
Real World - War Canoe vs. Fluyt
| View previous topic :: View next topic |
| Author |
Message |
Mooncusser

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 37 

 
1572 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2005 1:13 pm Post subject: Real World - War Canoe vs. Fluyt |
|
|
Here's what happens whent he modern day equivalent of the War Canoe attacks the modern day equivalent of the Fluyt. (This is a real news story from Sunday.)
Unexploded Rocket Found on Attacked Cruise Ship, Downer Says
2005-11-06 20:01 (New York)
By Fergus Maguire
Nov. 7 (Bloomberg) -- A Carnival Corp. cruise ship that was
attacked by pirates off the east coast of Africa on the weekend
still has an unexploded rocket embedded in it, Australian Foreign
Minister Alexander Downer said.
The Seabourn Spirit, which was scheduled to dock in the
Seychelles today, may be delayed as authorities try to disarm the
missile, Downer told Nine Network television's Today program.
``We're not sure whether, in the early stages, the ship will
be able to tie up at the wharf there because of concern about an
unexploded rocket that is embedded in some of the passenger
accommodation of the ship,'' Downer said.
The Seabourn Spirit was off the coast of Somalia when it was
attacked by pirates in inflatable boats on Nov. 5. One crew
member was injured in the attack.
The ship, carrying 151 passengers and 161 crew was on its
way to Mombasa, Kenya, nearing the end of a 16-day voyage from
Alexandria, Egypt, when it was attacked, the Associated Press
reported yesterday. There were 19 Australians on board, the
Australian Broadcasting Corp. reported. _________________ Mooncussers - pirating the lazy way.... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
oldman

Rigger 
Posts: 1095 


483 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2005 3:05 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I was shocked to hear the news yesterday... Mainly because, we are now in an age of media... and someone is still "dumb" enough to commit such a crime. It will be an international manhunt...
However, after a few hours of sinking in... I realize... if there is going to be any pirate... it will be in region where the international enforcement would be the weakest... Namely near African water.
I have heard the modern day pirates are nothing new... it happens frequently in deep sea fishing region near coast of African water... _________________ Seeking new bride in place of gramma Emma. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Wolfwood

Boatswain 
Posts: 2484 

 
33917 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2005 3:18 pm Post subject: |
|
|
There are modern day pirates at work every week even in these days. There are websites out there that specialise in reporting the activities of modern pirates... _________________ It is much better to be armed with a sword that has two edges than with an estoc [...], which is nothing more than a stick with a point. (Rapier Master G. Morsicato Pallavicini, La Scherma Illustrata, p. 14.) |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
headrock

Rigger 
Posts: 1512 


354 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2005 5:41 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Well that's how it goes - pirates will always be in the areas where government control is weakest and prizes are lucrative. Of course, in the 17th century, sometimes it was the PIRATES who were part of the government  _________________ Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Rook

Seaman 
Posts: 132 

 
517 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2005 6:00 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Ok, some of you might just call this spectulation but others might see my logic behind it. It was not an act of piracy, I'm willing to bet it was an attempted terrorist act that went bad. This is my reasoning behind it. After eight years in the U SNavy and 6 of those 8 at sea in the pacific, from Hawaii to Suadi Arabia and bcak to the Indian ocean, reports of pirate activity has been almost nil. Are they out there, yes definitly. The point is though, they woul dnever attack such a large target. A small zodiac boat like that can only hold 6 -8 men safely with gear. Your not going to take a cruise ship with 8 men, even if the missle had gone off. Also, modern pirates are well equiped, they have access to a lot of craft larger and more suited to piracy and smuggling. That, and an RPG launcher, even an old stinger or Russian made missle are not cheap, so if this "Pirate" cant afford something better then a zodiac, where did he get a launcher from?
Another point I wanted to make is that it was off the coast of Somalia.....Somalia being the same Somalia the US decided to mess with some years back. I'm not about to make this a political debate so Im not looking for any replys about it way right or wrong, I really don't care, but the fact is it happened and it is a known area of several active terrorist cells. they were active then and they are till active now. Even though Carnival cruise ships are world wide, its easy to assosiate it as an American company. Then again, terrorism has reached the stage now where its not just the US they are targetting, so it wouldn't have mattered to them either way.
What I'm trying to say is that a pirate would be looking to looting and ransoming hostages. Your not going to pull that off with one or two small zodiacs and a handful of men, even armed, won't happen. These men were out to damage and kill, most likely he was aiming for the waterline and missed terribly considering it hit in a passanger accomodation which are all below the main deck, which would make up most of the contact area anyway. Terrorists get in and get out, which would make the 1 or 2 zodiacs perfect, I've personally seen this tactic used in the gulf during my last cruise when we had a few closing in on my ship. Needless to say they were blown to little rubber shreds, but thats besides the point. Zodiacs are fast enough and has a low profile where you really can't see them coming visually. If you have never been at sea, I mean deep blue, its not as easy as you think to spot a black dot on a rolling ocean. Truth be told, if you ever fell overboard without your safety vest, the chances of you even being spotted, even if they knew where you fell off, is less then 10%. yes a boat is biger and makes a wake, but yo uhave to be actually looking for it, else you wouldn't know its there. Radar, isnt much of a factor either. A zodiac is small enough that it MIGHT pop up as a bouy, but that is based of tghe types of radar equiped and Im not about to go into that. (Yes I could if you would like too, shipboard radar and communications is what i did while active duty).
I think I've beaten my point to death by now, and I'm sorry, I just get excited about crap like this. Makes me wish I was still active duty. I'm just hoping that I am wrong, that is was just to dim witted two bit crook being stupid. I'm more worried that it might be the start of a new threat though. I mean why not right ? Subway bombings, buildings, and bridges are hard to get to compared to a civilian ship on the high seas. I hope Im wrong. _________________ Loyal subject to the Ruler of the Raging Main
"Imperium Neptuni Regis"
Rook
Managing Editor/Writer
www.hookedgamers.com |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
oldman

Rigger 
Posts: 1095 


483 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2005 6:48 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Rook... You brought up an interesting point... which, frankly... I didn't think much about when I heard it... (mainly due to the lack of knowledge on the "pirate" ship).
It does make sense that no 6-8 men can take on a cruise ship of 150 people... In current day situation... it is just not quiet possible... Althought probably doable... but, it wont be a sure win.
So... that brought up a theory of yours... which seems rather reasonable assumption... Perhaps, there is an alternative motive beside the ordinary pirate looting.
South Africa (the country) has been getting worse in the recent years... so near shore looting is not unheard of... but, at a scale like this one... is definitely the first. Therefore, they couldn't have done it without precision planning to pull this off... (+ finance to do it).
It would be interesting to see... whether the local governement(s) will ever solve this crime. _________________ Seeking new bride in place of gramma Emma. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Mooncusser

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 37 

 
1572 Gold -

|
Posted: Mon Nov 07, 2005 9:46 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Maybe they were terrorists - but who knows for sure, and I tend to think not.
I just don't think it's highly likely. There have been way too many "pirate" attacks in that part of the world lately (something like 20+ this year already), including one group that hijacked a UN aid ship for over 3 months earlier this year. (I don't remember if they ever got any ransom paid - but I am guessing they must have gotten something if they thought a cruise ship was a worthy target.)
Can that few people take over a cruise ship? Absolutely. It only takes one or two to take over a plane... Besides, all you have to do as an attacker is get on board. Then you are the only one with weapons on a boat full of senior citizens. (I know - gross generalization, but at the very worst, you are the only one with guns on a boat full of fat, formerly happy tourists.) Who's going to fight you as long as you don't indicate that you're going to sink the thing/kill everyone? As a passenger, the potential costs of dying in a fight against armed men don't match up well against the odds that someone (like Carnival) will pay a ransom and get me off for no cost out of my pocket. This is the way things used to be in airline hijackings until 9/11 - just sit tight, let them land the plane and then the negotiations start.
There are known pirate rings inhabiting the Somalia coast, making it likely that this was just another "bold" attempt. (I put bold in quotes, because there really wasn't much risk. Who's going to chase the attackers down? There's no law in the area to chase them. As long as they don't attack a warship, they're likely to face no serious opposition at any point of their pirate journey until they actually take the ship - in which case the ship and the tourists become the defense against an attacker.)
Also, it strikes me that terrorists would have been better armed/not given up so easily. - I mean, the one's you referenced in your thoughts didn't give up until blown out of the water. It just seems like there would have been a better plan than "fire a couple of rounds, see if you can get on board, then turn away if you can't". On the cost point - yeah, maybe RPGs are expensive, but last I heard weapons like that were in pretty good supply in that part of the world. If you can use a couple to get some hostage-cash, that's a better use than wasting a round on the warlord next door.
As for the idea that they were aiming for the water-line - again, none of us was there, so who knows, but so far reports are that the bridge was the main target of the fire, which would imply that the goal wasn't to sink the ship. (This doesn't mean that there weren't other terrorist goals in mind - maybe they wanted to get on board and shoot everyone, but it doesn't seem like outright sinking of the ship was the plan.) _________________ Mooncussers - pirating the lazy way.... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
headrock

Rigger 
Posts: 1512 


354 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Nov 08, 2005 1:07 am Post subject: |
|
|
I'd have to agree with mooncusser. The main thing that strikes me as odd with this being a terrorist operation to sink the ship is that you wouldn't need 6-8 people on the zodiac - two would work. _________________ Blondebeard: "Madre de Dios! Es el Pollo Diablo!!"
<Spanish Guitar Riff>
Guybrush: "Si! He dejado en libertad los prisioneros, y ahora vengo por TE!"
 |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Rook

Seaman 
Posts: 132 

 
517 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue Nov 08, 2005 2:17 am Post subject: |
|
|
OK, now Mooncusser made bery good points, of which I'm not going to argue over. My personal knowledge of the area is limited at best, but I definitly agree its a lawless region. What I'd like to address is the motives of these Pirates vs terrorists.
Can 16 armed men realistically take a ship of not 160, that was just passangers, but better to 300+ with crew. Could they do it? YEs agree they could, because they would have fear on thier side. The man with the gun is the scariest of them all and usually will get his way. It is a good generalization that most will be retired tourists with very little fight left in them, but 300 to 16 odds isnt very good once feel threatened enough to react. Many would die, more would choose not to fight, but either way it would be a bad choice to fight back unless the crew is equiped with a small arms locker, which most ships are, even cruise ships. Only a handful of officers have access to said locker, but it differs to much for me to comment on.
The real defense the ship would have it technology. The boarding would have been a surprise, but do you have any idea how hard it is to scale of 5 -8 story ship while its moving, from a zodiac no less? You can't. Even with some James Bond grapple/repelling gear, you would need to anchor a hook several stories up then start the climb. This going on all along with people checking out whats going on and of course fighting the wake of a ship over 100 times the size of your zodiac. The stories of small boats and people getting sucked into the propellers, that isnt a fairy tale, that is a true occurance and one that would weigh into how they approuched the ship.
Lets say though, they are on deck 1 group forward and 1 group aft. What is the first thing everyone is going to do....scream. The bridge is a phone call away and the call for help will be just as fast. Down side is considering thier location, there is no Coast Guard to save them, so help may not come at all.
As for terrorits and thier persistance. What I went through in the gulf was a suicide attack. It was 3 surface targets that was suspected to be loaded to the gunwale with mines and homemade explosives. There was no turning back for them. To them, that was thier purpose in life. Biggest mistake people make about terrorists is that they are JUST a bunch of raving suicidal fanatics. Thats is when they usually kill you, beacuse you were expecting a kid with a bomb strapped to his chest charge you screaming something to Alla. They are just a shrewed and cunning as any other soilder out there and are capable of rational thought just like our troops. They know how to ambush, track, flank and entrap. Not every attack is a suicide run, and this could be an example. Maybe they only had one round on them. Could that one round sunk that ship? Yes, of course. Would it need to be a dead on shot, definatly. But the threat and chance was there. naval ships of any nation are designed to take a series of hits and stay afloat, cruise ship are not. I promise you, if that RPG would have went off and started flooding from below the waterline, the ship would have been lost. It may have taken hours, but in the end, you would have a huge rescue effort and those life boats would have been prime pickings for anyone. Most of those watertight doors are automatic, but it only takes a couple to fail to start serious problems. My point is, the plan would have failed, so thier course of action was retreat, regroup, and plan something else for another day.
Ok I'm harping too much on technical stuff and I'm sorry, I think in the end of all this is that authorities wrote off this attack too quickly as a pirate attack. It could have been either one really, both cases are possible and I can go days on consperiacy thoeries about everything, but they are just that, theories. It just seems strange on why local pirates would harrass such a large target. Maybe they were just proving a point that they could do it if they wanted too? Maybe they are marking thier territory in a way, kinda like a 'get the hell out' situation. Too many possibilities. Needless to say, I'm sure Carnival is remapping some new routes to give the coast a larger birth. _________________ Loyal subject to the Ruler of the Raging Main
"Imperium Neptuni Regis"
Rook
Managing Editor/Writer
www.hookedgamers.com |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
oldman

Rigger 
Posts: 1095 


483 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue Nov 08, 2005 2:52 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I am begining to wonder whether I should cancel my family booking for the Disney Caribbean's Cruise... If it is not hurricane... then it is looting (too realistic)...
Then again... we only live once... really want to take a full advantage of what life would offer... and broaden my kids view of the world (eg... like going to the mountain side of European countries... Rome, Paris, London...etc).
I don't know... I travel extensively for my work... and never have any fear for travel... except if my family is with me...
I wonder if some of you well-traveled road warriors have the same anxiety when it comes to family travel? _________________ Seeking new bride in place of gramma Emma. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Rook

Seaman 
Posts: 132 

 
517 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue Nov 08, 2005 3:01 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I'd still go, your right, you only live once. Pirate or terrorist, doesnt matter, once you let yourself llive in fear and hiding in a closet, you let them win. Go take your cruise and enjoy the time with your family. I'd certainly go. WOOOOO BIKINIS ON THE POOP DECK!!  _________________ Loyal subject to the Ruler of the Raging Main
"Imperium Neptuni Regis"
Rook
Managing Editor/Writer
www.hookedgamers.com |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Mooncusser

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 37 

 
1572 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Nov 08, 2005 4:40 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I just posted a brilliantly thought out response to all above - and when I pushed "submit" - it disappeared...
Go on your trip Oldman, and don't think twice about problems. Not because we should ignore everything and "be brave" (I hate stuff that is designed to twist my emotions and rational thought process), but because there really is little to worry about.
I'll try to keep this short, but the main reason I think the whole cruise ship thing is a pirate attack is that it makes no sense as a terrorist attack.
Contrary to conventional wisdom, the 9/11 attacks were about the worst thing that terrorists could have done to themselves. Really - think about it. If it weren't for Iraq, they'd be nowhere right now. No home country, a harder time making money off of heroin, and everybody in the world thinking they were just a bunch of murderers. (OK, there are some hardcore fanatics that will always be around, but general support would be non-existent.)
Terrorists have to stick to their goals and make their strikes count. The Spain and UK train attacks were designed to get Spain and the UK out of Iraq. With Spain, it worked, with the UK it didn't. Shots at military targets are designed to show strength and the ability to fight back. Attacks on Iraq civilians are for local tactical purposes. Attacks on soft, random, civilian targets? They only make sense if there is a chance that they will affect national policy positively (from the perspective of the terrorists). If they do nothing or just steel the will of the enemy, then they are a waste of expensive resources.
Taking out a load of Australian tourists just makes Al-Quaida et al. look like evil butchers without producing any significant benefits. It won't help recruit dedicated followers (true adherants to the terrorist cause are there for more than murdering random civilians in pointless attacks), it won't likely significantly affect US or Australian policy (it may actually make popular support in "civilized" countries stronger for combatting "terrorist murderers", a-la 9/11), and it won't benefit terrorists in their goal of getting to power or developing a safe base to rule over.
As long as popular support for action against terrorists remains strong, there really is little reason to fear an attack by an organized and purposeful group like Al-Quaida. An attack by a fringe element "nutcase" (think Oklahoma City) is far more likely.
If you are someone like Rook looking at this from a military service point of view, then you are actually in the battle and are a true target. In his case, he was actually fighting an enemy, whether uniformed or not. (BTW - I hate that we call them terrorists in that capacity. I know the point is to not give them political creedence, but you are really fighting a guerilla enemy, not a truly "terrorist" organization.)
Have fun on your cruise, oldman! (Just don't be shocked if a Sloop of War pulls alongside and keel-hauls the lot of you sunbathing landlubbers!) _________________ Mooncussers - pirating the lazy way.... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
oldman

Rigger 
Posts: 1095 


483 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Tue Nov 08, 2005 8:23 pm Post subject: |
|
|
Thanks for the encouragement... Afterall, I also wonder about Pooh in bathing outfit... Red Top, Honey Jars... Well... open bottom...
Hmm ... is that why there is no princesses lying around the pool area on the cruise ships I wonder... (sorry... got WAY OFF TRACK)...
I think my kids would be thrill to be on the cruise... for that matter... ANY cruise... Except, with the Disney cruise... we do take a break from parenting... for brief moment that is. _________________ Seeking new bride in place of gramma Emma. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Mooncusser

Powder Monkey 
Posts: 37 

 
1572 Gold -

|
Posted: Tue Nov 08, 2005 9:02 pm Post subject: |
|
|
I've only been on one cruise in my life. To St. Thomas, San Juan, etc.
It was a Royal Carribean ship. We hung out in the non-kid pool area most of the time. Now I have a 3 month old and I'll never see the non-kid area again...
BTW - sorry about the rants earlier. I get a little worked up on some topics - mainly because I think we're fed a lot of substandard reporting and thought through our wonderful news media. (Uh oh. I feel another one coming on - gotta' go before it gets out of hand... )
(Get it? Mr. Green smiley for the Hulk?....)  _________________ Mooncussers - pirating the lazy way.... |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Howie

Helmsman 
Posts: 4223 

 
45890 Gold -

more...
|
Posted: Wed Nov 09, 2005 1:26 pm Post subject: |
|
|
| Mooncusser wrote: | I've only been on one cruise in my life. To St. Thomas, San Juan, etc.
It was a Royal Carribean ship. We hung out in the non-kid pool area most of the time. Now I have a 3 month old and I'll never see the non-kid area again...
| I've been on many a cruise in me sea farin' day. Been all over the world and even passed by some pretty scary ports of call. Even came across a pirate now and again. The pirates normally would steer clear of us though. Being that we were a Man O' War with some pretty big guns available to use to keep from being boarded by some scurvy pirates. We sailed the 7 seas, and kept that good old 5-inch cannon well oiled and ready to go at a moments notice. To back that up we had an assortment of surface to air and surface-to-surface missiles that could really light up some scurrilous pirate's ass if he was daring enough to take us on. I always kept me cutlass polished and at me side and was ready to beat back a boarding attempt by some half-wit pirate cap'n. Avast matey! I be seein' a mast on the horizon...  _________________
   |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|
|