven. As they are.. they're basically just list of things to get around to.. not very inspiring nor very rewarding imho.

Sea Battles: 4.5/5 - Why the .5 deduction? Because I have a whole fleet of ships, and a 1v1-2 battle isn't very inticing. It could have been expanded just a tiny to make things better. Just alittle 'spice' to liven things up alittle. Otherwise it's one of my favorite aspects of the game.
_________________
Some men bring home the bacon - I choose to bring home the booty.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
DJ1
Cutthroat
Posts: 250


11547 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 11:40 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I agree with you who say that it is to easy to win the lanbattles, shipbattles and fencing.

But I think that it should must be corrected in the right way. I dont think you sould actually loose 'fencing fights' if you have enough men. Those fencing fights you should loose you should do it cause opf that you loose men. If you would win 25% of the fencingfights for instance (win= you push your enemy into the water) you would need to reload. I like Pirates because you dont need to do that. However you should be able to not get time to knock yoiur enemy out if you dont have enough of men. In fencing you loose your men to slowly and the opponent has to poor defence so that you can take him out too quickly. If 300 men meets 30 then the 30 men should be 0 within seconds while the 300 men basically should stand still. It is to litlle rewarding to have many men.

I dont know how to fix this in seabattles though. Now it is nearly ridicilous easy. 5 men in a war Canoe takes easy out Montalban with 250 men. It is just a matter of patience. They should really update the CPU AI here. He should change direction when you fire against him. He shouldnt try to board you unless he will be sure to manage to do it. The Seabattles must also be more rewarding for ships with more cannons. I believe that if we played Pirates online those with Pinnaces and War Canoes would easily win over those with Ship Of The Lines. The cannons should be fired smarter I think. Now when they fire from long distance they do it to much on one spot. Very easy to not get hit then. The cannons should be spreaded out more. Then it would be much more difficult for the war canoes to get out of the fire.

I think SMPirate was most fun when I had started to learn the game. I had practised some and had decent skills in fencing and seabattles. I then actually didnt attack everyship simply because I was to affraid to loose. Now I attack everything cause I know I will win anyway. It shouldnt be like that.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 12:54 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

The main problem with war canoes winning more battles then SotL goes right back to the horrid fencing problems (ie: waaaaaay too easy).

I'm not saying Fencing should be impossible to win or only happen 25% of the time (forcing a reload), I'm saying fencing battles SHOULD MAKE SENSE.

Here's what I'm saying... crew size should be a lot more important in a fencing battle then it currently is... right now if you're on a war canoe with 30 men, charging a 250 manned SotL to board, fence and win is a no-brainer because you can't lose.

If I was all omnipotant and could snap my finger and change Pirates, Anybody who boarded a 250-manned SotL with a crew of 30-men would have about a 1-in-100 shot of winning the battle... sorry, but you're an idiot if you board in this situation. Now if you boarded with a much larger crew, your odds would improve... and say if you boarded with an equal sized crew, you'd stand a very strong chance of winning the battle (but it's still not automatic... there should be SOME risk in every boarding action).

Bottom line, making EVERY boarding action at least SOMEWHAT risky would force out a lot of these canoe jockeys and put more emphasis on ship-to-ship battles and trying to force a striking of the colors (the only risk-free way of winning a battle).

In the same breath, the smaller the ship, the greater the risk should be applied... I'm sorry, but in my mind, a "war canoe" made by indians shouldn't be worth ANYBODY's time... nobody should even remotely consider using an indian war canoe to sail the high seas and battle with frigates... I would propose the smaller the ship, the greater the chance of sinking in battle... ie: a flimsy war canoe might sink with a single cannon ball hit (maybe two), and could never carry a SINGLE cannon (how many indian war canoes every carried cannons?). If your boat could sink with a single hit, and you couldn't carry any cannons, and boarding a large enemy ship with 30 men was suicide, how many war canoe jockeys would we have then?

Pinnaces and Mail Runners could carry a few guns (not many) and would also be fairly easy to sink. Once again, with the fixes to fencing rules, ships of this size would probably not be very popular... once you start getting to sloops and above things start balancing out again, but as I mentioned, the changes in fencing rules should put a premium on large crews and bigger ships, which is historically more logical. This would also slow the progression rate of getting bigger ships. As it stands now, you can start the game in a sloop, and within minutes be sailing a Frigate (probably because of fencing)... that's just not right. With making smaller ships more easily destroyed by gunfire and making crew sizes count more in fencing duals, you could make this game a lot more interesting, more challenging and make a lot more sense.

I'm not saying this to force people to have to reload multiple times... you would only be doing that if you were dumb enough to take on a SotL in a war canoe. Either that, or you get greedy and try to take on a Large Frigate with a Sloop... at least then, you might stand a remote chance of winning if your skills were up to snuff, but it would no longer be an automatic thing... with the changes I suggest, your better course of action as a Sloop pirate would be to capture something easier (like a Brig) and then use the Brig to capture the Frigate... this would force a more natural flow of progression in the game and take the war canoe jockeys out of business (which frankly makes no sense at all).

Of course, my main problem is that I am not omnipotent and do not have mastery over all time space and dimensions. Woe is me... I'm stuck with War Canoes taking on SotL and winning!
Question

FINAL NOTE:
In my perfect world of Pirates.. a Frigate (or bigger) would be feared by anyone not sailing something equal (or at least close) in size... yeah, maybe you'd take on a frigate if you had your own frigate, or at least a brig, but if you were in a sloop or smaller, you'd either run or you'd be very confident of your skills... that's the way it would be in real life and that's the way it should be in this game... once I figured out how easy this game is, Frigates don't scare me (or anyone I would imagine)... instead folks in war canoes make a bee-line for these ships... that's just wrong!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
DJ1
Cutthroat
Posts: 250


11547 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 5:13 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I agree about everything you say.

you missunderstood me about the fencing.

What I meant was that there should be no risk to loose if you have more men than the ship you board. If you loose you should do it cause of that you dont have enough men. Then you in advance 'know' which ships to attack and which not too, just as you say. It is in situations where you may loose fencing fights where you have 100 men and your opponent 80 where you get to a situation where at least I would load again.

I think the riskissue in Landbattles is pretty perfect. You know how many men you need to attack without making it risky. It should be similarly done in fencing.

small conclusion from me (pretty much the same as yours):

* The amount of men must be far more important in fencingfights.

* In seabattles they have to make the it far less benefitial to play with small ships. Just as you say. It is ridicolous that people prefers 'War Canoes' over a SOTL.


Most people have complained about that the game is to easy. Many reviewers too so hopefully they will fix this for future versions. Cause Firaxis must do sequels/expansions to Pirates..?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Willard
Powder Monkey
Posts: 18



12 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat May 21, 2005 11:59 pm    Post subject: Magic Genie Game Making Reply with quote

At the risk of expanding the conversation outside the original topic, it seems that a lot of the gripes in the game have to do with lack of "realism." Other gripes have to do with the original Pirates!/P!Gold. Perfect example: Treasure hunts. "Real" pirates didn't bury their treasure. But, it's poetic license and fun. In the original Pirates!, you had to dig; there was no Neon-sign-illuminated pile of rocks forsaking its intended secret.

What if our friends at Firaxis/Atari put a Realism/Arcade slide in the game? (In addition to difficulty levels.) In total arcade mode, you sail your war canoe up to SotL's and head-swipe enemy captains into the water. In total realism mode, you certainly don't. Perhaps some middle mode for those of us who like a little of each.

Maybe in a "Real" mode the governer's daughter actually marries her fiance if you don't get back to visit at least once a decade.

Sneaking into town would make a lot more sense in a "real" mode. Especially if it involved quests where you had to visit a city... e.g. deliver secret message without getting caught/without anyone ever knowing that you were there/without just taking the town and installing your own governer.

It seems that compared to the original Pirates! (remember when you used to bleed when hit with a sword?) the developers have opted for the more fantastic, family-friendly, arcadey version. Which is fun...

But, what if....
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Orangebeard
Cutthroat
Posts: 287



4436 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue May 24, 2005 3:50 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I like the fact that none of the mini-games are too difficult. In reality, even if you are playing a game as a trade merchant, you will probably have to fight, duel and dance a little bit. Even with no special items or upgrades, it is still possible to be successful at any of these things.

I can't imagine enjoying the game as much if you could not be competitive in a ship duel without all 8 upgrades...

Anyway...

Ship Battles 5/5 - as easy or hard as you want them to be; wind is always a factor as is land position, crew, specialists, etc. Lots of ship variety

Dancing 4/5 - easy to blow it at the last second; at least in a ship battle you can opt out early and go for the duel; gifts are nice though...minimal risk even with a failed dance

Dueling - 3/5 fun, but predictably easy; to the extent that you wonder why you would ever fight it out with broadsides if you can just board them and duel it out

Sneaking - 3/5 high risk; low reward; this would be more justifiable if the city had something that was truly unique and thus worth sneaking for; i will admit that i will sneak into a town for a 5000 gold criminal...

Land Battles - 3/5 a little too slowly paced; I agree that even though you are the attacker, you end up playing defensively...not a bad way to thin out crew though and you just might win!

Trading/Merchant - 2/5 Fun, but very difficult to make a large amount of money strictly through trading; would be nice if you got a bonus for particularly large quantities of something (300 Spice or something like that...)

Treasure Hunting - 3/5 can be challenging; might be more interesting if there was no red X to guide you...just a general location and some landmarks...currently, we call this a bug when it happens, but if the treasure were really there, it might be fun

Well, despite the lower scores, I still consider this to be a 5/5 game when viewed as a whole! Arrrgh!
_________________
Sixty men all lost at sea,
All of them drunk except for me
'Twas I who had to brave the storm
With nothing in sight to keep me warm!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Yellowbeard
Seaman
Posts: 201


7885 Gold -

PostPosted: Tue May 24, 2005 11:14 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Great comments Willard... now a Reality Slider would be just fine for me! If you want to be a Canoe Jockey, that's dandy, but I'd jack that slide over to reality instead of playing as a Pirate in Never-Never Land!
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
frostynso
Swabbie
Posts: 51



1212 Gold -

PostPosted: Sat Jul 16, 2005 4:25 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

This is probably my favorite Pirates! yet. But I'll just get to my ratings.

Sea Battles 4/5: This is a lot more fun than I remember it. Having to ability to switch over to chain shot or grape shot is a great idea and dramatically reduces "accidental" sinkings without us old bucs having to swordfight.

Dancing 4/5: At first, i thought this was the dumbest part of the game, but that was before I read the manual and saw what her hand signals meant. Is a nice change of pace from the usual, sink/capture/plunder, though can become time consuming if your hitting a string of close together ports on a plunder-selling run.

Dueling 4/5: I love the extra little animations and seeing the crew fighting in the background. Is pretty easy but can get hard at harder difficulties once you get to be an old fart. I'm happy they kept the chice of swords, and the ability to pick up items to make you faster.

Sneaking 2/5: I've used it to get out of prison, and I can find the governer's mansion, but nothing else really. I don't know where any of the buildings are and I only found the tavern once. Maybe somebody else can do this alright, but I can't. I preferred it when you just had to duel the guard when you got caught instead of just going ahead and surrendering.

Land Battles 3/5: These are pretty fun, but i might be saying that because I'm good at them! It would have been nice to be able to choose which units you were given, or have some idea what force composition the enemy would have before choosing battle. A little too easy. I found 160 crewman sacking 300 troop towns (+ indians!) happening a little too often.

Trading/Merchant 4/5: Not bad I guess. I tried a game where i tried to be a trader. You don't make much money and are sometimes hampered by the ports not having enough cash. The right missions and the right trade routes can fix this. It'd be great for this to be viable from the start, but in fact it CAN be pretty fun/profitable. One of the more intricate parts of the game can actually be nurturing and building the ports along your trade route to maximize your trade profits. Not bad for a game where you're supposed to be a pirate.

Treasure Hunting 5/5: Nice an easy and I don't have to waste time finding the perfect place to dig. A lot of people don't like this, but I do...saves me time. I like all the landmarks too, though they get repetitive. Actually had my wife on here treasure hunting at one point.

Main Screen 5/5: Beautiful and fun to sail around viewing the beautiful Carribbean. I love watching the dolphins swim aheadof my ships and just that fact that every ship is rendered is great. I like that you actually see every other ship that you pass by and all in all I think this was very well done.

Overall: Despite Lower scores, I give it 5/5 overall. I love this game.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
Post new topic   Reply to topic     Forum Index -> Pirates! Chat All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum


Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group